Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I steer who my DC is friends with?

139 replies

Pineappleandhoney · 10/12/2022 18:49

I am parent of 1 DC who is very good friends with one other child in their school. My DC tends to gear towards having 1 great friend rather than a group of good friends.

Their previous best friend does not live with their birth parents but otherwise seems happy. I do not know the history but I have assumed there were safeguarding issues based on the little I do know. Their best friend prior to their current was a smart young child but I am somewhat certain they do not come from a great household. More than 1 teacher commented that the child used fowl language and distracted my child during lessons (I am sure at times my child did the same). I have observed the other child’s parents they are very scruffy and don’t seem to work despite on on outwardly appearances seeming able.

I AIBU to want my kid to socialise with kids from a similar or better socioeconomic background?

What has been your experience moving from an ok area to a better area with more socially mobile families or vice versa?

I know this in theory sounds bad but I am 100% sure I am not the only parent that has experienced this.
(Ultimately we will likely move to a better catchment area when DC reaches secondary school or internationally with work).

OP posts:
ErinAndTonic · 10/12/2022 23:11

At least your child seems to be far less judgemental than you are, hopefully they'll grow up to be a nicer person and know their own mind. Why the hell would being adopted be a reason to not allow a friendship.

Oh and also I wear sunglasses often, because my eyes are sensitive to bright light and believe me some overcast days can cause me to squint and struggle just as much as in the height of summer. Stop making assumptions and go off what you see. Agree with other posters if it was drugs or behavioural issues it would be different, but that comes irrelevant of background, you can't just simply cast aside your child's friend just because they come from the 'wrong side of the tracks'.

Dittosaw · 10/12/2022 23:02

You can never predict which friendships will harm your children because the druggies daughter might be lovely and the doctor’s daughter might be a manipulative bully, who tells everyone to be mean to your child. You just do not know. My best friend as a child had terrible things said “rough, coarse, common, dangerous” etc all because they were mixed heritage. I see some haven’t progressed from those times.

I suggest you read “An Inspector calls” and see if it teaches you anything

Teddybear00 · 10/12/2022 22:49

My mum always tried to control who I was friends with or gave me strong opinions and I never understood until now. I think if you know your kids friends are a bad influence on them then absolutely it's your duty as a parent to look out of your child. However, I wouldn't try steer them if they are different but not doing any harm

Coyoacan · 10/12/2022 22:37

Apart from anything else, being able to mix with all kinds of people is actually a very useful skill

Crunchingleaf · 10/12/2022 22:02

There is a girl who went to primary with my DS, we know her parents and her older siblings. Parents aren’t exactly engaged with their DC and the older siblings are trouble. Parents just laugh at things like their children getting involved in fights. There was no curfews for the older siblings so will probably be same for this girl too when she hits 14/15. The girl all through primary was a lovely girl, however her best friends parents had major reservations about the friendship and I can see where they are coming from, but they didn’t intervene as it’s only primary school. They have ended up in same class in secondary school now and the best friends parents are wondering if they should of done something to steer their daughter away from this friendship.
Sometimes if you actually know the parents of a particular child it can be difficult not to have doubts about a friendship. If you don’t know the parents then you are entering into being a snob territory.

Stressfordays · 10/12/2022 21:49

I let them be friends with who they want. As they get older I talk about good choices and being careful about the company you keep (meaning hanging around with the naughty kids will get you in trouble too).

I'm a lone parent, my kids dad was recently splashed all over the local news for some not very nice things. Luckily, no one seems to avoid me at school even though it is a 'posh' village school. My dc are always invited to parties etc.

Libelula1979 · 10/12/2022 21:49

I look a right scruff on the school run and probably 99% of the time, as it's just me. I just feel more comfortable in casual clothing.
I'm poor, live on an HA estate and - 😱 - I'm a single Mother.
OP, I'm the stuff of your nightmares...
I imagine some people do judge me, but I'm a fairly nice, decent polite person.
My DC certainly aren't exceptional in any respect, but they generally get along well with the majority of other children in their class, are pretty darn polite and decent most of the time, and I will happily chat to their friends' parents, whether they can cut glass with their middle class vowels OR sometimes say "innit".
I guess I'm just comfortable enough within myself to not try to steer my DC's friendships.
My Mother did it to me and wouldn't let me mix with what she called "common little street oiks" (the other kids on our estate), so my sibling and I grew up socially isolated and very lonely.
Perhaps encourage your child to embrace a wider friendship circle, or they are going to find life tough at high school.
And, OP, if this thread is actually 100% authentic, you might consider not being such a snob?

melonraspberry · 10/12/2022 21:42

After I left my marriage, I moved from a million pound house in a wealthy area and bought a house elsewhere in the country on a street which is mainly council, and dd started the local school, which was not 'outstanding' like her old one.

We have both flourished here, she is taking GCSEs and is expecting 8s and 9s, which is way above target, it is friendlier by a mile at her school and in our town.

This thread just reminds me of everything I realise now I hated about where I used to live. There's a lightness about living here we never had in the richer area.

At one point we were the family with social services involvement . Because I married a man who became violent. That is not our fault and I'm sure many judged but that is just ignorant . Anyone can end up in a bad situation, no one is completely secure .

70billionthnamechange · 10/12/2022 21:41

Wowsers

JustMarriedBecca · 10/12/2022 21:41

This is ghastly. What a horrific OP.

I look a total scruff on the school run, our car is a piece of crap, by far the worst in the car park.

That's because I'm so busy running a department and earning six figures to be arsed in the morning and I keep my suits in my large corner office.

Your opinion is unfortunately not yours alone though - I was once told when I went to view a nursery that "they had a lot of lawyers and doctors children" my child could mix with if I sent them there. I rejected it on that basis.

Incidentally, drug problems in my experience, are predominantly more of an issue in private schools.

Do I steer my children's friendships? No. I want them to mix with all kinds of different people.

And I can smell a social climber (and avoid them) a mile off.

Stopandlook · 10/12/2022 21:34

Just awful.

Poor child - judged and excluded from friendships by adults. Makes me so sad.

Never would I prevent my child from choosing their own friends. Obviously if I was concerned about something I would jump in and discuss it then. But all children should be allowed to reach their potential without being held back by snobs.

MyCatIsAFuckwit · 10/12/2022 21:32

Good luck in controlling your child's friendships 🙄
Could be possible other parents are trying to control their children from playing with the kid with the judging mum....and ends up with no mates at all.
Think on

yikesanotherbooboo · 10/12/2022 21:23

So much to say on this but I can't get it into words without seeming judgmental. OP , reread your post. All I can say is that assessing small children in this superficial way is wrong . Help your DC to learn social skills and discernment by mixing with whom they wish. It will be in their interests long term.

melonraspberry · 10/12/2022 21:21

Incidentally I am a single parent after a violent marriage and my dd is the loveliest child you could meet and one of the very top in her year. I probably look pretty scruffy as I wfh and don't spend much on myself, I make sure instead that we have a good safe and secure life and the occasional holiday.

Anyone who is friends with my dd is very lucky indeed .

melonraspberry · 10/12/2022 21:16

I'd absolutely hate it if my child was friends with a child with parents like you. Just awful. Sums up what is wrong with this country. I hope your child is more empathetic and mature.

mitsy5 · 10/12/2022 21:14

We shouldn’t judge a book by its cover either. I’m sure I look horrendous at the school sometimes but purely because I can’t afford to buy nice new clothes for myself because I’d far rather my kids have.

JustLyra · 10/12/2022 21:12

Yes. You absolutely should steer your children away from the children you mentioned.

Those children absolutely do not need your sneering judgement anywhere near their lives and will be far better off not being exposed to you and your attitude.

serenghetti2011 · 10/12/2022 21:09

Fgs I have 4 boys and never engineered any friendships. Kids need to mix with all children and make their own minds up. You don’t then have to invite them home with you to play but it’s not the child’s fault who their parents are - if they are on drugs etc but all children deserve friends and to be safe at school.

What happens at high school then once your child has left school when you can’t micromanage your childrens lives and the control is gone?…my kids all have lovely friends from all backgrounds and are nice well adjusted kids. Can’t stand judgy folk like you op.

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 21:05

MrsSchrute · 10/12/2022 20:33

I hate this snobbery. 'Chav children'? That's disgraceful.

I would far far rather that my child grew up to be kind, accepting, treat everyone with respect, and not judge people by their parents bank balance, then grown up valuing money and appearance above all else. How shallow!

Why would you teach your children to be ambitious in terms of the amount of wealth and power they can hoard form themselves, and not ambitious about the amount of good they can put into the world and the difference they can make? Find me the dressing gown mum, I'd much rather spend time with her!

Odd you think it’s to do with bank balance, you can be on a low income and not deck your child out in Nike tracksuits, with shaved heads and fags hanging out your mouth.

Plenty of families are on a low income and aren’t chavs.

mitsy5 · 10/12/2022 21:05

TheArtfulStodger · 10/12/2022 19:41

One of the worst families I'm currently in contact with, are middle class. Utter snobs, nasty spiteful children who are spoilt, absolutely nothing good to say about either of them - so I avoid mentioning them to other volunteers.

I much prefer my kids socialising with a range of kids from different backgrounds, though I definitely prefer it when the kids are from working class backgrounds. There's no shitty snobby pretense, fakeness, we've rarely been judged by others from our own class, unlike we have by those from the middle class I've known or met.

Yes, parents could have all the money in the world but this doesn’t mean their children will be nice, friendly little souls. And the child who’s parents both work hard but live in a bit of a rough area with a sh*t car could be ten times a nicer, better influence.

Remaker · 10/12/2022 20:55

Dear god. Working class children with no hope of elevation eh? I grew up working class in a rough neighbourhood, topped my primary school, went to University and got a Masters degree. My siblings are both university educated with professional careers. But we live in Australia so I guess that’s the difference.

I’ve tried to influence friendships in the younger years, mainly to stay away from nasty, entitled kids who bully, with parents who are far too busy with their high powered jobs and social lives to take any notice of them.

Absolutescum · 10/12/2022 20:53

Name change for this as I am so disgusted I may out myself!
Parents like you are the reason behind all the arrogant, ignorant bigots in the world.
I'm a single parent with 5 kids, 2 different fathers. From the youngest 3 being in nursery I have dealt with judgement, bullying, exclusion of myself and DC.
Now, 14 years in. My DC are winning school awards and receiving university offers, top of their classes. The 'higher class' kids are dropping out of school, smoking weed and moving into bedsits while their parents get fined for them being out of education.
I'm not saying ALL the 'better kids' are doing this but my 'scummy kids' are definitely on the best paths, even the youngest (8) is dancing in a major theatre production.
mmay look 'scruffy' in the playground but my kids get the best of everything and when they are in the 'higher class' like you, I know they will never, ever be so fucking judgemental!!!

Blueberrypeapod · 10/12/2022 20:52

Noimaginationforaun · 10/12/2022 19:05

Wow.

Sorry I probably shouldn’t reply but I genuinely felt upset reading that. My little boy (3) is adopted. He’s lovely! It makes me want to cry thinking some parents might not want their children to be his friend because he doesn’t live with his birth family.

This^
i cried reading OP’s appalling post. Has OP any idea how they come across? My child is also adopted (at 6 years old) and struggled with friendships. Throughout the whole of primary school they were invited to just one party, despite huge efforts by us to arrange playdates. It’s heartbreaking. Children can learn a lot from classmates of different backgrounds and this should be encouraged at school.

BeanieTeen · 10/12/2022 20:49

If the child was having a negative affect on your child’s emotional or physical well-being then I would say YANBU.
If you are just being an incredible snob then you YABU.

It’s well known that social group impacts a child’s progression and ambition throughout school.

Good luck to all those looked after children then I guess? You can’t be friends with anyone who isn’t in the same disadvantaged broken boat at you. Let them all sink together while the well to do kids enjoy sailing in their strong ship towards the land of the privileged without pesky children from low socioeconomic backgrounds rocking it slightly (not sinking it) on the way.
That very much sums up the UK for you…

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 10/12/2022 20:43

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 20:25

They’re steered towards friends with nice families yes, hence why we moved to private after the pool in their state primary was lacking.

I won’t feel bad for not wanting my children to surround themselves with children who look like county lines drug dealers with parents who have matching wardrobes,

Also, the poshest, most expensive private school in our area has an awful problem with drugs in the later years. Just something to be aware of. Your kids lovely friends will be able to afford a lot more drugs than the less desirable kids they left behind at state.