Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else cry over their bills?

107 replies

insanegasbill · 13/12/2022 08:16

Got our monthly energy bill this morning.

£525. For one month.

I honestly cried. I can't remember the last time I cried over a bill. How is this even possible?!

Last month it was £390 ish which was bad enough so we budgeted around £400 for this month and our usage seemed to be very similar.

We are both employed with good jobs and we are sinking with these ridiculous outgoings.

In January our rent will be £900 as it's going up.

So we are looking at £1400 ish just for rent, gas and electricity come January.

Heating is on a timer and we really do try to limit it, we've been using electric plug in heaters as much as possible instead.

AIBU that this just isn't sustainable? I just needed somewhere to get that out and scream into the void...... What's the actual point of working as hard as we do to be struggling like this? 😢

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NoMoneyForFancyStuff · 14/12/2022 08:51

It has to be your plug in electric heater. We pay less to use central heating in a 5 bedroom home. Also WFH and have the heating on all day.

Cheesuswithallama · 14/12/2022 07:53

Note, price cap is average, it differs depending on areas, few p ul and down

Proudboomer · 14/12/2022 07:05

This thread really shows how little people understand the current price cap and energy costs. There will be no cheaper providers to switch to so unless you are on a pre price increase fix we are all being charged roughly the same under Energy Price Guarantee - From 1 October 2022
Electricity

£0.34 per/kWh
Daily standing charge: £0. 46

Gas
£0.10 per kWh
Daily standing charge: £0. 28

electric heaters are all 100% efficient in that all electric used gets turned into heat but the cost and how much heat you get is going to be down to the wattage of the heater a 1kw heater will be 34p an hour for 1 kw of heat, 2 kw heater 68p for 2kw of heat. Oil filled or halogen makes no difference as it’s all down to the wattage. They just work in different ways. Oil filled is radiant heat so heats the air around you and if it’s high enough wattage the room. Halogen is directional heat so heats what’s in front of it not the air.
using electric heaters will always be more expensive than gas because electricity per kw is 3 times the cost of gas.
stop using the electric heaters and set you timer so it comes on when you need it as low as you can stand it or as high as you can afford. Put your trvs to 3. Don’t turn your flow rate down to low in this cold weather as your radiator s will never warm your rooms and the thermostat will never click off. The flow rate is the temperature of the water that flows around your heating system. You reduce that you of course Payless but you also get less heat. Turn it down if you want when this cold snap is over but not whilst it is -4 outside.
if you have smart meters then use your in home display to monitor your usage. Use your online account to track where you are using a lot and might be able to cut back. If you don’t have a home display then download one of the free appts like loop or Hugo and if you don’t have an online account make one.
smart meters very rarely go wrong. Usually if anyone has a problem it’s the in home display that’s not updated or not communicating but that’s not the meter so it’s very unlikely your bill isn’t correct.
I am using just over £20 per day of gas at the moment. Large house, 5 adults one of whom is elderly and disabled so I have and have always had high usage. This year I am using less but paying more as everything has tripled in price. Pay by direct debit so I build up credit in the summer when my usage is 1/4 of my winter usage so that the total cost is spread out over the year rather than having to find extra in winter. I also get a 5% discount on my unit price of energy for paying this way so might be worth doing but it won’t help you this year .

Grumpycatsmum · 14/12/2022 06:22

If you have a smart meter you can get readings broken down for every half hour if you ask the power company to do that.

I'd guess about third of that bill will be the electric heaters. We had to use them when our heating broke in January and they literally gobble energy.

Also don't use tumble dryer if you can avoid it.

If you have a condensing boiler (most people do) lower the flow temperature to about 50 or 60 degrees. See Flow temp. If you lower the temp and have heating on for longer you should save money.

stuntbubbles · 13/12/2022 14:39

That seems wildly high to me.

For context I’m also in an energy inefficient house – timber-built in parts with no insulation, gappy windows, etc. Both wfh all day and have small DC so boost the heating a lot, use a tumble dryer and dehumidifier a lot, have a stupid fridge. And have two electricity meters so two lots of standing charges.

Oct-Nov bill was less than half yours; predicted to be a bit higher now it’s got colder but nothing like that.

I think it’s the electric heaters and/or a meter problem.

Calmdown14 · 13/12/2022 14:32

Are you sure those figures are right?

It is very high.

As everyone else has said, electric heaters aren't cheap. I don't have gas so no choice but I'm on an economy 10 tariff to offset it a little (generally only available/sensible on an all electric system).

But even accounting for that it is a lot. What's the breakdown between electric and gas and how many KWh are you using?

Does the smart meter reading match the meter?

Do you have an immersion heater or something eating your electric?

Ginmonkeyagain · 13/12/2022 14:17

@insanegasbill if you have a smart meter you energy supplier may have an online app that allow you so see in graph from what your gas and electricity are costing you each day. You could run an experiment using your GCH one day and the electric heaters the next day to see the difference.

Robin233 · 13/12/2022 13:58

Before you do anything else STOP using the electric heaters
They are very expensive ti run.
Oil filled radiators are the best but still expensive
This is why people don't use them and have central heating which is way cheaper.
Are you taking daily readings?
I take mine EVERY day.
So far we are £200 odd ahead

holidayelbow · 13/12/2022 13:30

We are managing between £6-£10 a day depending on how cold. Use the electric heater every now and then but it has a thermostat. I wear my Oodie whilst working so heating is only on for a few hours a day.

November no heating at all. Bill was £150 for both gas & electric. Expect December to be around £300 but we have £100 in savings. Plus the £66.

StatisticallyChallenged · 13/12/2022 13:29

Both my current and past house were better with heating always on (and I tested carefully)

Current house is very well insulated and modern with an air source heat pump. It doesn't heat the radiators as hot as typical gas heating so takes quite a while to warm up from cold but once it's warm it's very good at maintaining temperature, just clicking on and off as needed.

My old house was the opposite, stone built and not very well insulated. We'd not had it long when the boiler broke down, temps dropped to 6 degrees inside. It took days to heat back up, it was like you had to warm the stone first! We tested always on (we did drop it a bit during day when we were out but only to about 18 vs 21) vs having it off during day and coning on say 6-8 and 4-9. For us, it was cheaper always on -the boiler would be running constantly to bring it up to temp from cold vs just firing on and off for short periods to keep it warm

Every house is different and it's something people should test

subtleartofnotgivingafuck · 13/12/2022 13:29

Trustmeimadoctor · 13/12/2022 09:26

Mine is much cheaper having a blast (1 hour) in the morning and a longer period (4 hours) in the evening than having it constantly for a lower temp. If you do this then keep an eye on the meter.

I have a smart meter and I did a test of this yesterday and today. GSH, 3 storey house in a inefficiently converted old hospital building. Big big windows (wooden but double glazed) and high ceilings. very old gas boiler, heating dial/sensor is on the ground floor which tends to be the coldest floor.

Yesterday, trying to save money - I had a 1 hour heat in the morning and a 2 hour stint in the late afternoon. Temps stayed pretty static - ground floor 14/middle 16/ top 17. In PJs, fluffy socks and hoodie - hot water bottle regularly topped up. WFH 'office' (box room lol) is on the middle floor and it feels colder being super sedentary. £10 gas for the day. It felt cold and uncomfortable all day

Today, dial set to 18 and continuous. no hoodies, no fluffy socks, no hot water bottles - house is sat at a steady even 18 on all floors and a little too warm if I am honest. £6 so far. So it seems to hold true that not having small stints works (for this house and our usage) - but ill run it over a few days to check

Tomorrow I will tinker with, dropping it to 17 and see how that goes.

Its worth experimenting in your own house within you own comfort zone to see what works for you you

BarbaraofSeville · 13/12/2022 13:27

DoraSpenlow · 13/12/2022 13:12

I truly don't mean this to be a boast but I am worried about our bills the other way.

About August time we were advised by our energy supplier to incease our monthly direct debit to £240 a month (gas and electric). Don't have a smart meter but DH submits monthly readings and we can then see online how much in debit/credit we are. We are now about £850 in credit, £100 up from last month! I don't understand it. This surely can't be right. Being careful with usage but certainly not going cold. I know there is a long way to go with winter yet but I'm really worried they are suddenly going to say something is wrong and we owe them hundreds of £.

If you're getting bills based on up to date and accurate meter readings, it could be right, but your credit probably won't last much longer. We're currently about £400 in credit, but I expect most of it will be gone in a couple of months, and we'll probably be in debt by Easter before paying it back over the summer.

However, in August, that could have been pre government protection, so if that was the time we were expecting typical use sized bills to be £3/4/5k pa, you might be overpaying a little.

Some providers only bill every 3-6 months, so you'll build up big credits in the time between billing.

Your bill should show your annual usage and you can work out how much it should cost and hence whether your DD is right:

www.moneysavingexpert.com/utilities/lower-energy-direct-debits/#calc

You could also be one of the minority still on an old cheaper fix, although most people have tipped over onto standard pricing now.

Squashpocket · 13/12/2022 13:16

We've just moved in to a new house which has electric underfloor heating in the part of the house that contains the dining table, so if we want somewhere for the kids to eat and do their homework we have to put the heating on in there for at least a couple of hours a day.

Our electricity bill was £650 this month.

It's not even warm with that amount of heating, just not totally intolerable.

The gas was £250, so £900 in total this month.

We've closed the doors to the dining room now, we just won't be able to go in there this winter. Kids will have to eat off their laps and do homework on the coffee table.

DoraSpenlow · 13/12/2022 13:12

I truly don't mean this to be a boast but I am worried about our bills the other way.

About August time we were advised by our energy supplier to incease our monthly direct debit to £240 a month (gas and electric). Don't have a smart meter but DH submits monthly readings and we can then see online how much in debit/credit we are. We are now about £850 in credit, £100 up from last month! I don't understand it. This surely can't be right. Being careful with usage but certainly not going cold. I know there is a long way to go with winter yet but I'm really worried they are suddenly going to say something is wrong and we owe them hundreds of £.

TERRRYsnotmine · 13/12/2022 13:10

leilani83 · 13/12/2022 12:51

I mean it's a big bill but 2 full time salaries in good jobs must still leave you with a decent disposable income? Half of those costs only comes to £700 each, for housing and gas/electricity that's not bad. Even on minimum wage you'd have around £1500 left for everything else.
I'm a single parent with housing costs alone of 1k a month (rent and council tax), current utilities costing £300 p/m, to put things in perspective.

I was going to say this. £900 in rent for a large house is incredibly cheap, and you both work full time!

No it's not that. This isn't fair to OP. I am a single parent also and it's not cheap it's just not comparable to a 2 person housholds bringing in 2 incomes

leilani83 · 13/12/2022 13:04

True OP, fair enough.

Topseyt123 · 13/12/2022 13:03

@Getoff Not in this house. I've watched it carefully on the smart meter. In these minus temperatures it has definitely cost less.

When the ambient temperature rises again next week and we are more back to normal then I fully expect that the heating will go back to normal and will be cheaper to use on the timer, which is our usual modus operandi.

With minus 8 last night (and still well below freezing now, I certainly want to minimise the possibility of frozen pipes too. Had that before and it wasn't fun.

insanegasbill · 13/12/2022 13:00

It might sound "incredibly cheap" but when you factor in high outgoings - for example a large childcare bill - on top of everything else, it's tight. Everyone's situation is unique isn't it.

OP posts:
leilani83 · 13/12/2022 12:51

I mean it's a big bill but 2 full time salaries in good jobs must still leave you with a decent disposable income? Half of those costs only comes to £700 each, for housing and gas/electricity that's not bad. Even on minimum wage you'd have around £1500 left for everything else.
I'm a single parent with housing costs alone of 1k a month (rent and council tax), current utilities costing £300 p/m, to put things in perspective.

I was going to say this. £900 in rent for a large house is incredibly cheap, and you both work full time!

panko · 13/12/2022 12:41

Brighton5555 · 13/12/2022 12:21

Totally relate. I have a 3 bed small terraced house and it’s costing me £7-8 a day just for gas ( smart meter , British Gas, we have one hour heating in the morning , two hours at night and shower every other day family of four ) this morning I turned it off after 15 mins when I saw we had gone through £15 of gas in a day and a half .

i went to full my tank and that was £90 then I went to asda which isn’t exactly Waitrose on prices and got hardly anything for £95 . Back home now with the heating off and the switches off . I am so depressed by this

See if you can get a sandtimer for the shower from your water company. Ours times for 4 minutes and we've saved loads implementing this with the kids

user1471439240 · 13/12/2022 12:30

Heating using electricity costs three times as much as gas. This has always been the case. It is the reason we have gas supplied to most of our homes. Gas is considered to damage the planet so the cost benefit is glossed over by the green lobby.

insanegasbill · 13/12/2022 12:29

@Brighton5555

It's utterly depressing isn't it. Flowers

OP posts:
Brighton5555 · 13/12/2022 12:21

Totally relate. I have a 3 bed small terraced house and it’s costing me £7-8 a day just for gas ( smart meter , British Gas, we have one hour heating in the morning , two hours at night and shower every other day family of four ) this morning I turned it off after 15 mins when I saw we had gone through £15 of gas in a day and a half .

i went to full my tank and that was £90 then I went to asda which isn’t exactly Waitrose on prices and got hardly anything for £95 . Back home now with the heating off and the switches off . I am so depressed by this

dementedpixie · 13/12/2022 12:18

Gas is cheaper than electricity so you're better using your central heating rather than electric heaters

My gas cost is 10.28p/kwh
My electricity cost is 33.76p/kwh

insanegasbill · 13/12/2022 12:09

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/12/2022 11:32

@insanegasbill are you with Scottish Power by any chance?

We are - while it won't help with monthly costs, if I don't manually 'submit' my readings at the same time every month it is so hard to see how much we're being charged for and how much we're using if I don't do that.

Your electric heaters won't be helping. I believe it's the electric radiators you need.

No we are with EoN

OP posts: