Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doctor refused to see 3yo with suspected scarlet fever

343 replies

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 21:04

My 3yo presented scarlet fever symptoms Sunday morning. Classic temperature, sandpaper rash, strawberry tongue so almost certain scarlet fever.
Phoned 111 at 10.30, get through around 12. Was told a clinician would call back within 2 hrs but very busy so could be longer.
Get a call around 3.45. Not the clinician but someone checking in. Clinician phoned around 7pm, really lovely lady who said she would make a referral to GP and that they will be ‘duty bound’ to see DC next day (today). DC was comfortable and settled down to sleep so she didn’t want to send us anywhere through the night, could end up being really late. We have a baby too.
This morning I phone GP first thing to book appointment. They acknowledged the referral from 111 and tell me a doctor will be in touch.

3.35pm my GP surgery phone to offer an appointment at a surgery 30mins (on a good day) away for 4pm. I said that would be impossible, so they offered 4.30 and that is the latest they can do. I accept the appointment but think it’ll be a tall order to get 2 toddlers, one quite unwell, in the car and there for 4.30 through two busy towns at rush hour but I was going to try my hardest. We got to the desk at 4.36 a flustered mess (I’m never late and hate being late)

They refused to see DC as we had ‘missed’ the appointment. I said they were duty bound to see her which they said they would but we could be waiting a while. As I’d had to rush everyone out of the door I’d not packed and snacks/toys so the thought of a long wait was not ideal but no choice.

At around 6pm a lady comes to tell us that they would not see her today. I said you’re duty bound to see DC today and she rudely responded with “you missed your appointment” and other remarks like “other patents managed to get here on time”. Yes but have other patients traveled as far, with such short notice, alone with two very young children?
Poor DC was even trying to show them crying saying “but look, I’ve got a nasty rash”.
AIBU to think this is truly appalling.

OP posts:
Hangingoninthere88 · 12/12/2022 22:48

Goldenbear · 12/12/2022 22:40

Hangingoninthere88, how did the OP not take responsibility for her child? She literally said she was under 10 minutes late. The broken system is not the general public's fault well arguably unless you voted Tory, even then are people asking too much if they want adequate not even good health care provision?

They're not unreasonable at all for wanting this. Frontline staff are equally (if not more) terrified and angry that they can't provide this. Fighting already burnt out staff about it isn't going to make the situation any better though. We should all be demanding better from the people at the top. I've already said in a pp that I wouldn't personally decline to see somebody if they were less than 10 minutes late. I may ask them to wait until I had a gap in my appointments though which could be a couple of hours or more. It isn't ideal service I agree but I can almost guarantee that the GP made the decision out of necessity and self-preservation rather than vindictiveness.

Lbw89 · 12/12/2022 22:48

GP here and find this absolutely disgraceful, I can’t imagine comfortably being able to go home with a potentially sick child unseen and would absolutely suggest you take this further. However (and it’s an aside!) to all the posters lamenting that we always run late- we don’t actually, and if we do it’s either a case of patients having far more complex needs that can be discussed in one ten minute appointment, but more commonly patients before them running late. I know it seems pedantic to you when it’s ‘only’ five or six minutes (and in this case your child absolutely should have been seen), but ultimately this is half your appointment and we can’t magic that time back- it only takes a handful of patients in a clinic to run a few minutes late (which happens frequently) and the last patient can easily be kept waiting half an hour which isn’t fair at all.

Moon22 · 12/12/2022 22:47

Very frustrating for you. However your repeatedly telling them they are 'duty bound,' to see your child probably didn't help.
Doctors are people too and can't be expected to stay late in their work (although people seem to expect this!).- as it goes, you were unfortunately a bit late, so that will be their get out clause if it comes to it.
Pity they made you wait all that time.
I think I would have asked to speak to a doctor or nurse, if it wasn't an actual healthcare professional who came out to speak to you.
I hope your child got sorted in the end and starting to feel better.

RosesAndHellebores · 12/12/2022 22:47

@Hangingoninthere88 what an absolutely horrible post. Perhaps 111 shoukd have advised the op to go to A&E? The op did what she was told to do as many people do.

Personally I stopped having truck with 111 about 23 years ago because they were hopeless. Always better to pitch up at A&E, preferably at sparrow fart when the drunks have been cleared.

I feel very sorry for the overworked GPs at my practice. Especially the couple who are so ground down they do two/three sessions a week at the local private hospital at £95 a pop. 8 patients in two hours. In addition to their part-time partner salary. Average for the practice £79k. All GPs part-time; all the partners have private interests be it GP to the local boarding school, or a directorship at a local "skincare/beauty" clinic.

And what do we get on this thread. GP and primary teacher bingo.

There are three problems with the NHS: attitude, arrogance and gross Inefficiency. It isn't the problem if the patients it doesn't work or join up.

ThorsMistress · 12/12/2022 22:46

YANBU. I work in a doctors surgery and the doctors are staying late to make sure that children are being seen. They’re even doing sit and waits.

To be left in a waiting room for 2 hours for being 6 minutes late is an absolute joke. I’m so sorry you had to deal with this.

MarshaBradyo · 12/12/2022 22:46

Op how is you dc now?

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 12/12/2022 22:45

Tessabelle74 · 12/12/2022 22:41

Fuckers! Funny how it's ok for us to be kept waiting whenever they're behind, I've been late into the first appointment of the day before! I hope you make a complaint to the practice and to the local authority

Do you understand why your appointment is late? It's because something more urgent that you had come up.

Nobody's sitting there with tea & toast keeping people waiting intentionally. Imagine you need to call an ambulance & monitor your patient until they arrive? So how long is the average response time these days?

And patients in a surgery are a lower priority as they already have a Dr with them....

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 22:44

Hangingoninthere88 · 12/12/2022 22:31

I'm a GP. At my clinic we single handedly manage a triage list when we're on call. Today I'd had over 40 requests for contact by 11am. Many of these ideally needed seeing F2F. I have to try and get this cleared by 2pm btw as this is when my choc full afternoon clinic of routine patients arrive ...

GPs are drowning in the work if anything more than most specialties. It's horrifically impossible. They don't have the luxury of pandering to your time schedule unfortunately. As the child's parent you need to take a bit of responsibility for their health and wellbeing. This means that if you genuinely feel they need seeing that day then you do everything in your power to get them seen that day even if it's an inconvenience. I don't think it was unreasonable to expect you to reach the surgery in 45 minutes given that it's presumably less than 5 miles away. I will say I would personally give patients at least 10 minutes grace and the opportunity to wait until the end of my clinic to be seen to be fair. If you genuinely were only 5 minutes late then this is perhaps a point to raise with the surgery. However you simply have to understand the pressure doctors are under and take a bit of responsibility for your own child. If you're worried about her then just take her to ED or a walk in centre and accept the inconvenience of waiting to be seen.

I would also question why you're so pissed at your GP who has a finite amount of time in the day to make contact with their patients and yet you lay no blame on 111. 111 are contracted to provide you with emergency care. They have walk in centres at their disposal who yes get busy but they are operated by doctors 24/7. Rather than signposting a child with strong signs of a potentially life threatening disease to one of these walk in centres they've shifted responsibility back to your GP instead. The system is broken. You need to just accept that and do what's necessary to keep your kid safe I'm afraid. The frontline staff are doing their best.

It was 13miles away, 40mins it took me

OP posts:
SeveruslyFrazzled · 12/12/2022 22:43

YANBU in that they didn’t give you enough time to get there!

Genevieva · 12/12/2022 22:42

Make a complaint. Given the 111 referral, the risks associated with scarlet fever, the fact that an appointment slot is more than 6 minutes long and that they knew your travel constraints when you accepted the appointment, their behaviour as unacceptable. That said, when I want a same-day appointment I now go to the surgery at 8am and speak to the receptionist directly. There is no point being stuck in a telephone queuing system. If you are infant of them they have to deal with you first and let the phone ring.

Tessabelle74 · 12/12/2022 22:41

Fuckers! Funny how it's ok for us to be kept waiting whenever they're behind, I've been late into the first appointment of the day before! I hope you make a complaint to the practice and to the local authority

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 12/12/2022 22:41

I don't think it was unreasonable to expect you to reach the surgery in 45 minutes given that it's presumably less than 5 miles away.

Why are we presuming it's less than 5 miles away when the OP has made it clear it wasn't her local GPs surgery

And even if it was, I, for example, don't even have a town 5 miles away, lots of people don't. We don't all live in built up areas

Goldenbear · 12/12/2022 22:40

Hangingoninthere88, how did the OP not take responsibility for her child? She literally said she was under 10 minutes late. The broken system is not the general public's fault well arguably unless you voted Tory, even then are people asking too much if they want adequate not even good health care provision?

biscuiteer · 12/12/2022 22:38

I also feel like enough of 'the court' commentators on this thread-OP did nothing wrong. Her child did nothing wrong.

fifteenohfour · 12/12/2022 22:38

YANBU you didn't even miss your appointment, I honestly think the receptionist booked you without checking properly first and double booked you, when you were 6 minutes late they were happy enough to use that as an excuse rather than admit their mistake. Because if they admitted their mistake then they would have to see your child, if they make it your fault then they could double down and refuse.

Either way disgusting and it was an advanced practitioner making that call? So risky.

I don't how you are financially but I used an expensive £40 online GP consultation who video called me and I showed them the problem through the camera and. They prescribed me something and sent it to my pharmacy for me. It was easy.

Don't know if they did it for kids though

whynotwhatknot · 12/12/2022 22:38

after what happened to that little girl who was fobbed off with strep a im astonished theyve turned yu away

how long would it take to give you anti biotics and a swab

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 12/12/2022 22:37

SnowlayRoundabout · 12/12/2022 22:30

You clearly don't have good friends who are primary teachers if you think those are their hours. I don't know any who aren't in school at around 8 a.m. or who leave before 4.30 pm or later, at which point they are taking home a pile of marking, report writing, lesson preparation etc. And that 's before you factor in things like covering school trips, sports events, rehearsals for school plays and concerts, after school clubs, meetings, parent-teacher evenings etc etc. And they work throughout most of the holidays. Pull the other one.

Oh I do. And also my dad was a teacher.

You for some bizarre reason think the workload teachers take home is higher than that which GPs do outside of hours.

You are wrong. Very very wrong.

Have you ever taken a form to a GP to fill saying "oh it'll only take a minute". Times that by 100. Every day.

And I reiterate - none of a teachers failures to action something same day will cost a life.

biscuiteer · 12/12/2022 22:36

Sounds like a really stressful and worrying day and I really feel for you OP. I hope your DD is ok. Of course you were not being unreasonable. I fear how stressful life is becoming and how our compassion and understanding for others has waned -to people using petty comments, being rude and hostile instead of supportive and helpful. Reading some of the comments on here reaffirms that feeling: that we are all struggling...but when it comes to a child being ill -5 minutes of time is not an issue.
You did your absolute best and you and your child were let down.

Mammillaria · 12/12/2022 22:36

I don't think it was unreasonable to expect you to reach the surgery in 45 minutes given that it's presumably less than 5 miles away

..and there's another who hasn't read the OP's posts. 30 minutes (minimum) drive, out of area surgery, had to drive through two busy towns at rush hour. All in the first few posts.

StPaulandTheBrokenBones · 12/12/2022 22:36

Why has PP brought the subject of teachers into this thread? It is absolutely irrelevant to what the OP is asking. News flash, not everything is about how many hours and how hard teachers work. In particular this thread is not about teachers and their hours of work.

OP. This is not ok and what happened to you and your child is appalling. Is this what this country has come to? Having to feel grateful that you’re offered a doctor’s appointment miles away, that you have a low chance of being on time for? And then not to have your ill child seen when you arrive a few minutes late?

It’s not good enough.

ReedRite · 12/12/2022 22:35

Nw22 · 12/12/2022 21:18

I don’t know what you expected them to do when you missed your appointment. Did you expect someone else to miss their appointment for you?

I don't know what you expected her to do, when she was only offered an appointment it would be touch and go to meet. What did you want her to do, fly? Explain how it was her fault she was late.

Sunshinegirl82 · 12/12/2022 22:35

Hangingoninthere88 · 12/12/2022 22:31

I'm a GP. At my clinic we single handedly manage a triage list when we're on call. Today I'd had over 40 requests for contact by 11am. Many of these ideally needed seeing F2F. I have to try and get this cleared by 2pm btw as this is when my choc full afternoon clinic of routine patients arrive ...

GPs are drowning in the work if anything more than most specialties. It's horrifically impossible. They don't have the luxury of pandering to your time schedule unfortunately. As the child's parent you need to take a bit of responsibility for their health and wellbeing. This means that if you genuinely feel they need seeing that day then you do everything in your power to get them seen that day even if it's an inconvenience. I don't think it was unreasonable to expect you to reach the surgery in 45 minutes given that it's presumably less than 5 miles away. I will say I would personally give patients at least 10 minutes grace and the opportunity to wait until the end of my clinic to be seen to be fair. If you genuinely were only 5 minutes late then this is perhaps a point to raise with the surgery. However you simply have to understand the pressure doctors are under and take a bit of responsibility for your own child. If you're worried about her then just take her to ED or a walk in centre and accept the inconvenience of waiting to be seen.

I would also question why you're so pissed at your GP who has a finite amount of time in the day to make contact with their patients and yet you lay no blame on 111. 111 are contracted to provide you with emergency care. They have walk in centres at their disposal who yes get busy but they are operated by doctors 24/7. Rather than signposting a child with strong signs of a potentially life threatening disease to one of these walk in centres they've shifted responsibility back to your GP instead. The system is broken. You need to just accept that and do what's necessary to keep your kid safe I'm afraid. The frontline staff are doing their best.

I feel incredibly sorry for front line staff, I know it's impossible at the moment. The OP does say though that she was sent to another surgery which is at least a 30 minute drive away, not accounting for school time traffic. In the circumstances I think she did her best to get there.

Tadpoll · 12/12/2022 22:35

watingroom2 · 12/12/2022 22:34

why are you so far away from your GP?

IT WASN’T HER SURGERY.

watingroom2 · 12/12/2022 22:34

why are you so far away from your GP?

marvellousmaple · 12/12/2022 22:33

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 12/12/2022 22:29

These are hugely inefficient time wise and are therefore limited to housebound patients in most areas. Very few toddlers are housebound.

Fair enough. They only operate after hours and on weekends here ( Sydney). No cost to patient.