Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's nothing left to try (13 month old sleep)

33 replies

nurserypolitics · 13/12/2022 15:04

At my wits end and concerned for my husband's health.

We have been night-weaning and I suppose sleep training DD2 for 2 months. So far, this involves my husband putting her to sleep. She has a bedtime routine (downstairs final breastfeed with me, upstairs for stories, sleeping bag, then placed in cot by him with white noise). She usually grumbles and tries to sit up, and he gently places her so she's lying down again in the cot. Then repeat. The 'norm' is after 5 minutes of this she rolls over and falls asleep, but some nights there are 10-15 minutes of her crying.

Then, if she wakes, he sleeps in the room with her and will usually shush her and then if needed pat her, and then if needed pick her up.

We had a similar approach with DD1 and within about two weeks she woke no more than once or twice a night, and all she wanted was a hand on her back to reassure her someone was there and she'd go back to sleep. We co-slept and this was fine.

So far, DD2 is still waking and crying for an average of ten minutes at least three or four times a night. Some nights she's woken every hour. The odd - very odd - night she's slept for up to 7 hours without a wakeup. Last night she woke at 4, cried for 40 minutes, I gave in and fed her and she fed pretty much till morning.

For a period of this early on she was sick and I co-slept and fed her but tbh it was awful for both of us, DD1 would co-sleep and actually sleep, DD2 co-slept as a younger baby but is clearly not comfy doing so now. She throws her head back and wriggles and can't sleep. If she does feed all night its clear it also makes her uncomfortable in terms of her digestion. So its not a case of persevering with this to get 'perfect' sleep its that there seem to be no other options.

Currently we have:

  • Clear short bedtime routine
  • Good daytime nap routine
  • Goes to sleep in cot (with someone there but usually no patting etc)

If I try to put her down it doesn't work at all, she just wants me to feed her to sleep. DH has had nothing but unbroken sleep for months and has returned to work and can't go on. He genuinely looks unwell.

I would try co-sleeping and feeding her to sleep but a) we'd need to sell our bed to do it safely and b) where we've tried it it clearly doesn't improve things. I don't want to do controlled crying and certainly not cry it out in the sense of leaving her but ended up accidentally doing something not dissimilar a few weeks ago when DH had to go away for a couple of nights and I had to deal with DD1 who kept being woken by the crying and she basically ended up hysterical.

Is there something I've forgotten? We can try something new over Christmas but something needs to change. I have looked up similar threads but everything focuses on night-weaning/getting them fall asleep in the cot or co-sleeping and we've tried all that but its still terrible.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Expectingfirstbaby · 14/12/2022 15:23

Could she still be hungry after her last breastfeed of the night? Could you also give her a top up bottle of formula after the breastfeed just to get her full?

nurserypolitics · 14/12/2022 15:16

Thanks all for the feedback.

@FlyingPandas I think its fair to call me out on not breaking the association that mummy = feed. We've tried to introduce 'loveys' etc, neither of my children have ever had the slightest interest in getting comfort from anything other than people. The 4 year old remains immune to the charms of teddies and dolls. We assumed she'd adapt quite quickly to going to sleep without a feed - which she did - and then we could swap me in, but that hasn't worked and its now two months on so I guess I will need to suck it up and start trying to alternate bedtimes. I tried a few weeks ago when my husband was away - this was when I gave in ultimately - and I can't describe how awful it was, she screamed hysterically literally for 90 minutes, I did pick her up at 15 minute intervals to try and soothe her but she kept trying to work her head down my body.

My eldest was a horrific sleeper, much worse than this one, and interestingly did have underlying medical issues. We've checked this one out for reflux/allergies and I think its not an issue but who knows if there's something minor. However the eldest did take much easier to sleep and night weaning at this age, but it was also the point where we'd cut out allergens and medicated the reflux.

