Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’m not sending Christmas cards this year, I’m donating to charity

160 replies

UseAMuckySock · 13/12/2022 20:30

Why is everyone announcing this on Facebook lately? Are we supposed to tell them how amazing and thoughtful they are?

OP posts:
ButteryNuts · 15/12/2022 00:40

I know someone who does this because she doesn't like Christmas - few bad experiences that took place on Christmas day, and then a very close death a few days before one year. She now doesn't celebrate Christmas at all, goes away every year, doesn't send or receive cards or gifts. I get the impression the charity donation is a protection for herself so she isn't just seen as a spoil sport/bah hum bug, not as a humble brag.

unclebuck · 14/12/2022 23:29

I am on the board of a Charity and a few years ago we did a banner people could add to their social media profile until the 12th day for a donation, We did't specify the amount. The average donation was £1.10. Yep, all of the generous donors did posts showing off about their banner and applied it. We all found it bizarre!

UseAMuckySock · 14/12/2022 20:23

ohioriver · 14/12/2022 10:06

Where is the op anyway?

waves

OP posts:
RoseMadderAsHell · 14/12/2022 12:23

notanothertakeaway · 13/12/2022 20:40

For most people, it means "I'm happy to receive cards, can't be bothered to write them, I still want to receive presents, and will buy a christmas tree, but if I pretend that I'm giving to charity, then no one will dare challenge me on it"

I'm not happy to receive cards never know what to do with them and there's always a twinge of guilt when I put it straight in the recycling.
Why do people insist on sending cards to someone who's said she doesn't want them?

GeekyThings · 14/12/2022 12:13

Technically giving cards out is more showmanship than Facebook posts - cards aren't made out of love and kindness, they're mass produced, disposable and mostly just sent out of obligation and/or posturing.

I also think it's weird to think that it's somehow lesser to give to charity and tell everyone about it. If you really believe in the charity you're giving to, surely you would want to advertise it to try and get them more money?

ancientgran · 14/12/2022 12:04

ohioriver · 13/12/2022 20:41

And I do give to charity every month privately. I just want to remember my mum publicly and say her name out loud so she isn't really dead just for the 2 seconds it takes someone to read my post

Nothing wrong with that, if people don't like it it's tough isn't it. I talk about my late parents a lot, I didn't used to. My father died when I was a child and I don't think I talked about him very much when my children were little but I talk to my GC about him lots. I strangely feel closer to him now, maybe it is part of healing.

Hillarious · 14/12/2022 11:56

I always send a personal message in my christmas cards. It takes a fair amount of time and effort to do them, but the people I keep in touch with this way are worth it.

I also separately raise money for local charities at Christmas, but don't announce this on Facebook.

SpikeGilesSandwich · 14/12/2022 11:55

The people who would most appreciate a Christmas card are usually the people not on Facebook. I know a lot of older people are online now but life is increasingly lonely for those who are not, I definitely don't begrudge them a card and a stamp once a year if it adds a tiny bit of brightness to their day.

forlornlorna1 · 14/12/2022 11:53

I buy my card from a chosen charity.

Comefromaway · 14/12/2022 11:50

It's to let people know what you are doing and not to be offended if they don't receive a card from you.

I posted a link to the specific charity as it is something related to a cause I believe in and I have a lot of friends in the same sphere so they might like to consider doing the same.

Livinginanotherworld · 14/12/2022 11:49

Hate it ! Give to charity without announcing it. Send Christmas cards or don’t.
Two different situations.

Flapjackquack · 14/12/2022 11:45

thecatsthecats · 14/12/2022 11:22

I sort of imagine that the same people who care about this are the same people anxiously tallying up who they have/haven't received a card from, as if it really matters.

If you need an annual card exchange to judge whether or not you're friends with someone, you have bigger problems.

You can simultaneously not care about Christmas cards, volunteer/donate to charity yourself, and roll your eyes at people who feel the need to tell everyone about their charity donations.

Nomorescreentime · 14/12/2022 11:38

I’m not a fan of Christmas cards, I am a fan of people donating to charity. So I have no problem with this at all and there are far worse things to get annoyed about.

thecatsthecats · 14/12/2022 11:22

DocMarteens · 14/12/2022 10:44

Years ago when I used to get Xmas cards I would put the message on my social media so people knew not to expect a card from me. And I was happy to donate that money to charity.

Now I don't receive as many cards, I don't put the message up and still donate that card and postage money to charity.

Also privately donate throughout the year.

I don't know why there's negativity about this

I sort of imagine that the same people who care about this are the same people anxiously tallying up who they have/haven't received a card from, as if it really matters.

If you need an annual card exchange to judge whether or not you're friends with someone, you have bigger problems.

DocMarteens · 14/12/2022 10:44

Years ago when I used to get Xmas cards I would put the message on my social media so people knew not to expect a card from me. And I was happy to donate that money to charity.

Now I don't receive as many cards, I don't put the message up and still donate that card and postage money to charity.

Also privately donate throughout the year.

I don't know why there's negativity about this

Picklypickles · 14/12/2022 10:38

I've only done cards for mine and dp's close family this year, not bothered with extended family or friends at all and I'm not donating anything extra to charity either (I already support a charity with monthly donations all year round) and I don't feel the need to announce my decision to anyone.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 14/12/2022 10:19

I don't see the need for the "...making a donation instead" posts. Smacks of "please like me". Send, or don't send - it's a free choice, make your peace with it.
I do send Christmas cards and know it's outdated, but I don't really do social media and like more distant friends and family to know I'm thinking of them. A personal Christmas text from someone is just as lovely to receive and serves the same purpose, but a generic "merry Christmas y'all" on socials is a bit why bother?

ohioriver · 14/12/2022 10:06

Where is the op anyway?

edwinbear · 14/12/2022 10:05

It doesn't bother me so much, I just make a note of the people who publicly announce they can't be bothered to send cards and cross them off my Christmas card list. Saves me time and money.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 14/12/2022 09:54

you are ok @ohioriver and I don't think you personally have been doing anything wrong. remember the OP wasn't about you, and neither was my reply to it. I agree that your over-all activity that you've described in your various posts is very different from what the OP and I are talking about. there are people who do a single "not doing cards" social media post and don't actually bother with anyone except those they actually see and exchange gifts with. that's the category we are talking about, and that's not you, obviously. I don't think you need to change what you do as those who are close enough to you that they might otherwise have expected a card clearly know that you care about them and appreciate what you do.

phoenixrosehere · 14/12/2022 09:52

thecatsthecats · 14/12/2022 09:36

I work for a charity, and the absolute PITA types to deal with are the people who have weird conceptions about what constitutes a charitable act and whether or not you should talk about it.

Always hoity-toity know-nothings who baulk at actually doing anything.

Never had any trouble from those who post about their charitable deeds, or from the service users.

But people who think that you shouldn't give charity gifts, shouldn't post about it etc - utter weirdos who harangue you endlessly for not fulfilling their vision of what charity is.

I agree.

If it leads to more people donating and awareness of different charities, why be annoyed or upset because you didn’t get a card. From the way some people act when they don’t get one, can’t blame some from not wanting to tell certain people in person.

ohioriver · 14/12/2022 09:41

but if you aren't going to send something on paper, then it would be a much more appropriate substitution to organise a zoom linkup with each person you would otherwise have sent a card to, in order to say happy christmas personally.

I don't do zooms but I do FaceTime or what's app video call, or just a call or go and visit. To every person I'd have sent a card to. I never did send cards to hordes of people anyway (I struggle with knowing what to write) and I couldn't write a box of cards now anyway, but I do phone or video call people or go to see them

I get that I'm doing it wrong. Message received and understood.

ohioriver · 14/12/2022 09:38

a Christmas card "donation" can be done without even a moment's thought about the people who thought that you mattered to each other.

This is so far from what I do it's not something I recognise at all

thecatsthecats · 14/12/2022 09:36

I work for a charity, and the absolute PITA types to deal with are the people who have weird conceptions about what constitutes a charitable act and whether or not you should talk about it.

Always hoity-toity know-nothings who baulk at actually doing anything.

Never had any trouble from those who post about their charitable deeds, or from the service users.

But people who think that you shouldn't give charity gifts, shouldn't post about it etc - utter weirdos who harangue you endlessly for not fulfilling their vision of what charity is.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 14/12/2022 09:33

yanbu op. Though I got flamed before in a previous year on a similat thread by plenty of mumsnetters who are keen to defend themselves, hating to see how they are perceived, but you can't flame someone into agreeing with you.

it's great to give to charity, and a lot of us do.

giving to charity is a totally different act from putting attention into our human relationships. we all have a range of different people in our lives who we might interact with to very different degrees. maybe you don't "need" to send a Christmas card to the ones you talk to regularly and don't actually care about the ones you barely see and don't feel the need to say happy Christmas to them, but I feel that cards from dozens of friends and relatives is an intrinsic part of a sitting room decorated for Christmas and it would be bleak and depressing not to have these colourful goodwishes.

but if you aren't going to send something on paper, then it would be a much more appropriate substitution to organise a zoom linkup with each person you would otherwise have sent a card to, in order to say happy christmas personally. obviously hardly anyone does that - it would be great if they did as that would be more inclusive of those who genuinely couldn't afford a stamp per family member/friend as opposed to those claiming they are giving the same money to charity. But these blanket announcements on Facebook simply mean "I have no interest in whether or not you have a happy christmas or in maintaining individual contact with you". They are in the same category as, albeit actually worse than "charity gifts" where you pretend that your charity donation is actually a gift for someone else (fine if they ask for it, not fine to choose if unasked) but at least the 'gifts' are something done on an individual basis so have a tiny amount of thought included. a Christmas card "donation" can be done without even a moment's thought about the people who thought that you mattered to each other.

Swipe left for the next trending thread