Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please help me with my misbehaving 4yo

65 replies

pandarific · 12/12/2022 08:33

4yo son lost morning tv privileges last night for being extremely defiant and basically vile. Screaming, shouting, hitting, biting - the works. YES he was tired, but me and DH are pretty sick of it, and I lost my rag with him and shouted quite a lot.

This morning when he woke up he was sorry, said he was going to be a good boy today, agreed to have his listening ears on today, etc etc, said I was the best mummy in the world, only whined a bit about not having tv… all good until the time came to stop playing and go to nursery. five minute warning given, then two. Then when told he had to stop playing and get his clothes on the little shit behaviour started.

he ran off upstairs, started laughing down at us, hiding, refusing to come back down. So dh goes up and gets him, brings him back down, we ask him to put on clothes, I remind him of his agreement to be good today. It doesn’t have any effect. He refuses, starts shouting etc, DH and I forcibly dress him while he wails, then they head to nursery, ten minutes late. FFS.

it’s always when he has to stop doing something he likes and eg go to bed, go to nursery. I’ve already decided from now on as soon as he wakes up I’m getting him dressed immediately, but anything else? So so so sick of the bratty behaviour.

OP posts:
Seeline · 12/12/2022 10:54

You still haven't said what you do when he kicks/bites. I would concentrate on that in the first place.

You need to stay calm, but be firm. Tell him no, that it's not nice to hurt people and give him a chance to calm down. I found the 'naughty' step a good way of dealing with this, although we didn't call it the naughty step. When Ds got so overheated that he resorted to hitting or screaming, I sat him on the bottom stair, got down to his level, explained that it was unacceptable, and told him he needed to sit there until he calmed down. I found the minute-per-year of age worked well. I stayed with him during the time, but didn't interact. At the end we had a nice cuddle, and I encouraged him to apologise. But you have to do this every time.

Also concentrate on praising every bit of good behaviour - whether it be putting on an item of clothing, sitting nicely to eat, picking up a toy, just being happy and smiley etc - comment on it positively.

pandarific · 12/12/2022 10:50

‘When it gets out of hand you need to own the blame as an adult, not put it on them as a child.’
I take your point on not taking bad behaviour personally, modelling good choices and keeping calm, however… I don’t think it’s somehow my fault when my child hits and bites me? How could my parenting possibly be so shit as to cause that? It’s really not! It’s perfectly normal, warm, loving well-boundaried parenting and though we can sure make some changes (below) I don’t think we should take the blame for what he does in a dysregulated rage.

‘It may well be that your child needs some extra support with their behaviour but I honestly believe that the first step is to look to your behaviour, language and attitudes and determine if you are creating the right environment for him to do his best’

I think we can make some changes, but nothing wild tbh.

  • less screen time - and none in the am
  • getting dressed immediately
  • Reward charts / visual ‘it’s time for this now’ charts
  • Us: not shouting, remaining calm, clear expectations
OP posts:
JoyBeorge · 12/12/2022 10:48

pandarific · 12/12/2022 08:57

@Pjsandhotchoc perhaps semantics, but I called the behaviour those things, not the child. I get very upset when my child hits and bites me, particularly as I do so much for him. I don’t deserve it. I would like for him to be better able to regulate his emotions for sure, but unless someone has something I haven’t tried, I’m at a bit of a loss.

You don't deserve it? That's an odd way of viewing it. Almost like he is expected to treat you in a certain way without any negotiation? He's 4. He didn't choose to be conceived and he doesn't owe you anything for the privilege of birthing him. You honestly will struggle to find many 4 year olds who don't play up and push boundaries like this.

avocadotofu · 12/12/2022 10:45

I think the behaviour you're describing sounds like pretty typical 4 year old behaviour except for the biting. I have a 4 year old and it's hard. Their little brains are still developing and they aren't always able to regulate their emotions. I know it's hard to stay calm but doing that will model regulating emotions. We calmly remind ours of what we want, redirect and if he doesn't get dressed we just dress him. There are some really great accounts on instagram that talk about brain development that might help.

pandarific · 12/12/2022 10:39

@sparepantsandtoothbrush definitely. I find that thought terrifying. I try not to think of it but I have been through hell in my upbringing with her and it is very scary to be seeing even the ghost of that behaviour from my child.

he is lovely and clever and has a good heart though, so will probably never happen.

we've not used reward charts but would like to - any recommendations? I think it could be a really good shout.

OP posts:
Remaker · 12/12/2022 10:31

OP as the mum of teenagers I feel the need to warn you that if you’re waiting for children to treat you in the way you think that you deserve and to be well behaved in appreciation of your efforts, you’ll be waiting a very long time and have a lot of disappointments. Parenting is in the large part rising above their behaviour to do the right thing by them, loving them even when they act in an unloving way to you, and most of all keeping your cool when they are losing theirs. None of us do it perfectly all the time, but you need to have the intention and commitment. When it gets out of hand you need to own the blame as an adult, not put it on them as a child.

It may well be that your child needs some extra support with their behaviour but I honestly believe that the first step is to look to your behaviour, language and attitudes and determine if you are creating the right environment for him to do his best.

Cinnabomb · 12/12/2022 10:17

@pandarific i would also say some children are much much harder than others. Obviously I don’t know if it’s the case with yours but I get a bit sick of reading the same advice over and over and it not working. Some kids are just harder. I don’t know why people are reluctant to admit this when giving out advice. Maybe it’s the MN race to the bottom of never acknowledging some people have it worse/ tougher, but it’s stupid to have this idea that “all kids are hard in their own way and they all have phases = all kids equally as hard”.

some children just are more difficult, I have no advice, what I mean by that is sometimes acknowledging that helps. I had a really really difficult newborn and I wanted to scream at people who would say “oh just pop her in the sling”. It’s like FUCK OFF IVE TRIED THE FUCKING SLING.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 12/12/2022 10:17

I get very upset when my child hits and bites me, particularly as I do so much for him

He's 4! He won't care or realise how much you're doing for him at this age

As others have said, consequences for bad behaviour need to be immediate at this age so a TV ban this morning for something that happened yesterday isn't any good.

Have you tried reward charts. I don't know if they're old hat this days but they definitely used to work with mine (they're lovely teens these days but my younger one especially was a nightmare at that age).

I know it's draining but you're the adult and need to manage your expectations of him as a 4 year old. Reading your last post, do you think the worry about him being like your sister could be escalating your reaction to it?

pandarific · 12/12/2022 10:17

Thank you @DinosWillGetYou , I know that’s what works, you’re right. I think I’ve been trying to be stricter as he’s been worse recently, but maybe that’s backfired a bit and resulted in power struggles.

ill have another read of this thread later and design a new morning routine and try to implement that.

anyone got any good sticker / visual charts? I’ve tried googling for them and there is a lot of choice - a bit too much really.

OP posts:
pandarific · 12/12/2022 10:15

Sorry for the self pity just there, I am tired and overwhelmed and SAD. DH just texted me to tell me he had to carry DS halfway to nursery this AM. It has been a few weeks of this now and we are both over it.

OP posts:
Pjsandhotchoc · 12/12/2022 10:14

Again, all about you. I have tried to sympathise OP, but you seem insistent that your child is the problem, despite many posters suggesting the contrary.

You’ve not taken on board any recommendations that your responses to your child’s behaviour could be better managed.

You say you’re not enjoying spending time with your badly behaved child, as if it’s their fault. I bet they’re not overjoyed to be spending their time being shouted at by parents.

You need to fix your own behaviour and then maybe you’ll get the “better behaved child” you so wish for.

pandarific · 12/12/2022 10:08

I don’t expect a magic solution. I would like a better behaved child, because I’m not much enjoying spending time with the one I’ve got right now and I am a bit terrified he won’t grow out of it and will become like the personality disordered sister I am NC with. I have seen bad behaviour escalate, go extremely wrong and break up my family of origin so I am 1000% invested in changing things and nipping this dysregulated hitting/biting/screeching in the bud.