I think it is very unlikely she is hungry. We have offered formula in the night a few times. I breastfed my eldest morning and nighttime till she was two, having night-weaned at 9 months and I found it invaluable when she was ill and a nice way to connect, I don't think she's crying because she wants a feed so much as she wants comfort, and I don't see how stopping feeding in the day time will have an effect.

A question though about the 'controlled crying' - my understanding is its all about getting them to sleep on their own. But she will sleep in the cot with minimal intervention and also her cot is in our room. Often in the night she will wake up, roll over, see someone is in bed next to her and go back to sleep. The problem is other times she'll cry for ten minutes then go back to sleep - while left in the cot, so essentially I don't see how its different than controlled crying it just hasn't abated after two months. And it can be every two hours in the night. I don't really see what controlled crying offers except changing what she's already got used to, and possibly introducing an expectation - sleeping in an empty room - that won't be her reality as she'll be sharing with us then her sister for the foreseeable.

(for the poster who asked why co-sleeping would mean selling the bed, Its a superking and she's a crawler and explorer: our room isn't big enough to have the bed with the mattress on the floor next to it and its too high to have her safely in it with the two of us)

I suppose over Christmas probably what we need to do is alternate putting her down, and put v clear sleep plans in place so we're both following exactly the same steps. It does feel like we're in an awkward place, and maybe she's not ready: I guess the back up plan is once again working out the minimal sleep we can both survive on and seeing how we can achieve that....

OP posts:
Greengagesnfennel · 14/12/2022 13:50

Have you looked into health reasons? It can be hard to tell what's wrong with such small children but acid reflux can cause little ones to wake a lot (worse when lying down). My daughter turned out to get it from milk (incl. Bf) which was a nightmare but infant ranitidine was good. And then she had night time asthma when she got a bit older. With both it was finding the right diagnosis and getting treatment that solved the sleep issues.

FTMbg · 14/12/2022 12:54

Have you tried making sure you both get a good dose of daylight as soon as it's available in the morning and through the daytime to make sure your circadian rhythm, melatonin etc is clear when night and morning are? Apparently melatonin goes into breast milk.

ArabellaScott · 14/12/2022 12:37

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 14/12/2022 00:08

To be honest OP, I think you are doing all the right things and you just need to keep at it. She's only a baby and I know sleep deprivation is torture but there are loads of bugs going round at the moment so she may be coming down with something if she has managed not night feeding for a while.

You have my full sympathy as I literally tried everything (other than CIO) and I was so sleep deprived for years but this too shall pass as they say.

Agree. It will pass. I know that sounds like small comfort, but babies change so fast.

mackthepony · 14/12/2022 00:09

I'd be putting her onto formula

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 14/12/2022 00:08

To be honest OP, I think you are doing all the right things and you just need to keep at it. She's only a baby and I know sleep deprivation is torture but there are loads of bugs going round at the moment so she may be coming down with something if she has managed not night feeding for a while.

You have my full sympathy as I literally tried everything (other than CIO) and I was so sleep deprived for years but this too shall pass as they say.

MilkyYay · 14/12/2022 00:00

. If either of us went near them during the grumble screech waking they would be up for ages. Its like they were annoyed at waking up then grouching themselves back to sleep.

Both mine were like this at various phases. God help you if you picked up the youngest when it happened, it made it SO much worse!

MilkyYay · 13/12/2022 23:52

Have you tried offering sleep props that don't involve DH to settle her when shd wakes?

A cuddly toy she's attached to, music playing on a baby monitor that you can turn on from your bedside etc?

Make sure she is warm enough. I found if i followed the guidance about room temp & clothing for toddlers in bed both mine were too cold and woke a lot.

Lilgamesh2 · 13/12/2022 23:35

Could she be hungry?

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/12/2022 20:36

Agree with this. She is used to your husband helping her get back to sleep if she wakes. She needs to learn to do it without him. How to get to that point is the difficult bit. If he or you has the patience then you can gradually lessen the input. Or if not then controlled crying. It's pretty awful but does seem to work for many.

AnotherAppleThief · 13/12/2022 20:26

Is there a reason you can't/dont want to wean her from the breast?

LazJaz · 13/12/2022 20:17

HTTPS://Batelle.com

Hankunamatata · 13/12/2022 20:16

My second two were screechy sleepers. They moaned and grumbled themselves to sleep (like a grouchy whinge but not crying) - if you touched them then all hell broke out. Then they would randomly wake during the night, moan and grumble cry for 5 mins then go back to sleep. I ended up sleeping in another room with earplugs as I could hear them when they really started to cry which was rare. If either of us went near them during the grumble screech waking they would be up for ages. Its like they were annoyed at waking up then grouching themselves back to sleep. We only discovered this when I had a sickness bug and couldn't physically leave the bathroom when they started.

ArabellaScott · 13/12/2022 19:51

kellymom.com/ages/weaning/wean-how/weaning-night/

Some really useful suggestions in there for gentle night weaning, OP.

FlyingPandas · 13/12/2022 19:38

I think a more accurate thread title would be 'to think there's nothing left I am willing to try'. Which is absolutely fine, no-one needs to consider any option they are not prepared to, but it's not true to say you are all out of options. You aren't - it's just that you don't necessarily want to try some of them.

Your problem is that only your DH can settle her, because, in your own words, "If I try to put her down it doesn't work at all, she just wants me to feed her to sleep. DH has had nothing but unbroken sleep for months and has returned to work and can't go on. He genuinely looks unwell."

So, essentially you have created a sleep association that means she will only accept you if you feed her to sleep. So DH has to do it all as she doesn't expect milk from him.

You need to get to a point where she does not expect to be fed to sleep when you try to settle her. So, you can either stop BF, or try a new routine that includes you putting her down but being absolutely firm and consistent that once she has had her bedtime feed you don't feed her to sleep. But this will inevitably involve crying and protests and that will be difficult, so if you are going to try it, you'd need to be consistent.

Merlott · 13/12/2022 19:03

Why would you have to sell your bed to co sleep?!!!!

BertieBotts · 13/12/2022 18:46

I think she just doesn't sound ready, so I'd go back to what you were doing and try again in about 2-3 months.

What have you been doing up to now? Do you go into her room to feed her and that's the part that you want to stop? I managed to night wean DS2 once we were in this stage by introducing a delay before feeding, I'd tried to do this previously by adding new things such as shhing/singing, stroking him in the cot and he just got angry and stood up and clearly didn't understand WTF I was trying to do as it wasn't soothing to him at all when he was expecting to be picked up and fed. When I changed my approach to do everything that I would usually do (walk to him, pick up, walk to chair, sit down, open clothing, feed) but in slow motion so that it took about 5 minutes, he wasn't anywhere near as distressed and it gave me back that control because he knew I was still there to soothe him, I just got more control over when. Before this whole approach I had always gone to him ASAP and tried to get him latched ASAP because I felt terrible that he was crying. So it was useful for me to understand that it wasn't an emergency. I would have lengthened it to 7 mins and then 9 and then longer but actually I didn't need to time it. He just started accepting a delay and often falling back to sleep without me getting to the milk part.

The other thing I did was detach him just before he was asleep and finish off soothing him in my arms. It takes a bit of trial and error but eventually you can do it earlier in the feed.

if you give in you have made all the previous crying pointless and your teaching them to cry harder then you will give in.

I don't think this is helpful and I don't think it's true. Lyndsey Hookway talks about three responses to sleep training: The fast responder, who cries for about 15-20 minutes for about three nights and then sleeps happily ever after. The slow responder who cries maybe up to 45-60 mins for several weeks but does eventually improve and it works, and the non responder who gets more and more worked up and it's really distressing for both child and parent.

If I was going to sleep train personally I'd put a time limit on it as I think that's the kind and sensible thing to do. I think doom mongering like the above is unhelpful and would make people persevere past the point that their instinct is telling them this is wrong. If it doesn't work (fairly) quickly, then the child probably isn't ready or the method isn't right for the moment and best to stop and try something else or wait a while. It probably is helpful to hang onto something that helps you push past the initial wanting to rush in and rescue them after 5 minutes, but I don't think it's true that if you stop you're undoing everything.

kirkandpetal · 13/12/2022 18:44

We did controlled crying when my dd2 was 8months. I used the super nanny method which is similar to what a pp has said, leaving the room for increased intervals until they fall asleep. She wasn't happy, more crossed crying that she wasn't getting her way but after 2 night we cracked it.

I know it's a pretty decisive method and for some it's not an option. But for us, at the time, it thankfully worked and we've never really looked back since. That 8th old is now 10yo!

MolliciousIntent · 13/12/2022 18:40

The issue is she needs someone there in order to go back to sleep. She needs to learn to fall asleep in an empty room.

mewkins · 13/12/2022 18:38

nurserypolitics · 13/12/2022 18:29

Sorry if I've been totally unclear but she isn't being fed to sleep. It has literally happened twice in two months of following this approach and the main reasonithappened last night was we're feeling out of options and like we can't keep doing this which is why I posted.

I included it to say we had a recent enough 'sample' that it wouldn't work, or be an easy alternative (if feeding to sleep/co-sleeoing got both of us enough sleep to function I would do it now). Aside from those two times DH follows an almost precise routine no matter what. The only time she's picked up is if she's upset for so long that she needs to be soothed/calmed before going back in.

The only real difference between this and controlled crying is that he doesn't leave the room and I guess maybe with controlled crying you never pick them up no matter how upset they get? But I dont'reallly see the benefit of that. I always assumed controlled crying was getting them out of the habit of needing to be stroked/held/fed to sleep. But DD has been following this approach for two months and she'll pretty consistently go asleep but then wakes and it gets harder to resettle.

In terms of giving her a bottle the first few weeks DH offered but she 100% isn't hungry and has no interest in it. This is why I feel a bit stuck.

What's her personality like? Is she very alert etc? My dd was very active and being in the room while she tried to sleep was just a distraction for her.

I would agree a consistent approach to night waking eg. If she wakes, wait at least 5 mins (time it) before going in, patting and then leave. It also helps if you set a time limit on feeding eg. If she takes a full feed before bed, she won't need another feed before xx. Up until that time, resettle by going in, a quick reassure then leave.

BernadetteAndHoward · 13/12/2022 18:35

I think you need to be more consistent. I would use controlled crying where you leave the room for increasing intervals. This gives her the chance to learn to settle herself. We did this and did pick them up for a cuddle if they got too upset, then put them down, patted them and left. It shouldn’t take long if you’re consistent.

nurserypolitics · 13/12/2022 18:29

Sorry if I've been totally unclear but she isn't being fed to sleep. It has literally happened twice in two months of following this approach and the main reasonithappened last night was we're feeling out of options and like we can't keep doing this which is why I posted.

I included it to say we had a recent enough 'sample' that it wouldn't work, or be an easy alternative (if feeding to sleep/co-sleeoing got both of us enough sleep to function I would do it now). Aside from those two times DH follows an almost precise routine no matter what. The only time she's picked up is if she's upset for so long that she needs to be soothed/calmed before going back in.

The only real difference between this and controlled crying is that he doesn't leave the room and I guess maybe with controlled crying you never pick them up no matter how upset they get? But I dont'reallly see the benefit of that. I always assumed controlled crying was getting them out of the habit of needing to be stroked/held/fed to sleep. But DD has been following this approach for two months and she'll pretty consistently go asleep but then wakes and it gets harder to resettle.

In terms of giving her a bottle the first few weeks DH offered but she 100% isn't hungry and has no interest in it. This is why I feel a bit stuck.

OP posts:
ShirleyPhallus · 13/12/2022 16:38

You really do not need to stop BF. Just decrease the minutes you feed at night and wean her or replace milk with water

Swipe left for the next trending thread