Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the encouragement to delay real life is a big cause in the explosion of mental health issues in under 35's ?

365 replies

rudolphrainbownose · 12/12/2022 21:20

Okay, so there is a well documented mental health crisis amongst young people , particularly university students, needing mental health support.

Is it just me or is the current culture of delaying "real adulthood" ( staying at school longer, young marriage/ pregnancy actively discouraged and frowned upon, uni unofficially taking the school leaving age to 23 for middle class young people, staying living at their parents well into their late 20's/ early 30's....)

To me it seems discouraging starting real adult life is fuelling this.

  1. Young women are told not to expect "security" in relationships, they are almost told to expect being ghosted by a series of men "not wanting to put a label on it," and going on a series of disastrous online dates is better than settling down young. Look how much marriage amongst under 25's is frowned upon on Mumsnet.

But I don't see many aspects of the dating scene today, ("friends with benefits" being cool, sex often expected without commitment before or afterwards on the first couple of dates, having to actually spell out you don't want the guy you are dating online to continue dating others online, being ghosted and blocked for no reason, being particularly healthy for the mental health of young people). Yet this is sold to them as more empowering than settling down into a steady relationship at a relatively young age....

  1. I'll expect to be flamed for this, but the active discouragement of having children in your 20's , probably robs a lot of women of a focus, ( because having your own family is often a nice focus), than drifting around without a purpose gives them. This also leads to probably more people experiencing the panic of miscarriage and infertility , ( risks increasing with age), into their 30's.

  2. Active encouragement into University without thinking often leads to a horrendously mentally unhealthy lifestyle.

For those with a passion for the subject, or doing a vocational course that leads to a career, of course university should be supported.

But that is not the case for your average student. Your average student goes to uni because, broadly speaking, it's what their college or sixth form expects of anyone vaguely academic. They pick a subject with no fixed career that they are at best, vaguely interested in, ( managed to scrape a B in business studies A Level, hated it the least, so I'll do it at uni to delay working for three years).

They head to uni to study a subject they are not particularly interested in, ith no idea what it will lead to afterwards. Most, have at most, six hours a week contact time, ( often less post covid). They sleep in late, browse the internet and get smashed a few times a week, ( the majority of students I know do not work in term time). Rinse and repeat. And they wonder why living this not very appealing lifestyle leaves students at poor risk of mental health ? And many are encouraged to take on a masters in a subject they are not interested in, with no direct career, to delay entering the real world for another year. They live in a bubble with people of the same age and inexperience as them. Compare that to a 19 year old office juniour being up and about, learning about the world of work, going for after work drinks with colleagues of a variety of ages ?

And the housing crisis means they are still likely to be living at home, ( especially if they are single), until 30. Often treated like overgrown teenagers, still in the habit of explaining to their parents where they are going of an evening. My friend , ( male), was explaining to me that at 28 he was working himself up to staying the night at his new girlfriends as he was so embarrassed to explain where he was to his parents, ( because if he told them he wouldn't be home for dinner as he was staying at his girlfriend's , they'd realise he was having sex).

In short, is delaying marriage, babies, work , moving out and leaving education actually causing everyone to be directionless and unhappy ?

OP posts:
KillingLoneliness · 13/12/2022 08:22

YABU, it’s extremely difficult for people in their 20’s to earn enough to buy a home and have the financial stability needed to raise children or get married.
I moved out into a rental when I was 20, by 22 I had my first child and I was married (a cheap registry wedding) and by 23 I had my second child.

We are now in our mid 30’s, still stuck in rentals, we’ve had two section 21’s, weve been homeless, we’ve had many job losses, there’s been so many ups and downs. I have chronic depression and anxiety I know I wouldn’t survive without my parents helping me all the time.
In hindsight myself and my husband should have got ourselves into a proper career before having our children so we could have given them more stability, I constantly feel like I’ve failed them due to be being so young and naive when we had them.

eyope · 13/12/2022 08:21

fb.watch/hnXMMRKDOo/

Great video clip of exactly why people get to middle age and feel unhappy. Lots of the older women I work with who married young,mentor our young apprentices and grads to enjoy their lives and find career success and speak of how they wished they had.

It's not just as publicised because most are from a generation where mental health wasn't talked about as openly as we do with the youth today.

yoyy · 13/12/2022 08:19

Aren't men over 40s most at risk from suicide? what's impacting that?

eyope · 13/12/2022 08:17

Completely disagree with 1 and 2 because we should be pushing young people to have careers, hobbies, explore the world and figure themselves out BEFORE they settle down. Dating and marriage and kids should not be the only thing young people have to look forward to. Adult life isn't just marriage and kids. It's learning responsibility for yourself, making a living, paying taxes and bills, learning emotional maturity and how to be a productive member of the society you are in. Far too many young people make rubbish parents and partners because they got socialised into doing these things when they weren't ready.

Doing this is young is exactly why so many middle aged people have crises and mental health breakdowns and divorces - because you get to your 50s, kids are older and moved away and you realise you don't even know who you are, you regret not having had any adventures and life seems to have passed by. The access of the internet, opportunities to do things via a phone, the world getting smaller only makes it more obvious how more there is to life.

I do agree kids should be encouraged to move away from home young and begin adult life asap.

SpicyFoodRocks · 13/12/2022 08:14

And anecdotally, nobody in my social circle had kids before their thirties. All are in good jobs, no divorces and have teens and young adults who are now excited about their own futures. The kids are not pathetic entitled youngsters. They are ambitious, kind, very hard-working and probably more knowledgable about the word than my generation was. My kids and their friends don’t post photos on social media at all, see no point in ‘influencers’ and don’t have nail extensions, fake eyelashes etc. So many cliches about young adults here.

I cannot believe so many women here are advocating that women don’t get an education and start breeding in their early twenties. My kids are so lucky to have parents who do not want them to restrict their prospects and who believe in gender equality.

helford · 13/12/2022 08:06

I think MH issues among the young, is due to a lack of hope in their future & the school ing system which is geared toward results and targets.

Low pay, poor working conditions, large amounts of debt & yes UNI or FE is required now for many many jobs from electrician to nurse.

Does the OP actually know that to get married and have kids requires a house and decent wages, which as i said needs qualifications, obtained at Uni FE.

As for the stereotyping of students? total BS.

ChristmasBallBall · 13/12/2022 07:57

I think young people's mental health is more affected by the fact that there are no decent or realistic prospects of adequately paid and secure jobs which can afford them enough to live independently of their parents.

Wages are too low and the cost of living is too high. Young people are kept infantilised by this because they literally can't afford to live away from home. Often they're saddled with a ton of uni debt too.

At least luckily women have far more options these days than settle down with a man and have kids.

SpicyFoodRocks · 13/12/2022 07:56

Of all the things causing young women stress these days, you pick them getting an education and not having babies young? Gosh OP you have backwards and sexist thinking and could not be more wrong.

yoyy · 13/12/2022 07:51

@MusicstillonMTV perhaps but I don't think that's to do with going to uni or delaying having dc.

yoyy · 13/12/2022 07:49

Why is not having dc delaying starting your life?

I met DH young, didn't have a dc till 10 years later. I wanted to build my career & enjoy the freedom of not having dc. @MrsBennetsPoorNerves I agree with you, I'm so grateful for that time because I will never get it back.

catmum88 · 13/12/2022 07:49

Women aren’t just walking wombs you know. I spent my 20s focusing on my career, I did extremely well and am now pregnant with my first child at 34 whilst being extremely financially and mentally stable. That simply wasn’t the case in my 20s. The same applies to most of my friends. Most of the people I know who got married and had children in their early 20s are now divorced, which doesn’t seem ideal either (being from a broken home myself). People now have choices in life which do not just involve popping out kids.

MusicstillonMTV · 13/12/2022 07:47

Also didn't previous generations tend to mask their mental ill more?

I think yes previous generations did do this and it wasn't always good but I also think the current generation is encouraged to wallow rather than seek tools to adapt and overcome their issues. We haven't got the balance right.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/12/2022 07:46

rudolphrainbownose · 12/12/2022 21:46

Well no, actually. I think drifting around without a focus has had just as big an impact on young male mental health.
It's not about having children per se. But it's about the encouragement of essentially spending your 20's waiting for life to start.

It's really interesting to me, and a little sad too, that you see the period before settling down and having children as "waiting for life to start". I couldn't disagree more!

I regard the period between leaving school and having my dd at 32 as one of the richest and most interesting periods in my life. I travelled a lot, lived abroad in 2 different countries, made friends, and had so many amazing experiences as well as time to explore who I really was and what I wanted. I wasn't waiting for anything, I was living my life to the full, in the moment.

Having had that time for myself made it so much easier for me to enjoy being a parent when dd came along. I didn't feel like I had to make sacrifices because I had already has a chance to do lots of the things that I wanted to do. I felt ready for that next stage, and I relished it, but I certainly wouldn't have been ready for a family 10 years earlier.

Having a family and building a successful career for myself in my 30s and 40s has been immensely rewarding, but I am so, so glad that I had those carefree years first when I wasn't weighed down by all of the responsibilities that I have now, when I was free to just follow my own interests and try new things. Life would have been so much poorer without those opportunities and my mental health would have certainly suffered.

My mum, who married at 22 and suffered terrible mental health problems. She has always said that she regrets not having had the opportunity to do more for herself, to live her own life. I always knew that I didn't want to end up like that.

Maybe some people waste their youth to the extent that it feels like they're just waiting for real life to start, but the answer to that in my view isn't to encourage them to saddle themselves with responsibilities from an earlier age, but rather to encourage them to do more with that time while they have it.

I still get satisfaction even now from reflecting on all of the things that I did in my younger years, and I want that same breadth and richness of experience for dd. She is going to have decades of thinking about work and family. I sincerely hope that she makes time to live a little for herself first.

LabradorEyes · 13/12/2022 07:44

Going to university is the best thing that happened to me. I took a subject which has been the focus of my career, I met great friends who I still see regularly 30 years later and gave me the confidence to build a good life for myself. I had a child at 33, after travelling the world and buying a house. It was the right time for me and I didn't feel I was missing out by having a child. I would have not been ready for motherhood before that.

Years later, I became single again and my MH didn't suffer, because I had the security of having a good job, a career, the friends and education to help me through the tough times.

It might not be for everyone, but I have encouraged my DC to do the same: study, travel, work and DELAY getting settled. Life is long and there's no rush to settle down

FlemCandango · 13/12/2022 07:41

I went to university 30 years ago in the hope that I would meet like minded intellectuals and more importantly get away from my shitty little town. I was largely disappointed but I am not sure getting the sort of job an 18 yo in a shitty little town could get would have been a great option so I have to disagree op.

I did have life experience, lived away from home, learned actions have consequences, learned to live with people not my family. All while studying a subject I enjoyed and a fantastic music based social life that has stayed with me. I also met the man who later became dh/ father to our 3 amazing kids all born when out of my feckless 20s.

I do not see uni as the be all and end all but it offers opportunities, as does working and for me after uni moving to London was the key to opening up more opportunities and I don't think I would have done as well without going to university. For uncertain, intelligent feckless young people (which I definitely was in 92) uni was the best option.

Mental health issues are complex and as I work in a role that puts me in contact with many people struggling with mental health, poverty, lack of opportunity, social exclusion and ill health is key to the majority of these issues, situation and pre disposition. Not going to uni when you didn't need to, or having children over 30. It is pointless looking back and saying things used to be better, as well as unhelpful. Our society is what we have made it, capitalistic, individualistic and inequitable. We need to address the real poverty and social divides that cause much of the unhappiness you witness

yoyy · 13/12/2022 07:38

Also didn't previous generations tend to mask their mental ill more? plus there was more reliance on crutches like alcohol & smoking?

WonderingWanda · 13/12/2022 07:38

I don't think that's the issue.

My dm left school at 16 with few qualifications had me young and by the time she was my age had been divorced twice. She made choices on men based on needing someone to look after her and has no way to financially support herself. She is an intelligent woman who could have had a career if the expectations had been higher.

In contrast I have a degree, a career and much more stability. I'm married to a wonderful man and I have dc but have maintained my ability to support myself and my kids financially on my own should the need ever arise.

I do agree that for some students the academic course they are pushed on to are not always suitable, at gcse there need to be more vocational choices and the government needs to not downgrade schools progress 8 if they reduce the number of gcse's a child takes. The real issue is low wages and high cost of living. I think young people would like to move on with their lives but cannot afford to do it whilst at the same time being bombarded with social media telling them what life ought to look like. This is the cause of the mental health crisis.

yoyy · 13/12/2022 07:36

it’s quite clear OP is talking in a general sense isn’t it? And generally women (and men) do.

I thought for younger generations they don't generally want dc?

Forever42 · 13/12/2022 07:27

In many European countries people study at university until their late 20s and don't start work until then.

Dittosaw · 13/12/2022 07:24

You’ve made some good points. Boys especially are told to be “men” and them treated like children. Women are told to aspire to shallow goals such as looking good, which hardly fill the soul with purpose. They find it hard to build anything meaningful. People aren’t religious and nothing has replaced that value system.

The old system of getting married young, working hard, buying a house and having kids may be archaic but it was fairly successful at creating a stable society. Kids are increasingly being brought up in single parent families and seeing unstable relationships which don’t last.

Something needs to change and fast.

Kids are not learning resilience from trying and failing, or being independent. They are cushioned and cosseted all their lives. Probably because their parents suffered but some degree of standing on your own two feet is needed.

Grumpybutfunny · 13/12/2022 07:23

Oh god know not having kids in your 20 helps close the gender pay back, I would never change DS but I do wish I had him a few years later. Not balancing a child and post grad qualifications would have been much easier.

As for living at home longer, that comes down to the parents DS will have a key and be free to come and go as he please. Yes I will still make him tea but if he wants to reheat it at midnight or take it to work the next day to throw in the bin that's up to him.

Parkopedia · 13/12/2022 07:21

I focussed on building my career in my 20s rather than having children.

YABVU

LlynTegid · 13/12/2022 07:16

I disagree with you on your point about later motherhood, but agree with the general sentiment of your views. Especially about universities.

1AngelicFruitCake · 13/12/2022 07:14

luxxlisbon · 12/12/2022 21:40

but the active discouragement of having children in your 20's , probably robs a lot of women of a focus, ( because having your own family is often a nice focus), than drifting around without a purpose gives them.

Yeah, the opposite of having children in your 20s is drifting around without a purpose 🙄

I’ve found the parents of children in my own children’s classes who have waited and have children later seem more stable, more likely to own, more likely to pay for clubs etc. Don’t think having children young makes you a devoted parent.

Beezknees · 13/12/2022 07:10

YABU. I had a baby at 18 and wouldn't recommend other women do the same.