Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the encouragement to delay real life is a big cause in the explosion of mental health issues in under 35's ?

365 replies

rudolphrainbownose · 12/12/2022 21:20

Okay, so there is a well documented mental health crisis amongst young people , particularly university students, needing mental health support.

Is it just me or is the current culture of delaying "real adulthood" ( staying at school longer, young marriage/ pregnancy actively discouraged and frowned upon, uni unofficially taking the school leaving age to 23 for middle class young people, staying living at their parents well into their late 20's/ early 30's....)

To me it seems discouraging starting real adult life is fuelling this.

  1. Young women are told not to expect "security" in relationships, they are almost told to expect being ghosted by a series of men "not wanting to put a label on it," and going on a series of disastrous online dates is better than settling down young. Look how much marriage amongst under 25's is frowned upon on Mumsnet.

But I don't see many aspects of the dating scene today, ("friends with benefits" being cool, sex often expected without commitment before or afterwards on the first couple of dates, having to actually spell out you don't want the guy you are dating online to continue dating others online, being ghosted and blocked for no reason, being particularly healthy for the mental health of young people). Yet this is sold to them as more empowering than settling down into a steady relationship at a relatively young age....

  1. I'll expect to be flamed for this, but the active discouragement of having children in your 20's , probably robs a lot of women of a focus, ( because having your own family is often a nice focus), than drifting around without a purpose gives them. This also leads to probably more people experiencing the panic of miscarriage and infertility , ( risks increasing with age), into their 30's.

  2. Active encouragement into University without thinking often leads to a horrendously mentally unhealthy lifestyle.

For those with a passion for the subject, or doing a vocational course that leads to a career, of course university should be supported.

But that is not the case for your average student. Your average student goes to uni because, broadly speaking, it's what their college or sixth form expects of anyone vaguely academic. They pick a subject with no fixed career that they are at best, vaguely interested in, ( managed to scrape a B in business studies A Level, hated it the least, so I'll do it at uni to delay working for three years).

They head to uni to study a subject they are not particularly interested in, ith no idea what it will lead to afterwards. Most, have at most, six hours a week contact time, ( often less post covid). They sleep in late, browse the internet and get smashed a few times a week, ( the majority of students I know do not work in term time). Rinse and repeat. And they wonder why living this not very appealing lifestyle leaves students at poor risk of mental health ? And many are encouraged to take on a masters in a subject they are not interested in, with no direct career, to delay entering the real world for another year. They live in a bubble with people of the same age and inexperience as them. Compare that to a 19 year old office juniour being up and about, learning about the world of work, going for after work drinks with colleagues of a variety of ages ?

And the housing crisis means they are still likely to be living at home, ( especially if they are single), until 30. Often treated like overgrown teenagers, still in the habit of explaining to their parents where they are going of an evening. My friend , ( male), was explaining to me that at 28 he was working himself up to staying the night at his new girlfriends as he was so embarrassed to explain where he was to his parents, ( because if he told them he wouldn't be home for dinner as he was staying at his girlfriend's , they'd realise he was having sex).

In short, is delaying marriage, babies, work , moving out and leaving education actually causing everyone to be directionless and unhappy ?

OP posts:
socialmedia23 · 13/12/2022 13:27

Blueeyedgirl21 · 13/12/2022 10:53

I don’t think it’s the lack of marriage and kids but I do agree with the point that young people are often pushed into uni with the view that they will be destitute later in life without some random degree they barely care about

how about encouraging them to get jobs, work up the ladder, move out and go into a house share , get some independence that way

Most of my friends were gifted 100-200k to buy their own places. Some even got houses purchased for them. I effectively got a gift of £50k for my place because of rent free living for three years. My dad also offered to buy me a house which I could stay in for free which i rejected as I wanted to buy a home in my name in an area of my choice. My friends and I all went to university so whether we went to university or not does not impact our housing situation or choices. Btw my peers are not from rich households, they were just bog standard middle class.

I don't blame my peers who are from asset poor families for being resentful as the inequality in this country means that someone can be on 70-100k but not being able to buy a flat of house within 50 miles of his place of work but someone with asset rich parents would be able to own a house even with very low income. You have to earn an extra 50k to outbid someone with a 200k deposit gifted from parents. Its no longer a meritocracy anymore and everyone in my generation (I am 30) knows it.

pocketvenuss · 13/12/2022 13:26

Yes yes. Education and independence for women.....such a bad thing 🙄

socialmedia23 · 13/12/2022 13:18

Blueeyedgirl21 · 13/12/2022 12:32

@JamSandle ?? Most jobs have a chance of progression or chance to increase your earning potential. A friend of mine started working in nandos at 17, quit uni after three weeks, now works training new nandos managers around the country and abroad, he earns £75k a year loves his job no student debt. There is chance for progressing further also. Even with a trade you can set up on your own, take on employees etc

My DH earns 65k and he says we are low income. According to ONS we are top 10% in terms of PAYE income (double income no kids) but most PAYE earners are struggling so that's not very comforting. I mean we own our flat in London and have a comparatively low mortgage at £1020 per month. But we are definitely just managing, luckier than the people visiting food banks but not miles better. What younger people need in terms of income is a lot higher than previous generations- unless you earn a 6 figure income-£150k, you will need help to buy property and you will worry about heating/bills. People on 45k are worried about rent never mind saving enough to buy your own home or childcare etc...

Moving out of London/SE would mean that you might have lower housing costs but you still get hit by inflation. What matters is that you earn 6 figures or you would still be vulnerable to the various economic push factors whether it's mortgage interest rates, heating bills etc.

whumpthereitis · 13/12/2022 12:48

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/12/2022 10:11

@JemimaTiggywinkles

You're assuming "life" is about getting married, having babies and buying a house. I know lots of people who prioritised those things - most are either divorced or unhappily married. I'm mid-30s and neither married nor have children (bought a house a month ago) and I'm genuinely outraged that you think I have no "life".

I don't understand why you're 'genuinely outraged' that someone thinks that you have no life. If you're really perfectly happy with your lot - being mid 30s and single, why are you taking such offence? If people sneered at me for getting married in my mid 20s and having two children, before 30, and letting my husband have the main career while I was the primary childcare and home maker/part time worker, I wouldn't give a shit because I have been really fucking happy with this. Working part time for the last 20-odd years, and having loads of time for my children and my family and friends. If you really are happy with it, I don't understand why you care what people think, and why you're 'outraged.'

That said, there's nothing wrong with being single in your 30s or 40s etc. And as I said, you don't need to get married at 21-22 and have kids by 25, to have a fulfilling life as the OP suggested. Remaining single and child free is not a life I would want, but each to their own.

There are some quite rude opinions and views on here about women that are still single past 25/26. But there are equally rude and snobby views from people in their 20 and 30s - and probably other age groups - about women/people who get married at 20-21 ish and start having babies in their early 20s and stay in the home town they grew up in....... Like there's something wrong with them because they didn't leave the town they grew up in. A lot of people are very, very happy to stay in the town they were born in. Around the friends that they grew up with and around their family. Also, many people still travel, even if they don't leave their 'home town.'

It's great to have a lovely support network all around you and over a dozen people closeby anytime if you need help. I know a number of people who moved away. Some got married and had children, some stayed single, some got married and stayed child free. Most of them have no one to turn to in an emergency because they left their family and 'old life' back in their home town. AND they were incredibly lonely through COVID. Particularly the single/child free ones. There's a lot to be said about staying in, or close to the town you grew up in. I can never see the point in moving permanently. Life won't be much different. It will be just as hard, but with much less support from family.

I’m not sure if follows that being happy with your life means you have to smilingly accept being spoken down to and patronised. It’s a weak gotcha: “Ha! You’re not really happy because if you were you’d be obliged to suck up my overt disrespect!” and is at best disingenuous.

overall though I agree, there’s no one way to achieve happiness and people should be respected for making the life choices that are right for them. The problems come when it’s not respected though, and people can’t seem to wrap their heads around people making different choices to them.

as an aside, and speaking from my own experience, moving away can mean a dramatically different life though.

TheLostNights · 13/12/2022 12:43

I'm with you @FlissyPaps . Agree with all you said, this thread is so judgemental and I'm just personally glad I don't judge the way some of you all do.
I feel sorry for people like my colleague who may come on here. Approaching 40, still at home, single, no kids, in a low paid job. But does a lot around the house, well liked and a lovely person and trying her best with health issues. I would never judge her. I wish I had more of her personality traits to be honest. I don't judge people on what they have but who they are. Some of the people on here may have it all but they are sorely lacking in empathy. It's also worth remembering that even if you do marry and have kids young, even if you do have the perfect career, one day, you will wake up and it's all gone. Then some of you will become like those people you pity and judge so much....

FlissyPaps · 13/12/2022 12:36

Blueeyedgirl21 · 13/12/2022 12:32

@JamSandle ?? Most jobs have a chance of progression or chance to increase your earning potential. A friend of mine started working in nandos at 17, quit uni after three weeks, now works training new nandos managers around the country and abroad, he earns £75k a year loves his job no student debt. There is chance for progressing further also. Even with a trade you can set up on your own, take on employees etc

For a lot of jobs, it’s incredibly hard to progress.

Even if you do progress it’s still incredibly hard to get on the property ladder.

Stop with this utter bullshit. Stop blaming everyday people for not being being proactive enough to move out and get well paying progressing jobs. It’s not that simple anymore.

PEOPLE CANT DO THAT BECAUSE OF THE SHIT STATE OF THE COUNTRY. THE GOVERNMENT HAS RUINED THIS COUNTRY.

Why are so many people blind to this? Am I the only one suffering the affects of 10+ years of austerity??? Anyone????

whumpthereitis · 13/12/2022 12:33

Well that depends on whether you accept the premise that ‘real life’ is only embarked upon with marriage and children, and that both are a requirement for fulfilment and happiness.

but sure, it’s nothing to do with increased awareness and acknowledgement of mental health difficulties, or indeed the pressures of an economy that is vastly different to that experienced by previous generations, it’s all because women aren’t settling down early and popping out kids.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 13/12/2022 12:32

@JamSandle ?? Most jobs have a chance of progression or chance to increase your earning potential. A friend of mine started working in nandos at 17, quit uni after three weeks, now works training new nandos managers around the country and abroad, he earns £75k a year loves his job no student debt. There is chance for progressing further also. Even with a trade you can set up on your own, take on employees etc

JamSandle · 13/12/2022 10:57

Blueeyedgirl21 · 13/12/2022 10:53

I don’t think it’s the lack of marriage and kids but I do agree with the point that young people are often pushed into uni with the view that they will be destitute later in life without some random degree they barely care about

how about encouraging them to get jobs, work up the ladder, move out and go into a house share , get some independence that way

In a lot of places there isn't a ladder to climb.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 13/12/2022 10:53

I don’t think it’s the lack of marriage and kids but I do agree with the point that young people are often pushed into uni with the view that they will be destitute later in life without some random degree they barely care about

how about encouraging them to get jobs, work up the ladder, move out and go into a house share , get some independence that way

SleeplessInEngland · 13/12/2022 10:12

Should add that Gen Z are well aware of uni needing to lead to something. I know a couple of lecturers and they've seen a stark difference in course expectations from new students. The 'go to uni and doss around for 3 years mentality' mentality is dated.

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/12/2022 10:11

@JemimaTiggywinkles

You're assuming "life" is about getting married, having babies and buying a house. I know lots of people who prioritised those things - most are either divorced or unhappily married. I'm mid-30s and neither married nor have children (bought a house a month ago) and I'm genuinely outraged that you think I have no "life".

I don't understand why you're 'genuinely outraged' that someone thinks that you have no life. If you're really perfectly happy with your lot - being mid 30s and single, why are you taking such offence? If people sneered at me for getting married in my mid 20s and having two children, before 30, and letting my husband have the main career while I was the primary childcare and home maker/part time worker, I wouldn't give a shit because I have been really fucking happy with this. Working part time for the last 20-odd years, and having loads of time for my children and my family and friends. If you really are happy with it, I don't understand why you care what people think, and why you're 'outraged.'

That said, there's nothing wrong with being single in your 30s or 40s etc. And as I said, you don't need to get married at 21-22 and have kids by 25, to have a fulfilling life as the OP suggested. Remaining single and child free is not a life I would want, but each to their own.

There are some quite rude opinions and views on here about women that are still single past 25/26. But there are equally rude and snobby views from people in their 20 and 30s - and probably other age groups - about women/people who get married at 20-21 ish and start having babies in their early 20s and stay in the home town they grew up in....... Like there's something wrong with them because they didn't leave the town they grew up in. A lot of people are very, very happy to stay in the town they were born in. Around the friends that they grew up with and around their family. Also, many people still travel, even if they don't leave their 'home town.'

It's great to have a lovely support network all around you and over a dozen people closeby anytime if you need help. I know a number of people who moved away. Some got married and had children, some stayed single, some got married and stayed child free. Most of them have no one to turn to in an emergency because they left their family and 'old life' back in their home town. AND they were incredibly lonely through COVID. Particularly the single/child free ones. There's a lot to be said about staying in, or close to the town you grew up in. I can never see the point in moving permanently. Life won't be much different. It will be just as hard, but with much less support from family.

SleeplessInEngland · 13/12/2022 10:11

Not reading the whole thread but it's bloody hard to 'grow up' when you can't afford a house, or in many case even rent. Solve that and you'll probably see things improve.

But we won't, because a powerful cohort of voters seem allergic to new houses being built.

EndlessRain1 · 13/12/2022 10:10

Active encouragement into University without thinking often leads to a horrendously mentally unhealthy lifestyle.
For those with a passion for the subject, or doing a vocational course that leads to a career, of course university should be supported.
But that is not the case for your average student. Your average student goes to uni because, broadly speaking, it's what their college or sixth form expects of anyone vaguely academic. They pick a subject with no fixed career that they are at best, vaguely interested in, ( managed to scrape a B in business studies A Level, hated it the least, so I'll do it at uni to delay working for three years).

This is a load of rubbish OP. If you look at countries with a much higher level of high education, mental health is generally better not worse. You are massively reaching and adding 2 and 2 together to make 349. Based on this alone, YABU.

Frabbits · 13/12/2022 10:09

Mulhollandmagoo · 13/12/2022 09:08

I don't think I agree with the marriage/children part if I'm honest, but the uni part, definitely! They maybe should only be offering courses that require for a job (medicine mainly)

But I do 100% think that it should be easier for young people to get on the property ladder (or more accessible rental properties) because my biggest jolt into adulthood was living alone, and paying bills, budgeting, washing my own clothes, cooking my own meals. The longer young people stay at home and have all this done for them the bigger shock to the system it will be when they have to.

How do you determine which degrees are "worthwhile" or not, exactly? And why do you think the sole purpose of going to university is to get a job in that exact field?

Frabbits · 13/12/2022 10:08

I thnk about 95% of that is utter shite.

Especially re: having kids, further education and leaving home.

KimberleyClark · 13/12/2022 10:04

Beanbagtrap · 12/12/2022 21:35

Poor women being unable to focus without a child 😒

This. Not having a baby doesn’t make you “directionless and unhappy”.

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 13/12/2022 10:00

yoyy · 13/12/2022 08:19

Aren't men over 40s most at risk from suicide? what's impacting that?

Well exactly, some people are quite happy to ignore this fact because then they get to moan about young people today doing it wrong 🙄

Suicide rates are decreasing for the younger age group not increasing. And whilst that is not the only marker of poor mental health it does point to better coping mechanisms around it (e.g. reaching out for professional help more readily, talking about it more). But that's just written off as introspective navel gazing.

socialmedia23 · 13/12/2022 09:54

babyjellyfish · 13/12/2022 09:38

OP you seem to have missed out a vital point, which is that most jobs now require a degree, and despite this, pay far less in real terms than they did in previous years. I'm sure there are some people who leave school at 18, get a reasonable job, get on the property ladder by their mid 20s and are "adulting" well enough to have had their kids by the time they're 30, but for most people, this simply isn't realistic. And in any case, even if it were, the country can't function just with people like that. We do actually need people with qualifications, which take time and money to obtain. I'm sure you'd be the first to complain if we no longer had any doctors, nurses, teachers, vets, dentists etc.

My SILs' friends mostly married by 22. The recent Sunday times ranking of comprehensives ranked their school as one of the top 10 in the country (orthodox Jewish school) in terms of results. They mostly went to university. But they also married though mostly to older men. And they do have careers and they do have kids. However I think they probably got more parental help than the average person. I actually do find in my social circle that it is the people who have parental help and good circumstances as well as a traditional upbringing that have children in mid 20s. Rather than who is building up their career etc. After all if you have parental help with childcare you would not have any impediment to continue working.

babyjellyfish · 13/12/2022 09:38

OP you seem to have missed out a vital point, which is that most jobs now require a degree, and despite this, pay far less in real terms than they did in previous years. I'm sure there are some people who leave school at 18, get a reasonable job, get on the property ladder by their mid 20s and are "adulting" well enough to have had their kids by the time they're 30, but for most people, this simply isn't realistic. And in any case, even if it were, the country can't function just with people like that. We do actually need people with qualifications, which take time and money to obtain. I'm sure you'd be the first to complain if we no longer had any doctors, nurses, teachers, vets, dentists etc.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 13/12/2022 09:34

This is one of those threads where people share their lived experiences and observations. Great. But then apply a universal maxim to them. It happened like this for me/x/y, therefore it's true.

I had my DD at 27 and it was the making of me after a turbulent home then university then city life. Her and DH grounded me and gave me purpose and routine to my life. That's my experience. Had some of my friends had that experience, it wouldn't have had the same effect because we're all so bloody different and need different things. My friends (all 35/36 now) are mostly starting to have kids, some still searching etc. Arguably they are more financially settled than we were and can offer more stability to their kids than us who lived in three rented properties (we moved cities) before buying!

I was mid-PhD when I had DD and I hated studying. It was a lonely, pointless existence for me. University was presented as the only option at college. Love that so many apprenticeships are available now. In hindsight I would get office experience earlier but if things hadn't happened this way, I wouldn't be on this path now (now that is true for all of us). Having DD motivated me to get real life work experience, working from low paid shitty jobs up to senior digital job now.

Everyone is different & motivated by different things. All we can hope for in life is we find the circumstances and people that are best for us to thrive.

Luellie · 13/12/2022 09:18

They maybe should only be offering courses that require for a job (medicine mainly)

But at a fundamental level, training people for jobs is not the purpose of universities. I hate how the culture in this country is seeming to place less and less value on academia. Not a good direction for a society to be heading in imo

Mulhollandmagoo · 13/12/2022 09:08

I don't think I agree with the marriage/children part if I'm honest, but the uni part, definitely! They maybe should only be offering courses that require for a job (medicine mainly)

But I do 100% think that it should be easier for young people to get on the property ladder (or more accessible rental properties) because my biggest jolt into adulthood was living alone, and paying bills, budgeting, washing my own clothes, cooking my own meals. The longer young people stay at home and have all this done for them the bigger shock to the system it will be when they have to.

Tuichi · 13/12/2022 08:45

PissedOffAmericanWoman · 13/12/2022 05:22

Why is it that certain kinds of people always assume that when someone is speaking generally that they must mean EVERYONE? Are you intentionally taking OP out of context for your narrative convenience or do you truly struggle with english this much? Did you miss the lessons on context clues in school?

Why so aggro? I don’t struggle with English, thanks, and I took the op’s post - as well as many of the responses to it - as her views on what’s good for young people and how life ought to be lived. It’s not a nuanced piece of writing and certainly made me think of all the exceptions to the stereotypes presented.

WandaWonder · 13/12/2022 08:25

This is general not not aimed at any age group, although in the past there was less mental health support is the over anaylsing everything people do or think or say these days make mental health currently any better?