Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I steer who my DC is friends with?

139 replies

Pineappleandhoney · 10/12/2022 18:49

I am parent of 1 DC who is very good friends with one other child in their school. My DC tends to gear towards having 1 great friend rather than a group of good friends.

Their previous best friend does not live with their birth parents but otherwise seems happy. I do not know the history but I have assumed there were safeguarding issues based on the little I do know. Their best friend prior to their current was a smart young child but I am somewhat certain they do not come from a great household. More than 1 teacher commented that the child used fowl language and distracted my child during lessons (I am sure at times my child did the same). I have observed the other child’s parents they are very scruffy and don’t seem to work despite on on outwardly appearances seeming able.

I AIBU to want my kid to socialise with kids from a similar or better socioeconomic background?

What has been your experience moving from an ok area to a better area with more socially mobile families or vice versa?

I know this in theory sounds bad but I am 100% sure I am not the only parent that has experienced this.
(Ultimately we will likely move to a better catchment area when DC reaches secondary school or internationally with work).

OP posts:
jamira · 10/12/2022 20:38

I would focus on encouraging wider friendship groups more than anything else, eg offering play dates. Regardless of this friendship your DC will benefit from not being reliant on one friend which can become intense and sometimes lonely

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 10/12/2022 20:38

sorry. *They’re.

WilmaFlintstone1 · 10/12/2022 20:37

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 20:25

They’re steered towards friends with nice families yes, hence why we moved to private after the pool in their state primary was lacking.

I won’t feel bad for not wanting my children to surround themselves with children who look like county lines drug dealers with parents who have matching wardrobes,

Blimey, you’re a right piece of work. You do realise drugs exist in middle class naice private schools don’t you? Do some research, you might educate yourself.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 10/12/2022 20:37

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 20:25

They’re steered towards friends with nice families yes, hence why we moved to private after the pool in their state primary was lacking.

I won’t feel bad for not wanting my children to surround themselves with children who look like county lines drug dealers with parents who have matching wardrobes,

If you want to spend your money buying your kids desirable friends then that’s entirely up to you.

but I don’t think it’s fair to hold how their parents present themselves against a young child. Kids are not their parents and some parents who may look a bit rough are actually very nice 🤷‍♀️. on the flip side some parents who look lovely and middle class from the outside are actually awful. At primary it doesn’t really matter who their friends with.

FlamingWreath · 10/12/2022 20:36

Have a word with yourself OP. If anything, yours is the family I’d want my child to avoid.
Must remember to wear sunglasses, forget to brush my teeth and hair so that parents like you ignore me on the school run.

Thinkwicebeforeyouleavemylife · 10/12/2022 20:34

Op in the nicest way possible I think you know you're being a bit snobby. However I think maybe you've just not articulated yourself that well, I think lots of parents would feel similar or would be dubious about their child mixing with certain children simply because of ingrained prejudices (not really our fault per se, its embedded in society)

Rather than judging the child's background (or what you think you know of it) you should invite these kids over and see the friendships develop? It doesn't matter what parenting children have and those you mention could be the ones most in need of a friend!
Xx

MrsSchrute · 10/12/2022 20:33

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:30

It’s well known that social group impacts a child’s progression and ambition throughout school.

If your child surrounds themselves with chav children who have no or limited ambition they will be more likely to have little ambition themselves. Same applies in reverse.

Yes children aren’t their parents, but you can’t pretend that the likelihood of a child from a working class background also then staying WC is low.

I hate this snobbery. 'Chav children'? That's disgraceful.

I would far far rather that my child grew up to be kind, accepting, treat everyone with respect, and not judge people by their parents bank balance, then grown up valuing money and appearance above all else. How shallow!

Why would you teach your children to be ambitious in terms of the amount of wealth and power they can hoard form themselves, and not ambitious about the amount of good they can put into the world and the difference they can make? Find me the dressing gown mum, I'd much rather spend time with her!

