Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think mothers are the most judgemental of other mothers?

64 replies

antelopevalley · 13/12/2022 11:55

And to feel sad this is the case, Most (I am not naive I know not all), mothers are doing a good enough job and their children are fine. So why do so many mothers criticise what are fairly minor things over a childhood?

Who cares if you do baby-led weaning or spoon-feeding. Or if you toilet train using chocolate buttons (my top toilet training tip). Or if you dress young kids in fashionable clothes or more classic clothes.

There are so many things that mothers judge each other on that really do not matter. Do what works for you and your child. Save judgement for neglect and abuse and report it. Not for simply making different decisions about everyday things.

And my title is because I find other people don't care about these things at all or very much. It is other mothers who do and who judge.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
wonderingpondering1 · 26/12/2022 22:01

@tensmumm yes! Have to admit I did a post on Xmas day to a WhatsApp group I’m in about needing prosecco to cope 🙈. But I mean, it was a joke, and Xmas day. I know what you mean about social media, I feel awful saying this in RL as I know people do struggle with parenting and it can be hard, but there are a lot of those oh woe is me posts and poems etc, almost competing about who finds it hardest, like a race to the bottom, when really, like most things in life parenting has good bits, bad bits and mainly just in the middle! Same as life without kids..

tensmumm · 26/12/2022 21:57

I've noticed something similar wonderingpondering, mums going out of their way to brag about not caring about XYZ. I've noticed mums talking about needing to drink alcohol to get through parenting, and acting as though it's cool to call your kids little wankers and similar. There's a lot on SM about this sort of thing, a sort of backlash to being a 'perfect' parent.

wonderingpondering1 · 26/12/2022 21:33

I don’t experience too much (obvious) judgement, but there is a lot of competitiveness…mostly subtle, and also, if this doesn’t sound weird competitive uncompetitiveness…an example, oh, I heard x saying in the playground how her DD is soooo good at reading, I mean, why would you do that, why does it matter? So vulgar etc etc (I have to admit I’ve been guilty of this but only in my head!)

tensmumm · 26/12/2022 21:28

The only time I have a reaction is when someone is doing something where there's a lot of evidence against it, or I've personally experienced the negative effects of. It's more of a helpless or sad feeling for them suffering. Witnessing a distressed child is difficult and combined with years of higher education and experience it can be a little jarring, but I've never shared an unsolicited opinion nor have I known others to give or receive them.

I can only think of one example of being judged and I'm at the teen stage now, it was by a woman running a craft activity at a cafe and garden. She was annoyed that I didn't make my toddler sit down at a table in the garden and do intricate crafts that weren't age appropriate for my toddler. The next closest thing was a childless friend telling me that their mum did CIO, in response to me having to get off the phone to soothe my baby, but I didn't take it as a judgement so much as them trying to be helpful.

HeleneLagonelle · 13/12/2022 22:39

ActionThisDay · 13/12/2022 12:22

Maybe I'm naive or lucky but I think the amount of judging that goes on is very little. A lot of what we feel is judgment is actually projection - I'm worried I'm not good enough so I imagine those other mums think I'm not good enough. In reality people just aren't that interested. I couldn't give a toss whether someone else dresses their child in X or feeds them Y (as long as we're not talking about neglect) and struggle to believe that many other people care either. Haven't we all got enough going on?

I agree. I’m genuinely unbothered by anyone else’s parenting. I tend to assume people are doing their best, apart from cases of obvious neglect or mistreatment.

PawPaworPapaya · 13/12/2022 21:53

I probably seemed quite judgemental when I had my first baby. I was suffering with PND and I felt like such a shit mother. I was really insecure at that time.

After having my second, my mental health has improved massively, and I no longer make negative comments about other people's choices, because I simply don't give a shit what everyone else is doing. I'm busy and happy.

I wonder if a lot of these "judgemental" mothers are actually just terrified that they're getting it all wrong. There's an awful lot of pressure on mums. You have to be thick skinned.

Gilmorehill · 13/12/2022 21:52

Yes definitely there are some mothers who love to judge. I remember the frazzled mum who scraped my car in a car park yelling at me that I was a bad mother 🤔 because my car door was open while I put my baby in her car seat. Some mums think they are amazing so judge and others are struggling so judge to feel better. Never let it get to you. Being a parent is so difficult and no one is perfect.

