Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how you afford your posh car?

289 replies

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 12/12/2022 19:56

My DS (22) is becoming increasingly frustrated by the disparity between the life he aspires to and the one he thinks is possible!

As a car enthusiast on a good wage, he is constantly surprised by the number of brand new premium brand cars (BMW, Mercedes, Volvo etc) that he sees on the roads, which he feels he has no hope of ever affording.

He’s asked my to ask you all, if you drive a premium brand car, paying presumably £400-500 a month to buy or lease, what type of job do you and (if it’s not too rude to ask, what sort of salary are you on?) And if your spouse also drives a similar car, what do they do/earn?!

I know there are lots of factors here including whether you’re paying a bit mortgage, is it a company car etc? But just a snapshot of who is driving these expensive new cars might help him put it all in perspective. TIA

btw I earn NMW and drive a 10 year old car so I’m no help here!

OP posts:
SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 13/12/2022 18:18

*shouldn’t read!

OP posts:
SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 13/12/2022 18:17

Aintnosupermum · 13/12/2022 16:54

Give the lad a break. I empathize with his thoughts. Doesn’t mean he isn’t being entitled or spoilt. I remember being 22 and wondering how people afforded things which I thought were normal. It’s part of growing up. I think it’s great he has asked the question rather than just going out there and taking on debt.

Thank you for your considered stance. He knows he’s fortunate, but he sees all around him young people his age who are buying houses and fancy cars etc and he’s saving hard to be able to get on the housing ladder, but he can’t keep up with the rising cost of housing and living etc and was just interested to know.

Thank you to those who have explained about salary sacrifice and car allowances for electric cars etc as that’s not something I have any experience of.

So it’s not just us moaning that we don’t earn enough, it’s both of us now realising that there are many different ways to pay for a new car and that many people wouldn’t have one if they didn’t have it included as part of their job.

DS knows he’s incredibly fortunate to be where he is, but tbh if someone is struggling financially then they probably should read a MN thread about posh cars!

He’s generally a very sensible and frugal young man and won’t be rushing out to sign a PCP on a brand new BMW, he’s just wondering how far he has adjust his aspirations (not expectations or entitlement) I guess!

OP posts:
Busytimes · 13/12/2022 17:10

My mate is wealthy bit also has an illness so he gets disability beenfit. He does jot need the benefit so he somply banks it for a few years . Then he gets a new car for his wife . ( he is not allowed to drive )
no loan .

Aintnosupermum · 13/12/2022 16:54

Give the lad a break. I empathize with his thoughts. Doesn’t mean he isn’t being entitled or spoilt. I remember being 22 and wondering how people afforded things which I thought were normal. It’s part of growing up. I think it’s great he has asked the question rather than just going out there and taking on debt.

123woop · 13/12/2022 14:49

Toomuchstufftodo · 13/12/2022 08:23

You would be surprised at the price of some RR on PCP, we looked at them before we got our car 4/5 years ago and they were less than £400 a month, albeit it would vary according to mileage but if you live in a town it would unlikely be that high. You would be looking at something seriously luxurious if spending £1k a month!

Yes majority are in the top of the range Range Rovers, Porsches and Mercedes which are just fortunes imho!!

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/12/2022 13:42

And yes, the idea that a 22 year old is "becoming disillusioned" because he can't afford a Porsche/Audi yet is ludicrous. It just feeds the stereotype that young people are entitled and not prepared to work for/wait for things, expecting it all immediately. (I know this stereotype isn't true, but the OP is fuelling it).

At 22, anyone sensible will be driving a cheap banger, if they have a car at all. Spending £££ on a lease because you're living at home and have disposable income is not very bright when that money could be put towards a house deposit.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/12/2022 13:37

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 13/12/2022 12:45

I don't really understand these threads... they seem pointless exercises in class envy and finger pointing without any particular goal except to make the OP feel worse about herself with a side order of stealth boasting from some people.

OP: How can you afford your house/car/clothes
MN: Because I have a high salary/big inheritance/I'm mortgaged up to the hilt
OP: Oh. I could have figured that out for myself really but I just wanted to make people feel guilty about having so much money and whinge that I don't have it.
MN: Either go out and earn the money or stop whinging
OP: It's so unfair...
MN: Stop moaning, you shouldn't have had kids

etc ad nauseam.

