Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think why have so many kids if you can’t afford their presents?

479 replies

yuletidey · 13/12/2022 04:50

Before I start I just want to say I have absolutely nothing against large families, I also understand people will have times in their lives where they struggle.

I recently volunteered for a local to charity, they donate toys to children in need all around the country. I have volunteered for around 6 years around Christmas time to get toys packed. Yesterday I was helping pack boxes as they are really overwhelmed with the demand.

Recently I think the charity has changed their criteria as before anyone could get in touch and they would receive toys, I think the founder was a bit naive there but hey. Now people need to be referred by a school, social worker, support worker etc as a lot of people were taking advantage.

Anyway a woman turned up to the charity yesterday, asking for toys. The young girl working there said they will be giving them out all next week, she mentioned they had changed the criteria. The woman was saying she has ten kids and she was relying on them for toys, she was saying how can I get toys, she has kids from 16 to 1. They will now have to go without and no one bothered to tell her the criteria changed. The young girl apologised and said all updates were on their social media but they can’t update everyone individually. The woman lost her temper saying they have ruined her kids Christmas, it’s the girls fault, she’s ruined 10 kids Christmas.

This went on for a bit until I someone else stepped in but I was just shocked. I appreciate people need help and the pressure of Christmas can’t be nice but this woman has used the toys since they started, in that time she’s had a few children. I realise it’s a touchy subject but I felt so sorry for the young girl as she was really upset at letting children down

OP posts:
Eatdrinkanddrink · 13/12/2022 13:39

Sorry my last post. So many 100s more in benefits per month as she passed her not fit to work assessment

Pertinentowl · 13/12/2022 13:38

I said you are not being unreasonable but if you are going to work in charity or human rights you leave your biases at the door. You haven’t done that. The young girl will of course have felt very attacked and upset but that doesn’t translate to giving opinions about peoples life choices. Choices that you have no idea how they came about. That is dehumanising and the very opposite of what anyone working in a charity should do. You refuse her the toys as per the rule, you defend the young girl, you don’t start to think up a life philosophy. Read all the posts on inter generational poverty and other reasons. This is a different world. You don’t come into it with your world view.
well, you do at first but if you are in it for the long haul, you reassess your own privilege. We all had to do that because if you are working with a sense of outrage you burn out and aren’t the person you wanted to be going into this work.

Eatdrinkanddrink · 13/12/2022 13:36

Underanothersky · Today 13:30
for some folk maybe, good at acting in some cases. Example. A local girl claiming she can’t go out, suffers panic attacks, has her mum taking her 5 kids to school. Saying she passed her assessment, so she gets so many 100s a month more. But if you go into her boyfriends fb page, we’ll that states a different story, pictures in nightclubs, going to New York, parties. Well she’s certainly fiddling the system. So many more do.

RottingAutumnApples · 13/12/2022 13:35

KrystynaZ · 13/12/2022 11:54

Based on all the research on child development, at that age they should be focusing on play, not on learning ABCs etc. Please point me to this research @TheHappyDaze.

In fact it is well-known that there are critical periods when a young child requires appropriate stimulation for the brain to establish the neural pathways for optimum development in language and literacy (and many other subjects). Furthermore, many of these critical periods are over or waning by the time a child is six years old, so reversing poor development is difficult after this age

There is an enormous amount of research on the benefits of play. Your post clearly thinks that play is valueless and ‘not learning’. When the opposite is true. You could try following the Upstart campaign and the book of the same name by Sue Palmer ( a literacy expert) A play based approach is a highly effective way to develop children’s cognition, language, social and everything else skills. It really is. Attuned, skilled adults use children’s play to extend their language and learning. On the other hand, dyslexia rates are highest in countries which start formal literacy at the earliest ages.

Cahveeare · 13/12/2022 13:33

@Underanothersky

My own anecdotal experience is MIL who has been on disability benefit for the past 30 years and has nothing wrong with her. She will outlive me. She’s cost the NHS so much money.

She even suggested I start the investigational process for my own (agreed very naughty but completely NT, 3 year old) because ‘DLA is not means tested’.

I have no idea if that’s right but she can’t be the only one.

Underanothersky · 13/12/2022 13:30

Cahveeare · 13/12/2022 13:25

It was always the case that people were having children for more benefit. That’s a tale as old as time.

In theory you can’t do that nowadays but you can if have children with health conditions that can’t be physiologically confirmed.

Same with grown up benefits. It’s a real shame as it trivialises conditions for people who are really suffering.

It's just that easy to get benefits for disabled people...

FourTeaFallOut · 13/12/2022 13:27

Now come-on...fake charities and mythical customers with ten fantasy children aside -

She had a choice with each kid and chose to make the wrong one because it’s an easy ride when the tax payer can bail you out. These people have an easy ride in the uk

Easy ride with ten kids??? The thought of laundry alone would make most people weep. An easy ride is a House of Lords peerage or a natural talent for counting cards.

palygold · 13/12/2022 13:25

"Ohhh God you have to be in denial to believe this 10 kids? Do you actually have any family members with 7 kids in one household?"

"I do. There's numerous issues and all I will say is that the mother loves her kids unconditionally, she has looked after them but there's something not quite right with my aunt and I think she is utterly selfish. Her eldest is 34 and the youngest is 8 it's f..King ridiculous 🙄"

What an excitable post, if a little difficult to follow! And I have no comment to make on your/that family situation.

I stand by my previous statement. Circumstances do change for many reasons - I've listed some examples in my previous post. It won't always be the case, of course, but worth bearing in mind.

Cahveeare · 13/12/2022 13:25

It was always the case that people were having children for more benefit. That’s a tale as old as time.

In theory you can’t do that nowadays but you can if have children with health conditions that can’t be physiologically confirmed.

Same with grown up benefits. It’s a real shame as it trivialises conditions for people who are really suffering.

TERRRYsnotmine · 13/12/2022 13:20

palygold · 13/12/2022 13:16

Might it be that their circumstances have changed, OP? A change in fortunes through death, unemployment, bankruptcy, that sort of thing.

Just a thought.

Ohhh God you have to be in denial to believe this 10 kids? Do you actually have any family members with 7 kids in one household?

I do. There's numerous issues and all I will say is that the mother loves her kids unconditionally, she has looked after them but there's something not quite right with my aunt and I think she is utterly selfish. Her eldest is 34 and the youngest is 8 it's f..King ridiculous 🙄

MintJulia · 13/12/2022 13:20

FourTeaFallOut · 13/12/2022 13:15

Surely nobody is so stupid as to think you can turn a profit on having a child at £15/ week?

Oh believe me, they're out there. We would have starved without family allowance.

And in the 70s domestic rates (council tax) were discounted for people with lots of children, which made us an even more attractive 'product'.

Lovageandrose · 13/12/2022 13:19

It’s because she will be getting hand outs left right and center. Her mentality will be one of why should I pay when someone else will. She had a choice with each kid and chose to make the wrong one because it’s an easy ride when the tax payer can bail you out. These people have an easy ride in the uk.

YomAsalYomBasal · 13/12/2022 13:18

@BabyFour2023 my point is you just don't know what life will bring. Having children in secure, stable circumstances is no guarantee that you won't ever need help.

palygold · 13/12/2022 13:16

FourTeaFallOut · 13/12/2022 13:15

Surely nobody is so stupid as to think you can turn a profit on having a child at £15/ week?

There's always one on these threads!

palygold · 13/12/2022 13:16

Might it be that their circumstances have changed, OP? A change in fortunes through death, unemployment, bankruptcy, that sort of thing.

Just a thought.

MintJulia · 13/12/2022 13:15

@YomAsalYomBasal

'Child benefit is not limited to two children'

Sorry, UC. My mistake.

FourTeaFallOut · 13/12/2022 13:15

Surely nobody is so stupid as to think you can turn a profit on having a child at £15/ week?

barneshome · 13/12/2022 13:14

We would love to have 67 kids but we have 2 as we know it costs money

notacooldad · 13/12/2022 13:13

Her circumstances could of changed drastically. She could of afford her ten but lost job or a relationship break down etc etc. multiple pregnancies, contraception fails, circumstances changes drastically
I love your positive thinking but not one of the case that I hold that have 6 or more children had any of those things. They all have had multiple partners and made active choices to have lots of children. When I did a home visit to a woman with her 7th child and the baby was 3 months old two weeks ago she told me that she was nearly done with babies , maybe one more! This is a family that is open to children's social care and she is not unusual but typical of my cases. She is a lovely lady and she is not stupid. She has never had a job and neither had her current partner.
I can't judge, but just to do the best I can for the children and encourage her to as well.

lindyloo57 · 13/12/2022 13:13

Completely agree, there's alot of people out there who takes advantage, I know of a pensioner who even though they don't need to, visit food banks every week and give most away to family who again all work and don't need it. I just thought food banks were for people in need.

BabyFour2023 · 13/12/2022 13:12

YomAsalYomBasal · 13/12/2022 13:10

And what will happen if one of your children becomes disabled, you can't work and your partner leaves you? Easy to be all smug when life is kind to you.

One of my DC is disabled. What’s your point? I don’t “work” in the physical sense anyway; we have 2 businesses which give us a very comfortable and privileged life without requiring day to day work from us. If my husband left me I would still have independent wealth so yes, I could still get them Christmas presents!

YomAsalYomBasal · 13/12/2022 13:11

MintJulia · 13/12/2022 13:09

YANBU

I come from a family of 7. My dps went on having children because it allowed my df to show what a 'big man' he was, and because he liked the family allowance (predecessor of Child Benefit). He tried to persuade dm to have yet another child at 45 so he could give up work and live off the family allowance. Thankfully she refused. Even so, it was no fun.

I'm glad the govt has limited CB to two births. At least it stops that sort of deliberate profiteering & exploitation.

Child benefit is not limited to two children.

YomAsalYomBasal · 13/12/2022 13:10

BabyFour2023 · 13/12/2022 09:46

I’m pregnant with my 4th and completely agree with you.
Its completely irresponsible and really frustrates me when I hear things like this.
Have the amount of children you can afford.

And what will happen if one of your children becomes disabled, you can't work and your partner leaves you? Easy to be all smug when life is kind to you.

Hellybelly84 · 13/12/2022 13:09

Agree- in my opinion, we can afford 2 kids and Husband has a good job and I work 4 days a week. If we had anymore, it would push us with all the extras - Christmas, holidays, school trips, days out. I want my kids to have all the opportunities and not be stretched to the limit. I will never understand having 10 kids and being unable to afford them - unless ofcourse circumstances have suddenly changed for this family.

MintJulia · 13/12/2022 13:09

YANBU

I come from a family of 7. My dps went on having children because it allowed my df to show what a 'big man' he was, and because he liked the family allowance (predecessor of Child Benefit). He tried to persuade dm to have yet another child at 45 so he could give up work and live off the family allowance. Thankfully she refused. Even so, it was no fun.

I'm glad the govt has limited CB to two births. At least it stops that sort of deliberate profiteering & exploitation.