LolaSmiles · 13/12/2022 21:45

I think sometimes it’s not a matter of judging someone, but as there are so many parts of parenting where there’s no one right way of doing something, it can seem like judgement where someone talks about doing something in a different way.

If you’re secure in how you’re bringing your child up then it probably won’t bother you, but if you are a bit wobbly or unsure then hearing that your friend is doing baby led weaning and is confident in doing so but you’ve chosen spoon feeding and have your reasons for that, then it may feel like you’re being judged
Agree with this.
If you're not feeling confident in why you're doing what you're doing as a parent it's easy to feel that anyone doing it differently or having a different perspective is judgement.

Bouledeneige · 13/12/2022 21:40

It's true but only in early years, you find your true supportive friends and then ditch the rest of them. I felt very judged for going back to work after having my two then within a few years everyone was envious I had a career. Real friends will out,

HighlandsMum · 13/12/2022 21:29

I think some women do. However, since I’ve moved to a more remote area the mothers around me all seem to really help each other out and are very supportive of everything

antelopevalley · 13/12/2022 21:27

Cinnabomb · 13/12/2022 16:08

In a cafe!!! Not a cage 🤣

Yeah I would have judged the cage. Xmas Grin

OP posts:
walkinthewoodstoday · 13/12/2022 21:03

Maybe first time mums but by the time you get to your second you don't really care and realise it doesn't matter what others do, or at least that's how it was for me! Everyone fed, no one dead.

TheWhalrus · 13/12/2022 19:57

Reindeersnooker · 13/12/2022 16:33

I'd like to think we're not all like that she you just got a wrong un. Maybe she was worried you would admire them if she didn't point out the flaws. No woman I know talks like that.

In fairness I was probably describing this in a slightly harsh way....I actually only learned this when we were having a conversation about what we look at on the beach. Basically I asked if she tended to look at other men on the beach (acknowledging that I may from time to time look at other women, although i try to be subtle about it)....I was actually expecting a 'yes a bit, but only the fit ones' (and this would have been just fine) what I got was something in a way much more interesting.....she tends to keep it to herself unless I specifically ask what she's doing. She also couldn't really explain why she does this, but at the same time she's also not particularly proud of this behaviour.

Sceptre86 · 13/12/2022 19:09

Some women do but many don't. You really do have to find your tribe. I took dd1 to groups and then ds too until he was mobile. At that point she would run in one direction and he another, at one group I went to there were a group of mums tutting at me. I never went back there. Now I have dd2 and we go to lots of groups. I do not care what people think and largely everyone I have met has been nice. Dd2 is a clingy baby but smiles at everyone so that helps with interactions. Plus I'm not a nervous first time mum, she's my third kid and I'm confident in my parenting (at least at this stage) so even if we don't make any friends it's about getting out of the house and having some fun together.

There's more than one way to parent and each kid is different. I've tailored my approach to meet the needs of each of my kids. I recognise most parents are just trying to do their best so I but out. I don't give advice unless asked and if my kids haven't been through something I'll be honest and say so. I've made friends with women on a birth group and mumsnet and we have a group on Facebook . It's full of women from all over the world and a very non judgementa space.

yoyy · 13/12/2022 17:07

As pp it's largely driven by insecurity & anxiety so they have to put others down to feel more confident in the path/decisions they took.

Buzzinwithbez · 13/12/2022 17:06

@Cinnabomb I often needed to be on my phone as I was running a business around my children.
Then there were times we'd been in all day, or out all day and that sit down with a cup of coffee and half an hour with some adult company - a friend who may have been sitting with me or may have been in my phone kept me going.

Sod the parents who didn't want to let their kids have a tablet. That's their decision. There are many reasons other parents seem to think our decisions affect them and their children,. I had glares from parents many a time because my kids were getting soaked to the skin in a muddy puddle having a brilliant old time and they didn't want their kids to do the same for whatever reason.

SpicyFoodRocks · 13/12/2022 17:02

I found much more judgement online than IRL. The mums I met when my kids were little tended to judge themselves more harshly than other parents.

lightand · 13/12/2022 16:56

Some things do matter.
Some dont.

I care how teenagers turn out.
It isnt by pure accident how they are, and how they are in adulthood.

Having said all that, I didnt say my thoughts that often.

PinkParfait · 13/12/2022 16:52

Women are extremely competitive with other women in general TBH. It starts early too - I first noticed it at school around the age of 12.

It's sad but I don't think we'll ever 'evolve' out of it as a society, because I don't believe it's 'learned' sociological behaviour, it seems to be a natural biological instinct that appears from puberty.

Ponoka7 · 13/12/2022 16:38

FourTeaFallOut · 13/12/2022 16:28

Oh please, let's not pretend there is a genetic imperative for survival when it comes to judginess that isn't more simply explained by the jolt of dopamine which is experienced when you consider yourself better than someone else.

Absolutely. In previous generations children were seen as mini adults and fended for themselves. Then childhood was recognised but clothing and feeding them was enough. Then came the psychologists/psychiatrists, who had fundamental religious backgrounds and liked to blame Mothers for everything. They needed to sell parenting books and not hold men responsible for their own behaviour. Women have been pitted against each other and taught to police each other. It was an easy form of control. If girls got pregnant families were convinced in giving them up to the Catholic laundries etc. If women were promiscuous, other women would shun them etc. Housekeeping standards were set by other women. Most orangutan lose their first baby through neglect/giving the baby to others etc. Judging is in no way part inherent.

Reindeersnooker · 13/12/2022 16:33

Annie232 · 13/12/2022 16:30

Your wife doesn't sound very pleasant tbh

I'd like to think we're not all like that she you just got a wrong un. Maybe she was worried you would admire them if she didn't point out the flaws. No woman I know talks like that.

Reindeersnooker · 13/12/2022 16:31

I find the worst are people who had children thirty or forty years ago - long enough to forget the inconvenient mistakes but recently enough to remember everything they did right and tell you.

Also childfree people who really should be having children because they seem, on listening to them, to be the only people safe to have children and not bring them up as grabby narcissists.

Annie232 · 13/12/2022 16:30

TheWhalrus · 13/12/2022 14:28

Coming from the perspective of a dad here (because I am one). I have to say I definitely notice this a fair bit. I don't understand why this happens exactly, although 'mum-upmanship' could be one explanation. You do see it in other areas as well: for example on holidays before children, DW used to love judging other women's bodies at the beach. Even the fairly normal bodies seemed to draw criticism, although she never, ever said anything about the men: even men with huge guts who nonetheless insisted on wearing speedos.

Dads, of course, come with many other undesirable characteristics, although i've never seen this particular one play out. If anything we tend to be reasonably understanding of each other's child-related problems. Supportive may be going a bit far, but we don't judge like some women do.

Your wife doesn't sound very pleasant tbh

FourTeaFallOut · 13/12/2022 16:28

Funkyblues101 · 13/12/2022 16:18

I think it's all based in nature: "bad parenting" could ultimately result in the species dying out, so judginess is there to ensure mothers (both parents nowadays) tow/toe (?) the line. Obviously nowadays, in Britain, children can get cold and generally warm up easily, stupid behaviour is often easily fixed in a hospital. Whereas before the above could very easily result in death so needed to be frowned on, consistently. Similarly, men being judged for lack of sporting ability (as referenced by a male PP) all stems from sporting ability being vital for catching meat.

Oh please, let's not pretend there is a genetic imperative for survival when it comes to judginess that isn't more simply explained by the jolt of dopamine which is experienced when you consider yourself better than someone else.

Brunilde · 13/12/2022 16:25

@Cinnabomb I said there are a few exception. Obviously in your case you would fall into that. Yes I wouldn't know and would probably judge silently, but you'd never know so it wouldn't make any difference at all. I keep my thoughts to myself and don't throw dirty looks at anyone.

But I think we all know there are a large number of parents who do throw a screen in front of their kids at every opportunity because they can't be arsed. And yes it makes my life harder because I have to explain to a 3 year old that he can't have a tablet at the dinner table and can't run around a restaurant getting in the way when other kids are. So whilst none of my business it does affect me.