Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want to let teens have google/YouTube on phone?

39 replies

Bbgy · 11/12/2022 21:03

I feel I am being overly harsh as their friends all have this. How do people allow this safely though? Eldest just turned 13 so I am just beginning this journey. I worry about them being able to look up anything at all and also the addictive nature of the internet access

they do have phones and can message friends, take photos etc but that’s all they have access to at the moment

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Heliumburgers · 12/12/2022 12:08

Look together at studied that show the affects screens have on the brain. Including addiction. Maybe you could role model and decide you want a phone like theirs too.5
That you have health concerns, so they are limited to getting out the laptop or something when they search and have a maximum amount of time.
They are still children, you need to do what you think is best for them, not to match what their mates are up too.

MatildaTravers · 12/12/2022 12:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Farradaymange · 12/12/2022 11:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

MissVantaBlack · 12/12/2022 10:44

@badgermushrooms Katharine Birbalsingh is indeed a headteacher, but she also happens to be Chair of the Social Mobility Commission (my phone changed social mobility to social media)

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/12/2022 09:38

Yes I am aware they can access it elsewhere but part of my issue if the constant desire to be watching stuff and looking stuff up instead of relaxing/reading doing homework etc

My Dd does her homework with her phone. For research and Show my Himework app from school.

She is permanently attached to her phone in one hand and a novel in the other.

Her relaxation is YouTube gamers.

She’s 16. She even managed to get all her GCSE whilst having Google/YouTube.

ChristmasCatsAndKids · 12/12/2022 09:38

Sartre · 12/12/2022 09:03

You’re being controlling. YouTube is the thing now for children, in the same way we watched crap on cbbc or whatever. Your DC is a teenager so should definitely be watching YouTube just as all of their friends will have been for many years.

wtf??

A parent being concerned with online safety is deemed as controlling?

ive heard it all now.

Either your kids are younger than teens or they are simply getting away with it and you haven't a clue.

ChristmasCatsAndKids · 12/12/2022 09:36

OP I can guarantee that the majority of those who have said YABU have never had a 13 year old and probably still in toddlerhood.

YANBU. I can't trust my nearly-teen with YouTube or Google.
I have tried, he has failed.

My eldest was the same. He couldn't be trusted until he was 14..... and even then 🙄

Hankunamatata · 12/12/2022 09:17

www.internetmatters.org/hub/guidance/youtube-tips-and-tricks-to-keep-your-children-entertained-and-safe/

Mine have iphones. You can set them so when they use search engines on their phones inappropriate content doesn't come up.

Bbgy · 12/12/2022 09:06

Thanks I appreciate your responses even the ones disagreeing with me. I just wanted to gauge what is normal here and I am looking for advice. I am not saying my way is the right way, that’s why I asked.

they do have YouTube on their iPads which I limit to about an hour a day.

OP posts:
Sartre · 12/12/2022 09:03

You’re being controlling. YouTube is the thing now for children, in the same way we watched crap on cbbc or whatever. Your DC is a teenager so should definitely be watching YouTube just as all of their friends will have been for many years.

badgermushrooms · 12/12/2022 08:53

@MissVantaBlack Katherine Birbalsingh isn't a "social media chief", she's a random headteacher whose fringe views on various issues get her in the papers a lot.

OP. Looking stuff up on google, I.e. reseaching things you're interested in, is a form of reading. You need to put parental controls on their access, not to ban them from learning anything that doesn't come from school. You're on the brink of creating those weird kids we all went to school with who weren't allowed to watch telly or choose their own library books and all went off the rails when they turned 18.

devuskums · 12/12/2022 08:53

Kate Winslet was talking about children and Internet safety a few days ago. She thinks that in years to come, our children will ask us why we didn't protect them more from harmful online content when they were children.

CrownTheTurkey · 12/12/2022 08:40

Pathetic. They're looking at YouTube not Debbie does Dallas.
Although they might watch DDD on their mates phone/iPad etc.
Stop being so controlling.
The more you try to ban something, the more they'll seek it out.

Bbgy · 12/12/2022 08:33

Yes I fell for that one already I have them Snapchat as apparently everyone else had it. Then immediately regretted it after I realised it is more than just a messaging app

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 12/12/2022 08:28

All their friends say that they have access, does not mean that they do. All their friends tell their parents that their friends (the children) have access.

Don't fall for that trick and do what you think is right. It's not only about protection, it should be about them having a life away from a screen.

TheGuv1982 · 12/12/2022 07:49

There’s lots of ways you can try to moderate the content that your children have access to, but I’ve found it needs trust in the child to have some degree of responsibility-

for example, I let my 8 year old browse YouTube because he loves certain YouTubers and I can softly monitor his history remotely. He knows to turn off vids with bad language, and I know that he does. He knows what bad language is because I take him to football and there’s no getting away from it.

It’s not without risk though, he loves history and I do worry he might end up watching something graphic, which is my big concern.

Bbgy · 12/12/2022 07:31

Thanks I will look those up round123. Yes missvantablack these are my concerns, I know some people say at some point you just have to trust your children but it is important to try and protect them too for as long as possible.

most parents I know are much more relaxed than me. But one friend of mine has two young adult children as well as two younger teen children and through her experiences with her older two she has been much stricter with the younger two and her children don’t get phones til 16! This is obviously quite an extreme position to take but she was a lot more relaxed with her older children and says she has learned from experience.

they Do have access to google on our computer at home which is in the family lounge. So it’s not like I have banned it completely. I was just wondering yesterday whether maybe i do need to give it on phones too but how to do it safely.

my eldest used to read a lot of books but seems to have stopped this since getting a phone as it’s so much easier to just flick through a phone, even with restricted access there is still quite a lot to play with.

OP posts:
Round123 · 12/12/2022 00:12

Child net and this contract is great www.childnet.com/blog/family-agreement/
Look up ceop too and go through issues together:)

MissVantaBlack · 11/12/2022 23:35

OP, I think you're quite right to try to restrict your DC's internet access, and social media chief Katharine Birbalsingh would agree with you, as would Children's Commissioner Dame Rachel de Souza. Like @Pondlifer , we have Family Link on out teens' phones, and that works well. We also talk to them about safer internet use, social media behaviour etc - you can restrict access and teach them about safe use, it's not a binary situation!

Somebody commented that if they have chromebooks etc at school, they can use Google etc. However, schools usually have heavily filtered internet access so they are unlikely to access anything untoward on the school's chromebook!

Certainly, the time will come when you'll have to allow unfettered access. But the longer you can delay that, the better. Access to beheading videos, violent pornography etc changes the developing teenage brain irreversibly, so try to limit their access as much as possible until they are more mature.

greenbirdsong · 11/12/2022 23:31

I worry about this for the future and my DS is only 5!
I think it's finding the balance of teaching them responsible safe use and having some restrictions/rules you can all agree on.

racingcar · 11/12/2022 23:29

There's a huge amount of slang that can help. If your child's phone has anything like MOS, POS, PAW, KPC or other acronyms like that, your child probably has two phones.

thelobsterquadrille · 11/12/2022 23:28

Bbgy · 11/12/2022 22:34

Yes I am aware they can access it elsewhere but part of my issue if the constant desire to be watching stuff and looking stuff up instead of relaxing/reading doing homework etc. I feel the constant nature of it is overwhelming. Maybe I am wrong I am just trying to figure it all out

So put limits on their screen time instead of banning Google!

racingcar · 11/12/2022 23:25

When I was teaching, most students had two phones - one for their parents to check and one for themselves for all the things they didn't want their parents to see. Parents had no idea. Virtually the only ones who only had one phone were the ones whose parents didn't ever check their phones. Either way, they were accessing and doing the same things. You're much better off teaching your kids about online safety, what to access and what not to access and when and why.

Easterdaffsx · 11/12/2022 23:21

Hi OP
My dd 4 is 12 amd I am absolutely strict amd limit or don't allow most things on her phone
Many will think this is harsh I know but I'm comfortable with this
Took me awhile to figure it out but any app she goes on either myself or her big sister have to approve on our phones from where ever we are at the time ( it only takes a couple of secs and can even do it on my Apple Watch)
No YouTube ..... during lockdown when I took my eye off the ball through working 12 hours a day and a 4 hour commute to see my children she developed an American accent and mimicked behaviour only seen on YouTube
No what's app
No social media
No snap chat
Screen time for gaming is limited to an agreed time
Downtime apart from specific contacts (family ) overnight
It was a hard decision amd especially to begin with

She had a friend over recently amd asked if I could approve a couple of social media sites .... her friend heard me decline amd said it's okay I'm not allowed them either .
They tell you everyone else has it but they really don't . Most do I appreciate but not all.
I am happy with my decision amd both my older dc ( now adults ) tell me they are really glad I did the same with them on reflection .
The benefits out weigh the negatives in my experience

It's a challenging one good luck !

ImprobablePuffin · 11/12/2022 22:58

I think banning Google is a bit silly.

Will you ban all the other search engines they will use instead?