Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think trying to persuade children to believe in Santa is wrong?

86 replies

antelopevalley · 12/12/2022 09:27

Most children reach the age where they begin to question the existence of Father Christmas. I think it is fine when children ask if he is real to say, what do you think? But I see some parents going to elaborate lengths to persuade questioning children to keep believing.

I think there comes a point where this switches from a nice story to have magic in your children's life, to lying to your children so that as a parént you can enjoy them believing.

I get in terms of things we all do wrong this is fairly minor, but I do think it is better if children are told the truth by parents about Santa when they ask a direct question.

OP posts:
Saz12 · 12/12/2022 12:19

Lots of children of 9 or 10 are perfectly able and willing to suspend their disbelief in order to enjoy Santa. Maybe younger children dont quite have that capacity when the setting is super familiar?
Just like adults will watch EastEnders, or Jamie Oliver in “his” kitchen, or Saw movies or whatever and temporarily ignore that it’s not real in order to enjoy the program.

There’s really no need to tell children there’s no such person 2 weeks before Christmas, or to suggest they must be stupid or gullible. If they ask then they probably want to know the truth, so I’d not lie, but at this point in the year I’d be going with the “what do you want to think?” type responses.

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 12/12/2022 12:19

When I was a child I pretended to believe for a good couple of years after I stopped, so as not to spoil it for my younger sister. I think parents should let the realisation dawn in its own time; not go to huge lengths to perpetuate it artificially, but not deliberately debunking it either.

antelopevalley · 12/12/2022 12:16

I would have lied at 3 to 4 years old.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 12/12/2022 12:16

Humans often communicate bigger, more meaningful truths via myth. That's what Santa is for me. A bigger truth about the live and generosity of the world, closer to creation myths which are a facet of all human civilisations. To see it as a 'lie' misses the point spectacularly in my opinion.

Christmasnero · 12/12/2022 12:13

My dad said he’d never lie to me if I asked a direct question
i asked when I was around 3 or 4, he asked what did I think and gave me a chance to change my mind, but obviously I wanted the answer.
I’d rather that he had brushed my question off and I could keep wondering, I was so little!
i don’t believe anyone grows up messed up because otherwise good and loving parents lied about this one thing.

Dittosaw · 12/12/2022 12:11

Morally I don’t think lying is that acceptable and it sets a precedent to lie about other things. I was at an event this weekend, which although good, involved the hosts bullshitting the wide eyed kids with little winks to the parents. It all felt a little bit off. I could see the kids going in to school if this snow ends and happily telling the lies that they had been fed and making fools of themselves in the process.

Cherrysoup · 12/12/2022 12:08

I find it odd that parents are so keen to keep it going as long as possible.

I must say, I’d find it really odd for a child of 11 to still believe. Surely they have friends with older siblings who have told their brothers and sisters years ago?

Farradaymange · 12/12/2022 12:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Doingmybest12 · 12/12/2022 12:05

I think most parents know when they are just causing confusion and feelings of worry about this rather than allowing a younger child to enjoy the magic. Hopefully they respond appropriately depending on which of these it is. I don't think other people need to tell other parents how best to manage this.

TriptotheBog · 12/12/2022 12:00

Not convinced how common it is for parents to aggressively insist Father Christmas is real (or else).

Pretending in Father Christmas is not wrong.

If there are parents so unhinged that they deny presents if a child expresses disbelief, then Santa Claus is clearly the least of their issues.

This is a made up problem.

MatildaTravers · 12/12/2022 11:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

TheKeatingFive · 12/12/2022 11:58

People on Mn are often deeply hysterical about FC, and it's far more about them and their ideas about 'magical Christmases' and 'childhood innocence' than their children

I don't see what's 'hysterical' about saying you enjoyed a lovely Christmas tradition and want to uphold it for your own children.

No one is suggesting there's anything wrong with doing Santa your way, your post comes across as really defensive.

TheKeatingFive · 12/12/2022 11:56

What a horrible thing to say about someone's dc.

Agreed. Really nasty.

Also, a bit obtuse. Magical thinking is strongly entrenched in some of the cleverest of children.

PortableVirgins · 12/12/2022 11:55

People on Mn are often deeply hysterical about FC, and it's far more about them and their ideas about 'magical Christmases' and 'childhood innocence' than their children. DS went to a very multi-cultural school for his first few years, where lots of the children were from ethno-religious backgrounds where they either didn't celebrate Christmas at all, or didn't 'do' FC/Santa Claus, so he was always on board with the 'some people believe' version. The fact that he never believed in FC as literally real has never stopped him being a massive Christmas enthusiast, putting out mincepies, following the sleigh on the tracker etc. He's ten now, and still adores Christmas to the point where he starts watching Christmas films in about September.

Stompythedinosaur · 12/12/2022 11:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

What a horrible thing to say about someone's dc.

Really nasty. Did it make you feel superior to insult an 11yo?

Farradaymange · 12/12/2022 11:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

TheKeatingFive · 12/12/2022 11:42

I've never felt anything other than love, appreciation and gratitude towards my parents for facilitating the Santa myth. A lovely part of my childhood, which is my joy to pass on to my own children.

blubberball · 12/12/2022 11:41

I just told mine that it's a nice story for children. I told them this from the beginning, so I never lied or made out it was literally real. It's a nice story for children, and that's the truth. Now I tell them to keep the nice story for their younger cousins.

My cousin told me when I was 4, so I didn't have to worry about being upset or anything. I just used to worry about my mum, because I thought she didn't know it was made up. I didn't want to tell her.

PennyRa · 12/12/2022 11:38

Every family has a right to their own belief system

Sunnidaze · 12/12/2022 11:35

LittleCottage · 12/12/2022 09:43

I don't ever remember feeling like I'd been deceived when I found out Father Christmas wasn't real. I don't even remember the actual time I realised.

I don't either. There was just some point in my life when I worked it out, but it was obviously so insignificant that I simply don't recall. My nephew is the oldest grandchild in our family, and quite a bit older than the rest of the grandchildren. My sister and I asked him about how he felt when he discovered that his parents were 'Santa' and he said he thought it was funny and loved seeing his younger siblings and cousins enjoying the magic. We asked if he felt betrayed/lied to/sad/let down/disappointed etc, and he said he didn't. He understood that Santa represented the magic of Christmas and the Christmas spirit and he admired the effort his parents went to to make Christmas special and magical. My older boys said the same thing when they came to us to talk about 'Santa' and our elf on the shelf, and they've loved helping create the magic for our youngest.

honeylulu · 12/12/2022 11:06

My sister and I never believed in Father Christmas. I'm actually quite gullible but never bought into that one! Our parents were/ are very religious and have always been a bit disapproving of FC being the main focus of Christmas. Their approach was to say there's a tradition that children hang up a stocking and it gets filled with small presents and the tradition started with St Nicholas etc .... They never advertising said FC actually comes down the chimney and we never asked.

My husband thinks it's really sad and a shame that we didn't have the magic of believing though honestly I dont feel that I missed out. It was still absolutely thrilling to go to bed with an empty stocking and wake up with a full one! And the "magic" never wore off because it was never spoiled by the realisation that FC isn't real. On the other hand my husband recalls being devastated age 6 when his older sister told him the awful truth and felt Christmas was never quite as special after that. That seems sad and a shame to me.

With our own children I planned to do similar to my parents but somehow couldn't resist the "big sell". My son (eldest) has ASD though so he was never particularly awed by FC, just the stuff that arrived! In our house FC does stocking gifts and it's always been clear that the big gifts under the tree are from us, though I've always bunged a couple of quite small but exciting things in the stocking.

At around 7 he started to ask me "is Santa a fake?" And I'd say "I don't know. What do you think? " and he'd end up saying that he'd concluded Santa is real. We thought he was hedging his bets in case the stocking didn't get filled but he confirmed years later that at age 7-8 he wasn't quite sure but by 8-9 he'd worked it out but was happy to play along.

Our second child was born when he was 9 and it all started again. Unfortunately she was terrified of FC as a toddler so we downplayed it at first. But we had a couple of absolutely magical years ahead 4-5 where she really did believe and was beyond excited that "he has been!!!"

Age 6 less excitement. Also a lockdown year so no Santa grottoes etc. Thrilled with the stuff, not much mention of FC. Last year, age 7, took her to see FC and she couldn't have been less interested so it had definitely gone for her by then. No devastation or disappointment. She's very sharp and not much gets past her! She also declared last year that she thinks I'm the Tooth Fairy. I think lockdown allowed for an FC slow fade. We've still not acknowledged out loud that he isn't real and she seems happy to play the game.

The funny thing is that when our son was about 12 (he's 17 now) he heard us discussing youngest's stocking presents and said "Wait, what, so it's YOU?" We were a bit shocked and said oh no, did you still believe? He said no, he'd worked out a few years back that FC isn't real but he didn't think we put the presents in the stocking either and he wasn't sure who did. The reasoning was that the wrapping paper was different and he'd never seen it in the house. I explained that was part of the fiction and he looked really shocked. Not sure if he was impressed by my planning or aghast at the extent of my deception!

So what is best? I don't know. I still think it's nice and fun but probably keep it light.

Helpel · 12/12/2022 10:59

Stompythedinosaur · 12/12/2022 09:40

Belief is not an all or nothing thing. DC can both know Santa isn't real and want to believe a bit on Christmas Eve. I think the finality of "you have got to X age, or had said X phrase so now I will tell you Santa isn't real so there is no room for doubt or further belief" is a bit clinical and lacking in joy.

Also, adults tell dc things that aren't true all the time - I'd say religion is part of this, but another example might be things like "playing fair is best in the end" or "you can be anything you want to be". As adults we fully know these things aren't necessarily true, but they create a world we want our DC to live in. It is the same impulse that gets us to hide the more brutal realities of life.

I think a disproportionate amount of space is given on mn to fretting about whether to tell dc about Santa. I have no intention of sitting my 11 and 9yos down and telling them, but I also know that they are old enough to not really believe. It is just a game we are playing together. They appear mentally unscathed by this.

This

Vegetablesupreme · 12/12/2022 10:53

I still won't admit it to my 21 year old dd....he still fills her stocking every year!
My 5 year old did question it about 6 months ago and basically I lied to him. 5 is too young to stop believing. In our household though, santa fills the stockings and then leaves just 2 bigger presents per child. The rest are from me. I know different households do it in different ways but as a child, santa only ever filled the empty stockings left on a hook on the bannister. I kept up this tradition but added in another 2 gifts as well so santa didn't look too mean in comparison to other children in dcs class.
I vividly remember my older sister telling me that santa wasn't real when I was 10. I was so upset as truly still believed 100% (I was a very gullible child!) I had no idea whatsoever that it was my parents filling the stockings but after that bombshell Christmas lost its magic a little for me. I think that's why I still keep up the pretence with dd...even though she obviously knows he's not real and I know that she knows he's not real etc etc.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 12/12/2022 10:49

Fimofriend · 12/12/2022 09:36

We have never encouraged anyone to believe in Santa in my family and none of my friends do it. I don't like the concept and find it to be old fashioned and not appealing at all

Stupidest thing I've read on here.

It's no more "old fashioned" than it was 50 or 100 years ago. It's not a trend!
My parents in the '70s could have said the same thing if they had wanted to look at it that way. All times we are living in are "modern times" after all, and Father Christmas has been around in one form or another for centuries. 🎅

Brightstarowl · 12/12/2022 10:23

It's just a bit of christmas fun and magic.

Why do people have to pick every thing apart...