Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if the NHS sends you an appointment for a significant surgical procedure, you turn up>

459 replies

XingMing · 13/12/2022 21:51

DH has waited two years for a (complicated) day surgery on his heart. He turned up for it at 7 am this morning and of the six scheduled booked patients, two arrived. There was a surgical team of ten arranged, who stood around waiting. If this is the normal, and the doctors, surgeons and nurses seemed to think it was, then complaints about underfunding the nhs funding needs should be kicked backed to the public. It's reasonable to expect the treatment paid for via taxation, but it is unreasonable to be so cavalier about non attendance. This was a procedure that cost the NHS £20k or more in salary costs... and two-thirds of the list were no shows. Can you tell that I am incensed for the people on waiting lists and the taxpayers funding the waste? For the record, the roads were all clear.

OP posts:
Tanfastic · 14/12/2022 05:27

Alopeciabop · 13/12/2022 22:51

Every time I have an appointment sent through it’s for a totally inconvenient time ie during school run or whatever. Then I figure out a way to make it work but will inevitably get an appointment cancellation letter a few days later. Then I’m sent another letter with a new date for a few weeks or months later. And often this happens more than once. Why couldn’t they just have secretaries or whatever you want to call them nowadays, like we used to?

like you say, just pick up the phone and say hello does this time work for you? Yes no great book it!

not an excuse for everyone I’m sure but honestly it’s such a convoluted process it surely has to account for some of the no shows

From my perspective due to the volume of patients I have to book on a daily basis it's just not a viable option to book by telephone. I book in advance and patients get reminder calls and options to rearrange on a day more convenient (they may have to wait longer if they can only do an afternoon on a Wednesday though for example).

On the odd occasion I have a clinic to fill that's been slotted in last minute and I have no option to book by telephone it takes me four times as long as no bugger answers their bloody phone!

Unfortunately most NHS admin I work with are so stretched there's just not enough hours in the day to complete the work set for them.

mumoffourminimes · 14/12/2022 05:10

I have to add the time they refused to cancel a post natal appointment I also got a text message from the same surgery saying they were "too busy" to see children ill with suspected strep A.

The NHS is a shit show

mumoffourminimes · 14/12/2022 05:09

Meh, under maternity 'care' I was made loads of appointments I either didn't want, didn't know about or didn't even know what they were for.

Tried to cancel, was told my receptions they "weren't allowed" to cancel appointments.

Another time I called several numbers to cancel an appt because I had covid. They had a phone call asking why I hadn't turned up.

For my post natal check, I declined for myself and just asked for an appointment for baby. Apparently the receptionist wasn't allowed to do that either.

The NHS systems are full of waste. That's what's maddening.

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/12/2022 04:58

The people suggesting that DNA'ers are charged for missing appointments..

HOW do you think this will work when the system can't currently cope, and is doing all the things multiple people in this thread have mentioned?

The letters arriving after the appointment date, the letters not arriving at all, appointments cancelled but patient not informed which are still recorded as a DNA, patients cancelling in plenty of time but recorded as a DNA, patients unable to attend as held up elsewhere in the SAME HOSPITAL, having informed the relevant department or asked for them to be informed recorded as DNA...

The list of fuckuppery goes on and on, its not one person, its not one area, it is nationwide, everyone I know, every single person, who even semi-frequently attends hospital or has medical appointments, has experienced at least one of these fuck ups.

So what chance they can run a DNA penalty fee properly, without adding to the burden and cost on the NHS?

Absolutely fucking zero.

SomethingOriginal2 · 14/12/2022 04:28

You should be charged for missing appointments you made yourself. But the system of just sending out a letter with a time and date is absolutely useless.
I got a letter about my wisdom teeth removal 2 weeks after the appointment and the dentist refused to refer me again because I missed an appointment.

DSs vaccine letters just don't turn up then he misses them and I get shit .

You should just get a letter saying "call us to book your operation" or a phonecall. It would be cheaper to pay someone to run the phones than to pay a whole surgical team to do nothing.

yesforone · 14/12/2022 04:27

They may have had their original surgery date postponed numerous times (common) and then received their new appointment date letter after the date of their surgery (not uncommon)

Onnabugeisha · 14/12/2022 03:21

This is definitely YBU
And to be completely frank, I do not think that "mental health" issues should be an easy automatic get out clause.

Only a person who has never been seriously mentally ill would say this. It’s an extremely ableist thing to say and disgusting that you think this really translates to “couldn’t be arsed” from your earlier post and your go to explanation as to why that number couldn’t get to the hospital.

You even mention deprioritising those with mental health conditions and charging them for missed appointments- WTAF? You really have no clue how disabling a mental health condition can be and seem to be just drooling over the chance to kick a person when they are down and unwell.

Onnabugeisha · 14/12/2022 03:01

I think YABU, the train strikes started yesterday and anyone outside London was unable to travel at all due to this. It’s fair enough saying “take the bus” but a one hour journey by train can often translate into a 5-6hr journey by bus. Specialist surgeries like this don’t usually happen at a local hospital. So its no surprise to me really that many missed appointments.

