Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Current tax thresholds act as a disincentive

86 replies

Transferwaiting · 12/12/2022 12:21

I have been asked to apply for a promotion at work starting next year. This would mean a big jump in responsibility and a 10k payrise. I've been working it all out and because it takes me into a higher rate bracket and we have 4 DC, I would lose all CB and pay 40% of this in tax. I would actually only see £150 extra per month which whilst nice would not make up for the increase in responsibility and potential impact this would have on our lives and also doesn't cover any extra costs incurred for childcare/commute etc . I feel so disheartened.

FYI I am happy to pay tax and happy to pay more but this feels like such a steep cliff edge between being worth it and not. Surely many people must find this and we are missing out on a lot of talented people where it's not worth it making that jump.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SirMingeALot · 12/01/2023 19:25

I wonder if CB is the reason they've not raised the 40% threshold, actually.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 12/01/2023 18:47

What's frustrating is the tax bands haven't been reviewed in years, £50k today is not the same as it was when it was last looked at this is the point the Tories are trying to remove CB altogether. In 10years only those on “low” incomes if 50k will qualify.

TizerorFizz · 12/01/2023 18:47

The government wants more tax so the bands are not going to change. Brings more people into paying high tax rates.

nc8975 · 12/01/2023 18:30

I'm in this exact position, civil service, G7 to 6 goes from approximately £50k to £60k. You also have the extra pain of an increased pension contribution rate when you go over £54k in the CS. We (usually) can't negotiate our salary. It's quite a big jump in responsibility too.

What's frustrating is the tax bands haven't been reviewed in years, £50k today is not the same as it was when it was last looked at.

It works out about £200 more a month for me overall, quite small considering the responsibility but I will do it because I want the role and to progress my career, hopefully the next jump will be more noticeable!

Transferwaiting · 12/01/2023 18:25

WoofWoofWoofMudToys I still haven't decided. Will make the decision in March when I will know more details about the promotion. There are also other considerations with my husband's employment so we need to speak to an accountant (he's self-employed)

OP posts:
WoofWoofWoofMudToys · 12/01/2023 18:03

@Transferwaiting

what did you decide to do??

LastNCof2022 · 13/12/2022 16:22

Generally speaking, the UK does not foster individuals' financial success, and entrepreneurship. The proportion of money you have to pay in one tax or another as your income increases, is enough to make many people say 'no thank you.' Especially when you are a net contributor.

updownleftrightstart · 13/12/2022 16:17

Are you sure you'd lose all CB? What would the salary be minus pension contributions?
As Jenn3112 said, you'd have to earn quite a lot over 60k to lose it all by the time you've paid pension contributions

southpolepenguin · 13/12/2022 16:06

My dh is in the same boat. Only just fell into hrt bracket and now his bonus is also taxed a lot more too. We only gave us two and dc no extra help. Exhausted all the time and I've gone pt which is making things much worse but we just couldn't seem to juggle everything with both of us working ft and price of childcare and everything else going up.

Dh took the promotion two years ago but his pay hasn't gone up that much and his company constantly promise rather elusive promotions that don't come to anything. So I'd say be careful if this is your limit of earning. Dh is more stressed than ever and now thinking to move jobs even if it means being paid lease

Getoff · 13/12/2022 11:46

ArcticSkewer · 13/12/2022 10:51

There are some types of pension contributions where you are supposed to tell HMRC you made them via your tax return and they refund you the 20% or 40% tax. That may be what the poster is talking about, but they didn't do the tax return, so didn't get their 40% tax back and also didn't get their taxable income reduced and their child benefit paid. Expensive mistake if so.

I think you can do tax returns for past years, so it may still be possible to get the tax back.

EndlessRain1 · 13/12/2022 11:37

The penalty for hitting 100k with children is worse. A HUGE rate of tax due to losing your personal allowance, and you lose the tax free childcare scheme.

But, I guess that they have to draw the line somewhere. There is always going to be someone disadvantaged. Exactly the same as the limits to losing other benefits. These line are drawn by policies and politics.

ArcticSkewer · 13/12/2022 10:51

There are some types of pension contributions where you are supposed to tell HMRC you made them via your tax return and they refund you the 20% or 40% tax. That may be what the poster is talking about, but they didn't do the tax return, so didn't get their 40% tax back and also didn't get their taxable income reduced and their child benefit paid. Expensive mistake if so.

Getoff · 13/12/2022 10:43

User963 · 12/12/2022 16:39

Was your pension a salary sacrifice scheme? I think it only counts if it is and your pension comes out of your gross earnings. Then it effectively reduces the amount of earnings that you have to pay tax on. Not all pension schemes are salary sacrifice schemes and some of them come out of net pay.

Even if the pension contributions were not salary sacrifice, I still think they will reduce taxable income, and this person would get the money back if they did a tax return.

I really want to know the facts, because I'm sure they are very different from what's being conveyed. It's not at all clear who is telling her this, and why.

