Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say “no” and mean it

66 replies

Flutterbybudget · 12/12/2022 07:28

Quick backstory, my ex DH is a scout leader. My DD (14) is a scout. She is in his troop. Their is a court order in place, specifying that she goes to scouts on Tuesdays with him. However, she has started doing the gold scouts badge, which involves lots of hiking and other activities. Many of these fall on weekends that she is with me. She enjoys them, and I’ve never tried to interfere or prevent her participating. However, he says that it’s my responsibility to cover the costs which I’ve always done. And to get her to where she needs to be - again, which I’ve always done, even when it’s a couple of hours away.
I have tried saying no before, but he guilt trips me with “if you don’t, she can’t go” and I always give in, because I don’t want her to miss out
This time, there are two events coming up. One in Jan, one in Feb. I haven’t had a holiday in 3 years, and have only had one week off work in a year. I work three jobs currently (all low paid, including day times, evenings and weekends) whereas he has a high paid office job (ie 9-5 mostly WFH) Ive booked to go away for a break, due to my main job closing down for a couple of weeks, giving me the opportunity to book a couple of days off my other 2 part time jobs to get a proper break. I’ve arranged for my dog to stay with a friend, a couple of hours drive away (somewhere where she will be happy and safe).
These two events for my daughter. happen to be on the only days that I can drop off and collect my dog, as I will need to be working at both ends of my holiday. My friend is unwell, and unable to drive, or he’d bring her back for me.
The plan had been that my DD would come with me to take and pick up the dog, so I wouldn’t have been leaving her on her own, but I’m unable to accommodate doing both the dog and getting her to her activity.
So AIBU to say that if he can’t take her, then she won’t be able to go?

OP posts:
TrixJax · 12/12/2022 09:38

As far as I am aware, there is no reason why he “can’t “ he just refuses to help out with childcare/ accommodating any requests for help in “my time” with her - that’s my problem to work out.*

Well there you go it's "your" days. He doesn't get to dictate what happens on your days, just as you don't on his.
Just do what you would do if this was another activity she went to, not with Dad, so say volleyball and this was a weekend camp. She either couldn't go or you would ask another parent for a lift.
Your days, your call.

And as mum of teenager DDs I agree with PP, sometimes they can't go to everything as there is something else important for another family member, and that's a good life lesson to learn.

superdupernova · 12/12/2022 09:35

Be honest with your daughter. Say you can't get her there because of your plans and that you asked her Dad but he won't help. Don't try to cover up how useless he is.

RethinkingLife · 12/12/2022 09:33

I can ask other parents, (or even my brother or other relative, who would help out if necessary - but live further away) but as far as I’m concerned, my DD isn’t THEIR responsibility - she’s mine - and officially my exDHs.

OP, you badly need your holiday. Approach these people now to help you. I'm sorry but it's plain that your xDH is indifferent to your needs and has no intention of behaving decently. He will not change.

Please have your holiday.

AbreathofFrenchair · 12/12/2022 09:11

KnickerlessParsons · 12/12/2022 08:33

Can she get a lift with a Scout friend? Or, given she's doing the gold badge, can she get a bus/train/taxi combination by herself?

Probably not. Scout campsites are not often near public transport routes and camp often starts at 630pm on a Friday night till 2pm on a Sunday.

Our nearest Scout campsite for example is in the middle of moorland and to take public transport would be around a 15 hour journey or a 35 minute car journey.

AbreathofFrenchair · 12/12/2022 09:07

Flutterbybudget · 12/12/2022 07:28

Quick backstory, my ex DH is a scout leader. My DD (14) is a scout. She is in his troop. Their is a court order in place, specifying that she goes to scouts on Tuesdays with him. However, she has started doing the gold scouts badge, which involves lots of hiking and other activities. Many of these fall on weekends that she is with me. She enjoys them, and I’ve never tried to interfere or prevent her participating. However, he says that it’s my responsibility to cover the costs which I’ve always done. And to get her to where she needs to be - again, which I’ve always done, even when it’s a couple of hours away.
I have tried saying no before, but he guilt trips me with “if you don’t, she can’t go” and I always give in, because I don’t want her to miss out
This time, there are two events coming up. One in Jan, one in Feb. I haven’t had a holiday in 3 years, and have only had one week off work in a year. I work three jobs currently (all low paid, including day times, evenings and weekends) whereas he has a high paid office job (ie 9-5 mostly WFH) Ive booked to go away for a break, due to my main job closing down for a couple of weeks, giving me the opportunity to book a couple of days off my other 2 part time jobs to get a proper break. I’ve arranged for my dog to stay with a friend, a couple of hours drive away (somewhere where she will be happy and safe).
These two events for my daughter. happen to be on the only days that I can drop off and collect my dog, as I will need to be working at both ends of my holiday. My friend is unwell, and unable to drive, or he’d bring her back for me.
The plan had been that my DD would come with me to take and pick up the dog, so I wouldn’t have been leaving her on her own, but I’m unable to accommodate doing both the dog and getting her to her activity.
So AIBU to say that if he can’t take her, then she won’t be able to go?

What has she got left to complete to get the gold? She can still work towards it in her first term at Explorers too.

And where is your daughter going while you are away?

I cant quite make sense of your post, sorry, so cant offer any useful advice but I'm reading it as follows

Dad wont take her to the weekends away in Jan and Feb. You are going away and need to take your dog and collect your dog. Those days your daughter needs dropping and collecting but you cant do both in one day so she can't go but you cant leave daughter to collect dog so she has to go with you?

Options are

Ask Dad been as he is going to these events, I cant understand why he wouldn't

You take dog and daughter on same day and collect? How far apart are they that it can't be done?

Tell your daughter she can't go because of having to drop and collect the dog and that her Dad won't help

Ask another Scout parent to drop and collect. We are a scouting family and do thos all the time with our child and other scouts (Explorers now though)

lifeinthehills · 12/12/2022 09:04

You matter too.You can say no and it's good for DD to realise she has to think of others sometimes. If you can't afford it or just need a weekend off, sometimes you can say no. If it means enough to her father, he can facilitate it.

Hankunamatata · 12/12/2022 09:04

For sanity I'd take ex out of the equation. Just treat him like any other scout leader. Does troop have online communication for parents? Id put a message out asking if anyone could give dc a lift. Asking for help from other parents isn't a weakness and.you can reciprocate further down the line.

Bournetilly · 12/12/2022 08:54

YANBU but what will happen if she can’t get there? Will you still be able to go away?

AngelinaFibres · 12/12/2022 08:35

I was you years ago. The first thing I would say is that this all seems huge now but it will all pass. You only have 4 years until your daughter is an adult. I know it probably feels like an absolute lifetime but it will come and then your contact with her father will be through her ,if at all. I found that the very best way , from a mental health point of view , was to remove his control from everything I possibly could. I had a solid and brilliant group of friends who helped me enormously. They knew how my exhusband was behaving and we swapped babysitting, lifts, holiday cover. I always said yes to things they needed and they were always there for me. Can you develop a support network so you are not always driving everywhere. I would certainly revisit court stuff. Things change and legal stuff needs to be up to date. It will pass. Your daughter will look back and realise how much you did. My sons are now married and having children of their own. We are very close . She won't forget what you have done. Hug to you.

KnickerlessParsons · 12/12/2022 08:33

Can she get a lift with a Scout friend? Or, given she's doing the gold badge, can she get a bus/train/taxi combination by herself?

PurpleNebula84 · 12/12/2022 08:32

Flutterbybudget · 12/12/2022 07:50

He pays the minimum child maintenance he could, based on the temporary pay cut he took during the divorce proceedings. He’s now changed his job but not what he contributes. Tbh, I’m not sure what that has to do with this question though, other than to show that he does the bare minimum that he has to to comply with the law/ court order.

Erm - go to CMS and request a variation.

I honestly don't see why you are doing the picking up and dropping off for an activity he has demanded - he is going anyway, so why isn't he doing the ferrying about? No offence, but I think he's taken you for a mug for all these years xx

liarliarshortsonfire · 12/12/2022 08:32

Just say no, it won't hurt her, infact it might even help, and make her realise that sometimes we don't always get what we want, and the bank of mum for time and money isn't always open. I used to cover for my exdh, but now simply say I can't or don't have the time/money. My dd is fine with this, actually it highlighted what a knob df was at times. She realised that sometimes I simply couldn't, but her df chose not to help.

If he starts to guilt trip you, just block him or have a few choice sentences in the bag: 'I'm sure she will get over it' 'it's not the end of the work' 'if you're so concerned you could take her'

America12 · 12/12/2022 08:31

The thing is , if you don't get her there won't you have to cancel your holiday?
You won't be able to leave her on her own.
Can she appeal to her Dad ? (Shouldn't have to I know)
Agree he is an arsehole.

PaterPower · 12/12/2022 08:25

She’s 14. If you refused to cooperate, and it went back to court (assuming he could be arsed to do that / spend the money on it), they’ll just ask your DD what she wants.

Even if they awarded him the same contact pattern, you could ask them to stipulate he picks up etc and they’d almost certainly add that in.

I’m another that thinks you should go down the CMS route. I can’t see his new partner being happy for him to cut his nose off by earning less.

MRex · 12/12/2022 08:22

Flutterbybudget · 12/12/2022 08:10

Yes, I can ask other parents, (or even my brother or other relative, who would help out if necessary - but live further away) but as far as I’m concerned, my DD isn’t THEIR responsibility - she’s mine - and officially my exDHs.

This is just a normal life event though. She wants to do something and you can't drop off. You aren't asking someone to adopt her, just to give two lifts. You know he's useless, moaning here won't change that. So just make other arrangements instead of sobbing about it.

SpinMeRightRoundBabyRightRound · 12/12/2022 08:19

I used to be a scout leader, it was absolutely normal for kids to all share lifts to and from expeditions so get her to text her friends to and if you want, offer to do it next time to even it up since your ex is a waste of space.

TimeForTeaAndG · 12/12/2022 08:18

Also, why are you not taking holiday time? You don't have to be going away anywhere to take a couple of days off, and you're entitled to holiday pay even if you're on a zero hour contract (you don't say what kind of employment you have, unless I missed that).

Flutterbybudget · 12/12/2022 08:16

2pinkginsplease · 12/12/2022 08:13

So the court order states she goes to scouts with her dad but you have to do the running about and fund everything?

surely if he wants her to go then that’s his duty to do the running about and the paying?

id just say no.

That’s my argument, but she loves going, and it’s been either “I” pay and do the running, or she can’t do it.
I know I need to put my foot down, but he makes it seem like it’s my fault
ffs, I’m crying again now

OP posts:
TimeForTeaAndG · 12/12/2022 08:16

Flutterbybudget · 12/12/2022 08:10

Yes, I can ask other parents, (or even my brother or other relative, who would help out if necessary - but live further away) but as far as I’m concerned, my DD isn’t THEIR responsibility - she’s mine - and officially my exDHs.

Ignoring the fact your ex-H is clearly an arsehole. Plenty of parents lift share or ask for favours, it's not a bad thing. Yes, our children are our responsibility but it's ok to ask for help now and again. It takes a village etc.

Flutterbybudget · 12/12/2022 08:15

UnsolicitedOpinions · 12/12/2022 08:08

I mean, he sounds like an absolute arsehole. It’s so important she goes to scouts with him that he gets a court order about it, but he won’t take her or pay for it??

The only thing that I think YABU about is the fact that you’ve put up with this for all this time but the only time you’re being firm and saying no is when it’s because of your dog!

The court order works when he wants it to - the days he asked for (and were given) are the days that I wasn’t working late at the time, I had to change my job to accommodate them, or I would have not had any time with my DD (she was 8 at the time). He refused point blank to make his days the ones that worked around my job, and the court said that he couldn’t be forced top have her if he didn’t want to. 😞
Ie he takes no responsibility when she’s not with him, but is equally likely to change it when it suits, such as if he decides that he’s going away, or his partner has a headache, or my DD is unwell or they have better plans - in which case I’m expected to drop everything to work things out. It’s one of the things that is really getting me down, and why I need this break so badly.

OP posts:
Morechocmorechoc · 12/12/2022 08:14

I'm sorry but why are you working 3 jobs but won't bother to get him to pay his share. He won't lose a decent job to avoid CMS. Just get it done along with stop being bullied on the scout stuff. You're doing this to yourself by letting him manipulate you and extort you

2pinkginsplease · 12/12/2022 08:13

So the court order states she goes to scouts with her dad but you have to do the running about and fund everything?

surely if he wants her to go then that’s his duty to do the running about and the paying?

id just say no.

piedbeauty · 12/12/2022 08:11

Sometimes kids just have to miss out on things. You sound like a great mum. Your ex, however, sounds like a right twat. And he's a scout leader?! Wonderful.

You carry on with your plans. You should come first for once.

What happens if dd wants to give up scouts? If she's 14, her wishes will be taken into consideration.

panko · 12/12/2022 08:10

Yeah say sorry you have plans ask your dad?

Flutterbybudget · 12/12/2022 08:10

Sparkletastic · 12/12/2022 08:05

She's old enough to take responsibility for asking other scout friends if their parents can give her a lift. She can tell them that her dad will cover the petrol contributions too.

Yes, I can ask other parents, (or even my brother or other relative, who would help out if necessary - but live further away) but as far as I’m concerned, my DD isn’t THEIR responsibility - she’s mine - and officially my exDHs.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread