Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doctor refused to see 3yo with suspected scarlet fever

343 replies

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 21:04

My 3yo presented scarlet fever symptoms Sunday morning. Classic temperature, sandpaper rash, strawberry tongue so almost certain scarlet fever.
Phoned 111 at 10.30, get through around 12. Was told a clinician would call back within 2 hrs but very busy so could be longer.
Get a call around 3.45. Not the clinician but someone checking in. Clinician phoned around 7pm, really lovely lady who said she would make a referral to GP and that they will be ‘duty bound’ to see DC next day (today). DC was comfortable and settled down to sleep so she didn’t want to send us anywhere through the night, could end up being really late. We have a baby too.
This morning I phone GP first thing to book appointment. They acknowledged the referral from 111 and tell me a doctor will be in touch.

3.35pm my GP surgery phone to offer an appointment at a surgery 30mins (on a good day) away for 4pm. I said that would be impossible, so they offered 4.30 and that is the latest they can do. I accept the appointment but think it’ll be a tall order to get 2 toddlers, one quite unwell, in the car and there for 4.30 through two busy towns at rush hour but I was going to try my hardest. We got to the desk at 4.36 a flustered mess (I’m never late and hate being late)

They refused to see DC as we had ‘missed’ the appointment. I said they were duty bound to see her which they said they would but we could be waiting a while. As I’d had to rush everyone out of the door I’d not packed and snacks/toys so the thought of a long wait was not ideal but no choice.

At around 6pm a lady comes to tell us that they would not see her today. I said you’re duty bound to see DC today and she rudely responded with “you missed your appointment” and other remarks like “other patents managed to get here on time”. Yes but have other patients traveled as far, with such short notice, alone with two very young children?
Poor DC was even trying to show them crying saying “but look, I’ve got a nasty rash”.
AIBU to think this is truly appalling.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 12/12/2022 23:00

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 21:12

I was given about 45mins notice for an appointment out of town. I did my best!

You knew yesterday that you’d need to see the GP. You got an appointment - most parents would have moved heaven and earth to make that appointment. You’re being belligerent and entitled.

Goldenbear · 12/12/2022 23:00

Hangingoninthere88, you quite clearly stated the OP should take some responsibility, how exactly? They drove 13 miles for an appointment with said sick child and then was under 10 minutes late - which you have pointed out would be your personal threshold to see a late patient so 'how' is she not demonstrating personal responsibility. There is 'no' battle in this scenario as a GP holds all the cards as this is the normalised system now there is simply nothing the patient can do except be ever so grateful for scraps of medical attention. It is simply not good enough.

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 23:00

Peashoots · 12/12/2022 22:51

Why haven’t you responded to a single other thing in @Hangingoninthere88 post, OP? You keep harping on about this 40 minutes. She is right, 111 could have signposted you to a walk in centre for treatment. Did it not occur to you to try this yourself, or childrens a&e? I know it’s inconvenient to wait but if I was that worried about my child I’d sit there all night.
GPs are not robots, they don’t run a 24 hour service. It’s a shame you wasted a journey but honestly if you knew you’d be cutting it fine, why waste the appointment? I hope your daughter is ok.

I have responded

OP posts:
LadyGaGasPokerFace · 12/12/2022 22:59

That was really tight of them. They could’ve slip you in somewhere, it’s not like you’d get seen in time anyway. Well, never get seen on time at my gp surgery.

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 12/12/2022 22:59

Sherrystrull · 12/12/2022 22:52

@OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty

Your low jibes at teachers are unnecessary. GPs I'm sure are trying their best and working hard, teachers are too. There's no need to bring anyone down. We've all been shafted by the government.

I am responding directly to a poster who clearly feels teachers are akin to God.

This is consistent with complaints I receive as a Practice Manager.

I speak as I find. We do our very best for all patients. Occupation is utterly irrelevant.

solomam · 12/12/2022 22:59

No, that’s only part of what she’s saying.
She says twice that parents need to take responsibility for their children which in the case of this OP (and many other mums / dads in similar positions recently) I find an outrageous comment.
We are taking responsibility. Many of us (including this OP by the sounds of it) are doing everything we possibly can and still getting doors slammed in our face at the time we need someone to help.

Completely agree

ancientgran · 12/12/2022 22:58

ShirleyPhallus · 12/12/2022 21:13

I’m in two minds about this tbh. The services are absolute rushed off their feet, it’s not their fault that you were late and all the stuff about being on your own with two toddlers, no snacks etc etc is somewhat irrelevant when everyone has their own challenges to get to the dr

But the woman sounded rude and I get it was frustrating to be kept waiting that long

Who was “the lady”, could you speak to the practice manager?

The thing is the child was ill and it wasn't the child's fault they were late so punishing the child seems pretty vile to me.

solomam · 12/12/2022 22:57

RosesAndHellebores · 12/12/2022 22:47

@Hangingoninthere88 what an absolutely horrible post. Perhaps 111 shoukd have advised the op to go to A&E? The op did what she was told to do as many people do.

Personally I stopped having truck with 111 about 23 years ago because they were hopeless. Always better to pitch up at A&E, preferably at sparrow fart when the drunks have been cleared.

I feel very sorry for the overworked GPs at my practice. Especially the couple who are so ground down they do two/three sessions a week at the local private hospital at £95 a pop. 8 patients in two hours. In addition to their part-time partner salary. Average for the practice £79k. All GPs part-time; all the partners have private interests be it GP to the local boarding school, or a directorship at a local "skincare/beauty" clinic.

And what do we get on this thread. GP and primary teacher bingo.

There are three problems with the NHS: attitude, arrogance and gross Inefficiency. It isn't the problem if the patients it doesn't work or join up.

👏🏻👏🏻

PurpleWisteria1 · 12/12/2022 22:57

Peashoots · 12/12/2022 22:52

Try re reading her post 🙄 she’s not shifting the blame onto OP AT ALL, she’s saying that 111 have inappropriately advised her.

No, that’s only part of what she’s saying.
She says twice that parents need to take responsibility for their children which in the case of this OP (and many other mums / dads in similar positions recently) I find an outrageous comment.
We are taking responsibility. Many of us (including this OP by the sounds of it) are doing everything we possibly can and still getting doors slammed in our face at the time we need someone to help.

Axahooxa · 12/12/2022 22:55

YANBU!!

It’s mind-achingly painful to read people responding to OP as if she were late got a hair appointment.

Her child should have been seen.
she should have left with antibiotics.

This is HORRIFIC.

solomam · 12/12/2022 22:54

SIX minutes late and they wouldn't see you?? Ridiculous. I'd make a complaint.

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 22:54

Moon22 · 12/12/2022 22:47

Very frustrating for you. However your repeatedly telling them they are 'duty bound,' to see your child probably didn't help.
Doctors are people too and can't be expected to stay late in their work (although people seem to expect this!).- as it goes, you were unfortunately a bit late, so that will be their get out clause if it comes to it.
Pity they made you wait all that time.
I think I would have asked to speak to a doctor or nurse, if it wasn't an actual healthcare professional who came out to speak to you.
I hope your child got sorted in the end and starting to feel better.

I only said it when they started trying to wriggle out of seeing DC, at which point I wasn’t very happy but never impolite. Did they not have a duty to see DC? I and others feel they did

OP posts:
BabyOnBoard90 · 12/12/2022 22:53

I think, especially given the current climate, YABU.

Hope the child makes a smooth recovery.

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 12/12/2022 22:53

PurpleWisteria1 · 12/12/2022 22:49

Wow if you are genuinely a GP then that’s a bit of an eye opener.
So the blame is on us mums because we are not ‘doing everything in our power’ to get our child seen?
wow just wow.
We are doing everything in our power and more. We move hell and high water to get the best for our kids and when they are ill we would walk over hot coals and not sleep a wink for days if it helped them recover.
The trouble is, we can’t get them antibiotics by ourselves. We are not given that power in the Uk.
Getting to see someone who can give us those is like getting blood out of a stone and incredibly infuryingly frustrating. I’ve been there myself this week for my child. I queued up in -3 for 35 minutes with two younger siblings in tow at 7:45am outside the GP surgery as instructed just to try to get an appointment. Child had rash, high temp, raging sore throat and muscle aches. And I still couldn’t get one.
Its broken.
This 3 year old was asked to wait 90 mins with suspected Scarlett fever and then told go home.
Someone actually locked up and turned off the lights merrily knowing that they turned that 3 year old away when they were only 5 mins late for their much needed appointment.
It goes way beyond ‘a point to be raised’
shame on them.

A surgery requiring you to physically queue for an appointment is a disgrace. I agree.

user1471447863 · 12/12/2022 22:53

StPaulandTheBrokenBones · 12/12/2022 22:36

Why has PP brought the subject of teachers into this thread? It is absolutely irrelevant to what the OP is asking. News flash, not everything is about how many hours and how hard teachers work. In particular this thread is not about teachers and their hours of work.

OP. This is not ok and what happened to you and your child is appalling. Is this what this country has come to? Having to feel grateful that you’re offered a doctor’s appointment miles away, that you have a low chance of being on time for? And then not to have your ill child seen when you arrive a few minutes late?

It’s not good enough.

The subject of teachers is actually quite relevant as it appears the previous generation of teachers failed to teach a large proportion of the population basic reading comprehension going by the number that still don't seem to have understood that it was not the OP's local surgery and was in fact in a far far away unfamiliar location at a busy time of day. Thus the timescale offered was tight with little margin.
But yes this is about Dr's not teachers.

I'd have been inclined to just head to A&E as obviously trying to go about it the correct way just isn't working.

I get the impression this is a modern practice (multi site group etc), so likely has electronic scheduling & check in etc (even if done by reception on arrival) , i doubt the Dr was bang on schedule and had prepped for you specifically and when you weren't there when they called out in the waiting room they then had to go back and read up for the next patient then call them in just as you arrived - more like you hadn't checked in yet and the next timetabled person who was there would have shown as next to be seen. All provided they were running bang on time which would be a miracle in itself.

suzyscat · 12/12/2022 22:53

6 minutes late? My GP surgery is amazing but you'd still be queuing at reception to check in by then and probably wouldn't be seen for the best part of an hour. They would see you though.

YANBU and should complain to pals or similar.

Sherrystrull · 12/12/2022 22:52

@OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty

Your low jibes at teachers are unnecessary. GPs I'm sure are trying their best and working hard, teachers are too. There's no need to bring anyone down. We've all been shafted by the government.

Peashoots · 12/12/2022 22:52

PurpleWisteria1 · 12/12/2022 22:49

Wow if you are genuinely a GP then that’s a bit of an eye opener.
So the blame is on us mums because we are not ‘doing everything in our power’ to get our child seen?
wow just wow.
We are doing everything in our power and more. We move hell and high water to get the best for our kids and when they are ill we would walk over hot coals and not sleep a wink for days if it helped them recover.
The trouble is, we can’t get them antibiotics by ourselves. We are not given that power in the Uk.
Getting to see someone who can give us those is like getting blood out of a stone and incredibly infuryingly frustrating. I’ve been there myself this week for my child. I queued up in -3 for 35 minutes with two younger siblings in tow at 7:45am outside the GP surgery as instructed just to try to get an appointment. Child had rash, high temp, raging sore throat and muscle aches. And I still couldn’t get one.
Its broken.
This 3 year old was asked to wait 90 mins with suspected Scarlett fever and then told go home.
Someone actually locked up and turned off the lights merrily knowing that they turned that 3 year old away when they were only 5 mins late for their much needed appointment.
It goes way beyond ‘a point to be raised’
shame on them.

Try re reading her post 🙄 she’s not shifting the blame onto OP AT ALL, she’s saying that 111 have inappropriately advised her.

been and done it. · 12/12/2022 22:52

Sugarfree23 · 12/12/2022 22:01

That's what I was thinking?

GPs used to have a catchment area and went ever happy to have people outwith their area.
I get the feeling op riled them with the 'duty bound' comments.

Whether they were pissed off with the comments is irrelevant there was a sick child to be seen.

Peashoots · 12/12/2022 22:51

Why haven’t you responded to a single other thing in @Hangingoninthere88 post, OP? You keep harping on about this 40 minutes. She is right, 111 could have signposted you to a walk in centre for treatment. Did it not occur to you to try this yourself, or childrens a&e? I know it’s inconvenient to wait but if I was that worried about my child I’d sit there all night.
GPs are not robots, they don’t run a 24 hour service. It’s a shame you wasted a journey but honestly if you knew you’d be cutting it fine, why waste the appointment? I hope your daughter is ok.

Goldenbear · 12/12/2022 22:50

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty, yes but that is exactly the problem, the normalised inadequate service and the patients are at fault for having some, any, expectations of a health care system!

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 12/12/2022 22:50

ThorsMistress · 12/12/2022 22:46

YANBU. I work in a doctors surgery and the doctors are staying late to make sure that children are being seen. They’re even doing sit and waits.

To be left in a waiting room for 2 hours for being 6 minutes late is an absolute joke. I’m so sorry you had to deal with this.

I don't think you've read the script.

GPs are all lazy privileged people who refuse to see people on a whim and wouldn't know what hard work is because they aren't a teacher.

I joke clearly - but thats the ridiculous way this thread is going.

Bunnycat101 · 12/12/2022 22:50

Im amazed they didn’t see you. When I had a poorly child who 111 said needed to be seen, the gp practice stayed open later for me as I needed to travel and then sent me straight to A&E as a red flag for sepsis. I’m incredibly grateful that the GP did that. I’m shocked that 6 minutes late they just didn’t see you at all especially knowing you were travelling across town, were sat in the waiting room for ages and had dragged out a poorly child and a baby.

PurpleWisteria1 · 12/12/2022 22:49

Hangingoninthere88 · 12/12/2022 22:31

I'm a GP. At my clinic we single handedly manage a triage list when we're on call. Today I'd had over 40 requests for contact by 11am. Many of these ideally needed seeing F2F. I have to try and get this cleared by 2pm btw as this is when my choc full afternoon clinic of routine patients arrive ...

GPs are drowning in the work if anything more than most specialties. It's horrifically impossible. They don't have the luxury of pandering to your time schedule unfortunately. As the child's parent you need to take a bit of responsibility for their health and wellbeing. This means that if you genuinely feel they need seeing that day then you do everything in your power to get them seen that day even if it's an inconvenience. I don't think it was unreasonable to expect you to reach the surgery in 45 minutes given that it's presumably less than 5 miles away. I will say I would personally give patients at least 10 minutes grace and the opportunity to wait until the end of my clinic to be seen to be fair. If you genuinely were only 5 minutes late then this is perhaps a point to raise with the surgery. However you simply have to understand the pressure doctors are under and take a bit of responsibility for your own child. If you're worried about her then just take her to ED or a walk in centre and accept the inconvenience of waiting to be seen.

I would also question why you're so pissed at your GP who has a finite amount of time in the day to make contact with their patients and yet you lay no blame on 111. 111 are contracted to provide you with emergency care. They have walk in centres at their disposal who yes get busy but they are operated by doctors 24/7. Rather than signposting a child with strong signs of a potentially life threatening disease to one of these walk in centres they've shifted responsibility back to your GP instead. The system is broken. You need to just accept that and do what's necessary to keep your kid safe I'm afraid. The frontline staff are doing their best.

Wow if you are genuinely a GP then that’s a bit of an eye opener.
So the blame is on us mums because we are not ‘doing everything in our power’ to get our child seen?
wow just wow.
We are doing everything in our power and more. We move hell and high water to get the best for our kids and when they are ill we would walk over hot coals and not sleep a wink for days if it helped them recover.
The trouble is, we can’t get them antibiotics by ourselves. We are not given that power in the Uk.
Getting to see someone who can give us those is like getting blood out of a stone and incredibly infuryingly frustrating. I’ve been there myself this week for my child. I queued up in -3 for 35 minutes with two younger siblings in tow at 7:45am outside the GP surgery as instructed just to try to get an appointment. Child had rash, high temp, raging sore throat and muscle aches. And I still couldn’t get one.
Its broken.
This 3 year old was asked to wait 90 mins with suspected Scarlett fever and then told go home.
Someone actually locked up and turned off the lights merrily knowing that they turned that 3 year old away when they were only 5 mins late for their much needed appointment.
It goes way beyond ‘a point to be raised’
shame on them.

Lozzybear · 12/12/2022 22:49

@Hangingoninthere88 well you may be a GP but you’re not very good at reading and understanding the facts…OP said that it wasn’t her usual surgery and was at least a 30 minute drive away. Then there’s the time to get her two young children in the car, work out her route given that she wasn’t familiar with the surgery and it was also rush hour which lengthened her journey.

You also presume that her surgery is less than 5 miles away. Well mine is 7.5 miles
away (and that’s the nearest one - rural
area).’There’s also not a car park at my surgery despite most patients living some distance away. My surgery is up a hill about seven minutes walk away from the nearest car park. Well, seven minutes if you’re fit and healthy and/or don’t have sick children with you….

Swipe left for the next trending thread