Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remove my kids from RHSP lessons?

231 replies

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 07:52

AIBU to ask if I am the only one who wants to do this? Has anyone here done this? Were there any negative consequences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
OMG12 · 11/12/2022 10:53

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 10:47

How would you answer a girl who says she doesn’t want a boy in her changing room seeing her naked or sharing a room on a trip just because he sees himself as a girl when you teach those lessons?

I would say that boys and girls do not share the same changing room (unless it’s primary school) as this doesn’t happen in secondary school.

And if there is any reason why an individual doesn’t feel comfortable getting changed in front of their peers then they can use the individual changing room or do things like come in wearing their PE top under their shirt like most teens do.

And what about if she uses a gym where men and boys identifying as women use those facilities, should she have to hide away in a cubicle to facilitate the wants of men?

on school trips what is the policy about boys who identify as girls? Which shared rooms would they sleep in?

Ofcourseshecan · 11/12/2022 10:51

FOJN · 11/12/2022 08:35

You might find this website useful OP. I'm surprised they are still signposting Mermaids after recent revelations and the Charity Commission investigation, I'd argue that's a significant safeguarding failure.

safeschoolsallianceuk.net/

Yes. I’m surprised a school isn’t taking more notice of this.

Helleofabore · 11/12/2022 10:49

realmsofglory · 11/12/2022 10:14

my sixth form dd has 2 girls in her year group who identify as boys and 1 who is gender fluid. She says they have gone from being unpleasant , unhappy people to being much happier as 'boys'
Does it really matter what the science is? It has turned around these young people's lives so why is it not okay to send the message to others feeling the same way, that it is ok ?

What are you making that assumption on? That they are happier as ‘boys’? Are they really? Or are there some confounding issues there that you will not know about unless you know those children and their families very well.

“It has turned around these young people's lives so why is it not okay to send the message to others feeling the same way, that it is ok ?”

Because even socially transitioning a child is not a neutral act. I recommend you do some reading around this issue and the potential for social contagion before you think ‘sending the message to others’ is the right thing. I say that as a parent who watched 5 of my teen’s friends, out of a group of 7, declare trans identities at 14.

This is an immense topic and has the potential to lead to life long medical patients. If you are interested, you might like to start with the interim Cass Report. Dr Hilary Cass has made clear that there are many issues around this issue. And that children who have comorbidities such as mental health issues, trauma including sex abuse, children who are diagnosed with ASD or ADHD, are homosexual and other issues are over represented in the current cohort of children and teens seeking transition.

This also includes girls seeking to escape the sexism and objectification that they are around them and in their future.

The majority are girls in this cohort.

It is yet unknown what the % of this cohort will be helped by transition, experts have said that at least 80% will desist by the time they reach adulthood. At what point does affirming a child leave them feeling they have little choice but to continue? When their school records have been changed, their family and friends have celebrated their transition, and everyone has had to adjust to the demands of new names…. If that child realises the impact, at what point are they reluctant to say ‘I am sorry, I got it wrong…’.

To me, that is why it is not okay to have well meaning people teach ideological based and not factual curriculum in school. Until more is known about gender identity in childhood, it should be handled very carefully.

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 10:47

How would you answer a girl who says she doesn’t want a boy in her changing room seeing her naked or sharing a room on a trip just because he sees himself as a girl when you teach those lessons?

I would say that boys and girls do not share the same changing room (unless it’s primary school) as this doesn’t happen in secondary school.

And if there is any reason why an individual doesn’t feel comfortable getting changed in front of their peers then they can use the individual changing room or do things like come in wearing their PE top under their shirt like most teens do.

OMG12 · 11/12/2022 10:44

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 10:39

I’m not in Scotland but I have taught PSHE myself and I would be reluctant to pull mine out without seeing the curriculum plan first.

The fact that you think the school is going to hide certain areas of the lesson plans from you, tells me your kids need to be in those lessons.

Firstly, you are not in the right frame of mind if you think that the school is conspiring against you by not including certain things.
Secondly, you are obviously not going to answer your kids questions yourself and so they need to be in an environment where they can ask and not be shut down by you.

This is a topic that isn’t going to go away by ignoring it - in fact you’re going to make it worse.

