Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the British royal family has had its day?

289 replies

Ladybugpolkadot · 13/12/2022 02:16

I had a lot of respect for the Queen, may she rest in peace… But now she has passed away I just feel like the UK Royal family/ establishment should just be abolished.

The younger generations are not the same standard as Queen Elizabeth was. There’s so many rumours and so much scandal in recent times. And what have these people really done in order to justify leeching of UK tax payer money to fund their privileged lifestyles?…

Am I the only one who thinks the members of the Royal family should give up their royal roles and get real jobs and earn their own living like anyone else in the country?

OP posts:
TodayInahurry · 13/12/2022 07:01

I, like tens of millions of UK citizens, like the Royal Family. I find it pathetic people moan about them.

Theunamedcat · 13/12/2022 07:00

The country is in crisis is this really where our focus should be?

It's not a dysfunctional family it's Harry and his wife no-one else is Jeremy Kyle they are all carrying on like he doesn't exist

Trainbear · 13/12/2022 06:56

KimberleyClark · 13/12/2022 06:34

And what about other countries with the king as head of state... Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Jamaica etc. Would we be forcing them into a constitutional crisis? Do we just not care about how we impact them?

Isn’t it a bit patronising to think these countries somehow need to have our monarch as their head of state and couldn’t manage without them?

Is it not patronising to say “WE in the “civilised, liberal, progressive ” (sic) West know better than you?

Prescottdanni123 · 13/12/2022 06:54

@SnoozyLucy7

A big draw for the Americans is that we still have a monarchy. Other countries too. Tourists coming over to visit a few castles after the monarchy is abolished won't draw in the same amount of money as it does while we have the monarchy.

Trainbear · 13/12/2022 06:53

magicthree · 13/12/2022 06:46

I think all the former colonies are probably more than ready, and will be very happy, to brake away from the commonwealth and elect their own heads of state. They are ready to move forward away from the archaic system they find themselves in.

Do you live in one of these "former colonies" and have canvassed all the people living in them? If the answer is no then I really don't understand why you think you are important enough to be able to speak on their behalf!

I don’t think Barbados had a democratic referendum for removal.

Trainbear · 13/12/2022 06:52

Ladybugpolkadot · 13/12/2022 03:29

Other countries seem to manage perfectly fine without some privileged royal to sign off laws they have no power to change anyway…

Im sure we would manage too

Other countries…. Yet Norway; Sweden; Denmark; Netherlands; Belgium all have monarchies and are considered leading liberal democracies. Is there a regular clamouring for their abolishment?

magicthree · 13/12/2022 06:46

I think all the former colonies are probably more than ready, and will be very happy, to brake away from the commonwealth and elect their own heads of state. They are ready to move forward away from the archaic system they find themselves in.

Do you live in one of these "former colonies" and have canvassed all the people living in them? If the answer is no then I really don't understand why you think you are important enough to be able to speak on their behalf!

KimberleyClark · 13/12/2022 06:34

And what about other countries with the king as head of state... Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Jamaica etc. Would we be forcing them into a constitutional crisis? Do we just not care about how we impact them?

Isn’t it a bit patronising to think these countries somehow need to have our monarch as their head of state and couldn’t manage without them?

Henrysmycat · 13/12/2022 06:27

So many here are so shortsighted and absolutely clueless or fundamentally uneducated.
Abolishing the RF, the monarchy, and not replace it with any other constitutional system of power?
It’s this stupid attitude that go uk in this brexshit mess.
Also, have a look at other countries with head of states. Is US, Germany, Greece any better with “elected” head of states?
At least here, you train them from birth unlike the idiots these countries vote for.
And I’m an immigrant here, I got no skin in this game. I just know that the grass is not always green on the other side, I’ve been there.

Remaker · 13/12/2022 06:25

I’m Australian. I would find it embarrassing if you got rid of the Royals before we did! But we’d get over it.

Australia tried to become a republic but it all came unstuck because we couldn’t agree whether to elect or appoint our head of state. Those kinds of details are boring but necessary.

