Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL gifts weird/controlling

189 replies

Santaslittlehelper83 · 13/12/2022 10:25

I may be massively over thinking this and should just see it as a kind and generous act ..but something is rubbing me up the wrong way about this. Just for context MIL has a history of controlling and manipulative behaviour, but generally relations have been fine recently. So...we have DS2 who is 4 months old. Whenever MIL visits she brings things like nappies/wipes/toiletries. We haven't asked for this and they are always the wrong size or brands we don't use (think highly perfumed wipes etc) . We have been gracious, sometimes accepted the gift as may be able to use, but sometimes politely let her know we wouldn't be able to use as wrong size or brand gives DS rash.

On the last visit I think I was abrupt and asked her to please not to buy these items for DS as we know what size/brand are suitable, and otherwise it is a waste. It's not like we can't afford these things ourselves and she has never asked us what would be useful/needed. Just something really rubs me up the wrong way about this, but I am massively sleep deprived. DH is in agreement that it is weird. AIBU?

OP posts:
Dreamsoffreedomjoyandpeace · 13/12/2022 12:33

Why not just say ‘MIL thank you so much for the nappies. The last ones were a bit big so we’ve put them away for now. Would it be possible to buy *? Those ones seem to fit nicely. I’ll write it down for you because the nappy aisle can be difficult to navigate because there’s such a big range’.

Use the baby wipes for cleaning.

pattihews · 13/12/2022 12:28

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/12/2022 11:22

As the mother of a son I honestly dread the day he may marry a woman who despises me because I have the temerity to buy nappies. MILs of women cannot win.

If this was your mum OP would it also be controlling

Yes — and as a MIL you're likely to be judged if you turn up empty-handed, or if you turn up at all, or if you don't turn up...

35 years ago my sister gave birth unexpectedly several weeks early. My parents were away at the opposite end of the country and unable to get back to visit her for a couple of days and she still holds it against them, even though they have both been dead for years. Apparently my mum arrived with a supplies for the baby and my sister and a picnic including a fruit cake. My sister was furious because she didn't like fruit cake and the nappies etc weren't the brand she'd decided to use. Mum just wanted to be helpful and to create as little pressure on my sister as possible.

GaslighterDenier · 13/12/2022 12:24

TinFoilHatty · 13/12/2022 11:31

Going against the grain a bit, I think she is deliberately making more work for you. She has been asked nicely to stop, it isn't helpful to clutter up your home with stuff you can't use. Your new little family has to work out who to donate the stuff to, and actually take it there. She is being really unkind, your husband needs to tell her to stop. Give her it back each time. She doesn't REALLY want to exacerbate baby's sore skin now, does she?

I have to agree with this tbh. I don't want other people's things in my house, I don't want to have to get rid of them, I don't want to think about taking them them somewhere out of my way to drop them off. I have asked you politely not to bring anything, it's as simple as that.

I also have a MIL who sounds very similar so know how you feel and honestly I've said 1000 times not to bring something everytime she visits. I would rather she actually spoke to my children instead of spending the whole time looking at her phone but thinking she's the best because they kids went nuts when she arrived as she bought them yet more tat! (Most of it broken or missing pieces from the charity shop)

Knittingnanny2 · 13/12/2022 12:01

I agree, if it’s the only annoying thing I would smile and donate them.
Im a MIL and I’m sure this has probably happened to me! Although I do try my best to only buy stuff I know they need or use. If I get it wrong and they mention it I’m perfectly happy for them to donate it. It’s not a big deal/problem.
Unless she’s on a tight budget.

Greengagesnfennel · 13/12/2022 12:00

I don't think it is controlling of her.

A bit controlling by you in that you want to be the boss of the precise brand she gifts. (Sorry op that's a bit pfb behaviour) But if you are tired and have a bit of a history with her maybe it is difficult to find the headspace to empathise with her.

EndlessRain1 · 13/12/2022 11:56

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/12/2022 11:55

We have this too and while on one hand we can just give the unwanted stuff to the food bank, on the other hand it is a type of controlling behaviour. The implication that we can't afford to buy our own very basic foodstuffs is also a bit offensive. Think things like onions and tinned tomatoes. The time he bought us a car was the last straw. It was from the police auction. I told him we didn't want that car as it was too small and had no service history. He tried to tell me we didn't need a bigger car. We refused to pick it up from his house and eventually he gave it to another relative. It needed a new engine a month later and they paid 3k in repairs. I mean obviously the offer of a car could be a kind gesture but it's the attitude of "you can't afford or choose your own car" that is the problem. The way to help would be to give some money towards it (not that we asked for or needed help but would have been grateful if offered). But he wouldn't do that as he thinks he knows best.

The implication that we can't afford to buy our own very basic foodstuffs is also a bit offensive.

This is SUCH a strange and twisted way to see gifts/ intended help. Do you also consider offers to childcare as implied that you can't look after your own children?

