Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Current tax thresholds act as a disincentive

86 replies

Transferwaiting · 12/12/2022 12:21

I have been asked to apply for a promotion at work starting next year. This would mean a big jump in responsibility and a 10k payrise. I've been working it all out and because it takes me into a higher rate bracket and we have 4 DC, I would lose all CB and pay 40% of this in tax. I would actually only see £150 extra per month which whilst nice would not make up for the increase in responsibility and potential impact this would have on our lives and also doesn't cover any extra costs incurred for childcare/commute etc . I feel so disheartened.

FYI I am happy to pay tax and happy to pay more but this feels like such a steep cliff edge between being worth it and not. Surely many people must find this and we are missing out on a lot of talented people where it's not worth it making that jump.

OP posts:
TizerorFizz · 12/12/2022 21:15

Don’t recall Truss as Chancellor. Thank God.

helford · 12/12/2022 19:45

Lostinalibrary · 12/12/2022 17:06

YANBU. This is kind of what Truss was getting at and it has led to low productivity and a brain drain. It’s also what is causing a crisis in the NHS. It’s even worse when you go up to the next bracket which is notorious as you lose personal allowance. Many consultants, dentists etc actively drop working hours to avoid the 100k-125k tax anomaly where you are paying roughly 70 % tax and NI combined and then student loans.

It is a huge problem in specialist industries such as medicine, tech, etc.

Hang on, Truss was in Govt for the last ten years and signed off all of these changes & 10 years of Austerity, probably the biggest act of self harm, alongside Brexit.

She is an idiot.

TBH the people i know who are leaving the country are healthcare staff and teachers, none of whom are anywhere the 40% tax bracket, the ones who are are earning 100k plus are quite happy here.

SirMingeALot · 12/12/2022 19:17

This is kind of what Truss was getting at and it has led to low productivity and a brain drain.

And yet she did nothing about this particular bottleneck when she had the chance!

Jenn3112 · 12/12/2022 18:56

To lose all your CB you would have to be earning quite a bit over £60k unless you are not putting anything in a pension which at that earnings level is pretty unlikely. I think the question is about what you want your life to look like rather than an issue about taxes. Do you want to earn a bit more for what might be quite a bit more work but gives you more options in future, or do you want to spend this part of your life prioritising home over work? Neither is a bad option, it's just which one suits your family.

pointythings · 12/12/2022 18:35

The big problem is the CB - the policy of doing it on highest earner is just ridiculous, it should be on total household income as that would smooth out the bumps for a lot of people (though not for all outliers). On the whole I would say it is worth it because it's a platform from which you can go even higher, at which point you will see more money and have a better pension too.

Testina · 12/12/2022 18:06

“At the moment I do the school run on my way home. However, I wouldn't be able to do that which would mean DH would have to travel to do that (25 mins each way for him)”

I’m going to throw in a, “so?”

Is that worth it for your career development and career progression?

It might not be - but don’t write it off.

Transferwaiting · 12/12/2022 17:38

Testina · 12/12/2022 16:56

I think you’re shortsighted.
That step up that gets you a £10K pay rise now, is what potentially gives you £20K more than now in 2 years…
Why does more responsibility mean more childcare costs? Is it because you have to give up WFH and go into an office?
Can their father flex his hours to support your career development and pay profession?

I’d do as a PP suggested - enough into pension to keep all your CB. You might even keep some of it as your existing pension payment might be keeping you partly under £60K.

Even if you end up net the same money for added responsibility, are you only looking at money? Quite apart from pay and career progression, taking on more responsibilities can make your working life more interesting!

On a more general point, I think YABU because your situation is niche. 4 lots of CB to lose is unusual.

It's not quite so simple. It's more that I would be expected to stay in the office for longer to provide the cover as a senior member of staff. At the moment I do the school run on my way home. However, I wouldn't be able to do that which would mean DH would have to travel to do that (25 mins each way for him) or we'd have to access wraparound care. Both of those options will cost money. I'll also be out of the house for longer meaning that ideally I'd outsource some of household stuff but that £150 extra a month won't even cover the childcare let alone a cleaner. So ultimately I'd be poorer and probably more stressed.

OP posts:
Transferwaiting · 12/12/2022 17:28

topcat2014 · 12/12/2022 16:37

If I offered someone a20% pay rise and they declined I'm not sure I ever would again. Be careful what you are ruling out. You are still better off

It is a very large organisation so I don't perceive this will be limiting but obviously it will take me longer to progress if I do choose to make the move up

OP posts:
TizerorFizz · 12/12/2022 17:16

If a Dr is earning £100-125,000 and paying student tax, they must have gone to uni in the last 10 years. DD had the old loan snd went in 2010 and has paid it off. All high earners have issues with pension pots being taxed when they get to £1.1m. Everyone who has skills and is a high tax payer. If everyone works part time we really won’t get productivity or a tax take big enough to fund our services. People do need to keep more of earnings.

Lostinalibrary · 12/12/2022 17:06

YANBU. This is kind of what Truss was getting at and it has led to low productivity and a brain drain. It’s also what is causing a crisis in the NHS. It’s even worse when you go up to the next bracket which is notorious as you lose personal allowance. Many consultants, dentists etc actively drop working hours to avoid the 100k-125k tax anomaly where you are paying roughly 70 % tax and NI combined and then student loans.

It is a huge problem in specialist industries such as medicine, tech, etc.

SirMingeALot · 12/12/2022 17:03

Four DC is niche, true, but the 50-60k bottleneck for parents is pretty well known. And if anything it's likely to become more common, bearing in mind that inflation is rising but neither the 40% nor CB thresholds look like they're going to be going up to match any time soon.

I think it's an issue worth considering. It's a decade since the decision to remove universal CB and tie it to higher rate taxpayer status was taken, with the figure being picked on the grounds of administrative ease and at a time when we had no general labour shortage to worry about. It may be that we're still best off keeping the 40% and CB thresholds where they are, but the factors that were in place when we initially chose it aren't the same now.

Testina · 12/12/2022 16:56

I think you’re shortsighted.
That step up that gets you a £10K pay rise now, is what potentially gives you £20K more than now in 2 years…
Why does more responsibility mean more childcare costs? Is it because you have to give up WFH and go into an office?
Can their father flex his hours to support your career development and pay profession?

I’d do as a PP suggested - enough into pension to keep all your CB. You might even keep some of it as your existing pension payment might be keeping you partly under £60K.

Even if you end up net the same money for added responsibility, are you only looking at money? Quite apart from pay and career progression, taking on more responsibilities can make your working life more interesting!

On a more general point, I think YABU because your situation is niche. 4 lots of CB to lose is unusual.

antelopevalley · 12/12/2022 16:47

I have put YABU because wherever the threshold is, it will affect some individuals quite a lot.

SirMingeALot · 12/12/2022 16:45

topcat2014 · 12/12/2022 16:37

If I offered someone a20% pay rise and they declined I'm not sure I ever would again. Be careful what you are ruling out. You are still better off

Depends on how you define 'better off'. I would agree that OP should be careful what she gives up, but that applies to more things than the money.

SeasonFinale · 12/12/2022 16:43

But surely if you dint take this promotion and rise it prevents you taking the next step up in the long term.

Do you have a partner? Surely the increased childcare care costs will be split with them?

User963 · 12/12/2022 16:39

LaMontser · 12/12/2022 16:02

Well mine didn’t count - looking at the guidance maybe it’s because I pay higher rate tax. I queried it more than once and still had to pay the whole lot back.

Was your pension a salary sacrifice scheme? I think it only counts if it is and your pension comes out of your gross earnings. Then it effectively reduces the amount of earnings that you have to pay tax on. Not all pension schemes are salary sacrifice schemes and some of them come out of net pay.

topcat2014 · 12/12/2022 16:37

If I offered someone a20% pay rise and they declined I'm not sure I ever would again. Be careful what you are ruling out. You are still better off

Buteverythingsfine · 12/12/2022 16:34

I am in this situation and a lone parent sogave no other income so CB solely off mine, whereas two parents on 45k each get full CB. So annoying!

SirMingeALot · 12/12/2022 16:24

Yes, 100k is another bottleneck. So too are the situations where people are going to lose most of every pound they earn in withdrawal of top up benefits. We have these spread across the income spectrum in the UK, not a niche thing at all. But obviously the 50-60k salary zone where you get the double whammy of child benefit withdrawal and the 40% rate tends to come up most on here, due to the demographic.

Wishawisha · 12/12/2022 16:06

This is absolutely a thing. Going over 100k can be very costly - the marginal tax rate is 60% even though this is not the cited rate (because you lose the tax free allowance gradually from 100k) and there are various benefits that don’t apply from 100k eg you don’t get 30 hours childcare for 3 year olds, you aren’t eligible for tax free child care.

A lot of the system is very flawed.

LaMontser · 12/12/2022 16:02

Well mine didn’t count - looking at the guidance maybe it’s because I pay higher rate tax. I queried it more than once and still had to pay the whole lot back.

123woop · 12/12/2022 15:52

Yeah we had this issue too. It was actually quite gutting as we celebrated, of course, and then were like "oh, we'll actually weirdly be worse off"

LlynTegid · 12/12/2022 14:19

There is too much focus on the marginal rate of income tax and not enough on the overall tax take. Also the corporate tax regime is based on a business world which has not existed for at least 20 years.

titchy · 12/12/2022 14:14

LaMontser · 12/12/2022 13:28

The pension contribution thing only counts for child benefit if you pay it into a private pension. Work place schemes don’t count. I had to pay back £1800 last year despite paying 12.5% into my work pension.

That's wrong. It goes by what's on your P60 which should be net of any pension contribution where to employer or private scheme.

Flossflower · 12/12/2022 14:07

Candlle · 12/12/2022 12:58

YANBU, this is the reason I won’t do overtime:

40% tax
12% national insurance
9% student loan
9% pension

I would get 30p for every £1 I earn!

This is a bit of a shortsighted argument
You would be reducing what is owed on your student loan and increasing your pension