Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think mothers are the most judgemental of other mothers?

64 replies

antelopevalley · 13/12/2022 11:55

And to feel sad this is the case, Most (I am not naive I know not all), mothers are doing a good enough job and their children are fine. So why do so many mothers criticise what are fairly minor things over a childhood?

Who cares if you do baby-led weaning or spoon-feeding. Or if you toilet train using chocolate buttons (my top toilet training tip). Or if you dress young kids in fashionable clothes or more classic clothes.

There are so many things that mothers judge each other on that really do not matter. Do what works for you and your child. Save judgement for neglect and abuse and report it. Not for simply making different decisions about everyday things.

And my title is because I find other people don't care about these things at all or very much. It is other mothers who do and who judge.

OP posts:
Funkyblues101 · 13/12/2022 16:18

I think it's all based in nature: "bad parenting" could ultimately result in the species dying out, so judginess is there to ensure mothers (both parents nowadays) tow/toe (?) the line. Obviously nowadays, in Britain, children can get cold and generally warm up easily, stupid behaviour is often easily fixed in a hospital. Whereas before the above could very easily result in death so needed to be frowned on, consistently. Similarly, men being judged for lack of sporting ability (as referenced by a male PP) all stems from sporting ability being vital for catching meat.

ChillysWaterBottle · 13/12/2022 16:10

I don't know, in real life my mum group friends are wonderful. Supportive, helpful, honest and non-judgemental. They've been brilliant for me on mat leave. That's not to say I've not encountered the judgy-pants brigade but I'm quite a confident person and its water off a ducks back for me. For me not being judgemental is a point of principle. Unless it strays into abuse or neglect other people's parenting is their business and I consider my role in their lives is only to be as helpful and supportive as I can. Kids are individuals and there is no one size fits all.

I think people are much judgier online than in real life because I have a suspicion that forums tend to attract a lot of unhappier, less sociable and less pleasant people. I find it disappointing since young mums come to places like this for community, advice and support and instead can get, well, dickheads. I'm laughing that some have already come on this thread. They can't help themselves!

(Also the idea that dads are less competitive and judgemental is hilarious. C'mon now)

Cinnabomb · 13/12/2022 16:08

In a cafe!!! Not a cage 🤣

Cinnabomb · 13/12/2022 16:08

@Brunilde you are exactly my point. You would have judged me if you’d seen my toddler on my phone in a cage. But it’s bonkers. It doesn’t make sense.

for example if I said “I had an afternoon watching Xmas films with my toddler on the sofa” - nobody would judge. Despite possibly 3 hours ish of screen time. there’s no evidence here of more interaction or benefit for the child - eg I could be doing chores whilst she’s plonked in front of the tv or sitting next to her scrolling on my phone. For example.

if I have a coffee in a cafe with my toddler having a screen. I get judged. For less screen time, maybe 30-40 mins. But somehow im now a lazy parent? Even tho my toddler would have been out and about before and after at park or similar? It makes absolutely zero sense and is absolutely pathetic. It really irritates me as we don’t really watch tv at home, so toddler might get 30 mins once a week or less when I’m out but that’s not acceptable. But 1-2 hours in front of the tv whilst mum does chores is?!

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 13/12/2022 16:07

See I find it goes:-

  • most bitchy - women who had small children over 20 years ago
  • quite critical - older men
  • middling - women who are yet to become parents (but want to at some point)
  • interested in a "might I be a bit of a better parent?" way - existing mothers to small dc
  • couldn't care less what you do - women who want to remain child free, men under 40
Thepeopleversuswork · 13/12/2022 16:00

I actually think some of the most judgemental people I've encountered are other women without children.

I have an old (child-free) friend who can't resist making comments about how I parent my 11 year old. I find the lack of self-awareness extremely difficult to take from someone who has literally no parenting experience whatsoever.

Brunilde · 13/12/2022 15:50

I don't judge other mothers for everything but I do some things. If you feed your kids processed crap all day I judge you.

If they run around in restaurants/ shopping centres etc because you can't be arsed to discipline them I judge you.

If you plonk your kid in front of a screen while having a meal so you don't have to entertain them or interact I judge you.

But I'm sure they all have some sort of special needs or mum has a good excuse. Maybe a couple will but most are lazy fuckers that can't be bothered parenting.

Cinnabomb · 13/12/2022 14:42

Agree and there’s a few examples on this thread already. The biggest one that bugs me on MN is the vehemence about screens in a cafe. I basically have been repeatedly told on MN that I’m a lazy parent because my toddler watched 30 mins of octonauts on my phone (on silent) whilst I gave my friend my full attention as she’d just found out her husband had an affair and needed to talk. 30 mins of screen time in a cafe once a month was unacceptable according to many threads here. But it’s ok if it was at home. Even tho it wasn’t disturbing other diners (on silent, on her lap so no one could see the screen). Fucking makes no sense and pathetic.

whattodo1975 · 13/12/2022 14:36

Women love a stick with which to beat other women with.

TheHouseIsInACircleNow · 13/12/2022 14:30

Personally I find a lot of the older generation are incredibly quick to judge, often regardless of the closeness of their relationship to the Mum where you might expect a degree of restraint and kindness. I’ve had unwanted unwelcome comments from parents in law, older aunts, and completely random strangers on the street and in the supermarket. Oooh we never did that in my day…….. 🫤

Mercurian · 13/12/2022 14:29

I saw Dads being judgy and competitive, usually with money, sports and holidays.

TheWhalrus · 13/12/2022 14:28

Coming from the perspective of a dad here (because I am one). I have to say I definitely notice this a fair bit. I don't understand why this happens exactly, although 'mum-upmanship' could be one explanation. You do see it in other areas as well: for example on holidays before children, DW used to love judging other women's bodies at the beach. Even the fairly normal bodies seemed to draw criticism, although she never, ever said anything about the men: even men with huge guts who nonetheless insisted on wearing speedos.

Dads, of course, come with many other undesirable characteristics, although i've never seen this particular one play out. If anything we tend to be reasonably understanding of each other's child-related problems. Supportive may be going a bit far, but we don't judge like some women do.

Mercurian · 13/12/2022 14:25

No. I judged parents WAAAY harder when I was childless. I knew what my parents did wrong with us so I thought I had enough insight to be a superior super parent. God, I was awfully judgmental.
Becoming a mother has humbled me, taught me to be kinder and more patient. It's been very hard. There is nothing like living the experience yourself.

123woop · 13/12/2022 14:23

I think it depends, I don't feel judgement at all but then I have deep confidence in what I'm doing so if someone did pass comment I'd tell them to bog off! 🤣 I think that there are just the "right" way to do things. Obviously I don't always do the "right" thing, but I trust wholeheartedly mine and my partner's judgement with things

ScotlandEuropa · 13/12/2022 14:15

Yeah. I formula fed my girls (who are 8 and 6 now - and perfectly fine and healthy) and my colleague actually rolled her eyes about it. Her kids are in their teens. How on earth do my feeding choices five bloody years ago impact upon her life?

Skinnermarink · 13/12/2022 14:13

I don’t judge (too much) but I feel very sorry for my brother and SIL who ‘can’t’ do a bedtime without hours of rocking, soothing, talking, up and down the bloody stairs like yo-yos. The children are 4 and 6. It’s completely mad, and they seem resigned to do it for as long as it takes. Literally every evening they endure this performance and it goes on until 10pm or so. It did make me very mindful of how I wanted bedtimes to look before I had my own.

You are right though OP, I have luckily a group of very supportive laid back mum friends but my original NCT- wow. So much thinly veiled judgement. The worst one was that sadly, I had the least money so my baby was the first to start nursery as I had to work, at ten months. SO much ‘oh my goodness what a long day for him!’ And ‘I could never, they’re only little for such a short time!’

5128gap · 13/12/2022 14:10

I think its insecurity in the face of so much pressure that seems to increase with every new generation. Women are bombarded with instructions as to the current absolutely essential thing they need to be doing, and its nigh on impossible to believe you're doing enough and getting it right.
Its a natural human response to look to others in comparison and this can lead to a 'well at least I'm not as bad as her' mentality.
Less charitably, I think there's also a tendancy for some women to approach child rearing with the zeal and competitiveness they previously aplied to their careers. They make a full time job out of going way beyond the necessary and validate it by judging other women who do 'less'.

EndlessRain1 · 13/12/2022 13:53

I would also say, there is a judgier category. The not-yet-parents. Whose children will never watch a screen, or eat sugar or go out without gloves.

Daisy38 · 13/12/2022 13:47

I think sometimes it’s not a matter of judging someone, but as there are so many parts of parenting where there’s no one right way of doing something, it can seem like judgement where someone talks about doing something in a different way.

If you’re secure in how you’re bringing your child up then it probably won’t bother you, but if you are a bit wobbly or unsure then hearing that your friend is doing baby led weaning and is confident in doing so but you’ve chosen spoon feeding and have your reasons for that, then it may feel like you’re being judged.

My kids are teen and pre-teen now and recently a friend with a baby and toddler was asking how I dealt with a particular bedtime issue when mine were little. I had to say that it had never been an issue for us. We had dealt with things differently when they were little so I didn’t really have any advice to give. I was aware as I spoke to her it could sound like I was judging her and hopefully that’s not what she thought, but I honestly couldn’t give any advice as it wasn’t an issue I had experience with so didn’t want to pretend I did.

Honeybirds87 · 13/12/2022 13:00

I spend a lot of time thinking "well that says more about you then it does about me/her" when I hear other people being judgemental, which I guess is a bit judgy of me to.

Honestly most people don't give a shit,

Strugglingtodomybest · 13/12/2022 12:30

Dailymash · 13/12/2022 12:16

Insecurity, I guess. Just like all other ways people judge one another. If someone is happy and confident in themselves and their decisions they accept that everyone is different and has different ways of doing things. In the majority of cases there is no right and wrong but if someone is insecure they will try to pull down anyone doing something ‘different’.

I agree with this. I know that when I was a new mum I may have come across as judging, with questions like "why do you do X?", but I was just so anxious that I wasn't doing things "right". It took me a good few years to settle down and realise that there is no "right".

RambamThankyouMam · 13/12/2022 12:27

DouglasTea · 13/12/2022 12:01

I agree but I think a lot of the time it is to boost ones own standing.

I read an article years ago about "mum-upmanship" which is a great name for it.

One-up-mumship would be better!

EndlessRain1 · 13/12/2022 12:23

ladywithnomanors · 13/12/2022 12:21

🙄

What? You literally admitted to be judgemental?!

ActionThisDay · 13/12/2022 12:22

Maybe I'm naive or lucky but I think the amount of judging that goes on is very little. A lot of what we feel is judgment is actually projection - I'm worried I'm not good enough so I imagine those other mums think I'm not good enough. In reality people just aren't that interested. I couldn't give a toss whether someone else dresses their child in X or feeds them Y (as long as we're not talking about neglect) and struggle to believe that many other people care either. Haven't we all got enough going on?

ladywithnomanors · 13/12/2022 12:21

EndlessRain1 · 13/12/2022 12:11

My son one winter - he was about 2 - refused to wear trousers. Shorts only. No matter how cold. That does not make me a lazy parent. But GREAT example of judgement for the OP.

🙄