Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I complain to the governors?

61 replies

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 18:01

DC has a history of anxiety. Severe episode 2 weeks ago which resulted in A&E trip and CAmhs referral within 24 hours. DH went to school to pick up DC for therapist appt which for which we'd pre-notified school. School were unable to locate DC. They'd been marked medically absent from a previous lesson and hadnt turned up to the following lesson. We had a torrid 40 minutes whilst they looked for them. They were found sitting in a corridor with a member of staff (thankfully) having had a panic attack.

Is it unreasonable to think this is a major safeguarding fail? Surely if a kid goes out of a class on medical grounds they should be checked on/notified to pastoral care at the very least.

We'd already been in discussions with safeguarding as they truanted from the last lesson of the day recently and it was not flagged up to anyone; I had to tell the school that DC had truanted and wanted to know why school hadn't contacted me.

Would it be unreasonable to involve the governors at this point?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
converseandjeans · 12/12/2022 00:57

I think you would contact class teacher, or your child's tutor to find out more. If you are unhappy escalate to Head of Year then someone more senior if you are still not satisfied. Governors would be a last resort.

I think it depends also whether you are looking for more support or you wish to complain. If you find out more detail you may be satisfied your child was in safe hands. It sounds like they had a staff member supporting them.

SafariRushHour · 11/12/2022 22:43

with It relating to safeguarding and a particularly vulnerable child best go through senco and safeguarding lead to resolve. If this fails jump straight to LA safeguarding and notify head/governors in retrospect.

Morticiathegreat · 11/12/2022 22:29

I think YABU to go straight to the Governors rather than discussing it with school first.

I am just trying to get the facts straight -

Your child left the lesson on medical grounds, but you haven’t actually said that they were having a panic attack at this point? What reason did they give the teacher for leaving the lesson? This would affect the teacher’s reaction.

If they had told the teacher they were just feeling a bit unwell and wanted to go to the medical room then the teacher wouldn’t have known they were in the corridor having a panic attack? they would have assumed they had gone to the medical room.

However, if a child was very upset or left a classroom with anxiety, in our school the teacher would have reported it to the on-call team (who are actually members of the senior teaching staff who are on a rota to deal with difficult situations) and ask them to try and find the child - a class teacher couldn’t leave the classroom themselves as that would involve leaving 20-plus children unattended. Once the on call team responds, the class teacher will assume it’s being dealt with.

The teacher for the second lesson - if there was an appointment already arranged, this could have already been noted in the register as ‘Medical’ appointment and the teacher will assume the student is there. Or that they are still in the medical room.

The Reception staff would not necessarily have been aware that your child had a panic attack. Secondary schools are large places and the assumption is that students are teenagers and will take some responsibility for themselves.

if your child has needs such that they need to be escorted at all times then you need to discuss that with the SENCO and safeguarding lead.

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 20:30

@Aroloruns thank you that is extremely helpful. You're absolutely right about trying to make this a learning experience not a confrontational one. I am so aware that resources are stretched and am very grateful to the lovely teachers my kid has (met most of them recently in person for the first time). I had talked to friends IRL who recommended the governor route, but ironically braving the viper's nest of AIBU has proved far more helpful

OP posts:
converseandjeans · 11/12/2022 20:22

@realmsofglory

This sort of thread is a real eye opener to me. What happened to teachers you know just teaching the kids , are they really expected to issue an alert every time a teenager leaves the room to get a breath of fresh air or something? Ridiculous!

This is why the job has become so stressful post covid. A big increase in anxiety. Students unable to stay in lessons.

I don't think OP is ridiculous however expecting someone to know where their child is during lesson time.

Carolthereindeer · 11/12/2022 20:19

It’s absolutely not a governor issue, at least not until you have exhausted the complaints process. Each school will have one, it should be set out on the website, but it almost certainly has several steps before it goes near the governors. At my school any complaint to governors would just be sent straight back to you with advice to follow the process. If you have identified what you believe to be a safeguarding issue it needs to go to the designated safeguarding lead, again not the governors. It’s simply not their role.

converseandjeans · 11/12/2022 20:17

We have a system where we log on class charts if student is out the lesson. This is then picked up by pastoral team.

