Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how you afford your posh car?

289 replies

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 12/12/2022 19:56

My DS (22) is becoming increasingly frustrated by the disparity between the life he aspires to and the one he thinks is possible!

As a car enthusiast on a good wage, he is constantly surprised by the number of brand new premium brand cars (BMW, Mercedes, Volvo etc) that he sees on the roads, which he feels he has no hope of ever affording.

He’s asked my to ask you all, if you drive a premium brand car, paying presumably £400-500 a month to buy or lease, what type of job do you and (if it’s not too rude to ask, what sort of salary are you on?) And if your spouse also drives a similar car, what do they do/earn?!

I know there are lots of factors here including whether you’re paying a bit mortgage, is it a company car etc? But just a snapshot of who is driving these expensive new cars might help him put it all in perspective. TIA

btw I earn NMW and drive a 10 year old car so I’m no help here!

OP posts:
SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 13/12/2022 09:33

Mince314s · 12/12/2022 23:37

If it helps, the car I had at 22 was my most fun yet. It had character, which is a nice way of saying the doors froze shut when it got cold, but I really enjoyed driving it. I worked for a luxury car manufacturer (think the same one as @Solmum1964 s DH) so got to drive a lot of nice cars and after a while they get a bit nice but dull. I have a sensible family car now and miss the banger!

Yeah he has had a couple of fun cars along the way and loves them too. I don’t think he’d really want eg Range Rover. It’s more that he’s astounded that in this financial climate that anyone can afford to buy a £50k car, but I guess not having a mortgage frees up a lot, having two (very) high earners together helps and the other little bonuses along the way help too.

I do think a second job could help but I’m not sure if his industry allows it, as there are quite strict rules on working hours. But if he had his own business I think he could comfortably earn another £1k a month on his days off. He hates being bored so would be an ideal candidate for that, as he gets 4 days off in a row at the moment.

OP posts:
ILoveeCakes · 13/12/2022 08:30

How? If he starts by doing his own research rather than by asking his mum, that will be a good first step.

Tell him that parents are not the font of all knowledge (he should have worked that out years ago) and they aren't his PA either.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/12/2022 08:30

FloydPepper · 12/12/2022 22:00

Same here.

advice to your DS is don’t be impatient. Loads of debt/payments/pcp when you can’t really afford it is storing up trouble

wait. Then buy a bit older but a lot more interesting. I have a sports car and a luxury car, both used so much cheaper than a new ordinary car.

think about this. For 30k you can have a new bmw 3 series, or a used 911. In 3 years guess which will have been the most fun and still worth what you paid.

Agree with this. We have a moderately cheap older hot hatch (one raved about by petrolheads), and after 11 years it's actually worth slightly more than we paid. That's the route most genuine car enthusiasts go down, surely?

OnTheRunWithMannyMontana · 13/12/2022 08:28

BIL has a brand new car every 2-3 years. He works in sales at a dealership and gets them through work. He does have to pay towards it though. SIL also gets a brand new car at the same time from him and she is on NMW in a warehouse.

We have a lovely brand new hybrid car but it's through motability. I would rather have my legs working and our 12 year old focus back though so you can tell him from me there's more important things to life than a brand new car.

Toomuchstufftodo · 13/12/2022 08:23

123woop · 12/12/2022 21:53

Myself and DH have the same conversation regularly! We are on a very very good wage with a v decent household income and there is no way we could afford the monthly outgoings on flashy cars. It baffles me!
We used to live on a modest street of houses, and we worked out that the majority were paying at least £2 K a month per household for their cars (£1k each - new range rovers etc)
I know a few people who have cars they spend thousands a year on and I genuinely have no idea where they get the money. Some are self employed so I don't know how they get the credit, some don't even have a job (!) and others with mid level manager jobs on £30-40K spending £12K a year plus on just a car.
And that's without considering that they don't own it, plus the fact these cars are depreciating so much. Plus everyone I know who's had one of these cars, when they've gone to take it back after 3 years they've received an ENORMOUS bill for "damage", like a "scratch" that costs hundreds to repair, or new alloys etc.

It just seems a crazy financial decision to me! Especially for my friends who are in rented houses - I don't know why they don't get a cheaper car and put the money towards a house deposit but maybe I'm just an old fuddy duddy 😂

You would be surprised at the price of some RR on PCP, we looked at them before we got our car 4/5 years ago and they were less than £400 a month, albeit it would vary according to mileage but if you live in a town it would unlikely be that high. You would be looking at something seriously luxurious if spending £1k a month!

Lunar270 · 13/12/2022 08:22

I think twice about buying fancy fruit teabags instead of own brand. I do spend time wondering how on earth we got things so wrong financially when apparently every other bugger in the neighbourhood has 40k to spend on a car

You probably haven't got anything wrong financially and the likely truth is that your neighbours don't have £40k either. As long as they can afford £300/month, that's likely all they need.

Apparently 90% of private new car sales are on PCP nowadays so rest assured that you're not doing anything wrong. In fact you're one of the winners if you've yet to get sucked into this scheme. The people on MN that say they've bought expensive cars outright are in a very small minority.

Devoutspoken · 13/12/2022 08:17

God, can't he find a different passion

Toomuchstufftodo · 13/12/2022 08:15

yoyy · 12/12/2022 21:42

Partner and I have combined income of about £110k, drive a bmw that we got on PCP for £630 a month for 4 years and then we paid the balloon payment to keep the car at the end.

We earn similar & no way could we afford £630 a month for a car. And although our mortgage is big it's far cheaper then renting something smaller.

We have no children (yet) and live in a rural area, our mortgage is about £800pm, house is only 5 yrs old so its energy efficient. Good example of why you can't really compare circumstances on income alone, so many other things come into it. If we lived somewhere else, it would be entirely different on our income!

NibbledSwitch · 13/12/2022 08:13

There's a lot of posts at the moment trying to fathom how much people earn 🤔

2pinkginsplease · 13/12/2022 08:09

PaniniHead · 12/12/2022 20:50

If you buy a car on finance, you can’t afford it. I am seeing a lot of 21/22 plate cars recently that have the sides dented in (or obvious accident damage) but the owners can’t afford the repairs on top of the finance cost.

Simply not true!

We have a relatively new car, an Audi, we can easily afford the monthly payment and with our savings could buy the car outright., so have money for anything that needs repaired. We also have a relatively low mortgage and earn under 50k between us.

we’ve always bought our cars outright and kept them for 8-10 years but I’m travelling more for work so wanted a more reliable car, hence why we have gone for finance and a newer model.

Pipsquiggle · 13/12/2022 07:55

Love this thread. So interesting.

I buy second hand and outright - no finance.

Currently have a 10 year old Mazda.

The reason being I work in an industry with high redundancies, if my job goes I want to know that I can still afford my car. This has been borne out of experience - I had a lovely Honda company car but it went after I was made redundant and I realised how marooned I was.

I am not a petrol head. My DH laughs at me as my requirements for a car are:
cup holder
leather steering wheel
heated seats (recent addition to the list, I blame old age)
cruise control.

I also see no point getting an amazing car when it gets trashed by young DC

If I drove a lot for my job, I would probably get a better car with all the gizmos

MigsandTiggs · 13/12/2022 07:20

CoffeandTiaMaria · 13/12/2022 07:07

@TinfoilTwat sums it up nicely for me:
I think twice about buying fancy fruit teabags instead of own brand. I do spend time wondering how on earth we got things so wrong financially when apparently every other bugger in the neighbourhood has 40k to spend on a car
As a retired nurse some of these salaries are eye-watering to me.
The most I have ever spent on a car was £20k and that took years to save for (old bangers before that) and I loved it.
I cannot imagine paying out some of the sums on here 😳

If you look at it as a percentage of disposable income, it makes more sense. A friend I went to uni with is a solicitor with her own practice. She drives a Porsche, owns an air bnb in addition to her home, and no debt. Different careers pay differently and being self employed makes a difference. My joiner bought his three children their first homes; he is easily on £70-80k. An in-demand tradesman today can write their own cheques.

CoffeandTiaMaria · 13/12/2022 07:07

@TinfoilTwat sums it up nicely for me:
I think twice about buying fancy fruit teabags instead of own brand. I do spend time wondering how on earth we got things so wrong financially when apparently every other bugger in the neighbourhood has 40k to spend on a car
As a retired nurse some of these salaries are eye-watering to me.
The most I have ever spent on a car was £20k and that took years to save for (old bangers before that) and I loved it.
I cannot imagine paying out some of the sums on here 😳

Benjispruce4 · 13/12/2022 06:57

At 22 I would be grated to go have any car and to have passed my test!

PurBal · 13/12/2022 06:50

When I was growing up everyone who owned a nice car either had a company car or was insanely wealthy. The greatest bit of marketing in recent history has been rebranding debt as credit. I bought my fancy car, top
of the range but not a fancy badge, with cash in my thirties, but it was a few years old not new. Arguably my dad fell into the wealthy category for a while (six figure salary starting with a 4) and he’s never bought a new car or a fancy car despite always coveting one.

fyn · 13/12/2022 04:26

A lot of people I know who drive flashy cars are soldiers, they live in block and have total living expenses of about £100 - 200 a month. The rest of their salary is disposable whilst they are young and single!