They could do a dummy tax return, register online and do one without necessarily submitting it, and that would tell them definitively if they've been over-taxed. I would not rely on anyone I'm talking to on the phone, either at my employer or HMRC, to be getting this right.

Kabalagala · 13/12/2022 10:36

We were in that position with DH's promotion last year. Wasn't really worth it, but we looked at it as a means to an end. The next promotion will be even bigger and we'll be much better off.

Cornelious · 13/12/2022 10:28

Could you do 4 days in the new role? So a promotion, less hours but the same money?

ILoveeCakes · 13/12/2022 09:50

Frabbits · 13/12/2022 09:32

Or that the people running the show are fucking idiots, perhaps.

I don't think that changing the people or party will help much. It's more systemic than that

Frabbits · 13/12/2022 09:32

ILoveeCakes · 12/12/2022 23:54

When the government takes this % in tax and still goes into massive debt, it's telling us that our government is too expensive/is spending too much.

Or that the people running the show are fucking idiots, perhaps.

Frabbits · 13/12/2022 09:31

topcat2014 · 12/12/2022 16:37

If I offered someone a20% pay rise and they declined I'm not sure I ever would again. Be careful what you are ruling out. You are still better off

Well that's just shit management, isn't it?

Not everyonet thinks money is the most important thing in life.

Lunar270 · 13/12/2022 09:23

Transferwaiting · 12/12/2022 12:21

I have been asked to apply for a promotion at work starting next year. This would mean a big jump in responsibility and a 10k payrise. I've been working it all out and because it takes me into a higher rate bracket and we have 4 DC, I would lose all CB and pay 40% of this in tax. I would actually only see £150 extra per month which whilst nice would not make up for the increase in responsibility and potential impact this would have on our lives and also doesn't cover any extra costs incurred for childcare/commute etc . I feel so disheartened.

FYI I am happy to pay tax and happy to pay more but this feels like such a steep cliff edge between being worth it and not. Surely many people must find this and we are missing out on a lot of talented people where it's not worth it making that jump.

Doesn't the decision also come down to the longer term potential of your career? You mentioned this is a big company so am guessing the opportunity for further promotion is possible?

If you don't think you'll be climbing any higher then you'd probably be right to hold off, but if you could move again in a few years then I'd feel like I was cutting off my nose a bit.

How's your current role? Is it still stimulating? Also, is this £10k increase right or a low offer? Being asked to apply is very flattering but needs to be met with the appropriate increase in salary.

ArcticSkewer · 13/12/2022 09:07

I'd still take it.

See if you can work compressed hours so you finish earlier one day.
Dh does 2 days.
Pay for wraparound care.

Then look at your salary. Salary sacrifice childcare, car, any pension (and btw to whoever posted about pensions, you were incorrectly advised as all pension contributions count), charitable donations. What's your actual salary after all that? And how much cb do you lose?

Baconand · 13/12/2022 09:04

This is why I went slightly part time. Is it an option for you?

At full time I pay 8.5% pension contribution and 40% tax and lose CB. I dropped a day a week and pay 6.8% pension (it drops me in to a lower band) , keep CB and 20% tax. With a day less of childcare I’m actually better off than working full time.

I plan to go back to full time eventually but it doesn’t add up at the moment.

pointythings · 13/12/2022 08:59

ILoveeCakes · 12/12/2022 23:54

When the government takes this % in tax and still goes into massive debt, it's telling us that our government is too expensive/is spending too much.

Well, it is spending too much. On the wrong things. It would be nice to see where the money was going, including lucrative PPE contracts for bezzie mates.

The massive debt is mostly due to COVID and Kwarteng's Idiot Budget - the markets hated it and let him know.

ILoveeCakes · 12/12/2022 23:54

When the government takes this % in tax and still goes into massive debt, it's telling us that our government is too expensive/is spending too much.

Ouchiebum · 12/12/2022 23:13

Transferwaiting · 12/12/2022 17:38

It's not quite so simple. It's more that I would be expected to stay in the office for longer to provide the cover as a senior member of staff. At the moment I do the school run on my way home. However, I wouldn't be able to do that which would mean DH would have to travel to do that (25 mins each way for him) or we'd have to access wraparound care. Both of those options will cost money. I'll also be out of the house for longer meaning that ideally I'd outsource some of household stuff but that £150 extra a month won't even cover the childcare let alone a cleaner. So ultimately I'd be poorer and probably more stressed.

Why don’t you negotiate working part time in new time, that way you get the development benefits without loosing school pick up and cb.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 12/12/2022 22:54

Dont discount it straight away. There might be hidden things like additional benefits that actually work out well financially even if they're not included in the salary. A higher % bonus. More holiday (which when kids are at school means less holiday clubs). Also more pension contributions which can make a big difference eventually.

Also kids are only in childcare a short time. When it's no longer needed the difference will be bigger.