Very true 😂

hookiewookie29 · 13/12/2022 13:26

Ours is a 2022 Motobility car,although we do have to sacrifice hubby's PIP payment for it

Derbee · 13/12/2022 13:13

A 22 year old who is earning well above the national average salary already, and is getting “increasingly frustrated” because he can’t afford a flashy car due to the fact that he’s saving £1k/month needs a kick up the arse and a reminder of how lucky he is.

I’d tell him to stop moping, and stop being so utterly ridiculous. He could afford any of the cars that he’s talking about it he saved at a slower rate.

The balance of savings/house deposit and cars is totally up to him. We have a comfortable life, and I’m still thoroughly irritated by your son’s attitude, and the fact that you’re encouraging it. Can’t imagine how some people who are struggling to eat/warm their homes would take this post.

theemmadilemma · 13/12/2022 13:01

Also worth adding - a lot of young people driving these cars are having them paid for by the bank of Mum and Dad. Saw that a lot down South around Ascot way for example.

Other people will be considerably older than your son. My DH is 37.

theemmadilemma · 13/12/2022 12:58

DP has a still not MOT'd BMW 6 Series. I know it costs him around £330 a month and he purchased just before the prices went silly.

But he earns over £70k and also has a car allowance, and visits customer sites throughout the UK. He drives a lot and long distances. Software tech and sales type role.

ILoveeCakes · 13/12/2022 12:50

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 13/12/2022 12:45

I don't really understand these threads... they seem pointless exercises in class envy and finger pointing without any particular goal except to make the OP feel worse about herself with a side order of stealth boasting from some people.

OP: How can you afford your house/car/clothes
MN: Because I have a high salary/big inheritance/I'm mortgaged up to the hilt
OP: Oh. I could have figured that out for myself really but I just wanted to make people feel guilty about having so much money and whinge that I don't have it.
MN: Either go out and earn the money or stop whinging
OP: It's so unfair...
MN: Stop moaning, you shouldn't have had kids

etc ad nauseam.

Like the "What do you spend on heating per month" type threads.

Can't the OP just imagine a range of numbers between £0 and £2,000?

What does it matter what someone else's bill is when the OP lives a different life in a different house.

Thelaughingtonepoliceman · 13/12/2022 12:45

I don't really understand these threads... they seem pointless exercises in class envy and finger pointing without any particular goal except to make the OP feel worse about herself with a side order of stealth boasting from some people.

OP: How can you afford your house/car/clothes
MN: Because I have a high salary/big inheritance/I'm mortgaged up to the hilt
OP: Oh. I could have figured that out for myself really but I just wanted to make people feel guilty about having so much money and whinge that I don't have it.
MN: Either go out and earn the money or stop whinging
OP: It's so unfair...
MN: Stop moaning, you shouldn't have had kids

etc ad nauseam.

EndlessRain1 · 13/12/2022 12:42

My hybrid BMW X3 is a company car. It is expensive if you consider I couldnt take the cash allowance, but relatively cheap in BIK because it's hybrid. I would never spend that kind of money on a new or nearly new car, but now I have it as a benefit I do love it. It's a great car to drive.

Buteverythingsfine · 13/12/2022 12:40

I fell off the property ladder for a long time. I have only owned my own home since about 47, and a fancy car for the first time at 51.

I don't think at 22 this is realistic! Finances and living are a long game.

MigsandTiggs · 13/12/2022 10:48

I usually buy cash but would consider leasing in future if the cost was the lowest after comparing total cost over the lease period, against the car's depreciation in same time period, and expected increase in value if the lease amount was invested instead.

Leasing per se, isn't necessarily a mug's game.

Rlt8990 · 13/12/2022 10:15

We have a salary sacrifice lease through husband's work, around 400 a month, new car every 3 years. Not a flashy brand but a decent new car. We had 2 old bangers and were able to swap them for one lease car for a while. It's reliable, we don't pay anything extra for insurance or tax. We fill it with fuel and we'd pay excess if an accident was our fault. But any minor repairs, service etc are all paid for. To me it saves us having to have a "car pot" as such. It was the best solution for us and now hubby has a v cheap company car as well to me it's worth the money to be hassle free. We earn around 70k household between us

HereIfYouNeedMe · 13/12/2022 10:10

DH gets a car allowance which pays for it

xogossipgirlxo · 13/12/2022 09:58

Oh, and to add I also have car in finance, but I share it with my husband, so we have 2 incomes security, and it's ours next year (we need to pay 1 grand). We bought it as used car, it's still worth over 10 grand, so not old banger at all. Decent German SUV. I told my husband this car needs to live now as long as possible, as we are not getting anything new (baby on the way and planning to build the house without mortgage- not in the UK though). It's best not to be bothered by new reg cars. His time will come, but he's only 22.

ILoveeCakes · 13/12/2022 09:57

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 13/12/2022 09:37

😂. He just knows I ask MN whenever I need to know something, so I said I’d ask!

There’s always lots of threads on here about earnings, mortgages etc so thought I’d get a reasonable spread of replies to demonstrate to him that there are many ways to get where he wants to be. There’s sort of a ceiling on the amount he can earn in this job, but that’s not to say he couldn’t pivot into a different industry or role in future where there’s potential to earn the big bucks.

oh and screenshot for the poster doubting this was even real (probably the same one who doubted my DD was real on my previous thread because she dared to call me mama!)

Not having a go, but sometimes to answer a question or solve a problem, you have to take a step back and ask a different question/solve a different problem.

Waking up one day and thinking "How do I get a load of money to buy a nice car" is great and a good start - but making money often starts elsewhere. It can be a journey that ends up bringing in money - and maybe you even end up buying a nice car because you might as well - but you didn't for years which is why you have even more money than you would have done if you'd only got into a position to do your job, and then done it, just for the money and then spent it on a car.

Ask him to think around and before the problem a bit.

xogossipgirlxo · 13/12/2022 09:56

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 13/12/2022 09:33

Yeah he has had a couple of fun cars along the way and loves them too. I don’t think he’d really want eg Range Rover. It’s more that he’s astounded that in this financial climate that anyone can afford to buy a £50k car, but I guess not having a mortgage frees up a lot, having two (very) high earners together helps and the other little bonuses along the way help too.

I do think a second job could help but I’m not sure if his industry allows it, as there are quite strict rules on working hours. But if he had his own business I think he could comfortably earn another £1k a month on his days off. He hates being bored so would be an ideal candidate for that, as he gets 4 days off in a row at the moment.

That's definitely it. Only people I know who can afford nice cars (for cash) are people in their 50s, good jobs, mortgage paid off etc. When I see someone in their 20s driving 22 plate Audi/BMW, most likely it's on finance or company car, so practically they don't own it. You lose the job, you lose the car.

VestaTilley · 13/12/2022 09:49

Oh, if it’s relevant - DH and I are high earners - banking and law. Hell would freeze over before I’d prioritize paying out for cars though.

VestaTilley · 13/12/2022 09:45

MIL and FIL drive a Range Rover Evoque and some kind of sporty, very low down and hard to get in to BMW. Paid for on finance - I know FILs was about £700 a month. MILs was probably similar but is paid off now I think.

They drove a convertible BMW and a Jaguar before that. She’s a retired senior assistant head teacher at state secondary, he’s a self employed SAP/IT project manager/consultant. They live in a cheap part of the country and have long since paid off their mortgage. They have comfortable private pensions.

Personally I think it’s ridiculous. Awful for the environment, gas guzzling, flash cars look ludicrous parked on the driveway of a normal, small suburban home. Why in the name of God would you shell out £1400 a month between you on CARS. It’s ludicrous.

In your position I’d advise your son to buy a used Fiesta and save every penny he can to buy a house and save towards his pension. The days of cheap credit and good workplace pensions are gone. He’d be mad at his age to sink a fortune in to a flash car.

DH and I paid cash for a second hand used Astra which we share. We’ll drive it until it claps out. Getting in to debt for a car is insane.

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 13/12/2022 09:39

Oh and @FloydPepper he’d absolutely take the 911 - I think he just wants to be in a position where had the choice!

OP posts:
SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 13/12/2022 09:37

ILoveeCakes · 13/12/2022 08:30

How? If he starts by doing his own research rather than by asking his mum, that will be a good first step.

Tell him that parents are not the font of all knowledge (he should have worked that out years ago) and they aren't his PA either.

😂. He just knows I ask MN whenever I need to know something, so I said I’d ask!

There’s always lots of threads on here about earnings, mortgages etc so thought I’d get a reasonable spread of replies to demonstrate to him that there are many ways to get where he wants to be. There’s sort of a ceiling on the amount he can earn in this job, but that’s not to say he couldn’t pivot into a different industry or role in future where there’s potential to earn the big bucks.

oh and screenshot for the poster doubting this was even real (probably the same one who doubted my DD was real on my previous thread because she dared to call me mama!)

to ask how you afford your posh car?
OP posts: