Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the encouragement to delay real life is a big cause in the explosion of mental health issues in under 35's ?

365 replies

rudolphrainbownose · 12/12/2022 21:20

Okay, so there is a well documented mental health crisis amongst young people , particularly university students, needing mental health support.

Is it just me or is the current culture of delaying "real adulthood" ( staying at school longer, young marriage/ pregnancy actively discouraged and frowned upon, uni unofficially taking the school leaving age to 23 for middle class young people, staying living at their parents well into their late 20's/ early 30's....)

To me it seems discouraging starting real adult life is fuelling this.

  1. Young women are told not to expect "security" in relationships, they are almost told to expect being ghosted by a series of men "not wanting to put a label on it," and going on a series of disastrous online dates is better than settling down young. Look how much marriage amongst under 25's is frowned upon on Mumsnet.

But I don't see many aspects of the dating scene today, ("friends with benefits" being cool, sex often expected without commitment before or afterwards on the first couple of dates, having to actually spell out you don't want the guy you are dating online to continue dating others online, being ghosted and blocked for no reason, being particularly healthy for the mental health of young people). Yet this is sold to them as more empowering than settling down into a steady relationship at a relatively young age....

  1. I'll expect to be flamed for this, but the active discouragement of having children in your 20's , probably robs a lot of women of a focus, ( because having your own family is often a nice focus), than drifting around without a purpose gives them. This also leads to probably more people experiencing the panic of miscarriage and infertility , ( risks increasing with age), into their 30's.

  2. Active encouragement into University without thinking often leads to a horrendously mentally unhealthy lifestyle.

For those with a passion for the subject, or doing a vocational course that leads to a career, of course university should be supported.

But that is not the case for your average student. Your average student goes to uni because, broadly speaking, it's what their college or sixth form expects of anyone vaguely academic. They pick a subject with no fixed career that they are at best, vaguely interested in, ( managed to scrape a B in business studies A Level, hated it the least, so I'll do it at uni to delay working for three years).

They head to uni to study a subject they are not particularly interested in, ith no idea what it will lead to afterwards. Most, have at most, six hours a week contact time, ( often less post covid). They sleep in late, browse the internet and get smashed a few times a week, ( the majority of students I know do not work in term time). Rinse and repeat. And they wonder why living this not very appealing lifestyle leaves students at poor risk of mental health ? And many are encouraged to take on a masters in a subject they are not interested in, with no direct career, to delay entering the real world for another year. They live in a bubble with people of the same age and inexperience as them. Compare that to a 19 year old office juniour being up and about, learning about the world of work, going for after work drinks with colleagues of a variety of ages ?

And the housing crisis means they are still likely to be living at home, ( especially if they are single), until 30. Often treated like overgrown teenagers, still in the habit of explaining to their parents where they are going of an evening. My friend , ( male), was explaining to me that at 28 he was working himself up to staying the night at his new girlfriends as he was so embarrassed to explain where he was to his parents, ( because if he told them he wouldn't be home for dinner as he was staying at his girlfriend's , they'd realise he was having sex).

In short, is delaying marriage, babies, work , moving out and leaving education actually causing everyone to be directionless and unhappy ?

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 13/12/2022 16:31

rudolphrainbownose · 13/12/2022 15:51

I haven't "imagined" them , it is the direct experiences of friends and acquaintances who are open about the fact they wish they had chosen something with more vocational direction and feel that this lifestyle had a negative effect on their mental health. Don't know why that would offend you .

You're describing three people you know.

Your anecdotes aren't relevant at a population level.

PissedOffAmericanWoman · 13/12/2022 16:29

rudolphrainbownose · 13/12/2022 14:58

I just wanted to clarify, this thread was not about slagging off young people, ( I'm 30, so I'd like to think relatively young ish).

It's more about how societal set up's seem to be doing more harm than good in a lot of cases, and in some cases damaging ( e.g. the economy making it impossibly difficult to leave home at a reasonable age, and the government doing nothing about it cos it suits their vested interests to keep house prices artificially high). It's not a young people are spoilt and don't know they're born premise. It's more, I'm not sure it's fair that current set up/ habbits/ expectations are negatively damaging young people's mental health.

R.E University - it's not about not going or being an inverted snob. It's about encouraging a bit of direction and purpose.

Actively encourage young people to have a plan with direction. Do a dentistry or surveying or physiotherapy or nursing degree, or a B'ed in teaching, with a direct pathway into a rewarding career.

Want to be a graphic designer, absolutely do a graphic design degree and spend three years building an amazing portfolio.

If you are passionate about a humanities subject, e.g. criminology or sociology, enjoy studying it and plan a career in research or probation etc.

Going to university with this sort of purpose is great. However, I also have at least three male friends who did history/ geography / sociology degrees. None were remotely interested in the subject, wanted to work in the subject area post qualifying or were particularly academic, ( C grades at A Level). They openly admitted they went to uni cos it was what was expected. They admit they sat around halls/ student houses playing computer games into the early hours, with a maximum six hours contact time a week and rarely getting out of bed before 1.00pm. Due to the need to repeat years etc this often turned into a four year period. No, I don't think sitting around halls in your dressing gown whilst playing computer games and attending six hours a week, ( and I do not blame them for this , it's a disgrace unis are allowed to charge so much for so little), whilst rarely mixing with the outside world was good for them. I don't blame them at all, cos they were doing what was expected of them, "pick a degree, go to uni, you don't need to have a plan as to what would happen afterwards).

It was not a healthy lifestyle to lead for four years, ( they complained of insomnia, depression etc), and yes would have probably been better off if they'd picked a vocational degree with a purpose or been mixing and socialising with a variety of people at work.

I don't think it's unkind to argue that encouraging them into the directionless lifestyle above probably created some significant mental health difficulties. I've also noticed the people I knew who went to uni with a degree with a purpose, ( e.g. pharmacy, nursing etc with placements), seemed to do much better as they couldn't do the above for four years straight.

I’m 31 and I’ve always gotten the feeling that with the increasing amount of elderly people rubbing governments that they don’t see us as adults. I mean even though many millennials are now in their 30’s the media still talks about us as if we are spoiled teenagers. Have you noticed that? At least in the united states that is the case.

LaLuz7 · 13/12/2022 16:29

Encouraging women to get married and have babies in their 20s (especially before 25) is a great recipe to fuck them over financial and get them stuck in subpar relationships.

I would never ever encourage a girl to go down that road.

We need to raise strong independent women who put themselves first. Which means sorting out your own career and finances before you sacrifice yourself to marriage and motherhood.

orchid220 · 13/12/2022 16:21

How old are you OP? Your post is ridiculous and incredibly sexist. The fact you think women need to have children at a young age in order to have a focus or be happy sounds like something out of the 50s. Also, having children later doesn't mean that you have to have sex with loads of random men or have shitty relationships. Nothing is stopping you from having fulfilling relationships while not procreating you know.

Bluekerfuffle · 13/12/2022 16:16

I think the mental health issues are more to do with analysing everything to death trying to find some way to be offended at all times.

Morghulis · 13/12/2022 16:13

Some of us are perfectly capable of living fulfilling lives with direction, goals and achievement without ever having kids… shocking, I know.

HamBone · 13/12/2022 16:03

@FlissyPaps That gets back to one of the original points the OP made-why push so many people towards university when it’s possibly not the best option for them?

I’m so glad that apprenticeships are popular now-they weren’t when I was leaving school. I think they’re a much better fit for many people.

Bewitched005 · 13/12/2022 15:59

Much of the problem is caused by society's expectation that a degree is necessary for all kinds of jobs. In reality, many jobs can be fulfilled by reasonably educated young people who don't have a degree.
There is also the huge problem of housing costs. It's almost impossible to get onto the property ladder in your twenties now, which means that more and more young adults are living with their parents, which isn't ideal.

FlissyPaps · 13/12/2022 15:56

HamBone · 13/12/2022 15:52

@FlissyPaps Those careers might still be better than a History degree, for example, and no idea of a career path. It’s one thing if you’ve got a plan-my friend’s son (20) is doing a Classics degree ( I’ve forgotten the actual major), he’s exceptionally talented in this field, has a clear plan to do a Ph. D. and will probably end up being recruited by a museum or university.

I think we need to focus more on what comes next after your degree. Many of my generation didn’t and it hadn’t helped us!

Good for him.

But the average UK citizen who are struggling to pay their bills and get on the property ladder aren’t incredibly talented in that field and will be no where near getting a PHD.

I HAVE A DEGREE. FOCUSING ON WHAT COMES NEXT ISNT GOING TO HELP THE SAD STATE OF THIS COUNTRY.

FlissyPaps · 13/12/2022 15:53

rudolphrainbownose · 13/12/2022 15:46

When on earth did I say I agree with Shit maternity pay or sick pay ? I don't.

But the fact some companies, ( and actually the NHS generally has a good sick/ maternity pay scheme), pay shit wages has nothing to do with the point that doing a degree with minimum contact hours, with no direction or vocational pathway, where you have no interest in the subject , no plans for after graduation and you sit around drinking and playing computer games is likely to make you a bit depressed.

I didn’t say you agree with it did I? I’m saying you’re sprouting bullshit. Which you are.

I work for the NHS and it absolutely does not have a good sick and maternity pay scheme. Not by a mile.

Again, you’re living in cuckoo land.

Are you oblivious to the current state of the country ? Are you?

Do you realise what 10+ years of austerity has done? Are you aware of the strikes from transport, postal workers, nurses, teachers? And you want people to go into these “promising” careers with optimism?

You think mental health problems are caused by siting around playing computer games????

I despair.

HamBone · 13/12/2022 15:52

@FlissyPaps Those careers might still be better than a History degree, for example, and no idea of a career path. It’s one thing if you’ve got a plan-my friend’s son (20) is doing a Classics degree ( I’ve forgotten the actual major), he’s exceptionally talented in this field, has a clear plan to do a Ph. D. and will probably end up being recruited by a museum or university.

I think we need to focus more on what comes next after your degree. Many of my generation didn’t and it hadn’t helped us!

rudolphrainbownose · 13/12/2022 15:51

babyjellyfish · 13/12/2022 15:49

These non-existent graduates that you have conjured up in your own head are quite the imaginary layabouts, huh?

I haven't "imagined" them , it is the direct experiences of friends and acquaintances who are open about the fact they wish they had chosen something with more vocational direction and feel that this lifestyle had a negative effect on their mental health. Don't know why that would offend you .

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 13/12/2022 15:49

rudolphrainbownose · 13/12/2022 15:46

When on earth did I say I agree with Shit maternity pay or sick pay ? I don't.

But the fact some companies, ( and actually the NHS generally has a good sick/ maternity pay scheme), pay shit wages has nothing to do with the point that doing a degree with minimum contact hours, with no direction or vocational pathway, where you have no interest in the subject , no plans for after graduation and you sit around drinking and playing computer games is likely to make you a bit depressed.

These non-existent graduates that you have conjured up in your own head are quite the imaginary layabouts, huh?

SleeplessInEngland · 13/12/2022 15:47

Again: deal with the housing crisis before bothering with anything else. It all comes back to that. Boomers could 'progress' because mortgages were only three times their salaries.

rudolphrainbownose · 13/12/2022 15:46

FlissyPaps · 13/12/2022 15:39

God you’re just spouting so much bullshit.

Actively encourage young people to have a plan with direction. Do a dentistry or surveying or physiotherapy or nursing degree, or a B'ed in teaching, with a direct pathway into a rewarding career.

These aren’t rewarding careers. You know why?

Because the government are not paying well enough into these public services. The NHS is on its knees. Its crumbling.

We have some of the longest working hours in Europe. Shit pay. Shit maternity pay. Shocking statutory sick pay. The list goes on and on.

You’re just not getting it OP. You’re living in cuckoo land.

Just stop it. Please. It’s fucking insulting.

When on earth did I say I agree with Shit maternity pay or sick pay ? I don't.

But the fact some companies, ( and actually the NHS generally has a good sick/ maternity pay scheme), pay shit wages has nothing to do with the point that doing a degree with minimum contact hours, with no direction or vocational pathway, where you have no interest in the subject , no plans for after graduation and you sit around drinking and playing computer games is likely to make you a bit depressed.

OP posts:
FlissyPaps · 13/12/2022 15:39

God you’re just spouting so much bullshit.

Actively encourage young people to have a plan with direction. Do a dentistry or surveying or physiotherapy or nursing degree, or a B'ed in teaching, with a direct pathway into a rewarding career.

These aren’t rewarding careers. You know why?

Because the government are not paying well enough into these public services. The NHS is on its knees. Its crumbling.

We have some of the longest working hours in Europe. Shit pay. Shit maternity pay. Shocking statutory sick pay. The list goes on and on.

You’re just not getting it OP. You’re living in cuckoo land.

Just stop it. Please. It’s fucking insulting.

Cuppasoupmonster · 13/12/2022 15:27

*have no debt

Cuppasoupmonster · 13/12/2022 15:27

I agree completely OP. I don’t think you’re being unkind at all. I’m early 30s, a lot of the girls from school who left to do ‘subject’ degrees (history, geography, sociology etc) have ended up in vague ‘marketing’ type jobs, on an average wage but most living in London and sinking that money into extortionate rent and repaying student loans. Lots still single and enduring the hell that is online dating, a few regularly phoning in tears about ‘ending up alone’. They may have had a good time at uni and a gap year but are now £££s in debt and feel a bit underwhelmed by life after the first few exciting and carefree years. Equally the girls I know who left to do apprenticeships or similar are on a good wage, have debt and are satisfying their urge to travel with regular holidays (which to me is a lot more appealing than one batch travelling followed by being skint for years!)

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/12/2022 15:21

What's your situation, OP? Did you go to uni and do you feel that it had a negative impact on your wellbeing? If you're married with kids, what age did you start a family?

Do you feel that you have direction in your own life? If so, where does that come from?

I find it very hard to get my head around the notion that "real life" only starts when you settle down into marriage with kids etc. That seems such a narrow, limiting perspective to me. So sad to think that all of the wonderful things that you could do in your young and carefree years are perceived as merely filling time while you're waiting for real life to start. It's no wonder that people end up with mental health problems if that's how they look at things. I see things very differently indeed.

rudolphrainbownose · 13/12/2022 14:58

I just wanted to clarify, this thread was not about slagging off young people, ( I'm 30, so I'd like to think relatively young ish).

It's more about how societal set up's seem to be doing more harm than good in a lot of cases, and in some cases damaging ( e.g. the economy making it impossibly difficult to leave home at a reasonable age, and the government doing nothing about it cos it suits their vested interests to keep house prices artificially high). It's not a young people are spoilt and don't know they're born premise. It's more, I'm not sure it's fair that current set up/ habbits/ expectations are negatively damaging young people's mental health.

R.E University - it's not about not going or being an inverted snob. It's about encouraging a bit of direction and purpose.

Actively encourage young people to have a plan with direction. Do a dentistry or surveying or physiotherapy or nursing degree, or a B'ed in teaching, with a direct pathway into a rewarding career.

Want to be a graphic designer, absolutely do a graphic design degree and spend three years building an amazing portfolio.

If you are passionate about a humanities subject, e.g. criminology or sociology, enjoy studying it and plan a career in research or probation etc.

Going to university with this sort of purpose is great. However, I also have at least three male friends who did history/ geography / sociology degrees. None were remotely interested in the subject, wanted to work in the subject area post qualifying or were particularly academic, ( C grades at A Level). They openly admitted they went to uni cos it was what was expected. They admit they sat around halls/ student houses playing computer games into the early hours, with a maximum six hours contact time a week and rarely getting out of bed before 1.00pm. Due to the need to repeat years etc this often turned into a four year period. No, I don't think sitting around halls in your dressing gown whilst playing computer games and attending six hours a week, ( and I do not blame them for this , it's a disgrace unis are allowed to charge so much for so little), whilst rarely mixing with the outside world was good for them. I don't blame them at all, cos they were doing what was expected of them, "pick a degree, go to uni, you don't need to have a plan as to what would happen afterwards).

It was not a healthy lifestyle to lead for four years, ( they complained of insomnia, depression etc), and yes would have probably been better off if they'd picked a vocational degree with a purpose or been mixing and socialising with a variety of people at work.

I don't think it's unkind to argue that encouraging them into the directionless lifestyle above probably created some significant mental health difficulties. I've also noticed the people I knew who went to uni with a degree with a purpose, ( e.g. pharmacy, nursing etc with placements), seemed to do much better as they couldn't do the above for four years straight.

OP posts:
BellePeppa · 13/12/2022 14:21

I was just saying a lot if this to a friend recently. At sixteen I had left school, had a full time job and was financially independent. At seventeen I left home for the first time and at nineteen I permanently left home. I was a resourceful and resilient adult before I’d reached twenty.

Nowadays apparently you can’t even have a full time job at sixteen, why on earth not?

I also said that given the choice (knowing what I know now) I would have chosen to meet my life partner young, at eighteen or nineteen rather than all the boyfriends and useless relationships I did have. I had my children later in life so now, when they should be well into adulthood I’m still dealing with teenage angst etc.

I was an anxious person and horribly bullied at school but had an inner resilience to just get on with it and I mourn the end of the ‘stiff upper lip’ as it can be positive and not just negative - it can teach inner strength.

My son suffers from depression even though his life has been far cushier than my childhood, he just doesn’t seem to have the mental strength I had unfortunately.

So yes I agree with you.

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 13/12/2022 14:12

I find it interesting that one or two posters on here blame those who move away for uni or jobs for the breakdown of community

I moved away from a small rural village to go to uni and to work. There were no universities within commutable distance at the time (there is one now) and there were hardly any jobs.

Encouraging people to stay in traditionally poorer areas with less opportunities is just encouraging generational poverty.

HamBone · 13/12/2022 14:09

How do you determine which degrees are "worthwhile" or not, exactly? And why do you think the sole purpose of going to university is to get a job in that exact field?

@Frabbits i think it's more having a plan, rather than exactly what you study. I was at uni in the early-mid 1990's and most of us had no idea what we were going to do next, and we were given v. little career advice. Neither my parents nor the university seemed to think beyond graduation. It's my fault too, I wasn't focused enough.

My DH and his siblings, however, had it drummed into them that they needed to be ready for the job market when they graduated, and all four of them were. DH started out in the Arts but switched to Computer Science after a year and boy, was that a good move in the 1990's when the tech industry was rapidly growing! He walked into a well-paying job.

tigger1001 · 13/12/2022 13:45

I do think we are heading to a mental health crisis but disagree as to why.

Social media has a huge role to play. People post about good aspects of their lives and it is easy to fall into the trap of "everyone else is doing better than me" . I think getting older helps with that as you learn life isn't that perfect.

I don't see university as extending childhood. It's just another step in some peoples life journey. For some people though it's their first taste of independence as the trend seems to be sheltering kids from any form of independence.

babyyodaxmas · 13/12/2022 13:42

My friend , ( male), was explaining to me that at 28 he was working himself up to staying the night at his new girlfriends as he was so embarrassed to explain where he was to his parents, ( because if he told them he wouldn't be home for dinner as he was staying at his girlfriend's , they'd realise he was having sex).

I think this is pretty unusual Dd is 16 if she tells me she is staying over at her boyfriends (same age) I just ask her what time she will be home the next day and to make sure she has done her homework.

DS is 18 and most of his friends in sixth form last year had boyfriend/ girl friends staying over without drama.