Ozgirl75 · 13/12/2022 04:04

You should get him to read “Rich dad poor dad” (although he probably won’t!) - it’s all about how you build wealth rather than waste it on depreciating items.
However, I’m probably the wrong person to speak to as we earn a good wage (around $500k) but I drive a Toyota because it’s reliable and fuel efficient 😄
Fancy cars don’t interest me really, ironically my dad used to race cars and has owned a selection of Ferraris over his life (bought cash)

Aprilx · 13/12/2022 03:48

Why is he getting frustrated about this at the age of 22? Not many people will have a flash car at that age. It is something he can work towards. Confused

My car is quite a nice car but not a flash car, an Audi Q3 bought new and paid in cash. We were both on just over £100k at the time although I am not anymore but I would never have paid £400-500 a month for a car.

TinfoilTwat · 13/12/2022 03:39

I've been wondering this recently. I don't really notice cars, but I've started noticing that every time I go out I see at least 3 Teslas. They're everywhere! Parked at swimming, school drop-off, supermarket, park run. I point them out; "ANOTHER BLOODY TESLA!!" We live in a very ordinary area. Kids at local state primary. DH and I both went to university and work fulltime at decent jobs. We could never afford a Tesla in this lifetime. I think twice about buying fancy fruit teabags instead of own brand. I do spend time wondering how on earth we got things so wrong financially when apparently every other bugger in the neighbourhood has 40k to spend on a car.

Aintnosupermum · 13/12/2022 02:47

@SteveHarringtonsChestHair

I can afford to buy pretty much any car I want. The journey to this point was hard work, lots of boring bits and being very careful regarding the choices made along the way.

Im now divorced and support 3 children on my own. I’m sure lots of people look at me and think ‘how does she afford 3 sets of school fees, a nice car, home and all those medical bills?’ The reality is I learned when I was 27, slow and steady wins the race. It’s really boring but the only acceptable debt is a mortgage. He isn’t doing anything wrong. It feels wrong because most young people his age are being irresponsible and spending way too much on a flash car they can’t afford. They then question why they are 40 and can’t afford to buy a home. If he is at home, has he considered working a 2nd job?

allboysherebutme · 12/12/2022 23:37

Put a lump sum down then monthly. X

Mince314s · 12/12/2022 23:37

If it helps, the car I had at 22 was my most fun yet. It had character, which is a nice way of saying the doors froze shut when it got cold, but I really enjoyed driving it. I worked for a luxury car manufacturer (think the same one as @Solmum1964 s DH) so got to drive a lot of nice cars and after a while they get a bit nice but dull. I have a sensible family car now and miss the banger!

Seadragonusgiganticusmaximus · 12/12/2022 23:37

IneedanewTV · 12/12/2022 22:44

Yep feeling the same.

Well the clue here is in the title of the thread! “AIBU to ask how you afford your posh car?”

Posh cars cost a lot of money. There’s no way around that (other than possibly buying an old secondhand one, but people who want a posh car usually want a new one so it doesn’t work for many).

So it should be no surprise that most of the answers are variations of “I’m loaded” (with a smattering of “I can’t really afford it but do it anyway”).

Pelo22 · 12/12/2022 23:24

I might be in a Range Rover 22 plate or a Jaguar or a Porsche
It's not mine Grin I just work in the industry. Actually own a VW polo which is reliable and cheap and parked round the back

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 12/12/2022 23:20

NightAndShiningArmour · 12/12/2022 21:52

OP, is your DS only interested in new cars?

I live with a Petrol Head OP who has built his career around a nice car

He got a job (skilled) which would these days command a c.45k plus salary. Instead of taking a salary increase to move jobs, he asked for his new co to guarantee him X car. They had to do him a special contract as normally your company car is a % of your salary.

He’s a genuine petrol head tho, so he would similarly appreciate a subtle car, rather than a swanky BMW or Merc.

we have a combined household income of £90k and run…
a Audi s4 avant (owned outright, as its older. Used for long runs)
Modern Fiesta ST (company car, used for short runs only, super sporty and high spec)
Range Rover Sport (owned, unsecured loan of £10k, daily family car cos we love it)

No, his dream cars are usually 1980s classics. It’s more that he’s trying to piece together a life, and seeing the ceiling salary on his job, even with the potential for two incomes if he moves in with his GF and still not seeing how they can afford the life other people have.

I think there’s an element of “comparison is the thief of joy” here and try to encourage him to see how many good things he has in his life, but when he can’t imagine being able to have a house car and family due to rising costs it’s a bit sad and I guess we both wanted to know what sort of salary affords you that. I know things will change over the years, interest rate fluctuations, housing market crashes etc so there will be opportunities that he can’t even imagine yet. But for now it seems that 6 figure salaries, generous car allowances, and then sadly inheritance or some other unfortunate circumstances seem to be the way. I keep telling him he’ll be ok once I die, but even then divided by all the DCs that won’t go far!

OP posts: