Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the British royal family has had its day?

289 replies

Ladybugpolkadot · 13/12/2022 02:16

I had a lot of respect for the Queen, may she rest in peace… But now she has passed away I just feel like the UK Royal family/ establishment should just be abolished.

The younger generations are not the same standard as Queen Elizabeth was. There’s so many rumours and so much scandal in recent times. And what have these people really done in order to justify leeching of UK tax payer money to fund their privileged lifestyles?…

Am I the only one who thinks the members of the Royal family should give up their royal roles and get real jobs and earn their own living like anyone else in the country?

OP posts:
Ladybugpolkadot · 13/12/2022 03:01

skilpadde · 13/12/2022 02:46

The trouble is, to do what you are looking for, abolishing the monarchy, means moving on from focusing on the idea of the royal family being leeches and focus on what system you would put in place to replace the constitutional monarchy we have.

What system would replace it? A system of government like Ireland? France? Germany? USA? Do you want an elected ceremonial head of state, or do you want the head of state to be leader of the government? Is there a better system for the UK, or is a constitutional monarchy the least bad option?

Then there's the issue of getting mass support. Create enough of a groundswell of support that a major political party agrees to put a referendum on its manifesto. Get that party elected to government. It holds a referendum.

How are republicans going to push a "yes" vote over the line? We were promised sunlit uplands from the last referendum... look how well that that's going. How is post-constitutional monarchy UK going to be better for us? There's no £200M a week for the NHS con that's going to do it this time. When people will err toward the status quo, how do you get a majority to vote for change? If it's a no, it'll be put to bed for decades, so this is the one big chance.

And what about other countries with the king as head of state... Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Jamaica etc. Would we be forcing them into a constitutional crisis? Do we just not care about how we impact them?

So, yeah. So far as I can see, grumbling about the royal family will go on as it always has, but I can't see anything actually changing in my lifetime.

Nothing needs to replace them. We have a government… The royal family have no say in the actual running of the country anyway… It’s not like the kings and queens of old times… They are ornamental, they don’t actually rule the country anymore, they are not even allowed to have an opinion…

OP posts:
FeelWellEnoughToTellYou · 13/12/2022 03:00

*too

FeelWellEnoughToTellYou · 13/12/2022 03:00

I don't want to agree with you op, but this family have been an embarrassing shit show for two long. Agree with above poster that the Queen was the glue that held them together.

skilpadde · 13/12/2022 02:57

KateLoseslet · 13/12/2022 02:49

And what about other countries with the king as head of state... Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Jamaica etc. Would we be forcing them into a constitutional crisis? Do we just not care about how we impact them?

Jamaica have started the process to become a republic so I wouldn’t worry about them too much.

Fair enough, Jamaica's moving onward and upward. What are your thoughts on the other 13 commonwealth countries with the king as head of state? What should they do?

We're already an ex-EU country. Do we want to instigate the dismantling of the commonwealth, or do we think they'd figure out a way to carry on without us?

FlairBand · 13/12/2022 02:54

This again..there have been loads of threads on this lately do we need another?

autienotnaughty · 13/12/2022 02:54

There's alway been scandals in the royal family. Princess Margaret and Prince Phillip had their share back in the day. Although yes the Queen never wavered in her responsibilities (that we are aware of) It's more financial really, Does the monarchy make more money than they cost? If no then I agree it's probably time they left.

KateLoseslet · 13/12/2022 02:49

And what about other countries with the king as head of state... Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Jamaica etc. Would we be forcing them into a constitutional crisis? Do we just not care about how we impact them?

Jamaica have started the process to become a republic so I wouldn’t worry about them too much.

skilpadde · 13/12/2022 02:46

The trouble is, to do what you are looking for, abolishing the monarchy, means moving on from focusing on the idea of the royal family being leeches and focus on what system you would put in place to replace the constitutional monarchy we have.

What system would replace it? A system of government like Ireland? France? Germany? USA? Do you want an elected ceremonial head of state, or do you want the head of state to be leader of the government? Is there a better system for the UK, or is a constitutional monarchy the least bad option?

Then there's the issue of getting mass support. Create enough of a groundswell of support that a major political party agrees to put a referendum on its manifesto. Get that party elected to government. It holds a referendum.

How are republicans going to push a "yes" vote over the line? We were promised sunlit uplands from the last referendum... look how well that that's going. How is post-constitutional monarchy UK going to be better for us? There's no £200M a week for the NHS con that's going to do it this time. When people will err toward the status quo, how do you get a majority to vote for change? If it's a no, it'll be put to bed for decades, so this is the one big chance.

And what about other countries with the king as head of state... Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Jamaica etc. Would we be forcing them into a constitutional crisis? Do we just not care about how we impact them?

So, yeah. So far as I can see, grumbling about the royal family will go on as it always has, but I can't see anything actually changing in my lifetime.

showysnowy · 13/12/2022 02:43

I respected the Queen so much and it made sense how things were but I really felt for the woman to have lived such a life in such a standard she raised and even in that, her husband, sister, children, dil's, grandchildren etc have done nothing but disrespect it and shat on it each and every time she tried to hold it together. With the Queen now gone, there is no respect left to the institution. They can all piss right off now the lot of them. What a spoilt and dysfunctional family and actually a very shameful one.

catandcoffee · 13/12/2022 02:42

I agree

Ladybugpolkadot · 13/12/2022 02:41

The Queen was the glue that held this whole shit show of a family together … and now she’s gone. Feels like the end of an era.

OP posts:
mydogsteppedonabee · 13/12/2022 02:37

Yes!!!
I really hope they fuck off soon

DogsAkimbo · 13/12/2022 02:35

I did not think I’d be one to agree with this, but yes. I think even when they’re doing a ‘good job’ (whatever that is) like Catherine, for instance, it’s just boring and irrelevant now. The queen was a link between the past and the present and without that, I just don’t feel anything.

starrynight21 · 13/12/2022 02:33

I'm inclined to agree with you. When the Queen was here it sort of made sense, but now we have this dysfunctional family which seems to get worse by the day. I'd be happy to see them go.