MintJulia · 14/12/2022 03:00

I recently went for a post-breast cancer mammogram and was seen early because the three people booked ahead of me hadn't shown up. Are they mad?

I was back in the car park and on my way home before my appointment time. Great for me but what a criminally stupid waste of resource.

Mumma · 14/12/2022 02:33

Personally, I had a letter today for an appointment for 8th December. Not helpful.

My friend kept getting appointments for pregnancy scans after a traumatic miscarriage despite them being informed.

The system is a mess and definitely needs looking at.

JustLyra · 14/12/2022 02:04

I think the assumption that adding another layer of admin into the processes would somehow make it easier and less appointments would be missed is really naive.

How many appointments are genuinely missed because someone thinks “I can’t be arsed today?”

And how would you safeguard the people who didn’t get letters, got letters late, couldn’t get through to cancel or rearrange, take ill on the day, have disabilities or mental health issues that stop them getting to the hospital, have technology difficulty so can’t cancel/get through to rearrange, or who simply make a mistake about the date of the appointment that was originally made 2 years ago and has subsequently been changed half a dozen times?

Plus what then happens when someone gets fined? What’s the financial implication of banning Steve from having another MRI appointment until he pays up, but then he ends up with a much more difficult, and expensive, condition to treat by the time he ends up in A&E weeks and months later?

And what happens to Betty who missed hers because of her learning difficulties and is on benefits so she can’t afford the fine? Does she just get left until her condition is critical or do people with difficulties end up not being fined which then adds another layer of admin because they then have to work out who should and shouldn’t be fined depending on their circumstances?
and how is that done in a timely fashion so that Mary, who never got a letter, doesn’t end up with her cancer professing further while she waits on a decision about something that wasn’t her fault?

Theres a reason it’s never been implemented on any of the occasions it’s been mooted. Because it’s just not a good idea.

and actually only benefits the NT people who actively chose not to bother and can afford the fine because their new appointment will be much sooner if all the people with issues get bumped out of the way!

Holly6547 · 14/12/2022 01:39

I waited 2.5 years for an appointment and then missed it because we took our first holiday in four years. Two weeks later we came home to a letter about an appointment that had already passed. I tried calling them several times before we left but it kept ringing and no one ever picked up.

XanaduKira · 14/12/2022 01:33

YukoandHiro · 13/12/2022 22:05

I know this is true but honestly I can't understand why. You get so many reminders texts about every nhs appt now, even phone calls for big ones. And clear info about how to cancel. You can even cancel by text!
What is the matter with people?

It's free for them, so they don't care.

I love the NHS but think there needs to be something that means people feel the consequences of no shows - Im not sure what and likely the admin would be cost prohibitive but there really should be a way to charge people if they don't cancel with enough notice.

IntheSnowySnowyMountains · 14/12/2022 01:31

In the European system I'm in, missed appointments are paid for. Some leniency is offered for emergencies (if you call to explain). Appointments have to be cancelled 24 hours in advance.

In 20 years I have never paid for a missed appointment, because I have either been there or cancelled in time.(I did once accidentally turn up the day before).

BUT, patients get a say about when their appointments will take place. They don't go home and wait for a possible letter or phone call for an appointment in two years' time!

I am pretty certain that if the NHS adopted both approaches (charging for missed appointments and giving the patients options regarding date/time,) their efficiency would increase overnight and the DNA rate would fall significantly.

XenoBitch · 14/12/2022 01:23

Summerfun54321 · 14/12/2022 01:04

Nah sorry, anyone with any empathy or forward thinking would make the call at least the day before whether they thought they could go through with the OP. Just pulling a no show is stupid.

Really?
Are you someone who has had to actually face this?

FetlocksBlowingInTheWind · 14/12/2022 01:15

My DP had a fracture clinic appointment a while back. He received about 6 texts a day for the 2 days before and day of the appointment reminding him about it 😂 It was ok at first but ended up being quite annoying. Reading this thread I now understand it!!

That hospital trust has clearly gone to an extreme with the reminders but evidently for good reason. I wonder what their DNA rate would be without them.

AlwaysFullOfQuestions22 · 14/12/2022 01:08

Yanbu
However i had a pre assessment for surgery and told the wait is up to a year and not to call i would get a letter. I gave it till 12m was up and called as was due to see a specialist in that area.
They said id been removed off list as i hadn't turned up 8 months prior!
I had no letter whatsoever. I said normally appointments arw text too. She said not for surgery
So had to go back to specialist to be referred again

comfyshoes2022 · 14/12/2022 01:05

If a certain proportion of appointments are no shows, the NHS should be planning accordingly (ie overbooking) when it makes procedures and other appointments so that staff time isn’t wasted. Yes, it will mean that occasionally some people won’t be seen as planned because everyone has showed up and so offices and hospitals are overbooked. However, it just seems like bad management for a surgical team to stand around waiting for people to show up for appointments if it’s entirely predictable that some people will be DNAs and there’s a two year wait time.

Summerfun54321 · 14/12/2022 01:04

XenoBitch · 14/12/2022 00:44

I did know someone who did DNA for an vital heart op. He was convinced he would die if he had it done... his anxiety ate him up.
He was not thick either, like you are implying.

Nah sorry, anyone with any empathy or forward thinking would make the call at least the day before whether they thought they could go through with the OP. Just pulling a no show is stupid.

Genevieva · 14/12/2022 00:51

@NoDramaMama12 I completely agree. There is no excuse for that. The NHS costs the taxpayer half a billion pounds a day. It really is not beyond the wit of a local hospital to be able to make sure that this is possible. I had the same years ago. I left messages all over the place, but then received a nasty letter saying I hadn't attended my appointment. Recently my Dad sat by the phone all afternoon waiting for a consultant to ring for a telephone appointment. The call never came. Apparently there is a six month waiting list for the next one. This is for an operation that he needs and that it was first suggested he need back in the winter of 2019/2020 (three years ago). They lost the scan, causing a huge delay. You really couldn't make it up. All the while he is in pain and his quality of life is rapidly diminishing.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 14/12/2022 00:50

Grimreapers · 13/12/2022 21:59

They're probably dead from having to wait 2 years....

Obviously you are joking, but it’s going to form part of my anecdotal experience of reasons why some of these things might happen.
I won’t bore with why, but as a whole, and for various reasons, my wider family are what I would call ‘heavy’ users of the NHS. And I have/have had to advocate for more than one of them. A few scenarios that have happened to us:
1 Three separate appointments all booked for our local hub surgery (half hour appointments for three people for asthma reviews). Booked via their online service, confirmed via their own text message system. All had to be cancelled as our holiday flights home were cancelled and we wouldn’t have got home in time. Followed their instructions for cancelling via the text message system well within the timeframe. Received text confirmation of cancellation. Got call from surgery asking why we didn’t show up - was able to show them the text msg cancellation and conf. No answer to what had gone wrong but the Dr sat for and hour and half that day not seeing other patients cos we weren’t there.
2 Husband had a brain tumour a few years back. Lots of varied appointments at various locations with various people. One booked at KCH London, a loooong way from where we live, cancelled last minute (after we’d arranged transport and hotel at cost to us) and we received a letter in post saying it was moved to our local hospital at 8am the following Sunday morning. Excellent we thought, better for us. Until we arrive to a department in darkness and are told by the main reception desk, that department is never, and has never been, open Sundays.
3 also re brain tumour - appointment with endocrinologist booked, and subsequently cancelled three times within an 18 month period. All by letters in post. Then a letter informing us DH missed his appointment. We were able to show them the letter we received cancelling said appointment.
4 and now to my original point. My DF, in hospital unfortunately since just before Covid shut everything down. I had to do all his care and advocating by phone and couldn’t get to see either him or the people caring for him. In a hospital in Essex, with various procedures booked. Suddenly get letters for him referring to a procedure booked for him at Homerton Hospital London - not the same care authority. No one could work out why it was booked for there, and in any case he’d already been seen at original hospital. Twice I cancelled the appointment, and yet they kept rebooking it whilst totally unable to explain why. By the time the last letter came through with the third appointment, my father had already passed away.
The whole system is fucked.

XenoBitch · 14/12/2022 00:44

Summerfun54321 · 14/12/2022 00:28

OP if you work on the basis that most humans are a bit thick, the world starts to make a lot more sense. Obviously no intelligent person would miss an important heart operation.

I did know someone who did DNA for an vital heart op. He was convinced he would die if he had it done... his anxiety ate him up.
He was not thick either, like you are implying.

Gagaandgag · 14/12/2022 00:41

iknowhimsowell · 13/12/2022 22:05

I didn't want to be the one to say it but my thoughts were along the same lines!

And mine…

bruffin · 14/12/2022 00:33

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 13/12/2022 22:05

My mum has had letters for appointments whereby the date had already passed.
Coincidentally, a lady at my GP practice, just this morning, complained that her letter to attend an appointment was weeks old.

I do think that the administration in the NHS might be a problem.

If someone moves or dies whilst on a waiting list , then perhaps the hospital doesn't get informed.

It's an enormous waste of time, resources and money.

In recent years I have had texts to remind me of gp and eye hospital appointments.

DD is a pediatric OT and in the summer only 2 out 5 parents turned up for their child's appointments

funnelfanjo · 14/12/2022 00:30

My mums eye care is under a team at a major regional hospital but she attends a clinic at her local hospital. The letters she gets has the major regional hospital details all over it, you have to read it very carefully to understand that she needs to go to the local place for her appointment. It’s a densely written A4 sheet in standard sized text. Aimed at elderly patients with vision problems. It’s forehead slapping daftness. She needs one cover sheet in large text saying “Dear Mrs Funnelsmum, your next eye appointment is at Local Hospital on Date at Time. If you can’t make it please ring Number We Will Answer in Clinic Hours.” That’s it. They can send all sorts of other bumpf if they have to, but it won’t get read.

in the old days I remember getting postcards from the dentist with reminders on but I suppose patient confidentiality meant that’s not an option these days (even if post could be relied on)

Swipe left for the next trending thread