Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think trying to persuade children to believe in Santa is wrong?

86 replies

antelopevalley · 12/12/2022 09:27

Most children reach the age where they begin to question the existence of Father Christmas. I think it is fine when children ask if he is real to say, what do you think? But I see some parents going to elaborate lengths to persuade questioning children to keep believing.

I think there comes a point where this switches from a nice story to have magic in your children's life, to lying to your children so that as a parént you can enjoy them believing.

I get in terms of things we all do wrong this is fairly minor, but I do think it is better if children are told the truth by parents about Santa when they ask a direct question.

OP posts:
AltheaVestr1t · 12/12/2022 10:22

My DD is 11 and still 'believes'. Highly intelligent, no SEN - she has a will of steel and and is absolutely determined that we all go along with it despite all evidence to the contrary!

IamnotSethRogan · 12/12/2022 10:21

Oh god people are getting so hand wringing about this. My eldest has stopped believing over the last couple of years. He didn't feel betrayed and it wasn't traumatising. He thought it was a nice thing that we did and it came to a pretty natural end. He's got a younger sister and still gets involved with the "magical" elements for her. Everyone just wants children to grow up and be tiny rational adults and quite frankly it's depressing.

Also I don't think 4 year olds have the emotional maturity that for example my son had when he was 8ish and stopped believing. It's pretty likely that they will tell all their class mates whose parents do the santa thing, whereas my son was old enough to understand he shouldn't expose the great awful lie that all the awful lying parents tell.

Hillarious · 12/12/2022 10:20

Some parents just get themselves into an unnecessary pickle over this. When I was growing up, Father Christmas was only ever the delivery driver. All my presents came from named friends and relatives. I was too logical as a child to truly believe, and anyway, we didn't have a chimney. We've done the same with our kids, ie not promoted Father Christmas as the person who provides all the presents and deems how deserving you might be. But the magic of Christmas is still there. We have no presents under the tree before Christmas Day. We've always put them out after they've gone to bed, and now they're 22, 24 and 25 and go to bed later than me, the presents are put out before they get up. It's lovely to see them all there and the eager anticipation of what great things might be wrapped up. The only disappointment may be that it's possibly pants and socks and electric toothbrush heads you're about to unwrap.

LizzieW1969 · 12/12/2022 10:14

DD1 (now 13) believed until age 10, but she has SEN and sees the world in black and white. DD2 (now 10) OTOH first said she thought the tooth fairy was ‘pretend’ at age 4. We managed to hold off her disbelief until age 7 when she asked me straight out whether Santa was real and I told her no. She immediately told her older sister.

DD1 was fine, but she wanted us to record ourselves filling the stockings!! 🤣

PeeAche2 · 12/12/2022 10:09

The 10yo knows, I can tell from the way her voice gets high when she talks about the big guy now. But we haven’t been asked outright and we’re keeping up the pretence for the 8yo. We have a baby that is too young yet.

I don’t know what the right thing to do is, but it seems like a small thing for any parent to tie themselves in knots over. All the kids are alive and well adjusted. I think we’ve done okay and I think you all probably have too, however you handle Father Christmas.

Noodledoodledoo · 12/12/2022 10:06

They maybe asking questions not due to thier own thoughts, but others saying things. I still remember being told by a daughter of one of my mums friends who was about 4 years older than me he wasn't real at about the age of 5 - she was a really mean spirited child in all sorts of ways so this was just another thing, I think I was convinced otherwise but it sticks in my mind.

FictionalCharacter · 12/12/2022 10:05

I agree. I’ve always thought that this is done for parents’ entertainment, not to benefit children. There would be no harm in telling kids that Santa isn’t real but it’s a game we all play, a nice fantasy.
I hated being tricked and lied to as a child. My family did a lot of this, thought it was amusing to tell children tall stories and laugh at how gullible they are, and I thought it was really nasty. Like a PP it made me distrust my parents and think well, what else are they lying to me about? And they lied to me a lot.

toastofthetown · 12/12/2022 10:04

I agree. I find the whole lying to children about Father Christmas questionable at the best of times. It’s one thing when it’s a cultural belief they’re swept up in, but quite different when children are coming to you with doubts and you are directly lying and misdirecting them. I went to a very small rural village school (the kind where those in MN would insist promote long belief in Father Christmas), but other than one classmate, everyone had stopped believing by nine. How can children see that Father Christmas acts differently in different households, not all children celebrate Christmas and therefore don’t have Christmas gifts at all, the annual fundraising and donations to ensure that all children around the country and world have Christmas gifts, as well as a growing understanding of the speed and distance involved, and aerodynamics of reindeer and not think something is amiss? The whole story is pretty preposterous when given a moment’s thought.

Despite not believing in Father Christmas from a young age, I’ve always found Christmas a wonderful and magical time of year, and stopping believing in Santa hasn’t stopped that. Other than bringing a stocking Father Christmas really wasn’t a big deal, so realising he wasn’t real also wasn’t a big deal. If you play along like Father Christmas is a game to play (and I still get a stocking if I’m at my parents’ house) and find magic and fun in real things, then I don’t think that the magic of Christmas can ruined as long as youare willing to find joy in it. It doesn’t need an imaginary man in a red coat.

atvb · 12/12/2022 10:02

It's such a non-issue.
no older child is going to be persuaded into believing in Santa- it would only really work for kids in the cusp of believing and letting them half believe the magic for an extra Christmas isn't going to harm or traumatise anyone.
no one has trust issues as a result of being told Santa is real. Maybe a few very extreme cases but generally non abusive normal parents telling their kids Santa is really is harmless.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/12/2022 10:01

@antelopevalley, yes, but my dd would have said it was me and dh - while really hoping for me to deny it!

I should have said, ‘Well, if you don’t believe in Father Christmas, he probably won’t come.’

(He did still come long after dds were grown up anyway - if they were sleeping here on Christmas Eve. Oddly enough he never seemed to be able to find them otherwise. 🎅🏻🎄)

summergone · 12/12/2022 09:56

My son is 9 and still really believes hasn't questioned it once , I'm pretty sure this is his last year thou. We have been going to a garden centre for years to meet Santa and he is absolutely brilliant spends 15 minutes with each child and this year he isn't there so had to find another which I felt quite sad about as obviously not many spend 15 minutes with each child .

RudsyFarmer · 12/12/2022 09:56

I have told them, across their years, that magic will exist for as long as they believe. That statement encompasses Santa, the tooth fairy, goodies always beating baddies, fairness and justice, wishes coming true - the whole lot of it. We know as adults that justice rarely prevails and the bad guys hold all the power. But cynicism is for adults and my kids very happily live in a bubble where they feel safe and happy.

Long may it continue.

antelopevalley · 12/12/2022 09:55

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER That is why I think asking the question - what do you think - is a good first response.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 12/12/2022 09:54

I’m amazed that so many people think children believe at 11/12. Unless there are SEN I would be concerned at the lack of critical thinking in a secondary aged child

I'm in ROI. It's not unheard of here. Just a more innocent culture presumably.

PeachSquashAddict · 12/12/2022 09:52

pointythings · 12/12/2022 09:33

I agree with you. When they start questioning they're usually ready to not believe. The key thing is how you handle it - when ours worked it out, we praised them for being so clever and deducing that it was us who did the presents, so they felt it was their achievement. Our oldest was happy to be sworn to secrecy until her sister worked it out for herself so she could also have that moment of 'I did it!'. When they had both stopped believing we brought in a new tradition where they got a budget to buy presents for each family member and we'd go Christmas shopping in pairs so that everyone could buy secretly for everyone else. It was always a great day out.

Oh I love this approach!! Thanks for the info, my eldest is 4 so hopefully have a while before needed but definitely will do this when the time comes!

MadameCholetsDirtySecret · 12/12/2022 09:50

I’m amazed that so many people think children believe at 11/12. Unless there are SEN I would be concerned at the lack of critical thinking in a secondary aged child.

I also think that if a young child asks the question, they should be told the truth, whatever age. The question is a result of the child logically reasoning and to lie wrong.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/12/2022 09:46

Dd1 was coming up to 9 when she told me in very matter of fact tones that she knew Father Christmas was me and Daddy, so I might as well admit it.

So I did.
When she was in her early 20s she told me she’d been dying for me to deny it, so she could go on believing a little longer. I so wish I had!

I suspect many kids are the same - strongly suspecting, but want to go on believing anyway.

And I don’t call it ‘lying’ BTW - to me it’s just innocent make-believe. I never once felt that my own parents had lied to me. On the contrary, I was very grateful for that magical excitement of childhood Christmas Eves.

helpfulperson · 12/12/2022 09:46

I think a lot of older children pretend to please their parents which is worrying. I agree that when they first ask questions is the time to acknowledge that he isn't a real person but still important. Or at least not insist he is real

minipie · 12/12/2022 09:45

antelopevalley · 12/12/2022 09:27

Most children reach the age where they begin to question the existence of Father Christmas. I think it is fine when children ask if he is real to say, what do you think? But I see some parents going to elaborate lengths to persuade questioning children to keep believing.

I think there comes a point where this switches from a nice story to have magic in your children's life, to lying to your children so that as a parént you can enjoy them believing.

I get in terms of things we all do wrong this is fairly minor, but I do think it is better if children are told the truth by parents about Santa when they ask a direct question.

I would agree with you except for the fact of younger siblings and other children. My older DD started questioning at around age 7. She has a sister 2 years younger. Yes I did prolong DD1’s belief because I knew that she’d probably tell her younger sister who was only 5.

2 years later DD1 still questioning, age 9, I told her the truth. Thought she was old enough to prefer the truth, and grown up enough to keep it to herself. Told her in a nice way, we are all part of the magic and now you are too, etc etc. She was a) very upset and b) told her younger sister 🙄

LittleCottage · 12/12/2022 09:43

I don't ever remember feeling like I'd been deceived when I found out Father Christmas wasn't real. I don't even remember the actual time I realised.

Himawarigirl · 12/12/2022 09:41

@DrNo007 you’ve reminded me that my eldest also found the whole idea of a strange man coming into our house in the night disturbing, ever since she saw him clomping about on the roof in a Peppa Pig episode. So that’s another reason I didn’t go big on Santa! Christmas is still magical without being built on the idea of Santa.

Stompythedinosaur · 12/12/2022 09:40

Belief is not an all or nothing thing. DC can both know Santa isn't real and want to believe a bit on Christmas Eve. I think the finality of "you have got to X age, or had said X phrase so now I will tell you Santa isn't real so there is no room for doubt or further belief" is a bit clinical and lacking in joy.

Also, adults tell dc things that aren't true all the time - I'd say religion is part of this, but another example might be things like "playing fair is best in the end" or "you can be anything you want to be". As adults we fully know these things aren't necessarily true, but they create a world we want our DC to live in. It is the same impulse that gets us to hide the more brutal realities of life.

I think a disproportionate amount of space is given on mn to fretting about whether to tell dc about Santa. I have no intention of sitting my 11 and 9yos down and telling them, but I also know that they are old enough to not really believe. It is just a game we are playing together. They appear mentally unscathed by this.

LoopyLoo1991 · 12/12/2022 09:38

Saw a post on Facebook about a 23 woman complaining her son didn't get any money from the Tooth Fairy for losing is first tooth!
Didn't even occur to her until others pointed it out that the windows being open or closed wouldn't stop the Tooth Fairy getting in, as it was her as a parent that had to leave the money.

Twenty three!

I'd possibly suggest to my friend's son that he set a booby trap for Santa 'just in case' he's real but be light hearted and leave it at that.

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 09:38

Another one of these?

Sleepygrumpyandnothappy · 12/12/2022 09:38

I agree.

DS is still a baby but DP and I are both struggling with how on earth we even begin the Santa myth. We’d be happy not to do it at all but SIL has made clear that his cousins need to be protected from the truth! 😁