Like sex, drugs, porn etc if no one talks about it and makes it forbidden, they’re going to search it up on the internet and then find God knows what on there.

In the PSHE lessons we do cover transgender issues but they’re a tiny part of a much bigger picture.
I’ve never pushed any ideology onto any student and I don’t know any teacher that would - why would they?

The emphasis is on being happy in yourself and not having gender stereotypes and if someone wants to wear pink or blue then you treat them with the same respect you’d treat anyone else.

At the end of the day your kids are free to research it up on the internet by themselves but the internet is full of people who are fully for or fully against these issues - not the best thing for a self conscious teen.

A classroom is usually a much more unbiased view.

How would you answer a girl who says she doesn’t want a boy in her changing room seeing her naked or sharing a room on a trip just because he sees himself as a girl when you teach those lessons?

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 10:43

I have just had a quick scan at RHSP.Scot and I cannot find anything that has been mentioned on here.

Please can someone direct me to where it says about lesbians with penis or forced sexual contact as right now it just seems like scare tactics.

name78change · 11/12/2022 10:42

I'm not in Scotland so may be different, but we still participate as there is a lot of necessary info. But we talk about it when we get home and we have had many conversations on gender ideology over the years (my youngest came home at FOUR saying his teacher told him boys could be girls and vice versa) so we talk it through and they know that it's not the case and that this is a political issue, not a scientific one.

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 10:39

I’m not in Scotland but I have taught PSHE myself and I would be reluctant to pull mine out without seeing the curriculum plan first.

The fact that you think the school is going to hide certain areas of the lesson plans from you, tells me your kids need to be in those lessons.

Firstly, you are not in the right frame of mind if you think that the school is conspiring against you by not including certain things.
Secondly, you are obviously not going to answer your kids questions yourself and so they need to be in an environment where they can ask and not be shut down by you.

This is a topic that isn’t going to go away by ignoring it - in fact you’re going to make it worse.

Like sex, drugs, porn etc if no one talks about it and makes it forbidden, they’re going to search it up on the internet and then find God knows what on there.

In the PSHE lessons we do cover transgender issues but they’re a tiny part of a much bigger picture.
I’ve never pushed any ideology onto any student and I don’t know any teacher that would - why would they?

The emphasis is on being happy in yourself and not having gender stereotypes and if someone wants to wear pink or blue then you treat them with the same respect you’d treat anyone else.

At the end of the day your kids are free to research it up on the internet by themselves but the internet is full of people who are fully for or fully against these issues - not the best thing for a self conscious teen.

A classroom is usually a much more unbiased view.

HeadNorth · 11/12/2022 10:38

OP, I would not pull my children out of lessons based on media scare stories and ‘someone told me’. If I were to consider singling my child out in this way, I would want the facts.

It is incomprehensible to me that you will not ask to see the content of the lesson before you make your decision on your child’s participation. That makes you seem knee jerk in your response and that you are using your child to make a larger political point about self ID.

OMG12 · 11/12/2022 10:37

Bakergram · 11/12/2022 10:23

Can you direct me to where lesbians (or anybody) are forced to have sexual relations?

rshp.scot

I am absolutely on side with not pushing many of the ideologies to are alluding to but the resources used in schools don't do that.

Although it might not be specifically mentioned, the trouble is by pushing and ideology without balance in schools it is endorsing the whole ideology which includes this.

StressedOutMama7808 · 11/12/2022 10:36

I should say gender AND sexuality will always come up in science.

Bakergram · 11/12/2022 10:35

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 10:24

@Bakergram I hear what you're saying but I believe this is an antiquated view now. There are no taboos for discussion at home. The taboos are at school in these class discussions when teachers are telling pupils they're not allowed to discuss or think certain things. Questioning taboos is essential and how I realised the harms here - when questioning how we arrived at questioning"lesbians penises" being the ultimate taboo I sought alternative resources. I want my kids to question. But they'll be penalised for it at school.

That's a really interesting perspective and one I hadn't considered.

StressedOutMama7808 · 11/12/2022 10:35

I'm a secondary Science teacher and the amount of misconceptions there are among year 7s when I teach reproduction is wild.

I always have a student asking me 'well how do lesbians have a baby?'. Gender will ALWAYS come up in Science, but we don't have the time to cover it properly aside from gender is what people choose, sex is what you're born as.

The purpose of sex and relationships education is to tackle these misconceptions and give students a safe space to ask questions and receive correct information.

It is better that they discuss these things in a safe environment where an adult can tactfully explain things without giving any misinformation.

My sister is a primary teacher and the language they use has been chosen very carefully. The aim isn't to indoctrinate your children or to make them question about their own identity; it's simply to make them aware about other people who may present themselves as having a different gender to male/female. Or they may come across families that have two mums or two dads.

FOJN · 11/12/2022 10:32

gogohmm · 11/12/2022 09:39

@Nothingandnowhere

Have you met a trans person in real life? There are people (we have a relative) that even aged 4 knew they felt very different, they felt male but they had a girls body. He's a happy well adjusted 28 year old, so this was long before the explosion of trans stuff in the media etc. trans people have always existed too, there's cases from 300 years ago in literature

Why yes I have but why do you ask? I lived with a trans person for several years, supported them through transition and we have celebrated most of life's milestones together. You could say we are good friends.

Do you think that knowing a trans person will suddenly make me believe that humans can change sex and it's OK to teach that to children?

Your relatives experience is radically different to what is happening today.
I'd suggest looking into things more deeply rather than assuming accurate information is hateful or will make you disloyal to someone you care about.

BravelyStunning · 11/12/2022 10:31

actually, i'd only be happy with gender ideology being taught if it was in relation to how regressive it is but i know that's not going to happen any time soon

OMG12 · 11/12/2022 10:27

CinnamonJellyBeans · 11/12/2022 10:14

That's what I meant, reassignment, sorry.

And there lies the rub. People going around confusing the two. Some bloke stating that they “feel like a woman” is rightly NOT a protected characteristic unlike sex. Businesses appear confused and certain groups like to perpetuate the confusion.

This confusion leads to males being allowed into womens spaces. (Although pre op males are unfortunately included if they are in the process of transitioning physically)

The difference cannot be over emphasised and clearly set out below

What are protected characteristics

Charley50 · 11/12/2022 10:26

@realmsofglory - I work with a lot of young people who identify as the opposite sex. Many of the ones I see are NOT happier once they change their 'gender identity.' They self-harm, they are school refusers, they isolate themselves and won't talk to their peers or adults (as their voice gives away their sex), they withdraw from learning and socialising, they are encouraged to have suicidal ideation and see themselves as victims, which impacts on their mental health. Yes some might be happy, but many are not. The happy ones are obsessed with their identity and get very upset if their actual sex (reality) is referred to. Staff are on eggshells around them.

Most also would grow up to be lesbians if it wasn't for this new ideology. They are so confused about their sexuality, they are excited about being able to take testosterone, they bind their breasts then faint at school. I have seen so much trauma in trans-identifying girls, and boys, but mainly girls. There are no positive lesbian role models being promoted at teens, it is all about being trans. It's terrible.

BravelyStunning · 11/12/2022 10:24

don't blame you, op.

I guess you need to verify what exactly is being taught, but any nod to gender identity is unacceptable if it's taught as fact. fair enough to teach that some people believe in gender identity and that it is an unprovable ideology but, right now in scotland, i doubt there are many willing to risk telling the truth!

of course, belief in the biological reality of the sexes is now enshrined in law (thanks, maya forstater), though would that include scottish law?? so that's one possible angle: anything that teaches that one can have a penis and be female is patently at odds with that particular "belief", so your kids miss the lesson on those grounds?
just thinking of my son's muslim friend who legitimately missed sex ed on grounds of religion/belief
i suppose the difficult bit is that you don't want your kids to be in any way alienated by others due to this, and that, unfortunately, is how sinister fads operate
if that's a concern, and they end up attending the lessons, just keep the lines of communication open between yourselves and gently discuss any gender bollocks that arises in their lessons
my son doesn't have any truck with gender woo but he gets irritated if I talk too much about it, so sometimes you have to operate with restraint!!
my daughter can't admit it's bollocks openly but i know she knows- she doesn't even want a male hairdresser due to discomfort- pretty sure she doesn't want eddie izzard in her changing room! ugh just typing that makes me queasy

btw, i realise how ludicrous it sounds to talk about belief in biology- like belief in trees or cats or breathing! but that's where we're at

best of luck, your kids are lucky to have a sensible mum

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 10:24

@Bakergram I hear what you're saying but I believe this is an antiquated view now. There are no taboos for discussion at home. The taboos are at school in these class discussions when teachers are telling pupils they're not allowed to discuss or think certain things. Questioning taboos is essential and how I realised the harms here - when questioning how we arrived at questioning"lesbians penises" being the ultimate taboo I sought alternative resources. I want my kids to question. But they'll be penalised for it at school.

OP posts:
Bakergram · 11/12/2022 10:23

OMG12 · 11/12/2022 10:08

The trouble can it be discussed? I a child says, actually this ideology is evil, it is taking womens rights back 100 years, it is trying to force lesbians into having sexual relationships with people they don’t want to through shaming and coercion, it is taking womens bodily autonomy away, it is trying to dehumanise women through actions and language to take away their voices and push misogyny on everyone disguised as a harmfully stereotypical woman. It is destroying the mental and physical health of so many children and young adults, it is destroying families. Will that be given equal airtime and weight as the abusive ideology the curriculum is set out to indoctrinate children with?

Can you direct me to where lesbians (or anybody) are forced to have sexual relations?

rshp.scot

I am absolutely on side with not pushing many of the ideologies to are alluding to but the resources used in schools don't do that.

PaterPower · 11/12/2022 10:22

“Surely letting them hear the one side with school and then discussing it with them at home and helping them to digest what has been said is more helpful than just removing them or them having half an idea?“

The problem with that POV is that many (most IMO) kids assume their teachers are always correct, and that what they’re taught in school is ‘factual,’ even in the face of evidence that some of it is anything but.

If the teacher relaying the content (which is already heavily slanted, if it’s sourced from Mermaids or similar organisations) is herself either a true believer in the gender BS, or is just too scared to stand up to it, then there’ll be no opportunity for OP’s child to question anything.

‘Dissent’ - even mild questioning - will be firmly shut down in class in these situations. Very few teachers, even if GC in private, are going to risk being reported for WrongThink. And the end result is that it’ll be an uphill struggle for OP to counteract with her DC.

Removing DC from the lesson, and ensuring they get a truly balanced viewpoint from OP, is the way to go.

FOJN · 11/12/2022 10:20

You need to consider that gender identity is a legally protected characteristic.

Gender identity IS NOT a protected characteristic. Gender reassignment is a protected characteristic and means that you cannot be treated less fairly than someone of the same SEX who has not reassigned their gender.

Whatwouldscullydo · 11/12/2022 10:20

realmsofglory · 11/12/2022 10:14

my sixth form dd has 2 girls in her year group who identify as boys and 1 who is gender fluid. She says they have gone from being unpleasant , unhappy people to being much happier as 'boys'
Does it really matter what the science is? It has turned around these young people's lives so why is it not okay to send the message to others feeling the same way, that it is ok ?

And what happens outside the school bubble when they start placing themselves in dangerous situations to continue affirming their identities.

Would you want a female child to start using mens loos at the bus station. Or not telling drs and risk harming an unborn baby or receiving the wrong treatment ?

How about when they join a.sports team and play alongside men and boys?

If I told you I could fly would you tell me when I was jumping off the sofa? How about a first floor window? Multi story carpark? Or is the concrete just a bigot fir not affirming ajd just killing me?

realmsofglory · 11/12/2022 10:19

I will add your kids will be mortified if you pull them out!
I really don't understand why you do not want them to hear any POV but your own.

Charley50 · 11/12/2022 10:16

OP, my colleague, in London, took her young son out of PHSE, after being warned by me of the ideology being pushed on children. She told me that other parents in her son's year took their children out too. She asked to see the teaching materials but the school was stalling on sending her it.

We already have a whole generation of indoctrinated children and young people. Frankly it is horrifying how schools are pushing this. Young children have so much belief in what teachers tell them.