Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doctor refused to see 3yo with suspected scarlet fever

343 replies

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 21:04

My 3yo presented scarlet fever symptoms Sunday morning. Classic temperature, sandpaper rash, strawberry tongue so almost certain scarlet fever.
Phoned 111 at 10.30, get through around 12. Was told a clinician would call back within 2 hrs but very busy so could be longer.
Get a call around 3.45. Not the clinician but someone checking in. Clinician phoned around 7pm, really lovely lady who said she would make a referral to GP and that they will be ‘duty bound’ to see DC next day (today). DC was comfortable and settled down to sleep so she didn’t want to send us anywhere through the night, could end up being really late. We have a baby too.
This morning I phone GP first thing to book appointment. They acknowledged the referral from 111 and tell me a doctor will be in touch.

3.35pm my GP surgery phone to offer an appointment at a surgery 30mins (on a good day) away for 4pm. I said that would be impossible, so they offered 4.30 and that is the latest they can do. I accept the appointment but think it’ll be a tall order to get 2 toddlers, one quite unwell, in the car and there for 4.30 through two busy towns at rush hour but I was going to try my hardest. We got to the desk at 4.36 a flustered mess (I’m never late and hate being late)

They refused to see DC as we had ‘missed’ the appointment. I said they were duty bound to see her which they said they would but we could be waiting a while. As I’d had to rush everyone out of the door I’d not packed and snacks/toys so the thought of a long wait was not ideal but no choice.

At around 6pm a lady comes to tell us that they would not see her today. I said you’re duty bound to see DC today and she rudely responded with “you missed your appointment” and other remarks like “other patents managed to get here on time”. Yes but have other patients traveled as far, with such short notice, alone with two very young children?
Poor DC was even trying to show them crying saying “but look, I’ve got a nasty rash”.
AIBU to think this is truly appalling.

OP posts:
PurpleWisteria1 · 12/12/2022 22:04

Nw22 · 12/12/2022 21:18

I don’t know what you expected them to do when you missed your appointment. Did you expect someone else to miss their appointment for you?

Appointments are 10 minutes strictly speaking by schedule. Some are way less and some are over. At the very least she had 4 mins left of her allotted time. 4 mins would be all that’s needed for the doctor to recognise Scarlett fever and perscribe antibiotics.

Prescottdanni123 · 12/12/2022 22:03

YANBU. Yes you were five or so minutes late but shit happens. It was going to be tight to begin with. I once waited 90 minutes in a GP waiting room. They should have squeezed you in, especially for a sick child with scarlet fever. What harm would it have caused? That the doctor wouldn't have been able to leave at 6pm on the dot?

Dixiechickonhols · 12/12/2022 22:01

Op had a car but no idea where it’s parked (not everyone has a drive or can park right outside) or what parking like at other end especially if it’s not a surgery op familiar with. It’s school run time and icy/snowy.
If practice has patients 30 plus mins car ride away then don’t offer then appointments for 25 mins time that’s just common sense. It sounds like op should have been told to come at 4pm much earlier in day.

Flippppppp · 12/12/2022 22:01

To those saying the system is overwhelmed…yes to a degree, but different practices are run with differing levels of efficiency. Myself and my daughter are asthmatic and the dr refused to prescribe any more inhalers until we had a review. Fair enough. I booked the two reviews consecutively and had to do so during school/work hours because the nurse only works 830-12. Each appointment was blocked out for twenty minutes. We got there, blew into a peak flow (we both have peak flows at home), she asked if we were in good health. Yes. Three minutes and we were done. I appreciate some asthma reviews might be more complex but honestly, what a waste of time and money. That nurse then won’t have seen anyone for another 35 minutes. I could have submitted the peak flows online and no appointments would have been needed at all (nor would I have had to miss work). I’m a teacher. My contracted hours are 37.5 a week. Do I work over that to meet the needs of my students? Of course I do. It’s dreadful that OP’s DC wasn’t seen. Lots of GP
practices (not all) are very inefficiently and uncaringly run. This is an example of that. I very rarely complain OP (mainly because I can’t be arsed!) but if I was you I absolutely would.

Sugarfree23 · 12/12/2022 22:01

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 12/12/2022 21:13

Do you have a gp closer? That sounds very far away

That's what I was thinking?

GPs used to have a catchment area and went ever happy to have people outwith their area.
I get the feeling op riled them with the 'duty bound' comments.

