Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how you afford your posh car?

289 replies

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 12/12/2022 19:56

My DS (22) is becoming increasingly frustrated by the disparity between the life he aspires to and the one he thinks is possible!

As a car enthusiast on a good wage, he is constantly surprised by the number of brand new premium brand cars (BMW, Mercedes, Volvo etc) that he sees on the roads, which he feels he has no hope of ever affording.

He’s asked my to ask you all, if you drive a premium brand car, paying presumably £400-500 a month to buy or lease, what type of job do you and (if it’s not too rude to ask, what sort of salary are you on?) And if your spouse also drives a similar car, what do they do/earn?!

I know there are lots of factors here including whether you’re paying a bit mortgage, is it a company car etc? But just a snapshot of who is driving these expensive new cars might help him put it all in perspective. TIA

btw I earn NMW and drive a 10 year old car so I’m no help here!

OP posts:
MoominPants · 12/12/2022 22:28

Company car

Cantstandbullshit · 12/12/2022 22:28

IToldYouAmillionTimesAlready · 12/12/2022 20:22

Someone I know has got a Tesla. He works at a picture-framing factory, gets minimum wage, and is up to his eye in debt (he tells people). He's not known locally as Soft Lad for nothing.

Wow, how do you even get approved for a Tesla on minimum wage? The cheapest model is already over £40k.

wonkylegs · 12/12/2022 22:27

We bought one outright with savings (we tend to keep cars for years until they no longer work for us) and the other one is on a very good salary sacrifice lease deal (didn't get to choose much about the car, black or black, no options, but it meant we have a car we couldn't otherwise afford)
We also have a good income and are in our 40's and not overstretched financially
When we were in our 20s although we were both professionals with no kids we drove a focus & a Yaris (both good cars for us at the time) and it took us a few more years to get to premium brands

Dangey · 12/12/2022 22:26

At age 44, I’ve been thinking the same thing. And from reading this thread, it turns out everyone except me is absolutely loaded!

ChangePlease · 12/12/2022 22:26

I’m not really convinced it’s as simple as that @NSA2103 - I owned my previous few (used) cars outright, it’s a bit cheaper yes, then when they start to age they can become a money pit. And you have an older car without new developments for comfort/safety etc…if that bothers you. And you have invested in a depreciating asset. I think there are pros and cons both ways!

blameless · 12/12/2022 22:25

Our two cars cost £7,000 the pair. One was 130mph out of the factory, the other a 4x4 workhorse. Each 150,000+ miles on the clock and old.

I earn £3k per week and love cars but haven't forgotten the lemon that blew an engine and cleaned me out in 2010. Comfort and reliability rather than flash for me.

Mrsmch123 · 12/12/2022 22:25

HappyOnion · 12/12/2022 20:06

DH and I share a Discovery and a Golf. Both bought with cash. We‘re both high earners, household income £600k+.

I think there are just lots of people who earn enough to drive expensive cars. For some it’s also a Q of priorities.

@HappyOnion whats your and your husband job? Just curious 😃

NSA2103 · 12/12/2022 22:20

Miajk · 12/12/2022 20:26

If you invest £500/mo for 5 years and leave it invested for 20 years you'd have a 100k based on a very conservative estimate.

Or you could spend it on a depreciating asset. Most people who drive fancy cars live beyond their means, and don't know much about building wealth, they just want to showcase it.

This!
The values I teach my children are: Live within your means
Don't judge people by what they have or drive.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 12/12/2022 22:19

We bought ours outright - a Tesla and a BMW. But we are not 22

Northby · 12/12/2022 22:19

The best thing to do is buy second hand fairly new. I bought an Audi for only a few thousand more quid than a VW, both only three years old. The Audi was around £12K cheaper than full price and only 20k miles! I used a bank loan for 4 years, with the intention to have the car until it dies (hopefully in about 10 years). The difference in cost meant a few more months of the loan, so it didn’t feel back breaking to spend that little bit extra (esp as they’re both so expensive already)! I wouldn’t have been able to buy any kind of car without the loan.
I know very few people who have bought a house in their 20s without significant help from “bank of mum and dad”. DH and I didn’t have that, saved really hard for a few years and jumped on the 5% mortgage offers last year. It’s really tough economically at the moment - Sending him all the best!!

Morielle · 12/12/2022 22:17

If you work for a car company head office or financial services devision you get offered a car + a second one for friends and family.
BMW and Porsche are in Reading, Mercedes and VW Group are in Milton Keynes.
1000 of brand new cars being driving by employees and then sold on ex demos in the retailer after 9 months - 12 months

Buteverythingsfine · 12/12/2022 22:16

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune I know what you are saying, but if you choose wisely not all second-hand but high quality cars depreciate at the same rate as say brand new ones. My FIL just sold his Volvo for the same as he bought it 8 years ago, I've no idea how! Also, flats/houses can depreciate, there's millions in negative equity and likely more to come, an individual property can suddenly need repairs, there's a glut in the market of a particular type, or the government can change the tax rules to make sure you pay hugely in capital gains, that's why lots of landlords are getting out of the market.

In general, I agree with your point and if I had no housing assets I would not buy a flash car, but it's not quite as simple as drive a shit car and be rich in property, it is quite complicated.

ChangePlease · 12/12/2022 22:15

22 reg luxury EV on a package including servicing etc - just under £1000 a month. I do it this way for convenience and having any issues quickly dealt with, it is my first foray into EV. And I like nice cars.

Earn around £170k

Solmum1964 · 12/12/2022 22:14

We have two premium cars as a legacy benefit through my husband's employer (vehicle manufacturer). I think he pays under £600 a month for them both from an £80K salary. This covers everything except fuel.
We used to be able to have a 'normal' car but the reciprocal arrangement with another manufacturer ceased. It was, however, very handy when my children were learning to drive as they were added to the insurance at no extra cost.
I've suggested my husband buys me a smaller car outright, as easier to park, but I regularly get punctures so he likes the convenience of just going to Kwik Fit and not having to pay. Cars used to be changed every 6 months/ 6000 miles but with the issues manufacturers have had getting parts this has now increased. Adult children can still drive them.

Opine · 12/12/2022 22:13

Some of these posts scream resentment. ‘Lease or tick’. How do you know? How has it escaped you that some people have a lot more money than others? Is this not just a recognised fact of life?

We have cars at the highest end of the market. We bought them outright because we can. To finance them would have required huge deposits, & huge monthly payments. That would be impossible to sustain did we not have the money. Anyone who buys such cars ‘on the tick’ must be able to service the loan. They are not average earners with few outgoings or any other suggestion of being chancers on a wing & a prayer.

Some of the cars mentioned aren’t premium. If he’s seeing a disproportionate amount of TTs for example it’s because they’re not luxury vehicles & cost far less than the upwards of 100k that even an entry level Range Rover now costs.

Rocklobstershell · 12/12/2022 22:13

We have a suv Audi etron which we lease through my DH’s work scheme for approx £400 pcm. It is substantially subsidised by a gov e- car scheme otherwise we would not be able to afford it.

Buteverythingsfine · 12/12/2022 22:11

Those saying you live in your house, so put all the money into that, I'm a lone parent, and I drive my teens around a huge amount, several times a day sometimes due to difficulties getting places on time/bus service packing in. I want an easy-to-drive nice car these days, I had the old cars that squeaked and crunched gears for decades (probably my driving). Driving a great car has improved my quality of life considerably. If you don't drive too much, I agree it's not worth it. I don't think having a good quality car is irrational in quite the way some people are making out (if you own already, for example).

Seadragonusgiganticusmaximus · 12/12/2022 22:10

PoinsettiaPosturing · Today 21:53

DBro drives a 72 plate Aldi

That must be a challenge to park. 😂

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 12/12/2022 22:08

Talk with your son about the difference between appreciating assets (those whose values grow, like a house) and depreciating assets (those whose value declines, like a car, fridge/freezer, caravan, fancy wristwatches, etc.).

Focusing on appreciating assets is one way to establish a comfortable life. I drove my cheap little Ford for 16 years and 250,000 miles when I could have "afforded" a newer, more flash car. Replaced it with similar, about 10 years ago, and plan to drive this one as many more years as possible. Meanwhile I put my money into real estate and that has really paid off in terms of security and return on investment.

If he feels at some point in life when he has other needs take care of like old-age savings, a home, education, etc., he should look at used models of the cars he aspires to.

But he might find that the thrill of a steadily growing bank account and pension outweigh the thrills of the flas car.

Ricco12 · 12/12/2022 22:07

We have a £50k Merc, which my husband bought cash.
He would never get a car on hire purchase or credit. His motto is if he can't afford to buy it he won't have it.

He works internationally on oil drilling rigs.

feistymumma · 12/12/2022 22:05

user1471518104 · 12/12/2022 20:03

I have a 90k Audi e-tron on an NHS salary sacrifice scheme that costs 600 a month inc tyres and servicing and insurance.

Earn 100k

Same here but mine is £380 a month and car is worth 60k. Earn approx 75k. Partner drives Q7 and pays £600, earns £500 a day as a contractor

Shaniice · 12/12/2022 22:04

I bought my 4 year old Range Rover at 28 by doing eyelashes. It’s back breaking but relatively easy money and I have no finance to worry about. DH has been in construction for only 5 years and earns over 100k, maybe this is something your son could look into doing? X

changeme4this · 12/12/2022 22:04

A family member (early 40's) and her DH drive very expensive and new (regularly replaced) high end vehicles that are supplied via a contract agreement with her FIL's business that employs her DH (his son) and are not personally owned (so if they separated, she doesn't keep a vehicle although I'm sure her In laws would see her with something safe for the children). Advertising industry.

Her Father, retired not long ago bought something in the range rover range, new.

He (and his siblings) worked their way up in various businesses, not from a wealthy family. He in management (his wife worked for one of the diplomatic communities in the early days) moved his career around the world child free, and moved through UK where they had a family, now based in Europe.

One of the siblings of above has a very nice Bentley and about to upgrade that. His wife drives a 2 door merc (and I get to drive that when I visit) and they also have a little ford fiesta for running about in. He started out as a tow truck driver, invested in commercial real estate businesses and sites inc. shopping centres, a brothel property (not the business) and accommodation for uni students. Not sure what they have now, don't ask them.

Only two people above went onto university education. Only the first couple benefited financially from a set of parents.

But don't get caught up in who drives what (like me driving my Aunt's merc). I remember friends (normal cars) had a photo shoot at their home promoting a certain then actress and a very nice up market car was lent to her for the day, she doesn't have a licence and never drove the car once, but you woulnd't have guessed it from the photos and article.

comical2023 · 12/12/2022 22:01

PaniniHead · 12/12/2022 20:50

If you buy a car on finance, you can’t afford it. I am seeing a lot of 21/22 plate cars recently that have the sides dented in (or obvious accident damage) but the owners can’t afford the repairs on top of the finance cost.

Rubbish. We lease, makes sense. No interest in tying up capital in a car

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 12/12/2022 22:00

I had an inheritance a few years ago and got an brand new car. Got a good deal at the time something like a years free insurance. Would never usually buy brand new as it goes down in value but knew it’d be a once in a lifetime buy. Have traded it for n since.

Swipe left for the next trending thread