Quite desperate for a break from it all actually and would pay £££ for someone else to just take over for a while, but that’s not happening so guess I’ll just ask for a stronger antidepressant and try to get to sleep earlier.

OP posts:
DinosWillGetYou · 12/12/2022 10:07

pandarific · 12/12/2022 09:37

Loving all the posts saying obviously it’s my fault he’s being a nightmare as obviously I’m modelling a lack of emotional regulation. Yup, that’s me, the bad parent going around wailing and screaming, not modelling good behaviour at all.

@DinosWillGetYou i think it’s probably anxiety too. How is your child now? (Please say great in school, lovely at home…😅) When you say ‘a totally different approach is needed’ what approach do you mean? He needs to be able to manage his emotions better and I don’t really know how to help him do that at the moment.

The practical tips are fantastic, thank you. I am definitely keeping no tv in the mornings. And yes he’s more of a mare when has had too much screen time so yes maybe no more than an hour in the evening.

The anxiety is much better tbh OP, still
blips but I think when I realised it was anxiety, which I certainly didn’t straightaway, and changed how I reacted that was the game changer.
I guess just approach it as calmly as you can (while internal screaming in frustration), reassurance, acknowledging his feelings…..‘I hear you are feeling worried, it’s ok to be anxious’ or whatever you feel appropriate……having a set routine everyday so he knows what to expect and what is expected of him. Quietly and calmly firm when needed. It’s hard keeping a poker face when you’re being hit and bitten I know, it gets easier though!
wish you lots of luck

Michellexxx · 12/12/2022 09:45

Sounds tricky. Try your best not to get wound up- it escalates the situation.
as per other suggestions, have clothes laid out and do everything in same order each day.
You could also get a visible timer- a sand countdown or whatever so that he can visually see how long 2 mins is- kids have no real concept of this.
Also, when issuing consequences around bad behaviour, it’s your boundaries you’re explaining, not his. So say “if you don’t put your shoes on, then I’ll take x away”. Don’t do “put your shoes on or you’re going to time out” Then follow through. You have control of the situation, not him.

So also say, “would you like to put the cars or the blocks away?” Or “put your jacket or shoes on first?”. He’s testing control boundaries. You can give him some with aforementioned questions. It might not always work, but stick to it. And walk away if you need to.

Pjsandhotchoc · 12/12/2022 09:44

I had a feeling you were going to take our responses the wrong way, @pandarific .

No one said you’re a bad parent going around wailing and screaming. But, you said yourself in your first post that you shouted quite a lot and had to forcibly dress him while he wailed. It doesn’t sound like fun for either of you. He isn’t enjoying behaving this way.

The main conclusion from the replies is not that you’re a bad parent, at all. Just that if you are able to respond to your child’s behaviour in a calmer way, it will undoubtedly help.

The problem is that there is no quick fix. I don’t know if you were expecting a magic solution and the suggestion that you may need to alter your own behaviour has hurt your feelings. But it honestly is true, and that’s not a personal attack.

pandarific · 12/12/2022 09:43

I am happy to change my behaviour, but I am asking for help because my 4yo has been incredibly badly behaved recently and I approaching the end of my tether with dealing with constant battles/wailing/defiance. I am fine handling a normal/regular level of misbehaviour, but this is more extended and extreme than that.

OP posts:
pandarific · 12/12/2022 09:37

Loving all the posts saying obviously it’s my fault he’s being a nightmare as obviously I’m modelling a lack of emotional regulation. Yup, that’s me, the bad parent going around wailing and screaming, not modelling good behaviour at all.

@DinosWillGetYou i think it’s probably anxiety too. How is your child now? (Please say great in school, lovely at home…😅) When you say ‘a totally different approach is needed’ what approach do you mean? He needs to be able to manage his emotions better and I don’t really know how to help him do that at the moment.

The practical tips are fantastic, thank you. I am definitely keeping no tv in the mornings. And yes he’s more of a mare when has had too much screen time so yes maybe no more than an hour in the evening.

OP posts:
Pjsandhotchoc · 12/12/2022 09:28

@Treesuphooray “ your DC isn’t a brat. They need you to change your behaviour so they can manage theirs “

This, OP, is the crux of it.

Mariposista · 12/12/2022 09:28

No tv, no toys no nothing until he is up, washed, dressed, eaten breakfast, teeth and shoes on. Then if there is any time left over he can use it to do something (chances are there won’t be time).

Doveyouknow · 12/12/2022 09:25

We have a very strict morning routine as my ds really struggled with getting ready in the morning when he was younger. Dressed / breakfast / coats and shoes on. Then the TV goes on and we turn it off and leave at the same point each day. I build in a bit of extra time for faffing which means I am not getting stressed about being late (because that makes thing worse).

Treesuphooray · 12/12/2022 09:24

At his age he will have little sense of time and even less impulse control.

getting into a battle about you promised to be good and you aren’t being is pointless.

1-have a clear structure to the day so he learns what to expect next.
2- when things are not going well; stop! Think about what you need to happen (what’s the most important task? Go to that don’t dwell on stuff you can leave) and how to make that happen. Losing your cool and shouting probably is going to make it worse so try not to. Walk away for a few minutes instead.
3- prep ahead. Get clothes, bags etc ready the night before so you have the minimum to do at any one time. That will lessen how overwhelmed you feel.
4- we do not negotiate with terrorists! Be clear about what you expect. Do not get in to ‘if you do x I’ll give you y’ (DP I’m looking at you!). Doing x is not negotiable.
5- bribery and distraction are useful. Oh look DS let’s read your favourite book (dress him whilst reading).

my now 4 year old can be tricky but she generally behaves way better for me than her dad. Dad has zero structure, tries to negotiate, gives into screams and gets in a tizz as he doesn’t plan.
with me DD knows she will get ‘screams get nothing’ and that doing the routine often results in play time/treats.

im not perfect. I went through a horrible period of being totally overwealmed when her brother was born and ended up screaming at poor DD more than once . I had to look really hard at what I was doing and change my approach to change hers.

your DC isn’t a brat. They need you to change your behaviour so they can manage theirs x

Merrow · 12/12/2022 09:17

We have a very rigid morning routine that he knows if he gets through quickly he gets extra time for play when it's done. Breakfast, toilet, teeth, dressed. If he's on the ball that means he gets a good chunk of play before the alarm goes off for nursery (I found having an actual alarm rather than me just telling him worked better), if he doesn't then I don't get stressed about being late and stay calm as there's a lot of time built in for him to argue every single step. It's when I try to rush him it all goes wrong, because he does pick up on my stress and slows right down, so getting up early and leaving a ridiculous amount of time for basic tasks works better for all of us.

And I agree that punishments that happen the next day don't really work.

DinosWillGetYou · 12/12/2022 09:15

OP, you know your child best, but as a parent who has an older child that behaved like this at that age, in hindsight his behaviour was trying to tell me something, that he wasn’t ok, and this was the only way he was able to do it. There’s always a reason for behaviour, it’s very rare children are absolutely naughty and awful for no reason at all.
From what you’ve put and that it’s around going to nursery and transitioning from one place/activity to another, I’d make a bet it’s anxiety.
Hurting you is never acceptable but if it is anxiety a completely different approach is needed. Getting cross and not acknowledging or reassuring his feelings is going to make it a million times worse and it becomes a vicious circle.

Seeline · 12/12/2022 09:11

How do you respond when he hits and bites? That would be the behaviour I would concentrate on. The rest seems pretty normal, and sounds as though he is treating it as a bit of a game, rather than being naughty.

Biting/hitting needs an instant response, not a punishment the next day (that rarely works for a child that young - they can't see the connection between the punishment and the crime over such a long period).

upfucked · 12/12/2022 09:10

Does he normally have TV before nursery? I would stop that.
You need to get the basics right, healthy food, exercise (at this age they need at least 3 a day), enough sleep and not too much TV for us that’s 30 mins a day. Routines need to be consistent and obvious - make him a visual time table.

The book how to talk so little children listen is really useful.

Swipe left for the next trending thread