Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's better to work full time?

68 replies

Catslovepies · 12/12/2022 15:38

I am hosting a guest from Ukraine- she's lovely and no trouble. I helped her get a job interview where I work for an admin job paying £21-£24k based on experience for 37 hours. At the moment she's working in a café for NMW topped up by universal credit. She works about 16 hours a week.

She has now said she's concerned as she will lose her universal credit so will be working a lot more hours for not much more money. I said I thought it would add up to more and that she would still receive child benefit (she has 2 children, 7 and 12). If she gets the job she could work 2-3 days from home and the rest from the office. On the days she works from the office I or DH would do the school drop-off for her and then her daughter would go to after school club for under £5.

So AIBU to think she would be better off working full time or is she right that she would be on approximately the same money as she is now? She has a good work ethic and I would have thought she'd rather work than take benefits she doesn't need but there should be a financial incentive to working surely? I have never been on benefits so don't understand it really but she says this is the reason many English people choose to work part time.

OP posts:
Catslovepies · 12/12/2022 18:49

Pumperthepumper · 12/12/2022 18:45

Just that the benefit-bashing didn’t take long, I’d say that was fairly obvious from my post.

It wasn't and still isn't. How on earth is saying that benefits should be for people who need them benefit bashing????

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 12/12/2022 18:45

Catslovepies · 12/12/2022 18:29

What is your point, @Pumperthepumper ?

Just that the benefit-bashing didn’t take long, I’d say that was fairly obvious from my post.

Homeworkandholidays · 12/12/2022 18:44

Maybe she's not planning to stay in the UK long term Confused If I suddenly had to take my kids out of a war zone to another country I'd want to spent time with them rather than thinking about building up a pension in that new country. Maybe being through a war made her think about her priorities.

Catslovepies · 12/12/2022 18:29

Pumperthepumper · 12/12/2022 18:18

That didn’t take long!

What is your point, @Pumperthepumper ?

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 12/12/2022 18:20

And this is why so much “benefit bashing” exists! Because it pays to work minimal hours and rely on the tax payers to pay the rest for your kids!

Instead of recognising that employees benefit from keeping wages low and rely on the tax payer to make it up to enough to live on - just. No one working full time should have such a low wage that they need benefits to top them up, and moving from part time to full time work should pay enough to see a signifier financial uplift from part time plus benefits.

Pumperthepumper · 12/12/2022 18:18

Catslovepies · 12/12/2022 16:56

I do think she sees it that way @Nirvanarama . But I still think in her circumstances as well as in most other people's that benefits should be for people who need them, not for people who just can't be bothered to work much. I'm a leftie too but this is ridiculous. I honestly had no idea the system worked this way.

That didn’t take long!

Allsnotwell · 12/12/2022 18:14

I don’t really get why the system incentives lower hours

The system doesn’t - what makes it pay is the low hourly rate that companies are prepared to pay experienced workers.

MarshaBradyo · 12/12/2022 18:09

Kazzyhoward · 12/12/2022 16:09

Goes back to Brown's tax credits, the idea being to get people back into work, even part time, hence the 16 (I think) hours threshold. Of course, without a matching incentive for part timers to go full time, it's just meant lots of people only want to work enough hours to trigger tax credits (now UC), especially with national insurance starting to be charged when people work more. So to work more, you pay income tax and NIC and lose tax credits/UC - hence the stupidly high marginal "tax" where you lose something like 70% of the extra income you earn for working more. Having a limit on deductions of 50% would make a massive difference and incentivise people to work more as they'd keep more of the money they earn. A "sliding scale" rather than cliff-edges such as 16 hours would also help.

I can see why working 16 hours is better than zero but in the other direction it seems madness if it increases state pay

Badgirlriri · 12/12/2022 18:06

And this is why so much “benefit bashing” exists! Because it pays to work minimal hours and rely on the tax payers to pay the rest for your kids!

Zanatdy · 12/12/2022 18:03

Long term, pension for example, and promotion prospects it’s better to be full time

Catslovepies · 12/12/2022 18:01

She has been here 6 months but I definitely take the point that she needs to do what suits her and her family. My surprise really is about the system rather than this particular case. It seems wrong to me that there is so little incentive to work.

My guest has pointed out that if she takes this job and then for any reason needs to rent her own place that she thinks she would be unable to get housing benefit so would be much worse off. She actuallyreally wants the job for the experience which would enable her to get a much better job in Ukrainewhen she goes back. But she is afraid of the financial repercussions of taking the job. It really shouldn't be this way. I didn't know any of this.

OP posts:
DontSpeakLatinInFrontOfTheBooks · 12/12/2022 17:41

She needs to do what’s best for her and her family. Has she written out a realistic budget for both scenarios? So her income and outgoings for both set ups?

Coyoacan · 12/12/2022 17:27

I only worked part time when my dd was young because I was not a genius mother who could guide and know my child while working fulltime.

Stupidquestion1 · 12/12/2022 17:26

It's crap that the system works like that. But I think you need to remember how much stress and worry she must be have. She probably needs some time and mental space to process what is happening to her family and her country.

Justcanttakeit · 12/12/2022 17:24

Catslovepies · 12/12/2022 17:21

Um, excuse me? I'm hosting her and her children (and doing a massive amount for her and her family), did you miss that part or are you just hard of thinking?

its clear you are doing a lot for her and her family which is lovely but you have to take a step back and allow her to make her own decisions about work. It’s her choice and she will know best what she can manage and what she can’t

Catslovepies · 12/12/2022 17:21

TabithaTittlemouse · 12/12/2022 17:08

A ‘leftie’ with no compassion for someone who is seeking refuge in the U.K.?
Someone who wants to survive?
I think you have a bit of Tory poking out.

Stop trying to parent her.

Um, excuse me? I'm hosting her and her children (and doing a massive amount for her and her family), did you miss that part or are you just hard of thinking?

OP posts:
Justcanttakeit · 12/12/2022 17:16

I think this is exactly the kind of person benefits are meant for . It’s not like she isn’t working at all!!!
she has been through trauma and upheaval I’d imagine and like you say she wants to go home when safe so this temporary I wouldn’t begrudge her a penny

Stressfordays · 12/12/2022 17:15

I do agree its a trap people fall into. I'm a lone parent who works full time because I'm aware my children won't be little for long and bigger children come with bigger expenses so I need to boost my earning potential. People just keep looking short term rather then long term. I do sort of agree with your guest though if she is going to return to the Ukraine and this is a stop gap for her just to survive.

TightPants · 12/12/2022 17:14

@TabithaTittlemouse how many Ukrainians are staying with you?

I think the OP has a lot of compassion. Wind your neck in.

pjani · 12/12/2022 17:14

@TabithaTittlemouse I think it sounds like she’s doing a lot for this refugee and their children? I don’t know why you’d criticise.

OP I’m with you, it’s good professional experience and it can mean promotion later down the track and even if she returns to Ukraine soon, it’s useful to have more professional experience.

Also why not have a bit of UK pension paid to you even if you return to Ukraine?

However, she’s an adult, probably traumatised, you’ve got to let her make her own decisions.

Overthebow · 12/12/2022 17:12

Nirvanarama · 12/12/2022 17:07

It's not the benefits that are the problem, it's low wages and the cost of living and childcare that's the problem. I dont claim benefits but I do work part time as I would lose money if I went full time.

That’s a different situation though. On UC people can get up to 80% of childcare costs covered.

Nirvanarama · 12/12/2022 17:09

And it's not because I'm not "thinking long term" either, I cant afford the childcare I would need. As in literally can't afford it

TabithaTittlemouse · 12/12/2022 17:08

Catslovepies · 12/12/2022 16:56

I do think she sees it that way @Nirvanarama . But I still think in her circumstances as well as in most other people's that benefits should be for people who need them, not for people who just can't be bothered to work much. I'm a leftie too but this is ridiculous. I honestly had no idea the system worked this way.

A ‘leftie’ with no compassion for someone who is seeking refuge in the U.K.?
Someone who wants to survive?
I think you have a bit of Tory poking out.

Stop trying to parent her.

Nirvanarama · 12/12/2022 17:07

It's not the benefits that are the problem, it's low wages and the cost of living and childcare that's the problem. I dont claim benefits but I do work part time as I would lose money if I went full time.

BungleandGeorge · 12/12/2022 17:06

I thought UC forced people to work more than 16 hours at nmw once their children were school age?
in any case she’ll still get UC on that full time salary