Tigger7654 · 10/12/2022 20:31

So your only real issue with these kids is one doesn't live with birth parents and the other has parents who are a bit scruffy. You heard some gossip that one child used fowl language (can't imagine why him talking about chickens would upset you so I assume you mean foul).

However you don't say anything about your child's behaviour changing so if it wasn't for gossip you presumably wouldn't have been alerted to the fact these people are 'below' you. So they're not bad influences or anything. I suspect your DC may have only one friend because other parents don't like you 🤷

Good luck trying to control your DCs friends by the way, that sounds like a plan that cannot backfire 🙄

Reugny · 10/12/2022 20:28

Let your child be friends with who they like in primary, just don't invite the kids you don't like to your home.

There are studies that show in secondary the vast majority of people self-select to be with people like themselves.

TulipCat · 10/12/2022 20:28

Whilst I don't and can't control who my children are friends with at school, I just don't encourage out of school stuff if I don't like the parents, eg day trips, lift shares, playdates at ours.

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 20:25

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 10/12/2022 20:04

Yes, my kids were friends with no one from primary at secondary after the first couple of weeks, despite going up with several.

so you’re saying that your DC are only allowed to be friends with middle class kids from nice families? Good luck with that. Honestly success is mostly down to parents being engaged and interested in their DCs education. Engineering their friendship to ensure they’re only friends with desirable children seems incredibly wrong to me. I’d like my kids to grow up valuing people from all walks of life.

They’re steered towards friends with nice families yes, hence why we moved to private after the pool in their state primary was lacking.

I won’t feel bad for not wanting my children to surround themselves with children who look like county lines drug dealers with parents who have matching wardrobes,

Hadjab · 10/12/2022 20:24

*Foul

If you don’t wear sunglasses in blistering heat, when exactly would you wear sunglasses?

Be prepared for your child to rebel against you when they hit their teens…

Coyoacan · 10/12/2022 20:24

Sneakyblinders · 10/12/2022 19:27

You are a snob and I'd hope my (middle class!) children would avoid yours!

Actually her child sounds lovely. Children can't help the parents they have

dolor · 10/12/2022 20:19

🙄

RaraRachael · 10/12/2022 20:19

You sound like my sister. Every time her daughter asked if a friend come round, she asked her, "What does her daddy do?"

RandomUsernameHere · 10/12/2022 20:18

One of DS's friends lives with his aunt, he's a lovely little boy. Really not sure why you would have a problem with a child who doesn't live with their birth parents.

I wouldn't try and control who your child is friends with. If you have concerns about the parents, just make sure you hang around during any play dates.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 10/12/2022 20:18

My mum tried to do that. As a result, i collected and tried to rescue all the "riffraff".Grin

It spectacularly backfired for years.

shivawn · 10/12/2022 20:17

I wouldn't actively intervene on an existing friendship without very good reason (I don't think, my son is too young for me to have any actual experience of this) but I do spend a lot of time researching schools and catchment areas to try and increase chances of him mixing with similar social economic backgrounds.

JubileeTrifle · 10/12/2022 20:16

Outside of school your kids do hang around with your friends kids and might be friends. The older they get, the less it works.
DD used to spend a huge amount of time with one of my friends DD, at around 10 it became obvious that they were very different and honestly, DD can’t stand her.

Inside school it’s impossible. DD went to a ‘rough’ school and I couldn’t stand some of the parents but you make do. Lots of the kids were really nice. DD is no longer friends with any of them though and has a lovely group of friends in secondary she has made.

There was a mum at primary who spent a lot of time managing her daughters friendships and pushing her to be friends with certain people. Being super nice to those kids and inviting them to nice things all the time. This included not being friends with my DD (I think because she competed for cleverest in the class). From what I heard this has not got well in secondary because mum can’t involve herself and the girl struggled to make friends.

SkinnyFatte · 10/12/2022 20:12

You don't know anything about this child. Just because she doesn't live at home etc doesn't mean she's going to have a negative effect. You are prejudiced against children like her and you are a crushing snob.

Orangesatsuma · 10/12/2022 20:09

I’m not sure really. I always look super scruffy on the school run as I’m not a morning person and struggle getting everyone ready.I once encountered the most awful, pretentious woman in the playground who clearly judged me and didn’t give me the time of day. Blatantly ignored me when I was speaking and talked over me on several occasions when I was speaking with others.I’ve never encountered anything like it…so rude!

Dh and I are both educated professionals and quite high earners but you wouldn’t necessarily know that from looking at us or our current house. We have both had a couple of promotions since buying our home but haven’t yet got the energy to move up the ladder, plus where we live is convenient for our jobs and the schools. 🤷‍♀️

I don’t mind who dc are friends with as long as they continue doing well at school, being respectful and there is no risk of them going off and doing drugs / smoking etc or safety issues. If you suspect drugs etc I wouldn’t blame you for not wanting to encourage the friendship though but it might be worth talking with the parent / guardian to get a feel for what they are like / if they are really into drugs or just don’t like their arms.

Smartiepants79 · 10/12/2022 20:07

You can have some control over these things while they are little. BUT it’s almost impossible to control who they spend time with in school.
They are drawn to whoever they’re drawn to.
You do sound a bit snobby.
The only reason I would attempt to stop my child spending time with another would be if I had concerns they where hurting mine or if I was worried they’d be at risk in some way.
I wouldn’t send her home with someone if I was worried but I’d invite the other child over instead. It’s not the child’s fault.

GetThatHelmetOn · 10/12/2022 20:04

Chocchops72 · 10/12/2022 19:56

I’ve kind of done it on a macro level by choosing to live in a really good (expensive) neighbourhood and send my children to good local schools schools, but on a micro level they are left to make their own choices. But like I say, the children they meet are probably not very diverse.

😁

IME it is far more often than not that the more affluent kids are the ones who are experimenting with drugs, porn etc earlier than the other ones.

I went to private school, the scruffy ones were the aristocrats, the posh ones the ones that were always trying to keep up with the Joneses and often had awfully entitled children. Good neighbourhood it is not necessarily a synonym of well to do people.

Incidentally, the aristocrats in DS state schools had hooligans for children, the dad was open about his use of recreational drugs and they had an open marriage 😁

That’s not to say poverty invests you with virtue, we also had the violent yob with nasty children 🙂

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 10/12/2022 20:04

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:58

Do you think friends change all that much from primary to secondary? Many go to the same schools, and stay friends with their childhood best friends.

And yes, connections and aptitude to learning at 6 does have an impact. It also impacts what your child is exposed to.

Yes, my kids were friends with no one from primary at secondary after the first couple of weeks, despite going up with several.

so you’re saying that your DC are only allowed to be friends with middle class kids from nice families? Good luck with that. Honestly success is mostly down to parents being engaged and interested in their DCs education. Engineering their friendship to ensure they’re only friends with desirable children seems incredibly wrong to me. I’d like my kids to grow up valuing people from all walks of life.

statetrooperstacey · 10/12/2022 19:59

No, only intervene if they are an actively bad influence or are horrible to your dc/a bad friend.
my dd 11 has a close friend since 2 and they are very different , when they were younger we thought her friend was overpowering a bit and our dd wasn’t really able to be herself, was railroaded a bit by her friend and maybe wondered if it would be a good thing to try and back off a bit and have them not hang out quite so much. We actually realised that the friend was full of the confidence that our dd wasn’t ( very shy) and that’s why they were good friends I think because they balanced each other out.

It’s good to have friends different from ourself , it’s more interesting for a start , good to get on with people from all walks of life.
If your son has found a connection, someone that he enjoys spending time with and that would have his back that’s lovely , encourage it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread