Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the British royal family has had its day?

289 replies

Ladybugpolkadot · 13/12/2022 02:16

I had a lot of respect for the Queen, may she rest in peace… But now she has passed away I just feel like the UK Royal family/ establishment should just be abolished.

The younger generations are not the same standard as Queen Elizabeth was. There’s so many rumours and so much scandal in recent times. And what have these people really done in order to justify leeching of UK tax payer money to fund their privileged lifestyles?…

Am I the only one who thinks the members of the Royal family should give up their royal roles and get real jobs and earn their own living like anyone else in the country?

OP posts:
Palmfrond · 13/12/2022 10:59

Blossomtoes · 13/12/2022 10:35

I’d be very happy to have things like the Crown Estate and the Duchy of Cornwall handed over to the state

The Crown Estate was handed over to the state by George lll in exchange for an income which is a fraction of the money it receives.

No, it wasn’t. It is no longer directly owned by the monarch, but they still get 25% of its income, which google tells me was £86 million last fiscal year, or the rough equivalent to the salaries of 2,500 NHS nurses.
Personally I’ve gotten a lot of value from NHS nurses of the years. I think they are great, work hard in a very hard job, and are saving lives every day, whereas I personally haven’t got a single fucking bean of value from any single “royal” ever. Unless you count supreme cringe as having some kind of value.

JamSandle · 13/12/2022 10:54

I like the Royal Family and I hope we keep them.

SnowyGiveAway · 13/12/2022 10:43

thecatsthecats · 13/12/2022 10:25

The thing about institutions is that they are inherently corrupt. They prioritise the institution as the vehicle of power, which mean individual crimes within the are hushed up.

Can anyone name an uncorrupt institution?

The Royal Family aren't better than any other institution. But I don't actually think that they're worse either.

I'm not anti-change, but I am a realist. Human behaviour and human fallibilities do not lend themselves to the modern day level of media and big money control that we have at present.

The extreme left would want the removal of monarchy because they loathe inequality. The extreme right would salivate at the opportunity to exercise more power. Level heads prefer steady but sure reform. But that doesn't appeal to the emotions, and it's by winding up emotions that votes are bought.

Some things are inherently wrong, and need to be removed for that reason. We do not need to remove them just because they are corrupt. We need to remove them because we are a modern society that does not truly believe in divine right to rule. Without that belief the monarchy doesn't work.

I don't believe that one woman's vagina is blessed by God to bestow rulers upon us, and that we should bow our heads to the ones divined to rule us.

We should abolish the monarchy because the idea of a monarchy is alien to our beliefs as a society.

Blossomtoes · 13/12/2022 10:35

I’d be very happy to have things like the Crown Estate and the Duchy of Cornwall handed over to the state

The Crown Estate was handed over to the state by George lll in exchange for an income which is a fraction of the money it receives.

thecatsthecats · 13/12/2022 10:25

The thing about institutions is that they are inherently corrupt. They prioritise the institution as the vehicle of power, which mean individual crimes within the are hushed up.

Can anyone name an uncorrupt institution?

The Royal Family aren't better than any other institution. But I don't actually think that they're worse either.

I'm not anti-change, but I am a realist. Human behaviour and human fallibilities do not lend themselves to the modern day level of media and big money control that we have at present.

The extreme left would want the removal of monarchy because they loathe inequality. The extreme right would salivate at the opportunity to exercise more power. Level heads prefer steady but sure reform. But that doesn't appeal to the emotions, and it's by winding up emotions that votes are bought.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/12/2022 10:20

This family is already splintering. All that privilege and they can't even behave with discretion and civility to each other in public: this goes for all of them, BTW. See how the nation feels once the honeymoon has worn off and it's endured 3-5 years of Charles III. William and Kate's reception in the US and Caribbean is also a clue.

They are fossils, and there's a definite sense they are on borrowed time.

Palmfrond · 13/12/2022 10:06

I’m not any kind of fan of the royal family, especially after Her Maj checked out, but tbf she was an outlier if you hold her up to the shower of libertines, losers, sadists, egomaniacs and freaks who came before her.
So, abolish? Maybe not, the institution does have some sort of intangible cultural, social and perhaps political value, but certainly I’d be very happy to have things like the Crown Estate and the Duchy of Cornwall handed over to the state, purely for the benefit of the people, and public funds allotted to the Royals kept to a bare minimum. They are, at the end of the day, fucking minted, and taking public funds is a piss take.

Bobbins36 · 13/12/2022 09:44

FWIW I think they represent decent value for money in terms of soft diplomacy, tourism, raising charity awareness. Not a huge monarchist but do like a bit of tradition and it’s something that is unique to the UK.

Yolanda524 · 13/12/2022 09:41

I feel the whole idea of monarchy is so outdated and needs to change. No one deserve power and leadership of a country just by right of birth.
However just the thought of the country voting and deciding on who should be head of state and how it would work gives me a headache. It will be Brexit ten times over.

i do think their privileges need to be reigned in. They need to pay tax including inheritance tax like the rest of us and their finances more transparent. Most people are struggling right now whilst they pay to heat massive castles. It doesn’t feel right that taxpayer pay so much to them.

Soozikinzii · 13/12/2022 09:40

I agree

Mirabai · 13/12/2022 09:38

Absolutely. The monarchy should have ended with the queen.

Charles is a very weak man and he and the courtiers have made the same mistake with H&M that they made with Diana.

It makes no sense to have a family stuck in internecine fighting representing the country.

SnoozyLucy7 · 13/12/2022 09:35

Iamsashafierce2 · 13/12/2022 08:49

God what a horrible thread! Funny how they still get queues of people lining the streets to meet them when they go on visits, so not everyone can feel the same way as posters on here. I think Kate and William are lovely- she does a lot of work with young children, so she's not just there to look good. I bet a lot of people that moan about them enjoyed watching the royal weddings and took part in the street parties so I'm sure they're not really causing your life too much upset

Why would debate, debate that allows for informed views and choices, to be made, be horrible? Why can’t things be challenged? Everything should be opened up to scrutiny other wise how do people, how do societies, evolve, move forward?. Just because something has worked in the past does not mean that it’s right for right now on the future. Just because people disagree with your views it’s not “horrible”. Yes, challenging the status quo can unsettle people but it’s part of the wider, democratic debate , regarding the monarchy and our system of governance.

OhPeggySue · 13/12/2022 09:35

Lampzade · 13/12/2022 09:05

We didn’t have social media and mobile phones so that is why they were able to ‘escape’ relatively unscathed .
Things are different now. As I said previously, they will survive but will be severely weakened.

It's like Joan Collins vs Katie Price. Joan (Queen) had a bit of old school glamour, decorum and mystique, whereas Katie (Charles) is a warts n all character. Charles is there with his affairs, his public tantrums etc and it doesn't quite have the same illusion.

OhPeggySue · 13/12/2022 09:30

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 13/12/2022 09:17

Never heard of it for Camilla but you're right about Diana. She wasn't the perfect princess many make her out to be, she had affairs like KC. What makes her affairs okay and his not?! Can't judge him for it without judging her

She might have thought sauce for the goose.

username8888 · 13/12/2022 09:30

It all needs slimming down, commonwealth countries need to be let go, although they could all still be part of a 'family of nations' and keep a mutually equal relationship. I do enjoy all the ceremony though. Our history is so long and so rich and the RF are the embodiment of it so I don't want to sink into the grey boredom of only having politicians. The RF are unique. They are colourful and interesting and they do a huge amount for charities. The only thing to replace them would be a bunch of vacuous celebrities promoting their latest movie or song.

The whole world recognises the British monarchy. Once Harry and Meghan finish the bloodletting exercise and concentrate on their humanitarian and charity work in America, the RF can just get in with the business of welcoming foreign leaders and charities. Camilla did a lovely visit to children with short life expectations (overshadowed by H&M) and no doubt brought a lot of money into the charity.

Accept the RF for what they do and forget all the drama from America.

MistletoeandBaileys · 13/12/2022 09:26

In Ireland we have Michael D Higgins as our President. He’s our figurehead and has no actual political powers but he is the one who signs the laws into place.

Similar to the Royal Family he has to remain neutral on politics and current affairs. Although he’s a very knowledgable man. But a wonderful thing about him is that he unites people. No matter what side of politics people fall in to, a lot of people really like him and think he’s a fantastic representative for our country.

People felt the same way about his predecessors Mary McAleese and Mary Robinson too.

I think you get into dangerous territory if the power solely lies with the government. I think they need someone “above”. Otherwise what’s stopping them from making up rules as they go along to remain in power? Whether or not that’s good for the people.

It’s not easy to overturn a Government.

LizzieSiddal · 13/12/2022 09:22

I agree with you OP and I never thought I would. I admired the Queen and felt proud that we had her. I don’t feel the same way about Charles and William I just cannot see being King. It seems so rediculous.

also re the scandals, yes there’s always been some how we never directed at the monarch by their own child! When a child of the monarch is attaching the institution you have a problem.

I also find William and Kate so bloody boring, plus when I saw them at the Queens funeral, walking alongside thier dc and not holding their hands, I felt so sad for them. Who else would expect their young child to walk into a cathedral, containing thousands of people, and not give them a bit of comfort? It really shocked me.

kingtamponthefurred · 13/12/2022 09:21

I doubt that any of them would be able to cope in a real job.

Sartre · 13/12/2022 09:20

I agree but we’ll have to wait for the older generation to die out before we’d ever push abolition through in a referendum. Lots of support and approval still among older people, younger people not so much.

anexcellentwoman · 13/12/2022 09:20

@Lampzade
As someone famously said, 'Recollections may vary'. The whole idea of justice in a court is both the defence and prosecution making their case. Harry and Meghan's documentary was made by them. There is no balance. As they themselves said, 'it is their truth' or their version of the truth. It is why trial by media is so dangerous. It is often completely one sided. I hope Justice never depends on whoever can produce the most glitzy documentary. At heart, most people know the truth generally lies somewhere in the middle. I am suspicious of people peddling their own truth. Look at all the right wing on line vloggers who supposedly tell their 'truth' to their followers. One sided truth telling us very dangerous

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 13/12/2022 09:19

MarshaMelrose · 13/12/2022 04:11

If you replace the monarchy with a head of state they'd still cost money. France's presidency costs €100m a year to run.
If you don't replace them, then you're making the prime minister head of state. How can you expect them to perform their current duties and take on the extra things the King does. Where will they find the time to do it all?

And the ‘elected ‘ heads of state are not exactly trouble free. Look at thé US, and megalomaniac followed by a senile man with a corrupt family.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 13/12/2022 09:17

RoseAndRose · 13/12/2022 09:13

Queen Camilla who's so so lovely but shagged married men all over the place

Got me thinking - because she didn't, did she? The only ones we know about are her (notoriously unfaithful) first husband, and her second husband. And if there were others, wouldn't that be generally known?

Whereas Charles and Diana both had multiple lovers - an affair with Diana breaking up at least two marriages

Never heard of it for Camilla but you're right about Diana. She wasn't the perfect princess many make her out to be, she had affairs like KC. What makes her affairs okay and his not?! Can't judge him for it without judging her

DillDanding · 13/12/2022 09:15

I have never heard gossip about Camilla shagging ‘married men all over the place’.

Thesenderofthiscard · 13/12/2022 09:13

Time for a serious downgrade.

RoseAndRose · 13/12/2022 09:13

Queen Camilla who's so so lovely but shagged married men all over the place

Got me thinking - because she didn't, did she? The only ones we know about are her (notoriously unfaithful) first husband, and her second husband. And if there were others, wouldn't that be generally known?

Whereas Charles and Diana both had multiple lovers - an affair with Diana breaking up at least two marriages