Cativy · 12/12/2022 22:00

@strawberrysea YANBU

Ignore all the rude idiotic comments saying you missed an appointment etc. I completely sympathise with you and would be making a complaint and getting back onto 111 this evening too.

justgettingthroughtheday · 12/12/2022 21:59

Nw22 · 12/12/2022 21:18

I don’t know what you expected them to do when you missed your appointment. Did you expect someone else to miss their appointment for you?

Technically she didn't miss the appointment but was late for it. Appointment times are 10 minutes. There was still 4 minutes of the appointment remaining. Perfectly long enough to prescribe antibiotics.

Valhalla17 · 12/12/2022 21:58

redbigbananafeet · 12/12/2022 21:47

Stop saying 45 minutes notice. It was 55 minutes. Are you in their catchment area? Your nearest GP is nearly an hour away?

How about you read the OPs post properly ffs

Minimalme · 12/12/2022 21:57

I would ring 111 op and use the out of hours service.

I have a child with two conditions which need urgent care roughly 6-8 times a year.

It is much easier to wait until the gp surgery closes and go via 111 because they can usually just issue a prescription.

GP Surgeries are actually broken.

CreamArran · 12/12/2022 21:56

YANBU. I’d have been absolutely raging about this. I think we’re really lucky where we live with the GP surgery, they are always friendly and I’ve never had an issue. I once collected toddler DD from nursery at about 5.30pm. She had a very high temperature and was very upset (I was really annoyed the nursery hadn’t called me but anyway). I wasn’t even sure if the surgery was still open but I brought her straight there, and thankfully it was still open. The receptionist was lovely, said the doctor would see her. I waited maybe 20 mins and in that time the receptionist came over to reassure me a couple of times, I must have looked worried. Doctor took about 2 mins to confirm ear infection and prescribe antibiotics. If I were you I would definitely complain.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/12/2022 21:55

I’d complain via practice manager. If they had offered appointment at 4 or 4.30 in the morning you would have been there.
It’s not realistic to offer an appointment 30 plus mins drive away at short notice.
Hope your dc is ok.

Itsoktogiveup · 12/12/2022 21:55

I’m so sorry OP, that’s awful. The bureaucracy involved for getting antibiotics is ridiculous in this country (as is the fact that you were told to sit in a GP reception for hours with a highly contagious disease).

You were six minutes late for a ten minute appointment with an illness that would take about 30 seconds to diagnose and another few seconds to send tbe prescription to an admin person.

Shocking.

I would…

  1. Call 111 again and tell them the GP refused to honour the appointment because you were 6 min late.
  2. See a private GP asap by videolink and get a private prescription.
  3. Change GP practice if possible.
  4. Put in a formal complaint re old practice refusing to see a seriously ill child that they had a legal duty to see who was there during her scheduled appointment slot - yes a little late but still there before the GP had to see anyone else.

What absolute power-trippy incompetent wankers, I’m furious on your behalf.

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 21:54

SillySausage81 · 12/12/2022 21:52

I would imagine there was a fair bit of eye rolling over the amount of time it took to gather yourself and your kids to attend the appointment though.

What, 15 minutes? For a baby and toddler with no notice? (Given that we know the surgery was a 30 min drive away "on a good day")? I'd love to know what super juice you drink to think that most people should be able to get an adult, baby and sick toddler ready (nappies changed, wees, coats, shoes, hats, gloves, strapped into car seats) in less than that time, I'm sure parents all over the world would love to know your secret.

This. And when they’re poorly and don’t want to get up and go….

OP posts:
Minimalme · 12/12/2022 21:53

redbigbananafeet · 12/12/2022 21:47

Stop saying 45 minutes notice. It was 55 minutes. Are you in their catchment area? Your nearest GP is nearly an hour away?

So you can count but not read?

Maybe this isn't the forum for you.

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 12/12/2022 21:53

RagzRebooted · 12/12/2022 21:11

That's shocking. Did they consult a GP before they sent you away or was that the receptionist making the decision? I work in a GP surgery and our GPs will always squeeze in a poorly child, and while they do get annoyed with people being late, it's rare that they aren't running at least 15 minutes behind so no one would mind. Also less than 10 minutes late is generally forgivable, you clearly tried.

There's no way our GPs would go home knowing there was a sick child waiting, especially not one with suspected scarlet fever.

Oh come on. If you actually work in a GP surgery you would know that no Receptionist would leave a poorly child sitting in a waiting room just to them unilaterally decide nobody could see them. Why even ask them to take a seat if you were going to do that?

OP, the fact of the matter is there are not enough GP appointments to go around on a good day - let alone just now with scarlet fever. The safe line needs to be drawn somewhere - ie the amount of patients it is safe for one GP to see in one day.

The error here is only offering an appointment you could never make. You wouldn't be seen at the surgery I work at if you were more than 10 mins late either.

Spoken by someone who had to close the emergency list at 2pm today (we close at 6) as there were more than 60 patients on it for 2 Dr's to see.

SillySausage81 · 12/12/2022 21:52

I would imagine there was a fair bit of eye rolling over the amount of time it took to gather yourself and your kids to attend the appointment though.

What, 15 minutes? For a baby and toddler with no notice? (Given that we know the surgery was a 30 min drive away "on a good day")? I'd love to know what super juice you drink to think that most people should be able to get an adult, baby and sick toddler ready (nappies changed, wees, coats, shoes, hats, gloves, strapped into car seats) in less than that time, I'm sure parents all over the world would love to know your secret.

HomemadePickle · 12/12/2022 21:50

Sorry I need to correct my PP, over 300 people died in the 2017/2018 outbreak, not 300 children.

"In the 2017/18 season, there were 355 deaths in total across the season, including 27 deaths in children under 18. “ 9th December 2022 update
GAS, iGAS and Scarlet fever - RCEMLearning
www.rcemlearning.co.uk/foamed/gas-igas-and-scarlet-fever/
www.rcemlearning.co.uk/foamed/gas-igas-and-scarlet-fever/"

whatkatydid2013 · 12/12/2022 21:50

YANBU. That is ridiculous. It’s so stupid 111 can’t just find the nearest available appointments and book you into one you can get to directly. Personally I would take LO to OOO urgent care or A&E. I know it isn’t an actual emergency but without antibiotics scarlet fever can be very serious indeed and if you can’t get them via a sensible route like a GP appointment I’d find another way. I’d also make a complaint to the practice and say that while you understand they are busy etc that to refuse to see you due to an unavoidable delay in reaching the surgery, even after asking you to wait for over an hour you find unacceptable and you’d like their feedback as to whether or not the person turning you away followed policy and if so why they feel that policy is reasonable.

MushMonster · 12/12/2022 21:50

You were 6 minutes late..... they were hours and hours late! I cannot believe they took so long to come back to you with such clear symptoms. They should have sent you straight to the out of hours GP on Sunday! For a 3 year old!
I would file a complaint.
And take my child to the out of hours GP, here is just by A& E.

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 21:49

redbigbananafeet · 12/12/2022 21:47

Stop saying 45 minutes notice. It was 55 minutes. Are you in their catchment area? Your nearest GP is nearly an hour away?

So sorry

OP posts:
WinterLobelia · 12/12/2022 21:49

Oh ffs. My child;s school is usually a 40 minute drive away. In school hour peak traffic. Today it took me 3 hours there and back due to the vagaries of road closures and temp traffic lights and ... just because.

6 minutes late to an appointment you have been given less than an hour's notice of is nothing. Nothing.

The child should have been seen. The OP should not have been treated with such disrespect.

MardyHa · 12/12/2022 21:48

I would write all the details down and email to the Practice Manager and ask them to confirm that they’re comfortable to send away your child without being seen who has very likely got Strep A.

Also, I’d bet quite a bit that if you’d been on time you still wouldn’t have been seen by 4.36pm. And if you would have been and they’re not running late at all, then they’d surely have time fit in one small child with Strep A.

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 12/12/2022 21:48

You could call 111 and tell them because they will have guidelines as well and it will be then on the system you took her and were not seen

Odile13 · 12/12/2022 21:48

I’m so sorry, that sounds awful. YANBU.

Phyllisdoriss · 12/12/2022 21:48

MassiveSalad22 · 12/12/2022 21:46

Hmm. He didnt need to be seen really, you just needed to get your hands on the meds. DS age 5 came down with scarlet fever on weds morning, sent photo to the doc and they prescribed antibiotics without seeing him. Doc said they had a surgery full of sick kids so no need to come down and be exposed/infect anyone. Was glad not to have to go!

I would have loved to not have to go! I can only do as I’m told a follow the advice given to me. Would be more than happy to send photos and collect the necessary meds

OP posts: