Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I complain to the governors?

61 replies

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 18:01

DC has a history of anxiety. Severe episode 2 weeks ago which resulted in A&E trip and CAmhs referral within 24 hours. DH went to school to pick up DC for therapist appt which for which we'd pre-notified school. School were unable to locate DC. They'd been marked medically absent from a previous lesson and hadnt turned up to the following lesson. We had a torrid 40 minutes whilst they looked for them. They were found sitting in a corridor with a member of staff (thankfully) having had a panic attack.

Is it unreasonable to think this is a major safeguarding fail? Surely if a kid goes out of a class on medical grounds they should be checked on/notified to pastoral care at the very least.

We'd already been in discussions with safeguarding as they truanted from the last lesson of the day recently and it was not flagged up to anyone; I had to tell the school that DC had truanted and wanted to know why school hadn't contacted me.

Would it be unreasonable to involve the governors at this point?

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 11/12/2022 19:43

I agree with others regarding saying you are concerned for your DC's safety and please could a plan be put in place whereby at minimum there is an immediate flag if they don't turn up to a lesson, or if you really feel it is warranted supervised at all times (what would happen at lunch time?).

However if a child is at serious risk of self harm that they have to be accompanied everywhere I'd wonder whether school was the best place for them.

MichelleScarn · 11/12/2022 19:40

How does a teacher stop a child leaving the class when they want to?

racingcar · 11/12/2022 19:39

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:21

@Gagaandgag there wasn't a handover - the other staff member just found them in the corridor. First teacher wasn't aware they were still there. It just strikes me as an odd way to deal with things. If it was a work colleague this wouldn't happen (not on my watch anyway); if someone left a meeting I was running on medical grounds I'd follow up with them to make sure they were ok.

By the way I am grateful for all the responses - even the rude ones :)

Kindly, I don't believe this for a second. If you were at work, giving a presentation, and a colleague stepped outside having a panic attack, then you would stop your presentation and check on them even though you knew other members of staff would be in contact and were tasked with handling that exact scenario? Leaving all your other colleagues sat on their own with nothing to do and no support? And that doesn't even take into consideration that your colleagues are (presumably) adults who can be left alone in a room without you. Would you really be ok with a teacher just walking out of the classroom and leaving an entire class (minus one pupil) on their own? What if your child were one of the ones left behind - I assume you'd be wanting to complain to the governors...

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:32

@neverbeenskiing DC hasn't got an EHCP and I doubt the school would be able to support this level of safety plan without one. I think asking for DC to be flagged up to on call is probably the most constructive way forward. Again thank you for replying. Getting an understanding of possible procedures has been really helpful.

OP posts:
camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:26

@NeverDropYourMooncup thanks that's interesting to note re the safety plan. I can see how that can be problematic for both the child and the school but as you say it keeps them safe.

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 11/12/2022 19:26

So your DC was using an 'exit pass' but actually needs a Safety Plan. Talk to the sendco and dsl about getting one set up. That will mean that dc isn't allowed to leave class on their own for any reason, but has to be escorted everywhere if they need to move during lesson times and SLT are notified if they aren't in a lesson from the start.

We don't know that they have this protocol in OP's sons school though. I work in a secondary school and we do not have the staff available to escort students around the school site, unless they have a 1:1 TA funded by an EHCP. Vulnerable students are flagged up to "on call" by the Teacher if they leave a lesson or don't turn up to a lesson and someone will look for them, which seems to be what happened in OP's case.

DriftwoodOnTheShore · 11/12/2022 19:23

It's difficult for you, I can see that.

But the teacher's job is to teach the class. You expect him/her to interrupt a lesson to notify someone about your child. That just isn't practical.

Your child needs a better plan for if he/she needs to leave the classroom. Somewhere else to go. But the teacher has to teach the others. That's their job.

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:21

@Gagaandgag there wasn't a handover - the other staff member just found them in the corridor. First teacher wasn't aware they were still there. It just strikes me as an odd way to deal with things. If it was a work colleague this wouldn't happen (not on my watch anyway); if someone left a meeting I was running on medical grounds I'd follow up with them to make sure they were ok.

By the way I am grateful for all the responses - even the rude ones :)

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/12/2022 19:16

For ours, they have a note added to sims that they have a safety plan and any absence must be notified to SLT on call/do not allow to leave class unsupervised.

The child is able to present themselves at medical on lesson changeover as it's always staffed and then has to stay there for the rest of the lesson until collected by a member of SLT or returned to class. This means that they often see other unwell or injured kids. But they're under supervision, so they're safe.

It's unrealistic to expect that there is always somebody waiting in a quiet space to fit one child that isn't the usually very busy medical room. If nothing else, because there could be 20 kids in similar circumstances.

Gagaandgag · 11/12/2022 19:13

When she had the panic attack in class did the teacher pass them over into the care of another staff member or did they just leave and the other staff member stumbled across them

realmsofglory · 11/12/2022 19:12

This sort of thread is a real eye opener to me. What happened to teachers you know just teaching the kids , are they really expected to issue an alert every time a teenager leaves the room to get a breath of fresh air or something? Ridiculous!

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:10

@treesandweeds that empathy bypass worked out well for you?

OP posts:
camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:07

@peppaminttea I'm so sorry you're also experiencing this. Bloody nerve-wracking isn't it. Thanks for your very helpful suggested questions. I will definitely use these.

Would you be able to share what the protocol looks like for your child? (feel free to DM me if easier). I don't want DC to get any more stressed about school than they already are.

OP posts:
treesandweeds · 11/12/2022 19:06

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 18:41

@declutteringmymind not sure why you are saying "she"? Anyway DC has "wandered off site" as previously mentioned and also the Camhs assessment did uncover previous self-harm so maybe that's why I'm more than a little concerned?

Thanks for the phrasing around "glad someone was with them etc" because that is a helpful one to use.

I will go back to the safeguarding lead again (we had a meeting at the beginning of last week).

I get the point about building a relationship with the school so was definitely in two minds about approaching the governors as aware it might be counter-productive.

Why are you saying"they" ? You sound a bit OTT with everything.

MichelleScarn · 11/12/2022 19:01

From username obvs!

MichelleScarn · 11/12/2022 18:59

@Stickstickstickstickstick thanks for the ear worm! 😆

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 18:59

Thanks to everyone who has commented with evident knowledge about the workings of secondary schools. It certainly helps put my concerns in context. I guess asking school to flag it up a bit more keenly if DC leaves mid-class for any reason is the way forward. DC isn't considered an immediate danger to themselves by camhs but they've been very good at masking so far so I do wonder how accurate that assessment is.

OP posts:
Stickstickstickstickstick · 11/12/2022 18:57

If I’m taking the register and it says that the child has a medical appointment and they’re not in the room then I’m obviously going to assume that they’ve gone to it. If I found a child having a panic attack in the corridor I would stay with them and help. There’s no failure of process. If your child doesn’t have a specific risk assessment then you can’t expect someone to walk them down to reception. If you want a risk assessment then you need to speak to the DSL.

peppaminttea · 11/12/2022 18:53

If school are aware that there may be a safeguarding risk by your child going missing and they are ignoring this then a complaint would be valid. However it may be more constructive first to speak to the SENCO or Head of Pastoral to raise the issues and to see if they will put a plan in place.

I have a child who has been known to go missing in school for anxiety reasons and there very much seems to be a protocol in place for when this happens. (We are fortunate that this happen without having to ask). The protocol has been tweaked as initially it was causing my child more anxiety. It isn't perfect currently but it is a happy medium that keeps my child safe and the school side of things happy.

Some questions you could ask are: What is their protocol if this happens? How should a member of staff alert someone if your child goes missing/who should they alert. Is there a safe space that your child can go to if they are too anxious to be in class? (Don't accept a medical room or somewhere similar that there may be lots of other people, because I am guessing that won't work for your child- hopefully your child may be able to suggest somewhere).

It is really tough and there are no magic answers but you may get further if you try to work with the school rather than complain. Schools become very defensive if complaints are made and if you get to this point it may be in your childs best interests to find an alterative placement. Also, if your chold is too anxious to go to school, don't be afraid to listen to them and be guided by that.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/12/2022 18:52

So your DC was using an 'exit pass' but actually needs a Safety Plan.

Talk to the sendco and dsl about getting one set up. That will mean that dc isn't allowed to leave class on their own for any reason, but has to be escorted everywhere if they need to move during lesson times and SLT are notified if they aren't in a lesson from the start.

The SG link governor won't mind being asked if there is an established safety plan protocol and if not, could one be arranged for the children who are at particular risk/must be watched at all times.

2bazookas · 11/12/2022 18:50

He was with a member of staff who was looking after him during a panic attack.

I can't see why you think they failed to safeguard him.

racingcar · 11/12/2022 18:50

User135792468 · 11/12/2022 18:40

It’s not a failure of process at all. They are teenagers and they are trusted to be responsible and take themselves off to where they need to be. Your child can join the army in 2 years, drive in 3 and get married in 4. Teenagers don’t need to be followed across the school or have a member of staff escort them. If a child didn’t come back from the toilet, I’m sure the teacher would email the office or send another pupil to check up on them. Many times in medical, they sit them down and allow them to stay for a while so it’s not unreasonable to think that they’re still there 40 mins later?

Did you meet with the school after the visit to a&e and tell them your child is a danger to themselves and that they are not to be allowed to leave the classroom on their own? If you did and your dc was allowed to leave then I can understand you speaking to the school. Even then, I wouldn’t word it as a complaint.

If you start throwing your weight around and shouting about complaining to governors, they will think you’re a complete knob (no offence intended) and it’s in your interest to work with them for the sake of your dc.

I agree with a lot of this but a teacher can't physically prevent a pupil leaving a classroom. If they want to leave then they can leave - it's not a prison and pupils wouldn't be restrained. A member of staff cannot then follow the pupil if that would mean leaving their class unattended. Most teachers would then contact "on call" which is where another member of staff who currently isn't teaching locates the pupil - so would result in exactly what happened in this circumstance where the pupil is out of the classroom, usually in a corridor, with a member of staff.

OP could ask the school a thousand times not to allow her DC out of class by themselves but no teacher would ever be expected to enforce that.

racingcar · 11/12/2022 18:46

YABU.

Reception won't know where your child is if your child isn't where they're supposed to be. They'll know a) where they are supposed to be and b) if they're not where they're supposed to be - but they won't know where exactly they are if they aren't where they're supposed to be because pupils don't have individual tracking devices. DC was with a member of staff and being looked after. That means the school as an entity knew where she was - telling reception isn't even remotely relevant to anything because it's highly unlikely that reception would need to know. Reception aren't notified every time a pupil goes to the toilet or gets sent to a different classroom or needs to run back to their form room to get their PE kit etc. As long as the school knew where she was (roughly) and that she was safe and looked after, you have nothing at all to complain about.

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 18:41

@declutteringmymind not sure why you are saying "she"? Anyway DC has "wandered off site" as previously mentioned and also the Camhs assessment did uncover previous self-harm so maybe that's why I'm more than a little concerned?

Thanks for the phrasing around "glad someone was with them etc" because that is a helpful one to use.

I will go back to the safeguarding lead again (we had a meeting at the beginning of last week).

I get the point about building a relationship with the school so was definitely in two minds about approaching the governors as aware it might be counter-productive.

OP posts:
User135792468 · 11/12/2022 18:40

It’s not a failure of process at all. They are teenagers and they are trusted to be responsible and take themselves off to where they need to be. Your child can join the army in 2 years, drive in 3 and get married in 4. Teenagers don’t need to be followed across the school or have a member of staff escort them. If a child didn’t come back from the toilet, I’m sure the teacher would email the office or send another pupil to check up on them. Many times in medical, they sit them down and allow them to stay for a while so it’s not unreasonable to think that they’re still there 40 mins later?

Did you meet with the school after the visit to a&e and tell them your child is a danger to themselves and that they are not to be allowed to leave the classroom on their own? If you did and your dc was allowed to leave then I can understand you speaking to the school. Even then, I wouldn’t word it as a complaint.

If you start throwing your weight around and shouting about complaining to governors, they will think you’re a complete knob (no offence intended) and it’s in your interest to work with them for the sake of your dc.