Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I steer who my DC is friends with?

139 replies

Pineappleandhoney · 10/12/2022 18:49

I am parent of 1 DC who is very good friends with one other child in their school. My DC tends to gear towards having 1 great friend rather than a group of good friends.

Their previous best friend does not live with their birth parents but otherwise seems happy. I do not know the history but I have assumed there were safeguarding issues based on the little I do know. Their best friend prior to their current was a smart young child but I am somewhat certain they do not come from a great household. More than 1 teacher commented that the child used fowl language and distracted my child during lessons (I am sure at times my child did the same). I have observed the other child’s parents they are very scruffy and don’t seem to work despite on on outwardly appearances seeming able.

I AIBU to want my kid to socialise with kids from a similar or better socioeconomic background?

What has been your experience moving from an ok area to a better area with more socially mobile families or vice versa?

I know this in theory sounds bad but I am 100% sure I am not the only parent that has experienced this.
(Ultimately we will likely move to a better catchment area when DC reaches secondary school or internationally with work).

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 11/12/2022 10:54

I'd usually leave kids to it. The only time it would be worthwhile controlling it is if your kids go to school with George or Charlotte - in that instance you'd be forgiven for orchestrating a friendship.

phoenixrosehere · 11/12/2022 10:21

Unless they are a massive detriment to your child, I’d leave them to it, while also encourage them to make friends with others unless they are the type who enjoy their own company and aren’t fussed.

My mother tried to. She wouldn’t say stay away but she would make comments and ask questions about their home life that I never had an answer for. I never asked questions about their home lives unless they felt comfortable to discuss it with me and I wouldn’t disclose something unless I was concerned. I rarely paid attention to what they didn’t or did have (why would I unless it was something highly noticeable). She would say things off first impressions and made it less likely that I would ask for help. The times she did interfere, only strengthen my resolve to make friends the way I chose. She sent me to a summer holiday camp with the type of people she wanted me to be around, but I spent most of it being bullied because I was “different” (you name it, they found an issue with it) while the adult counsellors did nothing. She sent me back three times to places like that.

I still had a diverse, eclectic group of friends of my own accord. A good chunk being the type people would consider as inferior or had negative gossip about them. None of them deserved such treatment. It’s a major reason I can’t stand gossip especially the tabloid kind that is so prevalent in our culture.

Ilovemybed2022 · 11/12/2022 10:10

Pineappleandhoney · 10/12/2022 19:37

*Sorry correction long sleeves in blistering heat and sunglasses every time I saw her at the gate summer or winter.

This is hilarious. I sometimes look scruffy; I work from home in a well paid, responsible job, and I’m usually in a rush from work to collect DS. I wear sunglasses in all weather to prevent migraines. I also have bad teeth: years of bruxism have ruined them

Ilovemybed2022 · 11/12/2022 10:03

For someone who can’t spell “foul” you’ve got a bit of a cheek being so snobby.

I was the kid from a lower social economic background. I’ve done better in life than friends from a higher income family.

How2Support · 11/12/2022 09:42

@Baconsprouts you are talking complete bollocks. All the evidence for school education in the UK indicates that the socioeconomic circumstances of the home environment (income, maternal education level, number of books etc) is a far FAR bigger influence on a child's educational success than a child's school friendship group.

TodayIsFridayHooray · 11/12/2022 09:35

melonraspberry · 10/12/2022 21:42

After I left my marriage, I moved from a million pound house in a wealthy area and bought a house elsewhere in the country on a street which is mainly council, and dd started the local school, which was not 'outstanding' like her old one.

We have both flourished here, she is taking GCSEs and is expecting 8s and 9s, which is way above target, it is friendlier by a mile at her school and in our town.

This thread just reminds me of everything I realise now I hated about where I used to live. There's a lightness about living here we never had in the richer area.

At one point we were the family with social services involvement . Because I married a man who became violent. That is not our fault and I'm sure many judged but that is just ignorant . Anyone can end up in a bad situation, no one is completely secure .

Wish there was a like button on Mumsnet! I want to 'like' this post 💛

EmergencyPoncho · 11/12/2022 09:33

Your OP doesn't read very clearly. Ultimately, as long as my DC's friends are kind, fun, not leading them astray* etc, I'm happy and I don't care about their background at all. But for several reasons, I would discourage your DC from having just one friend: what happens of that child is away? A life lesson is to be able to get on with more than one person, and so on.
*nothing to do with socioeconomic background.

TodayIsFridayHooray · 11/12/2022 09:31

My son has lots of friends at school, one of them, who he sits next to in class, is the kid who gets put in 'reflection'/'seclusion' etc.. daily. This boys brother has already been expelled (this is primary school). The family, sadly, have a reputation (some known criminal background) and the mum is often ignored at the school gates :( Personally, I like the mum. She's doing her best. Her son, who is friends with my son, has a lovely side to him. Clearly life is tough enough for him without the other kids being told to stay away from him. Obviously, if my son was being bullied by this kid (or vice versa), or my son was being drawn into his naughtiness, I'd need to step in and find a way to support my son, but currently this isn't happening and they are forming a nice friendship. I'm pleased my son doesn't have the prejudice or judgemental attitudes which come with age, and the two boys can just enjoy being kids with each other. For now (age 8) that seems more than fine to me.

lollipoprainbow · 11/12/2022 09:29

The teacher shouldn't be discussing other children with you, very unprofessional.

Dotcheck · 11/12/2022 09:21

Dacadactyl · 10/12/2022 19:22

Oh come off it, some of you are so sanctimonious!

As if you'd be chuffed to bits with your kids hanging out with the child of a mum who turns up to the playground in her pj's, dressing gown and fag hanging out of her mouth, swearing at a whole rake of offspring behind her!!

🙄

And yet it STILL wouldn’t be the fault of the child, now would it?

buckeejit · 11/12/2022 09:17

OP, I think you're getting an unfair time here.

There's a difference between occasional recreational drug use & covering arms - you're implying needle marks which would concern most people.

My dc have broadly chosen their own friends. Their best friends currently are 1-from old money millionaire family & 2-single parent council house respectively. Both are lovely children who are kind with good manners & generally pleasant dispositions.

There are other children who have been from varying parts of the spectrum & depending on the child the behaviour has been varied. Regarding not living with birth parents (i don't think the Op means adopted), it's understandable that these children may need more support as for whatever reason their parents were unable to look after them. I wouldn't be surprised by these children being more volatile as they are likely to have endured more struggles but it wouldn't put me off my dc having a friendship with them same as any other child, until anyone's behaviour becomes apparently unacceptable.

Like others have said, the children who dc have told me swear, wind up my dc & behave badly in school, I generally don't extend invitations to unless I'm sure they're going to be a group big enough to spread the load of them among. My ds is now by himself at 13 slowly distancing himself with a friend like this.

TheaBrandt · 11/12/2022 08:44

Hence in my view the solution if private school to avoid issues definitely wouldn’t work!

TheaBrandt · 11/12/2022 08:43

Mine are teens now and looking back they have never had a moments trouble from the “rougher” girls the op would shudder at who are by and large pretty decent- any misery inflicted has always been by middle class evil ones.

JustKeepSlimming · 11/12/2022 08:41

I encourage them to be friends with people who are kind, patient, forgiving and not too full of themselves. I encourage my DC to be good friends by behaving that way towards others.

I couldn't care less about the family background (unless they were known drug dealers or something, but that can happen with nice middle class parents too). If the parents smoked in the house or swore all round them, I'd probably not encourage my DC to go to their house; I'd invite them to ours instead, but I absolutely wouldn't discourage the friendship if the child was generally pleasant.

Ivyonafence · 11/12/2022 08:39

This can't be real.

People aren't this clueless.

littlehouselights · 11/12/2022 08:30

I never knew that wearing sunglasses marked me out as lower class.

I have very sensitive eyes and the sun makes them run like mad. So I have photochromic lenses. What does that make me?

Judgyjudgy · 11/12/2022 00:38

Peashoots · 10/12/2022 19:18

It’s foul, not fowl.
Who are you to judge anyone.

Ha, I thought this too

Clymene · 11/12/2022 00:36

You can be as snobby as you like in primary. They'll be friends with all sorts in secondary.

TheaBrandt · 11/12/2022 00:29

Both ours without exception gravitated to families “like ours”. Parents of similar outlook /education level /jobs and income. It was uncanny actually. Even at secondary when I overlap with the parents of dds friends they are lovely and exactly like my friends are.

ReginaGeorgeIsAFuglySlut · 11/12/2022 00:24

Well you can try to engineer your child's friendship but it might not turn out the way you hope. I am a young single parent living in the equivalent of a council house. My children's father was in jail when they were young due to DV. They have zero contact now.

So you would probably deem my kids as below you. It would be your loss though, as they are incredibly hard working, they do well in school and have more empathy than you have displayed in your posts by a mile. They are also the type of boys who would include your son when his one friend was sick or absent from school because they don't like to see people left out. Sometimes it is worth looking a little deeper.

Absolutescum · 11/12/2022 00:23

@AnneTwackie Thank you. I've worked extremely hard to ensure they get a good start in life. 1 of my children is mixed race but don't tell OP! 🤣

riotlady · 11/12/2022 00:15

AIBU to want my kid to socialise with kids from a similar or better socioeconomic background?

But if you don’t want your kids to mix with those from a “worse” socieconomic background, why would parents from a “better” one want their child to mix with yours? You might drag them down

fifteenohfour · 11/12/2022 00:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ehb102 · 10/12/2022 23:49

I'm all for not letting your child sit amongst rotten apples, but these do not seem to be rotten apples.

Rotten apples can be found anywhere. People with bad spots that may spread. Selfishness, rudeness, unkindness, dishonesty, callousness, they are what we want to keep our children from seeing as normal . Money has nothing to do with values.

AnneTwackie · 10/12/2022 23:13

@Absolutescum you and your kids sound amazing!

Swipe left for the next trending thread