I feel like it’s a bit unfair complaining about William and Kate being dull. The Queen wasn’t exactly the life of the party either. It’s not part of the job description to be opinionated and exciting.

AnotherLogOnTheFire · 13/12/2022 06:17

But who would the tabloids feast on? Megan and Harry like his mother make our gutter press very rich - they are vital to the hoards of people who need daily updates on how badly they are handling their lives. We need someone to hate (btw- I don’t hate them, don’t love them - just can’t seem to get away from the hate everyone spews about them) it’s too easy.

SnoozyLucy7 · 13/12/2022 06:17

jtaeapa · 13/12/2022 04:02

Why we are hell bent on destroying our own culture perplexes me. Most of us would not in a million years suggest that another culture should ditch its traditions etc. But when it comes to ours, we’re happy to just say fuck it!

I wouldn’t swap places with any of the royals and I don’t think they’re privileged. Yes of course in terms of money etc - but would you like to be Kate and have death threats regularly to your family? would you like not to even be able to go to Tesco without getting papped? Would you like to be judged and criticised for every outfit you wear? They bring in far more money and interest than they cost. They attract interested tourists from all over the world. They don’t even rule us - politicians do.

When tourists come to this country I am pretty certain that 99.999% never see of any of the royals. Yet, they still come in droves.

The Palace of Versailles and Lourves, for example, are one of the most visited palaces the world and yet the monarchy there was abolished in 1789. The tourists will always come.

SnoozyLucy7 · 13/12/2022 06:09

skilpadde · 13/12/2022 02:57

Fair enough, Jamaica's moving onward and upward. What are your thoughts on the other 13 commonwealth countries with the king as head of state? What should they do?

We're already an ex-EU country. Do we want to instigate the dismantling of the commonwealth, or do we think they'd figure out a way to carry on without us?

But why wouldn’t they figure it out without “us”? These are modern democracies who can democratically elect their own heads of states. They don’t need a monarch, who lives thousands of miles away, to be their nominal leader. The monarchy represents empire, which was never a good thing, the constitutional monarchy is a symbol of that, in many ways. Why would thriving democracies want to hold on to something so archaic and out dated, and find a much more better and effective?

Cuppasoupmonster · 13/12/2022 06:07

YANBU but after Brexit I’m very wary of constitutional change

SnoozyLucy7 · 13/12/2022 05:59

skilpadde · 13/12/2022 02:46

The trouble is, to do what you are looking for, abolishing the monarchy, means moving on from focusing on the idea of the royal family being leeches and focus on what system you would put in place to replace the constitutional monarchy we have.

What system would replace it? A system of government like Ireland? France? Germany? USA? Do you want an elected ceremonial head of state, or do you want the head of state to be leader of the government? Is there a better system for the UK, or is a constitutional monarchy the least bad option?

Then there's the issue of getting mass support. Create enough of a groundswell of support that a major political party agrees to put a referendum on its manifesto. Get that party elected to government. It holds a referendum.

How are republicans going to push a "yes" vote over the line? We were promised sunlit uplands from the last referendum... look how well that that's going. How is post-constitutional monarchy UK going to be better for us? There's no £200M a week for the NHS con that's going to do it this time. When people will err toward the status quo, how do you get a majority to vote for change? If it's a no, it'll be put to bed for decades, so this is the one big chance.

And what about other countries with the king as head of state... Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Jamaica etc. Would we be forcing them into a constitutional crisis? Do we just not care about how we impact them?

So, yeah. So far as I can see, grumbling about the royal family will go on as it always has, but I can't see anything actually changing in my lifetime.

I think all the former colonies are probably more than ready, and will be very happy, to brake away from the commonwealth and elect their own heads of state. They are ready to move forward away from the archaic system they find themselves in.

Prescottdanni123 · 13/12/2022 05:05

There was plenty of scandal in the queen's time too.

Once Harry and Meghan cancel themselves (which they are well on the way to doing, even in the US) and William trims down the monarchy things will get better.

I'd rather not lose the millions they bring into the economy, which we WOULD lose if we become yet another European country who got rid of it's monarchy. And the history surrounding Royal families for centuries will start to be forgotten. With how little some people care for history in a few generations kids will be asked when was the monarchy was dissolved, they'll answer with "We had a monarchy?"

And Kate and William are far better doing their charity work than doing night shifts in Sainsburys.

Malariahilaria · 13/12/2022 05:03

Agree 100%. Sick to the back teeth of all of them. King Charles pontificating about climate whilst owning 35 big houses and flying in private jets. Queen Camilla who's so so lovely but shagged married men all over the place. Prince Andrew who paid a woman he's never met millions for something he didn't do whilst shouting at staff to line up teddies. Catherine the mute mannequin, William the dull man. Harry and Megan who will not shut up (and I was so pleased at first when she joined because I'm brown and never thought I'd see the day but its all just too Californian for me now). Versaille makes plenty of money without actual royals. The prorogation of parliament made it clear they have zero power or role other than waving. Time for it to end.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 13/12/2022 04:28

Ladybugpolkadot · 13/12/2022 02:16

I had a lot of respect for the Queen, may she rest in peace… But now she has passed away I just feel like the UK Royal family/ establishment should just be abolished.

The younger generations are not the same standard as Queen Elizabeth was. There’s so many rumours and so much scandal in recent times. And what have these people really done in order to justify leeching of UK tax payer money to fund their privileged lifestyles?…

Am I the only one who thinks the members of the Royal family should give up their royal roles and get real jobs and earn their own living like anyone else in the country?

Tend to agree. Who are they, really, to have such cushy lives relative to the rest of us?

What has Prince George done to merit more than any other child his age, for example.

MarshaMelrose · 13/12/2022 04:11

If you replace the monarchy with a head of state they'd still cost money. France's presidency costs €100m a year to run.
If you don't replace them, then you're making the prime minister head of state. How can you expect them to perform their current duties and take on the extra things the King does. Where will they find the time to do it all?

jtaeapa · 13/12/2022 04:02

Why we are hell bent on destroying our own culture perplexes me. Most of us would not in a million years suggest that another culture should ditch its traditions etc. But when it comes to ours, we’re happy to just say fuck it!

I wouldn’t swap places with any of the royals and I don’t think they’re privileged. Yes of course in terms of money etc - but would you like to be Kate and have death threats regularly to your family? would you like not to even be able to go to Tesco without getting papped? Would you like to be judged and criticised for every outfit you wear? They bring in far more money and interest than they cost. They attract interested tourists from all over the world. They don’t even rule us - politicians do.

Spliffle · 13/12/2022 03:50

Definitely not.

RichPetunia · 13/12/2022 03:48

I'm totally on the same page and would never have considered it a year ago. It's just not the same and to be honest I feel sorry for Prince George that his life is already mapped out. As someone else said, the Queen held it all together. Now she's no longer here, I'd have no objection to seeing it end.

Ladybugpolkadot · 13/12/2022 03:29

skilpadde · 13/12/2022 03:14

Of course something needs to replace them. Our system is a constitutional monarchy. The king is the head of state. He has no power in practice, but he signs the laws. The government is the king's government.

If we want to have a UK without a monarch as head of state, then we need to decide on some other system of governance to replace a constitutional monarchy.

The country is not like some company that will just function with an acting-CEO for a few months.

So, how much constitutional reform should the country seek?

Other countries seem to manage perfectly fine without some privileged royal to sign off laws they have no power to change anyway…

Im sure we would manage too

OP posts:
skilpadde · 13/12/2022 03:14

Of course something needs to replace them. Our system is a constitutional monarchy. The king is the head of state. He has no power in practice, but he signs the laws. The government is the king's government.

If we want to have a UK without a monarch as head of state, then we need to decide on some other system of governance to replace a constitutional monarchy.

The country is not like some company that will just function with an acting-CEO for a few months.

So, how much constitutional reform should the country seek?

Cheekymaw · 13/12/2022 03:09

Absobloodelutely, OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread