Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think trying to persuade children to believe in Santa is wrong?

86 replies

antelopevalley · 12/12/2022 09:27

Most children reach the age where they begin to question the existence of Father Christmas. I think it is fine when children ask if he is real to say, what do you think? But I see some parents going to elaborate lengths to persuade questioning children to keep believing.

I think there comes a point where this switches from a nice story to have magic in your children's life, to lying to your children so that as a parént you can enjoy them believing.

I get in terms of things we all do wrong this is fairly minor, but I do think it is better if children are told the truth by parents about Santa when they ask a direct question.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hadalifeonce · 14/12/2022 12:10

My children are young adults now, but still remember the magic of believing. DD loves it, even now, if I leave a trail of 'Santa dust' from the fireplace, and outside with a partly eaten carrots.
DS summed it up when I told him just before he started secondary school, that even if Santa doesn't exist, the spirit of Christmas does.
I always tried not to lie to them if they had questions, but at the same time avoided the truth until about 11.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/12/2022 11:53

@caringcarer , I remember arguing with girls at school that of course FC was real - how would my (almost invariably skint) parents have been able to afford all the stocking presents? I was probably 7 or 8 - and aware from a very young age that money was always very tight.
Still grateful to my long-gone parents for making that effort when there was so little cash to spare.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/12/2022 13:44

Any 11 year old who believes a magical overweight man travels the entire globe within a 24 hour period delivering gifts, isn’t all that intelligent and should potentially be getting additional science tutoring

What a truly horrible thing to post. 😡

Honestly, maybe try remembering it's the season of peace and goodwill. Or something. Anything that will stop you stating other people's children.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/12/2022 13:37

Stompythedinosaur · 12/12/2022 09:40

Belief is not an all or nothing thing. DC can both know Santa isn't real and want to believe a bit on Christmas Eve. I think the finality of "you have got to X age, or had said X phrase so now I will tell you Santa isn't real so there is no room for doubt or further belief" is a bit clinical and lacking in joy.

Also, adults tell dc things that aren't true all the time - I'd say religion is part of this, but another example might be things like "playing fair is best in the end" or "you can be anything you want to be". As adults we fully know these things aren't necessarily true, but they create a world we want our DC to live in. It is the same impulse that gets us to hide the more brutal realities of life.

I think a disproportionate amount of space is given on mn to fretting about whether to tell dc about Santa. I have no intention of sitting my 11 and 9yos down and telling them, but I also know that they are old enough to not really believe. It is just a game we are playing together. They appear mentally unscathed by this.

What a brilliant post! I agree with every word, so well put.

caringcarer · 12/12/2022 13:12

My sister told all her children that Santa was not real. The three oldest accepted it but the youngest 6 1/2, absolutely refused to believe her. She said she sees him on TV in films, he came to her Xmas Fayre and Mummy and Daddy could not possibly afford to buy all the presents in the sacks for her brothers and sister and her. So Mummy must be making it up for some reason. Made us crack up with laughter when sister told us. Niece asked me if we get presents in stocking on Xmas day so I said yes, because we do stockings iny house. Apparently this convinced her even more because no young children in our house but stockings still filled. I told my sister if she wants to believe so much just let her have the magic.

Sparklybanana · 12/12/2022 13:09

I loved receiving that sack of presents. It didn't change for me knowing it was mum and I don't remember feeling devastated.
I actually started doing a sack for my parents too!
I don't 'push' Santa but I go with the flow. My dd8 knows I'm sure but she's staying quiet!
It's the idea rather than the presents - father Christmas has never delivered an expensive toy and most things are very unpresent like - toothbrush? Magazine? But still fun. If you can't have wonder and magic when you're a kid then the world is a little sad.

Stompythedinosaur · 12/12/2022 13:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

I suppose I am just amazed that an adult would say such mean-spirited things about a child.

Libelula1979 · 12/12/2022 13:05

I've never done the Father Christmas thing with mine, but they started Reception this year and both (twins) believe now.
So, I'll go along with it for as long as they need me to and when they start questioning it all, we'll chat about it then.
But, they've never been told that they need to be good.in order to get presents and they think Mummy and Father Christmas have a chat in December to agree what both girls might like. 😅

theleafandnotthetree · 12/12/2022 13:01

TheKeatingFive · 12/12/2022 09:54

I’m amazed that so many people think children believe at 11/12. Unless there are SEN I would be concerned at the lack of critical thinking in a secondary aged child

I'm in ROI. It's not unheard of here. Just a more innocent culture presumably.

My daughter swears that there's only 2 out if her class of 16 that don't believe! They are sixth class so 11 or 12. I can hardly credit but if she's even half right, it's still a lot of children!

Sartre · 12/12/2022 12:56

Depends on the age. If they’re under eight and sceptical because of something another child has said then I think it’s fine to go to elaborate lengths to ensure they still believe because they’re young and should have that magic in their lives. If they’re older than eight then yeah, it’s natural for them to question and eventually conclude that he isn’t real.

StrawberryWater · 12/12/2022 12:55

DappledThings · 12/12/2022 12:43

Some parents just get themselves into an unnecessary pickle over this.
Tell me about it. FC brings stockings only here. We do the whole leaving out a mince pie for him thing but don't make a massive deal. 6 year old asked this year if it was just us pretending so I confirmed it. Didn't feel like a thing. Just something he worked out and asked about so I answered.

Ds has never been that big on FC so FC doesn’t bring anything here. The only thing FC is responsible for is spreading Yuletide joy. All presents and stockings are from us / relatives.

I’ve never liked the whole naughty / nice thing anyway.

Plus it avoids so many questions about present disparity (making it easier to say that Dave has a new PlayStation because they can afford it and we can’t) and how can Santa travel the globe in 24 hours and how can he eat all of the food put out for him and how can he live in the North Pole etc etc.

Tdcp · 12/12/2022 12:52

My daughter is 8 and got very upset about not believing in Santa, she said "I really want to believe but I just don't think I do". I ended up saying something like "it's okay, as you get older you may feel that you don't believe in Santa anymore but that doesn't mean that Santa won't believe in you". It's entirely up to her if she doesn't believe, I won't be trying to convince her he does but I won't be telling her he doesn't exist either.

Grimed · 12/12/2022 12:50

What annoys me is all the parents who spend the entire of December emotionally bribing their children into doing whatever they say all they will go on the naughty list. It wrong and definitely not inkeeping with the Christmas spirit.

1982mommaof4 · 12/12/2022 12:50

YABU

Yellaboots · 12/12/2022 12:48

TheKeatingFive · 12/12/2022 12:37

Yeah they’re definitely not fine.

You don't seem to have much understanding of children and you're being very nasty with it. Christ knows why, does it make you feel better about something?

I expect that's why people are 'labouring the point'. Very odd to see a grown woman speak of a child she doesn't know in this way

I agree. How nasty.
Obviously this poster has their own issues and unhappiness to deal with but it's not OK to speak about a child like that, or to attempt to upset someone the way she has.

Lollypop701 · 12/12/2022 12:47

I told mine that Santa exists for children that believe, once they stop believing then mums and dads take over the job. Ds still wanted the magic at 11, Dd was around 8. I still wait till they are asleep to put stockings out. Whatever works for your own family

TheWorstWeek · 12/12/2022 12:46

My DC are 6 and 4 and thankfully neither of them are asking questions about whether he's real or not. I get lots of questions about how things with Santa works and I've just been replying "I don't know. Santa magic I suppose". When the day comes that my eldest is asking whether or not he's real I don't think I'll lie to prolong it. And hope he doesn't spoil it for his little brother! Just explain that's it's a kind of surprise to make Christmas feel really special. It'll break my heart when they learn the truth but only because the magic and innocence only really lasts a few short years from when they get the concept of Santa.

DappledThings · 12/12/2022 12:43

Some parents just get themselves into an unnecessary pickle over this.
Tell me about it. FC brings stockings only here. We do the whole leaving out a mince pie for him thing but don't make a massive deal. 6 year old asked this year if it was just us pretending so I confirmed it. Didn't feel like a thing. Just something he worked out and asked about so I answered.

TheKeatingFive · 12/12/2022 12:37

Yeah they’re definitely not fine.

You don't seem to have much understanding of children and you're being very nasty with it. Christ knows why, does it make you feel better about something?

I expect that's why people are 'labouring the point'. Very odd to see a grown woman speak of a child she doesn't know in this way

Babdoc · 12/12/2022 12:35

“Santa Claus” was undeniably real. He was St Nicholas, bishop of Myra, who lived from 270-343AD. The legend developed after his death, based on his gifts of gold dropped through poor people’s windows or down chimneys, to provide dowries for their daughters to get married.
I explained this to my DDs when they were old enough to understand. As Christians, they knew the most important gift at Christmas was Jesus, anyway. Salvation and eternal life, from the loving sacrifice of God, beats the hell out of any plastic tat and tinsel!

FanFckingTastic · 12/12/2022 12:35

It depends what you believe in. I believe in the magic of Christmas - I can feel it, and can see the excitement in my kids and family as Christmas gets closer. I believe in the concept of giving presents and not expecting anything in return, just giving for giving's sake. I don't believe in the coca-cola advert Santa's dressed in red suits, squeezing down someone's chimney and neither do my kids anymore but we all believe in the idea of Christmas.

Farradaymange · 12/12/2022 12:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Stompythedinosaur · 12/12/2022 12:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

I'm sure their dc is absolutely fine.

Adults picking on kids is absolutely not on.

Starlight86 · 12/12/2022 12:23

I think parents should always deny when asked, i also think children will naturally find out themselves whether it be age 7,9 or 11.

What does it matter if they are a little older, its meant to be a magical thing for them and god knows they dont have much of that when they hit adult life.

My mum still says to me "well i believe" and i will use the same on my 3dcs, they arent going to get into adulthood still beliving.

Let them have the magic, its only for a short period in their lives.

Figgypuddingpiggyfudding · 12/12/2022 12:23

I think this is one of those things that parents can over think.

Just parent the child in front of you, trust your instincts.

And as for those parents of young children wondering how to approach the subject of Father Christmas...Good lord. How lucky we are in our lives that this an issue we have head space for.

(I am a believer at age 40 btw 😁)