Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ungrateful brother

34 replies

Positivityonemoretime · 10/12/2022 22:36

Ok, so my brother came to UK to study in university 3 years ago. I financed the course he studied and paid ten thousand. Then he wanted to study further (a very tough course) which is for 2 years and the first instalment of ten thousand was paid by my parents. Then second was paid by me that is four thousand. All this while he was staying in my house and I was bearing all his expenses including pocket money, food, clothes etc.

He was at the beginning of his third semester (start of Covid lockdown ) when he suddenly started living outside stating that he’s living at his friend’s house. All lockdown he didn’t come to ours and slowly stopped picking calls and responding to messages. Being worried I used to call his university asking for his well being and sometimes also called police as he would not call or messages and my parents who live in another country were worried.

After a year, he called my mum and told them that he has a girlfriend and expecting their first child. Now the problem is I called him at my responsibility and he has betrayed my trust. His announcement has come as a cultural shock to my parents as in our family no one has child outside the wedlock. He’s the only son of my parents and he had damaged them completely. I know in this part of the world it’s very normal to have child without being married and I respect that and don’t judge.

Before he left my house (during lockdown ) he asked me £2000 for something and I gave him. After a year and half he came to my house to take his suitcase and behaved so weird. He was like a mad person, coming to hit me and had careless attitude . Since then he never calls me or pick my call or message me. Very weird ! He would call me parents once in 3-4 months. They are always asking for him, crying and begging him to come and see them but this person’s heart would not melt a bit. I wonder how much a person can change in a year ? From being a lovely son, brother to this cold blooded person. Plus how ungrateful of him. I did so much for him and in return he gave me this. My parents blame me for all this and I don’t complain as I was the one who called him to UK so that he could study and do well in life.

Last year I received a letter from his university that he needs to pay ten thousand fees for his third semester. I made him and his partner aware of it but today I again received a letter saying that they will take legal action if not paid. He has changed address for bank, Job and everything but cunningly not for university. What should I do ? I don’t know his address, don’t know anything about his whereabouts. How can I complain about him ? He’s in what’s app but hardly open my messages. I’m so angry at him and hoping the karma hits him back soon.

OP posts:
Positivityonemoretime · 10/12/2022 23:33

@malmi can I report this to police ?

OP posts:
Positivityonemoretime · 10/12/2022 23:33

@Allsnotwell sorry but I’ve zero interest in him or his partner or his child. He’s a selfish person and one who could not appreciate his parents or sister, I doubt will appreciate his partner or child.

OP posts:
malmi · 10/12/2022 23:26

It's up to the university how long they take before referring the debt to debt collectors or taking him to court. To take him to court they will need to find his current address. If they send debt collectors to your address you may need to be prepared to convince/prove to them that he has moved out. Don't let them come into the house though.

Allsnotwell · 10/12/2022 23:26

Firstly you are now an auntie, your brother has found a girlfriend and obviously lives with her and is happy.

The money he owes is his debt - all you have to do is send the letter back ‘unknown at this address’ and let him deal with it. Clearly you still want control over him!

You aren’t building any bridges. You have no right to his address, and he doesn’t owe you anything. You chose to pay for him without May agreement or expectations.

Your parents should love their son regardless if any wedding! They have a grandchild they should be welcoming. He clearly knows how they feel, otherwise they would be thrilled for him.

Positivityonemoretime · 10/12/2022 23:19

@Kitkatcatflap its been a year the university is sending letters to my address but they haven’t taken any action yet. How long will it take them to take action and how will they find him ? It’s been a year they are sending letters but so far no action is been taken. I just want them to force him to pay so that he knows the value of money.

OP posts:
Positivityonemoretime · 10/12/2022 23:15

@Kitkatcatflap thanks for your kind words. He’s 27 years old. I feel hurt and somewhere am guilty as well. Sometimes I just wish I had not called him here. I’ve kids as well and can imagine the pain of not hearing back from children. Just sad and unfortunate!

OP posts:
Kitkatcatflap · 10/12/2022 23:08

I can imagine you feel hurt, angry and let down after all the help you have given him over the years. To not answer your calls and ignore your messages seems mean.

You don't say how old he is but given all the courses, I guess he is around mid to late 20s. Your brother is a grown man and a father now. He may be ungrateful but you are not responsible for his behaviour nor his debts. Your parents should not blame you for the way is living his life.

Do not pay his debt, let the university chase it, tell your parents you will leave the door open for communication but you will stop chasing him if he doesn't want to be found. Given time, perhaps he will make his way back. If he contacts you again asking for money - refuse. You are a sister who has been very generous to him and not a bank. You may feel disappointed with his choices but truthfully I think your biggest issue is managing your parents expectations and pressure.

Good luck OP

Positivityonemoretime · 10/12/2022 22:46

@BattleofBeamfleot but how would they know where he lives now. The letter is coming to my house. Also it seems he did attended 3rd semester but failed it. Where can I make his complain as university also doesn’t know his address. How will they find out ?

OP posts:
BattleofBeamfleot · 10/12/2022 22:40

If the letter is in his name, that £10,000 sounds like his problem - and not yours.

At this point it sounds very much like he has chosen his freedom, and the family obligations are unfortunately no longer something he wishes to do. There is nothing you can do about that, but let the chips fall as they will. If his studies are important, he can pay it. If not, he will drop out and he will have to make his own way.