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/12/2022 11:55

We have this too and while on one hand we can just give the unwanted stuff to the food bank, on the other hand it is a type of controlling behaviour. The implication that we can't afford to buy our own very basic foodstuffs is also a bit offensive. Think things like onions and tinned tomatoes. The time he bought us a car was the last straw. It was from the police auction. I told him we didn't want that car as it was too small and had no service history. He tried to tell me we didn't need a bigger car. We refused to pick it up from his house and eventually he gave it to another relative. It needed a new engine a month later and they paid 3k in repairs. I mean obviously the offer of a car could be a kind gesture but it's the attitude of "you can't afford or choose your own car" that is the problem. The way to help would be to give some money towards it (not that we asked for or needed help but would have been grateful if offered). But he wouldn't do that as he thinks he knows best.

Nirvanarama · 13/12/2022 11:53

My MIL used to do this, I would smile say thank you and put them in the food bank collection next time I went to the supermarket. The charity shop tat she bought round (and continues to bring round) is much more annoying.

Hopeyoursproutsarealreadyon · 13/12/2022 11:52

Urgh my ils were like this bringing wipes! . When we had 2 x dc close together they were keen to buy us a double buggy. Very much appreciated.. But they wanted to chose it!
Weeks of them touring pram shops.. This was post birth. Dh told them either we all went or we would just buy one ourselves.. They eventually met us at a shop and I chose one.
Now mil had no chance in Hell of managing a double buggy. She was less than 5 foot and about 6 stone.
Control ime op.

Horsesandzebras · 13/12/2022 11:49

Someone I know does this. She does it so she can say she did something and you were ungrateful. Manipulative behaviour.

TheLittlestLightOnTheXmasTree · 13/12/2022 11:48

Waiting for a massive drip feed now...

paintitallover · 13/12/2022 11:48

You were abrupt over an unwanted gift? Wow. That's so rude.

SleeplessInEngland · 13/12/2022 11:45

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/12/2022 11:22

As the mother of a son I honestly dread the day he may marry a woman who despises me because I have the temerity to buy nappies. MILs of women cannot win.

If this was your mum OP would it also be controlling

As long as your son's future wife isn't on mumsnet - where everyone will tell her that you're the devil - you'll probably be alright.

YellowTreeHouse · 13/12/2022 11:44

YABU and you’re being precious.

I am very much doubting all the different brands she’s bringing gives your PFB a rash, I think that’s an excuse so you don’t sound as ungrateful, but even if they did, just donate to a baby/food bank.

It’s not a waste at all.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/12/2022 11:42

Sounds a kind enough gesture and not really a hill to die on, IMO. Don't sweat the small stuff.

Even so, if you've asked her to stop then she should.

Blossomtoes · 13/12/2022 11:41

miceonabranch · 13/12/2022 10:28

Just accept them then donate them to a food bank. She's happy, the food bank are happy and you don't have to have the house cluttered up with random stuff.

This. She thinks she’s being helpful. Or of course you could ask her to buy the right brand as her crystal ball is malfunctioning.

Brightstarowl · 13/12/2022 11:40

TinFoilHatty · 13/12/2022 11:31

Going against the grain a bit, I think she is deliberately making more work for you. She has been asked nicely to stop, it isn't helpful to clutter up your home with stuff you can't use. Your new little family has to work out who to donate the stuff to, and actually take it there. She is being really unkind, your husband needs to tell her to stop. Give her it back each time. She doesn't REALLY want to exacerbate baby's sore skin now, does she?

Being unkind by buying stuff for her grandchild....

I've heard it all now! 😭

takealettermsjones · 13/12/2022 11:39

I actually know what you mean OP. I struggle a lot with this kind of thing. My MIL bought my DD shoes, and for various reasons (all to do with me/my childhood), I immediately felt like she was implying that I couldn't provide for my child. She wasn't, she was just trying to be nice, but I totally understand how someone providing "everyday" items as gifts can make you feel. I think the clutter thing would annoy me too but I think that's a secondary issue!

Brightstarowl · 13/12/2022 11:38

Imagine getting annoyed at this....

Use the perfumed wipes to clean the baby's hands....it's not a big deal surely.

I think you're the one being weird.

TinFoilHatty · 13/12/2022 11:31

Going against the grain a bit, I think she is deliberately making more work for you. She has been asked nicely to stop, it isn't helpful to clutter up your home with stuff you can't use. Your new little family has to work out who to donate the stuff to, and actually take it there. She is being really unkind, your husband needs to tell her to stop. Give her it back each time. She doesn't REALLY want to exacerbate baby's sore skin now, does she?

Pieministers · 13/12/2022 11:25

Mil is constantly buying us food, despite us asking her not to. It sounds generous, but it’s actually her indulging a shopping habit by buying things to give away. It’s almost always stuff we never eat or wouldn’t buy, so I end up giving most of it to food banks. I would just do the same with the stuff she gives you.

ThinWomansBrain · 13/12/2022 11:24

Probably intends to be helpful and more useful than arriving with unnecessary gift of toys for child every visit - give what you can't use to a foodbank.
Weird but probably well intentioned - but can't really see how it's controlling.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/12/2022 11:24

I also think people who have tiny babies and may not realise how much they will need childcare for the next 18 years shouldn’t burn their bridges so early with loved ones.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/12/2022 11:22

As the mother of a son I honestly dread the day he may marry a woman who despises me because I have the temerity to buy nappies. MILs of women cannot win.

If this was your mum OP would it also be controlling

thistimelastweek · 13/12/2022 11:20

I suspect she just likes buying baby stuff. Makes her feel like a granny.