However we have a huge increase in students who for whatever reason are unable to cope with a full school day. So it depends on who is available as the pastoral team could have numerous students to deal with.

Teaches are not allowed to leave the classroom. So once it has been reported it would not be logistically easy to keep checking on them.

I understand that you are anxious and worried. But if we have a full class & we are expected to teach a proper lesson with starter, questioning, a group task etc it's hard to keep popping out the room to check on that other student. If each class has 2-3 students needing this level of care nobody would get any learning done.

I say this as a parent of a child who suffered anxiety post covid. So I am sympathetic.

KrisAkabusi · 11/12/2022 20:16

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:55

@KrisAkabusi would you still think this was acceptable if a child was having an asthma attack? You seem to be a bit dismissive of panic attacks - any idea what they're actually like to experience?. A teacher happened to find them (and I'm very glad and grateful to them that they did)

I'm not dismissive of panic attacks at all! I've witnessed them in adults and children and I know what's involved. I'm simply saying that a medical condition occurred and a teacher helped out!
If a child had an asthma attack I would say the same thing. The child left the room, stating where they were going. If they then had an asthma attack in the corridor and a teacher spent 40 minutes with them, I would still fail to see what the school had done wrong.

cansu · 11/12/2022 20:09

I think that you need to be very clear with the school if your dc is at risk of harming themself.
If he is and if he cannot be trusted to stay on site and in class, then ask them to produce some instructions for staff.
This could be that he is not allowed out of class without a member of staff.
It could be that if he is missing, staff email pastoral support.
However, you and he will then have to live with these restrictions. You cannot then ask for him to be given an exit pass to go for a walk or to stand in the corridor.
I think it would be unreasonable to complain in these circumstances. I am assuming he was allowed out of the lesson to go to sick bay as he felt unwell or was allowed out as he felt anxious. He then did not do that. He was picked up and cared for by someone so complaining would be unreasonable.

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 20:09

@Bewitched005 well they have to mark the child medically absent anyway so it's surely not much of a stretch to ping a note to pastoral care/safeguarding. If there's a medical incident in a classroom it causes a certain amount of disruption; thems the breaks. If there was a projectile vomiting incident or someone fainting for example. Or would you be another dismissing mental health?

OP posts:
Aroloruns · 11/12/2022 20:08

I am a teacher and SENCo. In this situation, if I thought I child was visibly distressed, I would have called using our online system for Emergency Support. I would also have asked another child to go and check on her. Or if I was really worried, checked the nearest department office and asked if a member of staff could help. I would do this for extreme anger or upset too. We have students at our school who are also red slip and marked on the register, if they aren't there within the first 10 mins or leave in a state, you must call for support. You should find out if the school have a similar system. I personally wouldn't make a complaint here as it is a tricky situation as individual teachers are unlikely to knows the details of your DC's anxiety etc. You could also ask the school to share this with teachers so they are aware and also offer a bit more tlc.

I would see this as a learning opportunity rather than a complaint. Schools are honestly on their knees at the moment. Staff absence and budget cuts means everyone is doing their best but sometimes things could be handled better and learned from.

treesandweeds · 11/12/2022 20:06

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:10

@treesandweeds that empathy bypass worked out well for you?

Rude, again.

Bewitched005 · 11/12/2022 20:03

@surreygirl1987 what you did in emailing someone to alert them is exactly what I would hope would happen in these circumstances.

So the teacher has to stop teaching to send someone an email? I can imagine how you would react if your son came home and told you his teacher was emailing someone during his lesson.

Also, most people don't answer emails immediately (especially not another busy teacher who is, you know, teaching at the time?)

DisneyChops · 11/12/2022 20:00

I'm surprised the school even had a spare teacher wandering aroud to be fair. Nowadays any spare teacher is used to teach non specialist subjects.

OP there should really be a 'plan' in place. A member of the safeguarding team or similar should be alerted and looking for your child.
I'd be having a polite and constructive conversation with the school about this. I certainly wouldn't be going to governors.

For context I work in a primary school where safeguarding matters are absolutely huge and a number one priority.

Gagaandgag · 11/12/2022 20:00

Maybe have a look at the schools safeguarding policies etc

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:58

@surreygirl1987 what you did in emailing someone to alert them is exactly what I would hope would happen in these circumstances.

OP posts:
Bewitched005 · 11/12/2022 19:57

But you can't expect a teacher to follow your child out. What about the twenty other people they are supposed to be teaching? Your child had a panic attack that lasted 40 minutes. A teacher was with them. I can't really see what the school have done wrong in this particular situation.

This. Some posters seem to forget, or ignore the fact that the primary function of a teacher is to deliver lessons. They can't just leave a class unattended every time a student decides to leave the room.

The panic attack didn't last 40 minutes. The OP said it took 40 minutes to find (him, I assume, although the OP is being ridiculously coy about the child 's sex), after he had had a panic attack.

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:55

@KrisAkabusi would you still think this was acceptable if a child was having an asthma attack? You seem to be a bit dismissive of panic attacks - any idea what they're actually like to experience?. A teacher happened to find them (and I'm very glad and grateful to them that they did)

OP posts:
CaptainMum · 11/12/2022 19:55

What would you prefer to have happened?

DC specifically not allowed to leave the class?
DC accompanied to their destination? By whom? Always handed over? Paid for by whom?

What about the other teens? Do they get taught or left? Does the teacher follow up with an email- to whom, phone call- mobiles not allowed, in person, abandon a class of kids.

In schools there is a degree to which a child (particularly at 14) has some responsibility. If they're not up to that, a meeting with the Senco to discuss their needs and the funding is required.

Complaining to the governors is ridiculous.

Gagaandgag · 11/12/2022 19:53

Maybe she is expecting the teacher to do something similar to you did - ensuring at least someone else is there for her

surreygirl1987 · 11/12/2022 19:52

PS I'm a teacher too and I've had a pupil run out of the classroom with a panic attack too. I couldn't follow the child out as I was obviously responsible for all the other pupils too. I quickly sent an email o the head of house asking for someone to try and find him, and sent two of my more responsible pupils to see if they could see him across from the building. Someone found him in the end. Short of tagging all our pupils, I'm not quite sure what else you would expect a teacher to do??

Gagaandgag · 11/12/2022 19:51

I get what other posters are saying but in an emergency like this I would always have someone to hand a child over to. I am not suggesting the teacher leaves. They should have a plan in place for situations like this. I know the child is older than I am used to dealing with but they are still a child in the care of the school

surreygirl1987 · 11/12/2022 19:49

Are you serious?? Your child was being looked after. Probably by a very busy teacher when he or she was going to be doing some marking or planning instead, but did the right thing and looked after your child. And you want to complain? This is secondary school. Teachers do not keep tabs on every pupil for every second of the day. It isn't a prison, and some level of responsibility is expected from the child.

KrisAkabusi · 11/12/2022 19:46

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:21

@Gagaandgag there wasn't a handover - the other staff member just found them in the corridor. First teacher wasn't aware they were still there. It just strikes me as an odd way to deal with things. If it was a work colleague this wouldn't happen (not on my watch anyway); if someone left a meeting I was running on medical grounds I'd follow up with them to make sure they were ok.

By the way I am grateful for all the responses - even the rude ones :)

But you can't expect a teacher to follow your child out. What about the twenty other people they are supposed to be teaching? Your child had a panic attack that lasted 40 minutes. A teacher was with them. I can't really see what the school have done wrong in this particular situation.

Gagaandgag · 11/12/2022 19:44

camegonfle · 11/12/2022 19:21

@Gagaandgag there wasn't a handover - the other staff member just found them in the corridor. First teacher wasn't aware they were still there. It just strikes me as an odd way to deal with things. If it was a work colleague this wouldn't happen (not on my watch anyway); if someone left a meeting I was running on medical grounds I'd follow up with them to make sure they were ok.

By the way I am grateful for all the responses - even the rude ones :)

I am a teacher (but primary - which I do understand is different here) but even so I believe the teacher had a duty of care. I would personally not be happy

Swipe left for the next trending thread