Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL gifts weird/controlling

189 replies

Santaslittlehelper83 · 13/12/2022 10:25

I may be massively over thinking this and should just see it as a kind and generous act ..but something is rubbing me up the wrong way about this. Just for context MIL has a history of controlling and manipulative behaviour, but generally relations have been fine recently. So...we have DS2 who is 4 months old. Whenever MIL visits she brings things like nappies/wipes/toiletries. We haven't asked for this and they are always the wrong size or brands we don't use (think highly perfumed wipes etc) . We have been gracious, sometimes accepted the gift as may be able to use, but sometimes politely let her know we wouldn't be able to use as wrong size or brand gives DS rash.

On the last visit I think I was abrupt and asked her to please not to buy these items for DS as we know what size/brand are suitable, and otherwise it is a waste. It's not like we can't afford these things ourselves and she has never asked us what would be useful/needed. Just something really rubs me up the wrong way about this, but I am massively sleep deprived. DH is in agreement that it is weird. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HeckyPeck · 08/04/2023 15:09

Totalwasteofpaper · 08/04/2023 15:03

Yabu.

My mum does this. Totally well meaning and actually attempting to be helpful.

We just said thanks and said generally we use X brand. she started buying those.
Or if too big I'd keep them until shes bigger.

Highly scented wipes are still good for feeding time or wiping hands when out and about.

I think the difference is that your mum listened to you and bought the things you actually use, rather than OP's MIL who keeps getting things knowing they aren't useful.

HeckyPeck · 08/04/2023 15:08

JassyRadlett · 29/12/2022 08:52

You'd check first about the right size and brand, though, right? That would be the kind and normal thing to do.

Exactly. I like to buy things for my nieces and nephews, but if my brother/SIL said the things weren't the right size or weren't being used for any reason, I'd make sure to buy the right ones next time. I'd rather than than they pretended to like them, but secretly gave them to a food bank.

It's really weird and wasteful to keep buying things you have been told aren't useful.

Totalwasteofpaper · 08/04/2023 15:03

Yabu.

My mum does this. Totally well meaning and actually attempting to be helpful.

We just said thanks and said generally we use X brand. she started buying those.
Or if too big I'd keep them until shes bigger.

Highly scented wipes are still good for feeding time or wiping hands when out and about.

cobden28 · 08/04/2023 14:49

When my daughter was born in 1991 I would dearly have loved to receive a stack of decent quality terry nappies from my Mum (I'm an only child), but she never thought to ask what we wanted for our baby. She offered to buy us a big coachbuilt pram, which we didn't have room for and which we'd never use as I was returning to full time work after my maternity leave; when i told her we'd already got a decnt second-hand pram/pushchair combo anyway she seemed offended. When I was 8 months pregnant and getting too big to fit behind the steering wheel of my little Mini she offered to take me out on a shopping trip 'to buy something for the baby' but this was also on the hottest day of the year and at 8 months pregnant to traipse round the shops on a scorching hot day was the last thing I wanted to do, so I told mum blkuntly 'no thanks' and suggested that packs of all-in-one stretchsuits and lots of baby underwear would be most useful. Wehn Mum visited me in hospital when daughter was 2 days old (we live in a differnt city to mum) she tried to give us a large package of baby items which I'd toldd her NOT to bring to the hospital as there wasn't any room to safely store it, but suggested she drop the parcel at our home on the way back. At the time, Mum and my ex weren't on speaking terms so Mum refused to drop off said package at our home and until daighter was three months old she kept pressuring us to accept the package of baby items. It turned out that the package contained lots of frilly pink dresses for a newborn which we didn't want and would never use anyway - that's why we specified stretchsuits, underwear and terry nappies as this was what we needed in preference .

We ended up buying most of daughter's clothes from charity shops as only i was working at the time, or my knitting lots of things.

JassyRadlett · 31/12/2022 19:48

Jccox0911 · 31/12/2022 05:35

This is very typical behavior for a new parent. It's your first child and you want everything to be "perfect". You want everything to be what you have picked or decided for the little one. By the time you have a second one this will either all go away or die down a lot. Your mil is just being kind. Now, if she was pushing for you to use them then it would be weird.

Nah. If you've got a kids with skinny legs, or one who's prone to rashes, or whatever, once you find a brand of wipes/nappies/cream that don't lead to bleeding nappy rash/eczema on their hands/poo explosions every time you stick to it like glue, regardless of whether it's your first or your tenth.

In fact for your later children you're more likely to refuse to deviate from What Works because you are older and wiser and less likely to give into the 'kindness' of the apparently well-meaning.

Blackcat10 · 31/12/2022 17:47

If she knows the brands, type, size that you like and still buys whatever she wants then you have a valid argument. If that's the case, then you should say you will not accept these. That's a power play on her part.

Jccox0911 · 31/12/2022 05:35

This is very typical behavior for a new parent. It's your first child and you want everything to be "perfect". You want everything to be what you have picked or decided for the little one. By the time you have a second one this will either all go away or die down a lot. Your mil is just being kind. Now, if she was pushing for you to use them then it would be weird.

Baconbgr · 30/12/2022 05:32

Santaslittlehelper83 · 13/12/2022 10:25

I may be massively over thinking this and should just see it as a kind and generous act ..but something is rubbing me up the wrong way about this. Just for context MIL has a history of controlling and manipulative behaviour, but generally relations have been fine recently. So...we have DS2 who is 4 months old. Whenever MIL visits she brings things like nappies/wipes/toiletries. We haven't asked for this and they are always the wrong size or brands we don't use (think highly perfumed wipes etc) . We have been gracious, sometimes accepted the gift as may be able to use, but sometimes politely let her know we wouldn't be able to use as wrong size or brand gives DS rash.

On the last visit I think I was abrupt and asked her to please not to buy these items for DS as we know what size/brand are suitable, and otherwise it is a waste. It's not like we can't afford these things ourselves and she has never asked us what would be useful/needed. Just something really rubs me up the wrong way about this, but I am massively sleep deprived. DH is in agreement that it is weird. AIBU?

Honestly, I've dealt with a MIL like this and I swear they do this on purpose. just say MIL, thank you, I appreciate you getting these for DS but he's unable to use these because of X,Y,Z reason and that you'll have to give them to someone who can use them. Then she can decide what she wants to do. You're not arguing, or being disrespectful, you're just being honest with her. Or you can do what some others say and just ignore it.

JassyRadlett · 29/12/2022 08:52

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/12/2022 11:22

As the mother of a son I honestly dread the day he may marry a woman who despises me because I have the temerity to buy nappies. MILs of women cannot win.

If this was your mum OP would it also be controlling

You'd check first about the right size and brand, though, right? That would be the kind and normal thing to do.

thecedes · 29/12/2022 08:42

"Forget the shrinks" is extremely disrespectful to those (including myself) who've written about behaviours that can be driven by underlying mental health conditions. Encouraging OP to give as good as she gets literally achieves nothing, aggravates the situation further, and wouldn't be particularly great for her partner. But sure, she should listen to you because, for no explicable reason, you seem to think you know better than others who've shared genuinely relevant insight and who've tried to be understanding.

keysgirl01 · 29/12/2022 00:36

Just saw this. Forget the shrinks talking.
Your mil is absolutely bringing brands and useless items over to be an a**.
When people have been told that the stuff that they bring over is not used or wanted; they are disrespecting you.
If she wanted to be helpful. She would be bringing items you use.
Leave them next to the door, and when she leaves make a big deal of carrying it all to her car so she can take it to good will on her way home since she can't seem to understand what you use. So that SHE can help someone out with it. You just can't find the time since YOU are the one with the baby.
Make sure you tell her that SOMEONE will be able to use them since you have told her you don't. Just very firmly add can't and won't to the statement.
There is nothing nice or thoughtful about what she is doing.
She's being an A**. Treat her like one.

BigMama32 · 27/12/2022 21:27

Sounds like she has good intentions, agree with the others just donate or use an app like peanut to say you have these items available to give someone in need

Ramsbottom · 27/12/2022 20:53

I don’t think controlling means what you think it means op.

nonamesleftatall · 27/12/2022 20:51

I haven’t read all the pages however I think you sound rather controlling. When my daughter was born my mother in law bought me a packet of nappies and wipes every week when she did her shoppping. I used pampers nappies but she often bought boots brand. She bought what ever wipes were on offer and I accepted both graciously and used them. Use the perfumed wipes for hands? Use the nappies for lighter use in the day? You also sound really snobby and brand judgemental. Many people wouod be incredibly grateful of these items so donate if you don’t want them. We are ina cost of living crisis so she is probably trying to be helpful.

coronafiona · 17/12/2022 19:52

She is probably of the generation who struggled financially when babies were born - my mum is like this. 20% interest rates and no maternity so had to give up work.
She's buying you practical things to make it easier on you. Accept it or politely hint that something else would help, cooking you dinner or doing the ironing or something.
Be kind.

Hadtochangeforthisone · 17/12/2022 18:51

Interesting that you only reply to the person who kinda agrees with you..

You are massively precious from my POV .. donate them if you don't like them .. everyone wins !!

N1no · 17/12/2022 18:44

Little suggestion for the rush. I am guessing you don’t want to do cloth nappies because of the extra work, however, I can recommend silk liners. I got mine from Disana (in Germany). You can lay them inside disposable nappies. They really help the healing. You still have to wash them either by hand or on a delicate program.

N1no · 17/12/2022 18:29

I understand how you feel. The presents feel like a hint how you should be doing things and what brands you should be buying in her eyes. This means it is or it feels like a lesson.
Are you sure she is trying to educate you or she is just not able to take enough care when choosing a size and brand?

i have encountered both. A friend of mine regularly buys clothes for DD in a selection of sizes. Size and season don’t really match even though I tell her what size she is currently or how much smaller she is compared to the age indicated in the garments. However, it’s all meant well.

Unfortunately, my stepmother buys our “poor” DD new clothes because her awful parents have chosen to buy her mainly second hand clothes or use borrowed/ handed down clothes for environmental reasons and because of the chemicals contained in new garments. She knows this, it’s what I do for a living (research and lecturing on the impact of the fashion industry). There are many more things I or we are doing wrong: breastfeed too often, using a car seat which puts her in a seated position instead of laying her in the car, not feeding enough solides, doing a combination of baby lead weaning and purées instead of purée only, not bathing her every day, giving her to a childminder instead of me staying home for 3 years, her sitting and standing up early however it’s not a problem that she also walked early, and there will be much more. I’m bracing myself for the Christmas holidays.

i think it’s only worth firing the battle if your case is like the latter. Otherwise, a donation is the best you can do.

Good luck!

thecedes · 16/12/2022 13:52

Brightstarowl · 13/12/2022 11:40

Being unkind by buying stuff for her grandchild....

I've heard it all now! 😭

I get what you mean, and in general, I do think MIL is trying to be helpful and not controlling. But, these care items are really for the parents, surely? That's an important difference here, I think, it's not a 'gift' as such. Possibly it's better for MIL to ask 'is there anything that you need?' before buying things that might otherwise be unhelpful, and ultimately a waste of her money too.

OP - I also sympathize with you, one of my parents has a shopping addiction and behaves like this and it can be frustrating, particularly after you have explained multiple times and it carries on regardless. Then you have to work out what to do with it, as very often it's seen as an insult to refuse/ask to swap it. However, I honestly don't think it is a control thing, or any sort of message about you not being able to provide for your child. With my parent, I believe it stems from not having much when they were a child. Might be worth sitting down with your partner and talking through what deeper psychology could be behind it. I've found that to help me have a more empathic response over the frustration I used to feel.

Autumn61 · 16/12/2022 00:51

“Thank you Mil, that’s so kind of you.” Then give them to charity you ungrateful woman

Blossomtoes · 15/12/2022 23:39

She even took it upon herself to buy us a stair gate even though we'd made the decision not to have one!

So she basically cares more about your child’s safety than you do. I think I might keep quiet about that if I were you.

Kjpt140v · 15/12/2022 23:26

Take these things to the food bank.

Dizzybet74 · 15/12/2022 17:27

My MIL used to do the same and it also annoyed me. Same thing buying brands we didn't use, would have been better to give vouchers for somewhere. She even took it upon herself to buy us a stair gate even though we'd made the decision not to have one! Massively controlling. One Christmas she thought it'd be a good idea to get me some diet books too!!! Grrrr

10HailMarys · 15/12/2022 13:39

You said nothing and 'graciously accepted' these items for ages and then suddenly you were 'abrupt'?

Basically, you let her think for ages that you were happy to receive these items and then suddenly snapped at her for doing something she'd been led to believe was welcome. I don't think your MIL is at fault here and I don't think it's controlling of her to bring these things over - she probably thought it was helpful and useful, and until now you hadn't suggested otherwise.

bridgetreilly · 15/12/2022 12:20

It sounds to me like she’s actually trying to be generous in a thoughtful way, just not quite getting it right. She isn’t spoiling him, she isn’t filling your house with huge or noisy toys, she isn’t piling up handwash only clothes. You don’t have to put this stuff on display whenever she comes. Just let it go and, as others have said, stick it in the back of the car and put it in the foodbank collection next time you go to the supermarket.