Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Religious friend says my mums in hell!

331 replies

Rosiesmydog · 13/12/2022 10:18

Excuse the rather hysterical subject title! She didn’t actually say she is, only that she may be…
context: my mum died last month. She was 99 and very frail. She had Covid. That’s on the DC but afaic she died of extreme old age.
I met with a very good friend of mine last night. GF is very religious…I’m absolutely not. I don’t believe in the hereafter or god or any other deity. GF knows this but tolerates my ungodliness. GF offered condolences and let me rabbit on about my mum. All well and good…
I spoke about the funeral, how we had a celebrant but had a hymn as my mum did have a little bit of faith and did a lot with the church when I was a kid. However, my mum was often hard work and I jokingly made a throwaway remark about how I used to tell her she’d never go to heaven and she’d end up in hell (all in jest).

last night I got a msg from her, basically saying that if mum hadnt accepted Jesus as lord and saviour then she will be in hell and that I should accept him or I’ll end up there…
really don’t know how to respond to this! Feeling quite upset that GF has judged my mum by her standards and chooses to lecture me about my ungodliness. Seems very unchristian really given the circs.
just looking for some words of wisdom from you folks I guess. I don’t want to break a friendship, she’s always known how I feel about religion but I think she’s crossed a line here and I feel quite conflicted. Im tempted to just ignore and sweep it under the carpet, but it’s blighted what was a good friendship and at a difficult time for me, given my recent loss 😔. I now realise that joking about heaven and hell to a committed Christian is a big no no!

OP posts:
5128gap · 13/12/2022 13:16

Mittens1717 · 13/12/2022 13:09

This, if you dont believe in hell then surely you know your mum is not there, just tell your friend theres no such thing as hell

I don't believe in hell either so would not be upset that there may be truth in it. Rather that a good friend thought it appropriate to judge my mum and to respond to my grief with something pointless, cruel and highly likely to upset me further.

Eyerollcentral · 13/12/2022 13:16

OP is your friend a born-again Christian? I have a few born again friends and while they are genuinely lovely people who would do anything they could to help someone and see that as their duty, they also see it as their duty, being saved, to evangelise and tell those around them about salvation. As another poster referred to upthread I am also a Catholic and they don’t regard me as saved. Several have tried to get me to attend meetings, etc in the hope of saving my soul. I don’t agree with the posters saying these kind of people are indoctrinated, some may be, in the case of every one I know in fact they have thought deeply about their faith and live it through their daily lives. That said it is wildly insensitive to say that about your recently departed mum. As back to front as it sounds this friend will think she is being a loving friend by telling you to accept Christ, otherwise you are damned.

Frabbits · 13/12/2022 13:16

Mittens1717 · 13/12/2022 13:09

This, if you dont believe in hell then surely you know your mum is not there, just tell your friend theres no such thing as hell

Is it honestly so hard to understand why, even if you don't believe in it, having someone tell you your mother in hell is an utterly wankerish thing to do?

newnamequickly · 13/12/2022 13:15

It's a good thing God isn't religious. This man made stuff is hurtful, inaccurate and not helpful in the slightest.

I do happen to believe in God but I also believe in the thousand steps to unconsciousness after the body has departed this earth. In any one of these steps a person can acknowledge God. Your friends' beliefs are standard Christian beliefs trotted out time and time again.

I stopped going to church in 1987. I still believe in God. I just don't find the traditional Christian way very representative of the God I know.

antelopevalley · 13/12/2022 13:11

Tell her you forgive her for her sin. Although you realise only God can decide whether to forgive her or not.

Siriusmuggle · 13/12/2022 13:11

Unacceptable and unforgivable. This is one of my major objections to religion.

Mittens1717 · 13/12/2022 13:09

HikingforScenery · 13/12/2022 10:31

Also, as you’re absolutely sure there’s no hell, why are you upset? Why not just chalk her comments down to ‘silly beliefs’?

This, if you dont believe in hell then surely you know your mum is not there, just tell your friend theres no such thing as hell

Ch3wylemon · 13/12/2022 13:09

MsProbably · 13/12/2022 13:00

There's a real push sometimes on these threads to 'sever all contact immedietly' or reject someone after one mistake - but it's completely fine and normal to call up a friend on something that hurt you, and you should do. And it might even build on the honesty and openness in your friendship and make it better, not worse.

I think sometimes people say things that are so offensive that there is no friendship to recover. In this case the so called friend went home and considered her response and sent an especially cruel text to someone recently bereaved.

If I believed in hell I know who I think belongs there.

OldFan · 13/12/2022 13:08

really don’t know how to respond to this! Feeling quite upset that GF has judged my mum by her standards and chooses to lecture me about my ungodliness. Seems very unchristian really given the circs.

Them's the rules- the rules aren't subjective. Maybe she thought it might encourage you to accept Jesus if she said that. But she shouldn'tve said that, it was tactless. Maybe she thought you felt that way as you mentioned it in a light/joking/in response to your mum's behaviour in the past.

Heatherjayne1972 · 13/12/2022 13:05

Oh my. I’m so sorry op.

your ‘friend’ was very much out of order saying that
I believe God looks at heart of an individual person - If there’s any ‘judging’ to be done.

RedToothBrush · 13/12/2022 13:05

Shes not your friend.
Nor is she a Christian.

Tell her she won't get to Heaven for her judgment and distressing you at a sensitive time.

MsProbably · 13/12/2022 13:00

There's a real push sometimes on these threads to 'sever all contact immedietly' or reject someone after one mistake - but it's completely fine and normal to call up a friend on something that hurt you, and you should do. And it might even build on the honesty and openness in your friendship and make it better, not worse.

Iamnotausername · 13/12/2022 13:00

What a horrible, horrible person. There is no excuse for her to say that. She sent it by text so can't even say it was clumsily worded.

I am angry on your behalf.

You sound like you want to keep her in your life though so what do you need to happen to do that?

capricorn12 · 13/12/2022 12:59

My father in law said this about my mum at my mum's funeral. When he dies I'm going to go and do a big shit on his grave. I wouldn't bother with her again.

Herejustforthisone · 13/12/2022 12:59

Christian she ain’t. She’s a fundamentalist. Emphasis on the final three syllables. What sort of a decent person would tell a friend their recently deceased mother was in hell as she didn’t accept Jesus as her lord and saviour? A fucking shit one.

Chooksnroses · 13/12/2022 12:54

A few years ago I started attending our local Free Church. They put on a play called "Heaven's Gates and Hell's Flames" which was horrific in the extreme (saying what your friend said). I haven't been back to church since. I am a Christian. I believe in an afterlife. I also believe what I read once, that the popular definition of hell was a mistranslation, and that Hell simply means "underground". So, in other words, buried. People like your friend and my old church have elaborated over the generations, and created the fires of hell in order to keep people in line. I refuse to believe that your Mum or mine are being subject to anything other than Heaven, (In my belief) or nothing (in your belief). I'm so sorry for your loss. I do think you should tell your friend you are upset, but bear in mind that to her, the thought of you going to hell when she could potentially save you is also upsetting.

HedgehogB · 13/12/2022 12:53

Ok. So I’m a committed Christian. What your friend said was not only unacceptable, it’s wrong. My cousin is a C of E vicar. I expressed some worries to her about my dad (her uncle) when he died as an atheist at 80. She said God sees all sides of us. No one good can ‘go to hell’ and it’s not really a concept the Church pushes now - just that God loves and forgives us all. She also said that ‘there are many opportunities to meet God’ even after death. It’s just maybe that very committed Christians get a bit nearer in heaven! If your relative was a nice kind person it’s highly unlikely they are in anything other than a peaceful place. Tell your friend that if she goes around talking like that she should remind herself of what the bible says about judging others!! Don’t give her silly mean words another thought x

Glasgow1985 · 13/12/2022 12:51

Block and delete.

Sometimes good people say stupid things. Sometimes bad people out themselves with a one-off horrendous comment.

She's in group two. She's entitled to her opinions but had shown an extreme lack of empathy.

Lobelia123 · 13/12/2022 12:51

What a narrow minded and bigoted religious bore. As far as I know, every religion in the world from Islam to Christianity to Judaism teaches that God is a god of love. Theres nothing loving about her vile message. Id find it very hard to overlook how she's used a deeply sad and vulnerable time in your life to try to hammer home her own agenda in the most crass way. This is not what God wants.

Velvetween · 13/12/2022 12:51

WinterLobelia · 13/12/2022 10:24

I would write back and say 'Your comments were both inappropriate and gratuitously hurtful. I feel that I might need some space from you for the foreseeable future'.

You do not need a person like this in your life.

This ^^ all the way.

m You are entitled to make the heaven and hell joke in the midst of your grief. She is bang out of order to go home, have a think, type out that text and send it. Christian my ass.

Fraaahnces · 13/12/2022 12:50

You could write back that while you respect her right to her beliefs, sharing them in such a manner when someone is in the midst of grief is an act of cruelty. Your mother’s faith doesn’t matter now because she’s dead. You were the recipient of that message and received the wound instead.

FTY765 · 13/12/2022 12:49

I know it doesn't matter much if you don'y believe in heaven and hell, but Christians don't (or shouldn't) believe they can judge the actions of another person and how God will judge them. Only God can judge. Plus, Jesus himself said one only needs a tiny bit of faith.
That said, it was a truly awful thing to say and I wouldn't even bother to respond or speak to her again myself.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 13/12/2022 12:49

I'm also completely 100% athiest.

But if she were Christian she'd know only God can judge, it is not her place.

So she should wind her flipping neck in.

SleepingStandingUp · 13/12/2022 12:48

Dear Friens
I'm Feeling quite upset that <you have> judged my mum by <your> standards and chooses to lecture me about my ungodliness. Seems very unchristian really given the circs.
I don’t want to break a friendship, <you've> always known how I feel about religion but I think <you've> crossed a line here and I feel quite conflicted. I'm tempted to just ignore and sweep it under the carpet, but it’s blighted what was a good friendship and at a difficult time for me, given my recent loss

That's what I'd be sending her. What you've written in your op

5128gap · 13/12/2022 12:48

What a horrible cruel thing to say.
I think your friend has badly misunderstood both her religion and her role as a Christian. I'd be suggesting she had a chat with her religious leader, who might be able to offer her some guidance on empathy, decency and kindness.