Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the encouragement to delay real life is a big cause in the explosion of mental health issues in under 35's ?

365 replies

rudolphrainbownose · 12/12/2022 21:20

Okay, so there is a well documented mental health crisis amongst young people , particularly university students, needing mental health support.

Is it just me or is the current culture of delaying "real adulthood" ( staying at school longer, young marriage/ pregnancy actively discouraged and frowned upon, uni unofficially taking the school leaving age to 23 for middle class young people, staying living at their parents well into their late 20's/ early 30's....)

To me it seems discouraging starting real adult life is fuelling this.

  1. Young women are told not to expect "security" in relationships, they are almost told to expect being ghosted by a series of men "not wanting to put a label on it," and going on a series of disastrous online dates is better than settling down young. Look how much marriage amongst under 25's is frowned upon on Mumsnet.

But I don't see many aspects of the dating scene today, ("friends with benefits" being cool, sex often expected without commitment before or afterwards on the first couple of dates, having to actually spell out you don't want the guy you are dating online to continue dating others online, being ghosted and blocked for no reason, being particularly healthy for the mental health of young people). Yet this is sold to them as more empowering than settling down into a steady relationship at a relatively young age....

  1. I'll expect to be flamed for this, but the active discouragement of having children in your 20's , probably robs a lot of women of a focus, ( because having your own family is often a nice focus), than drifting around without a purpose gives them. This also leads to probably more people experiencing the panic of miscarriage and infertility , ( risks increasing with age), into their 30's.

  2. Active encouragement into University without thinking often leads to a horrendously mentally unhealthy lifestyle.

For those with a passion for the subject, or doing a vocational course that leads to a career, of course university should be supported.

But that is not the case for your average student. Your average student goes to uni because, broadly speaking, it's what their college or sixth form expects of anyone vaguely academic. They pick a subject with no fixed career that they are at best, vaguely interested in, ( managed to scrape a B in business studies A Level, hated it the least, so I'll do it at uni to delay working for three years).

They head to uni to study a subject they are not particularly interested in, ith no idea what it will lead to afterwards. Most, have at most, six hours a week contact time, ( often less post covid). They sleep in late, browse the internet and get smashed a few times a week, ( the majority of students I know do not work in term time). Rinse and repeat. And they wonder why living this not very appealing lifestyle leaves students at poor risk of mental health ? And many are encouraged to take on a masters in a subject they are not interested in, with no direct career, to delay entering the real world for another year. They live in a bubble with people of the same age and inexperience as them. Compare that to a 19 year old office juniour being up and about, learning about the world of work, going for after work drinks with colleagues of a variety of ages ?

And the housing crisis means they are still likely to be living at home, ( especially if they are single), until 30. Often treated like overgrown teenagers, still in the habit of explaining to their parents where they are going of an evening. My friend , ( male), was explaining to me that at 28 he was working himself up to staying the night at his new girlfriends as he was so embarrassed to explain where he was to his parents, ( because if he told them he wouldn't be home for dinner as he was staying at his girlfriend's , they'd realise he was having sex).

In short, is delaying marriage, babies, work , moving out and leaving education actually causing everyone to be directionless and unhappy ?

OP posts:
Hellothere54 · 13/12/2022 06:45

Damn! If only I’d known that focusing on finding a man, pumping out a couple of kids and settling down would be the answer to everything! Instead I have moved around, lived in various cities, enjoyed myself (without sex or a man as am completely disinterested in both) taught multiple classes of amazing little minds and (I know this is considered disgusting and wrong on here) but I enjoy living in rented accommodation so I can up sticks and move easily. Am I always happy - no. Have I had MH difficulties - occasionally. Would I change my life and experiences to settle down with a man and focus on a baby - no!

BMrs · 13/12/2022 06:40

Perhaps this is your experience but certainly not mine or the world we live in.

I work at a College and we actively support our students progressing to university, we even have our own HE courses. But this is because this generation is expected to have a degree. It's the equivalent of what our GCSE English and maths results used to be, almost a minimum requirement now for anything more than an entry level job.

However, we do not encourage studying a vague subject that doesn't lead to a career, delaying growing up by studying and studying and ending up in debt. We focus on career progression, specific pathways etc.

I would argue the mental health crisis has more to do with social media than anything. Also, we've always had huge mental health issues but now it isn't something to be ashamed of so more people are speaking up and seeking help for it.

ASDADHDBAME · 13/12/2022 06:29

Also why is there such disdain for those who live in their hometowns all their life!
Me and DH live very close to where we grew up. Have been together since 16 (now 30) and are married with DC. Both have good educations (via Uni for me and Apprenticeship for DH) and earn similar wages that are good money for our area (mid 30k)
We live close to our parents and can help out with things and receive help vice Versa , and can support with caring for my grandparents.
I think in some ways the expectation that people are not expected to help older generations is quite damaging to society.

KTheGrey · 13/12/2022 06:27

The most ironic part of this being that there are scads of very good looking young parent influencers on social media, basically funding their families by selling an ideal family life of travel and cute small children.

Ylvamoon · 13/12/2022 06:22

I think the trigger for the mental health crisis starts much earlier than op suggested.

I also think that parents, teachers and society at large are partially responsible. The mantra of everyone is a winner leaves young people ill prepared for negotiating adult life.

Luellie · 13/12/2022 06:05

mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 12/12/2022 22:22

I definitely feel that getting married and having children relatively young (24) was very good for me and DH, in terms of having a focus. We did go to university first, however, so had the best of both worlds, because we have decent careers too (especially him, as my early career was hampered by having three children).

I really don't think it's possible to have it all, and having children was definitely a big priority for me.

This is my experience too.

I agree with OP that there's something to be said for it not being 'cool' to have high standards for relationships in your 20s. So many of my friends tiptoe around their boyfriends, trying to squeeze out some level of commitment without ever feeling able to actually ask for what they want. They don't want to come off "crazy" or "pushy".

I also think that with uni, there's no shame in getting a degree for the sake of it if it's something you're passionate about. I think high levels of education are good for society, whether or not it leads to a 'better' job. But false expectations about where a degree will lead would be disappointing, I suppose.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 13/12/2022 05:49

Great post. Something I’ve thought about a lot over the last few years but you’ve articulated it really well.

PissedOffAmericanWoman · 13/12/2022 05:22

Champagneexterior · 13/12/2022 04:37

What if women don't want children? I don't and I have plenty of focus thanks! I will echo what others have said about those who have married young! The people I knew from school from my small hometown who married/settled down young have not broadened their horizons since school, lower income, have stayed in their hometown, drink at the same pubs, same group of friends, same small town mindset. They also generally look much older and tired like they've given up- we are only around 30 but plenty of them look like they are in their 40's! You will see plenty of the women on Facebook trying to engage you in their next hun army MLM. I would never swap my life of university, travel and establishing myself in my career, meeting my partner in my late 20's and buying a home together for settling with my sixth form boyfriend, taking on a 20k a year job and sending my kids to the same school I went to in the same small town. I appreciate the disastrous dates I've experienced in my 20's as they've helped me decide what I want in a partner and I believe have helped me ultimately find a better partner.

Why is it that certain kinds of people always assume that when someone is speaking generally that they must mean EVERYONE? Are you intentionally taking OP out of context for your narrative convenience or do you truly struggle with english this much? Did you miss the lessons on context clues in school?

Memam · 13/12/2022 05:20

It's an interesting question, but to me the problem has a lot to do with people being fed a constant celebrity/influencer-led, picture perfect lifestyle without the celebrity/influencer income. People who buy into it end up trapped in debt. It has little to do with marriage or kids as security comes from within not from having a partner or kids.

My cousin married and had kids later in life and she said knowing what she knows now, alongside obviously feeling fortunate to be fertile, she's glad not to have lost her freedom through marriage or parenting at a younger age. She's always had great jobs, been financially secure and had high self-esteem.

It's great food for thought OP and your points about poor dating culture are good, but I reckon they just add to the main problem. I think most mental health issues are a combination of celebrity/influencer role models, comparing one's life to a social media feed, trying to (as mentioned above) live a celebrity lifestyle without a celebrity income (in reality most likely fuelled by the Bank of Mum and Dad), all leading to very low self-esteem and lack of real autonomy.

Cuppasoupmonster · 13/12/2022 04:40

@Champagneexterior it’s quite clear OP is talking in a general sense isn’t it? And generally women (and men) do.

Champagneexterior · 13/12/2022 04:37

What if women don't want children? I don't and I have plenty of focus thanks! I will echo what others have said about those who have married young! The people I knew from school from my small hometown who married/settled down young have not broadened their horizons since school, lower income, have stayed in their hometown, drink at the same pubs, same group of friends, same small town mindset. They also generally look much older and tired like they've given up- we are only around 30 but plenty of them look like they are in their 40's! You will see plenty of the women on Facebook trying to engage you in their next hun army MLM. I would never swap my life of university, travel and establishing myself in my career, meeting my partner in my late 20's and buying a home together for settling with my sixth form boyfriend, taking on a 20k a year job and sending my kids to the same school I went to in the same small town. I appreciate the disastrous dates I've experienced in my 20's as they've helped me decide what I want in a partner and I believe have helped me ultimately find a better partner.

Jenasaurus · 13/12/2022 04:31

I get where you are coming from with this but each situation is different and sometimes its the only option. I have 3 adult DC, my eldest left home and bought a place with his GF when he was 29, he saved and with the addition of an inheritance from his grandma he managed to finally buy and move on with his life. He also stayed with me I feel as I had gone through DA and split from his DF and was in a bad place, I think he wanted to help get me through it and even when he left home, both him and his GF constantly contacted me to check I was OK, so it was more he felt I needed support than the other way round. My DS is 33 and his GF have got engaged but want to move to a larger home with a garden before they have a family, they are worried about the cost of living at the moment and dont feel its the right time to move or start a family, his GF is 28 so probably wont have DC until early to mid thirties

My middle DS left for Uni and then instead of coming home, he rented with his GF (now wife) who he met at Uni, he said he would have come back but because I could only afford a small flat and he was used to living away from home he would cope better than the other 2, with finances and 'real life" He moved out at 18 I guess and it did do him well, he has an excellent job. lovely home and got married this year. Incidentally he works for the same organisation as me, and I see him more often than when he was living at home, I am always at their house dog sitting etc., His DW wants to be a SAHM when they have a family, and my DS has said they are waiting until they are financially secure to have DC if they do, he is 29 and she is 28 so no rush

My DD is 27 and lives with me, but her BF also lives here, he sadly lost his DM in 2020 during the pandemic and needed help as he found himself alone and potentially homeless at the age of 20 (yes my DD is 5 years older than him), My DD is in her final year of studying to be a teacher after making the decision to change her career and before that was on a relatively low wage as a TA and then a manager of a holiday care group for children. So low paid childcare roles and not in a position to either rent or buy. She will be buying somewhere next year with her BF at the age of 28 when she qualifies and gets a paid teaching post. Her BF has been promoted recently to a manager so both will be in a good position to buy, sadly both have also got a deposit each from inheritances, My DD and her BF have been lovely to have around and it has worked well. My DD has decided against having DC herself for health reasons so no ticking clock. (although she may change her mind)

My 3 all made very different choices about when the time to move out was, there was/is no pressure from me, and I think they made the right decision when I compare it to what happened to me. I left home at 19 bought my first home, them moved after 2 years and then again, we had 3 DC and were together 28 years, but I felt pressurised to leave home when I did, not by my family but because my Ex lost his parents when he was 18 and said I was all he had left and we should buy a place together. My DP didnt like him as said he bullied me and to be fair he was a bully, i was immature and got with him as an act of rebellion which in effect ruined 28 years of my life for making a point. I guess what I am saying, living at home for a bit longer if your not ready to move out or in the right relationship etc, isnt always the wrong thing.

To be fair I went back to live with my mum in my 40s whilst we sold up and split the home, My DM also was very unwell so I stayed to care for her until she had to go into a home with Alzeimers when she deteriorated.

People are all different and with the cost of living its no surpise that young people want to save up and live at home for longer, as long as it works for all parties then thats what works.

PissedOffAmericanWoman · 13/12/2022 04:23

You’re not wrong. I’ve been feeling the same way. While I don’t think all women need to get married and have children to be happy, I think many are delaying those milestones because it’s fashionable or because they are scared but they actually want those things.

I was met with a lot of unexpected skepticism when I was engaged, married and then again when I became pregnant.

I’ve been in a very happy healthy long term relationship though so… I just don’t understand it.

When I got engaged I was in a relationship for 7 years and it has been smooth sailing the entire time. You know how people talk about the honeymoon phase going away after 2 years? We were still in it. We were 26. We eloped. I felt like I was spiritually married to this man for years already. When I told my friends they were shocked. They said aren’t you too young to be married?! I didn’t see the point of waiting. 26 is well into adulthood and the relationship was clearly very solid. What were we waiting for exactly?

Then I announced my planned pregnancy at 30. Still very happy very smooth relationship. Once again met with shock but this time from my friends AND my parents. Once again saying I was too young. Look I don’t want to be rude but I can’t think of a more ideal scenario to become pregnant. Happy in love parents who want baby and have money, plans and space for baby to be and have been together for 10+ years still going strong.

Are we just waiting for some arbitrary number? How is 30 too young? I was starting to feel like if they had it their way we would have waited until menopause kicked in or something.

I don’t want to speak ill of the people that I love but my parents got married waaaayy too young so I think they were projecting that fear onto me because of it. As for my friends I love them but they are all in very screwed up relationships. We got the girl whose been engaged for ten years and depressed realizing she’ll never get married, the guy who is upset that he can’t find girls who will accept his polyamory sexuality and changes relationships like he changes his underwear, the girl who focused on becoming a pilot for so long that she’s now unable to conceive because she waited too long to properly date and start a family and is now trying to find egg donors so she can become pregnant… alone. And another that feels like she has to settle for a cheating boyfriend and calls it an open relationship so others don’t ask too many questions…

They joke that I’m old fashioned. I guess being in love and daring to be loved back and having a family is old fashioned now. That’s kind of depressing.

I will gladly be labeled as outdated then deal with… any of that mess.

cloudsandream · 13/12/2022 04:02

Ah another youngster bashing thread, cry me a river 🙃

Mamanyt · 13/12/2022 03:29

Interesting fact. The portion of the brain that deals in recognizing consequences does not fully develop in women until around age 25, and in men it is even later...around age 30.

It is very possible that delaying these things does a bit of both....young people feel a bit rudderless, but when they DO make a choice, it is more considered than when they are younger.

Tabitha888 · 13/12/2022 02:59

I think you are trying to justify your course of life. Married with a lack of understanding about mental health .

The new generations have dealt with so much, recessions, the Conservative party messing a lot of things up for them. A global pandemic which wasn't great for anyone.

It's such a sweeping post, If anything women have been taught to look after themselves better, and that it is ok to have sex and enjoy it. You don't have to rush into kids.

You waffle on about so much. It's frustrating.

RobinRobinMouse · 13/12/2022 02:47

Oh, also I got married at 24, so fairly youngish, but we both wanted to do other things before having a child.

RobinRobinMouse · 13/12/2022 02:43

I'm always so glad I had my child in my 30s, I don't think it has done much to my 'focus', whatever that is supposed to mean.

WineCap · 13/12/2022 02:39

Hmmmm...I agree that lack of direction and opportunity can cause mental health issues. However, you can have direction and standards while also holding off on starting a family. I met my DH while studying one of those 'pointless' degrees.

We lived in our university city for a couple of years after I graduated as my DH needed an Masters for his career. I spent that time working in a bar, doing an internship, volunteering and travelling around Europe. I had a great time and found a career path off the back of the internship.

We then moved into my in laws for 2 years to save for 3 months of travelling and a house deposit. I started my career after travelling and became a home owner at 25. My in laws loved spending that time with us and it has certainly allowed us to have stronger relationships.

I got married at 28 and spent 7 years in my career before I had my first DC at 30. I'm now a SAHM that is thoroughly enjoying motherhood following lots of incredible experiences. I'm about to launch a business, and that is only possible because my lovely in laws care for my DC one day a week.

I've really enjoyed each stage of life so far and that is partially because I always had direction but also because I took my time to get married and have children.

In the end, I think that teenagers need more freedoms AND responsibilities to give them to confidence to tackle life's future challenges. Too many parents fuss over their teenagers and won't let go and gives them a childish mentality into adulthood.

ChillysWaterBottle · 13/12/2022 02:29

the active discouragement of having children in your 20's , probably robs a lot of women of a focus, ( because having your own family is often a nice focus), than drifting around without a purpose gives them.

Lmao come on OP. Only the unhappiest and most messed up of my peer group had kids in their 20s. The happier, more successful, more stable ones all started families in their 30s.

I would look instead to growing inequality and the poor prospects available to many young people.

I do think social media is an unmitigated disaster for mental wellbeing though.

zingboom · 13/12/2022 01:56

@rudolphrainbownose No.

I will partially agree with you on education, i.e. that too many young adults drift into a degree that does them no good because we don't talk enough about the alternatives to uni and how they're just as valid. I also don't think uni is a particularly worthwhile use of anyone's time unless they do a vocational degree. I have a non-vocational degree - it's a very good one from a very good uni - but speaking honestly, even though it made me more employable, I don't think I got much out of it. The lie just perpetuates. I suppose it keeps academics in a job.

The housing crisis is forcing more people to stay at home for longer, as is the difficulty in getting your first relevant job to the career you want. However, I'd say entitlement is part of the problem. I know plenty of young people who think their only two choices are living with their parents or renting a very expensive posh flat with more rooms than they need. They seem to think that a houseshare is beneath them (what do they think they're doing with family?), but it would allow them more independence and still the ability to save a little. They don't need to rent the sort of flat they'd like to one day buy - when you first move out, you have to set expectations lower.

I think if women want to have children, they should think about it carefully from a younger age as fertility does decline remarkably sharply. However, it's incredibly insulting to suggest that having a child is what makes a woman's life complete. It's also insulting to suggest that women in their 30s are unhappy because they didn't have a kid ten years earlier and thus have a fulfilling relationship with a man.

If you're in your 20s and dating men your own age, chances are, you'll end up a single mum because men in their 20s are immature and run away. Being a single mum takes away a large number of choices in the UK - the cost of childcare can be prohibitive, especially if you have no family support. And if you're in your 20s and dating older men, maybe you've found love, and love doesn't recognise age gaps, but more likely, you're being taken advantage of.

The women who fall in love in their 20s, have children and stay in lasting relationships are the lucky exception not the norm. The women who don't end up in that situation don't end up in their situation because they're doing anything wrong.

And don't forget, some women don't want children, and that's OK. And also don't forget that being single is also OK.

I agree that women should get security in relationships, but a lot of men these days are just shit. We'd be doing young women a disservice to teach them that all men are nice and will treat them well - we have to be honest as to what red flags to look out for and how to protect themselves from financial inequality/abuse in a relationship.

I'd love to wave a magic wand and make all unpartnered-off men decent men, but I'm not Harry bloody Potter.

socialmedia23 · 13/12/2022 01:37

Liorae · 13/12/2022 01:29

Jewish people are lucky in the sense that they mainly live in London/Herts/Manchester
That will be news to the worldwide Jewish community 😉

Well antisemitism is separate to this issue. I meant relative to most people in the UK who would mostly not have a family home in the capital or even within commuting distance. Most of the Jewish diaspora do tend to live in cities, as my rabbi says we are an urban people. I guess this is changing as an increasing percentage of Jewish people now live in Israel.

Liorae · 13/12/2022 01:29

Jewish people are lucky in the sense that they mainly live in London/Herts/Manchester
That will be news to the worldwide Jewish community 😉

socialmedia23 · 13/12/2022 01:00

Liorae · 13/12/2022 00:54

This is why ultra orthodox Judaism encourages very young marriage. Rather than sowing wild oats you are focused on supporting your family. It's considered to be beneficial for all concerned.

Having children before buying a house does make it more difficult to buy a house. Jewish people are lucky in the sense that they mainly live in London/Herts/Manchester so they are fairly near economic centres so would hopefully have had a few years of living at home for a decent deposit even if they marry young/have kids young. That's how we managed to buy in London- it was all thanks to DH's mum insistence on living near her synagogue in the 1990s even if it meant staying in a 1 bed flat with 3 children until she could afford a house in the same area. If she had not been Jewish she would have moved out of London and probably we would not have been able to live with her and have our jobs in London.

EmmaAgain22 · 13/12/2022 00:59

Liorae · 13/12/2022 00:54

This is why ultra orthodox Judaism encourages very young marriage. Rather than sowing wild oats you are focused on supporting your family. It's considered to be beneficial for all concerned.

This whole thread gave me this ear worm but esp this post.

gi me the birth control...