Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our economy infantilises young people

182 replies

HurryupwiththeteA · 10/12/2022 17:34

I’ve got a DS who’s 18 and I’ve been thinking a lot about this. I love history and learning about different time periods and when I think what some of the 18-25 year olds used to have vs now it’s stunning. Henry VIII became king when he was 18. Slightly more realistically, up until not so many years ago young people were able to move out, get jobs that actually pay money you can live on, get married, have children, etc. I know some can especially closer to 25 but for many that’s simply not a reality.

Today minimum wage jobs (which are absolutely necessary and often quite skilled) are simply not enough to live on meaning that for many they feel their only option is university.

The student loan system requires you to be dependent on your parents (especially if they earn more) as the maintenance grant simply will not cover living expenses and (back to my last point) they’re only option is minimum wage will does not pay.

After graduating in most areas home ownership is not realistic given the exorbitant cost. This leaves them with the option of living at home for many years to try and save up (or rent and most likely never be able to afford a house deposit).

Because they don’t have their own place, relationships are often either causal hookups or quite short lived. This means that marriage or children if usually out of the question until they are much older.

Many other things such as being treated like they’re not really adults by older people, being marketed crap they don’t need keeping them in the rat race, calls to raise the age to smoke, so many other things.

Sadly I think the answers to these problems just aren’t going to happen. Major house building, distressing the importance of degrees for jobs that simply don’t need them, making the minimum wage enough to actually live on, controls on rent, stopping interest on student loans and raising the repayment threshold. None of these will ever happen, for political reasons, but frankly they should.

Aibu to think that young adults (18-25) are pretty infantilised today. It seems like 25 is the new 18 and until your mid 20s now society often still sees you as a child. Furthermore, Aibu to think this

OP posts:
Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 20:00

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:52

Of course this has everything to do with having no qualifications.

You didn’t have an issue with NMW, you had an issue with having no qualifications

No, I have an issue with NMW.

School qualifications are obtained in childhood. Childhood is affected by parents. Feckless parents and childhood abuse often result in children moving out early with minimal qualifications.

They should be able to support themselves reasonably independently on a full day’s work. It benefits society for them to do this. If they later want to get into a career, they can do this by studying while supporting themselves, but first they deserve to be paid appropriately rather than continuing to be exploited.

I believe in one thing: a fair day’s pay for a fair day’s work.

I have an issue with anything that impedes it.

SnackSizeRaisin · 10/12/2022 19:54

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:50

I had 12 GCSEs, dropped out halfway through college due to family/home issues. Worked in a shoe shop then got receptionist apprenticeship.
Then did another receptionist apprenticeship, because the qualification isn’t worth the paper it’s written on.

Wasn’t trying to get into a profession, just wanted a NMW job rather than apprenticeship or age-minimum job.

Sounds like you did ok all things considered. Wasn't criticising you just saying that qualifications do help with getting better paid jobs. That is what they are for after all. I've witnessed the repeated reception apprentices in my work place. The apprentices were usually much better and less lazy than the permanent staff. It was the other poster's professional at 18 story that seemed dubious.

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:52

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:37

FGS I literally said above I was offered jobs on the condition I accepted below the wages they were offering on ads. I had employers ask me, would you consider doing another apprenticeship with us.

Maybe it varies area to area because I was not the only one of my friend group in this position. When DD was 2 I returned to studies, possibly I was hindered by lacking school qualifications, I’ll never know but this is what happened repeatedly.

Of course this has everything to do with having no qualifications.

You didn’t have an issue with NMW, you had an issue with having no qualifications

SnackSizeRaisin · 10/12/2022 19:51

maddiemookins16mum · 10/12/2022 19:34

You’ve got parents on here not prepared to let 15 year olds catch a bus home at 6pm, 17 year olds not allowed to stay home alone etc etc, the way society treats young people is the problem. God knows how the 18 year olds going off to war 80 years ago managed.

Not that well by all accounts. In many ways they would have been far more sheltered than today's young people. Most had never travelled beyond their local town and they had no TV and few books. They would have been more used to physical hardship and more independent in some ways (although lots of 18 year olds would still live with parents until they married, it would be highly unusual for a single young person to live in their own house)

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:50

SnackSizeRaisin · 10/12/2022 19:46

If you have no school qualifications that explains why you were limited to low paid jobs then. You were probably lucky to get any kind of job - even apprenticeships usually need some GCSEs.

On the other hand what professional role can you do at 18? Surely the definition of a profession is that it needs specialist high level education? Doctor, lawyer etc?

I had 12 GCSEs, dropped out halfway through college due to family/home issues. Worked in a shoe shop then got receptionist apprenticeship.
Then did another receptionist apprenticeship, because the qualification isn’t worth the paper it’s written on.

Wasn’t trying to get into a profession, just wanted a NMW job rather than apprenticeship or age-minimum job.

NoelNoNoel · 10/12/2022 19:49

I get what you are saying OP but with the retirement age being moved to so late in life I don’t think there’s as much as a rush to enter adulthood ‘proper’.

magicthree · 10/12/2022 19:47

I think throughout history young people have lived at home with their parents. I think the idea that you can get your own house, car etc at say 20 is a very modern expectation.

When I was young, 70s/80s, few people lived at home with their parents. They moved into flats with other young people. However, I agree that buying a house at a very young age is a modern expectation. I certainly didn't earn enough when I left school to even consider it.

SnackSizeRaisin · 10/12/2022 19:46

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:37

FGS I literally said above I was offered jobs on the condition I accepted below the wages they were offering on ads. I had employers ask me, would you consider doing another apprenticeship with us.

Maybe it varies area to area because I was not the only one of my friend group in this position. When DD was 2 I returned to studies, possibly I was hindered by lacking school qualifications, I’ll never know but this is what happened repeatedly.

If you have no school qualifications that explains why you were limited to low paid jobs then. You were probably lucky to get any kind of job - even apprenticeships usually need some GCSEs.

On the other hand what professional role can you do at 18? Surely the definition of a profession is that it needs specialist high level education? Doctor, lawyer etc?

IneedanewTV · 10/12/2022 19:45

I was thinking this today as I took my son to a uni open day. My parents in the 80s didn’t take me to uni open days - not sure they were even a thing for first generation uni students. On my first day at uni I caught the coach with my bag and went to a new city 100s of miles away to a room in lodgings with a family.

today we were looking at en suite uni rooms with parking - I mean wtf???? Not sure if they are enfantised or spoilt to be honest,

MrsHughesPinny · 10/12/2022 19:44

My Mum started her first job in the public sector at 16, was married at 20, homeowner at 21 and had me at 24. Neither she or my father were well off, neither had degrees or well-paying jobs and they were both raised in urban council houses.

Their first house cost £25,000 and at the time they earned £6,000 each. That’s a very different ratio to today’s earnings to first home price.

lljkk · 10/12/2022 19:44

Those who survived the early years would have had similar life expectancy to us.

No, that's not true, they died in childbirth, from infections, in violence, from accidents, from strokes, gout & cancers. Modern medicine makes people live years after they would have otherwise died. If you get to 18 now in good health, you could hope to get to 85 before dying. If past people got to 18 in good health in 1800, they could feel very pleased to reach 60.

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:37

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:33

You weren’t barred from progress, if you apply for low level jobs on NMW then that’s an active choice.

At 21 (am only 29 now) I was earning £25k a year and owned my own home, age isn’t the defining factor, the fact I had been in a professional role since 18 was.

At 21 I don’t remember any of my friends on NMW. It’s not that or nothing

FGS I literally said above I was offered jobs on the condition I accepted below the wages they were offering on ads. I had employers ask me, would you consider doing another apprenticeship with us.

Maybe it varies area to area because I was not the only one of my friend group in this position. When DD was 2 I returned to studies, possibly I was hindered by lacking school qualifications, I’ll never know but this is what happened repeatedly.

BabyOnBoard90 · 10/12/2022 19:36

Agreed, our economy perpetuates the Peter Pan syndrome

maddiemookins16mum · 10/12/2022 19:34

You’ve got parents on here not prepared to let 15 year olds catch a bus home at 6pm, 17 year olds not allowed to stay home alone etc etc, the way society treats young people is the problem. God knows how the 18 year olds going off to war 80 years ago managed.

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:33

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:30

No, at 21.
I was referring to your ‘experience on low wage and then progress’. I was barred from progressing because they could legally pay me less.

You weren’t barred from progress, if you apply for low level jobs on NMW then that’s an active choice.

At 21 (am only 29 now) I was earning £25k a year and owned my own home, age isn’t the defining factor, the fact I had been in a professional role since 18 was.

At 21 I don’t remember any of my friends on NMW. It’s not that or nothing

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:30

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:27

3 years of experience at 16?

No, at 21.
I was referring to your ‘experience on low wage and then progress’. I was barred from progressing because they could legally pay me less.

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:27

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:23

lol, no, they wanted to pay me less because they could. Why tf would they pay full wages when they knew I’d just finished an apprenticeship but was still under the age for minimum wage? I had 3 years experience on FOH and great references, but businesses are out to make money.

3 years of experience at 16?

luxxlisbon · 10/12/2022 19:26

I’m not sure what was better about the days of a man starting work in the factory down the road, a girl getting married and knocked up at 18 and a life of having more children and little options due to limited education.

This ‘20somethings are so babied’ line is trotted out on mumsnet and it’s just bizzare. It’s often mostly from parents too and just strikes me as a desperate ‘everyone else’s parenting and kids are awful except me’.

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:23

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:19

Then you can’t have had much in terms of experience they valued.

lol, no, they wanted to pay me less because they could. Why tf would they pay full wages when they knew I’d just finished an apprenticeship but was still under the age for minimum wage? I had 3 years experience on FOH and great references, but businesses are out to make money.

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:21

tickticksnooze · 10/12/2022 19:16

You can't have a very good understanding of history and social or political structures if you think they were doing those things alone.

Many were, yes some very young kings had support, but when they hit 14/15 most would rule alone with minimal input

Same applies to young girls running a household, I can’t imagine many 13 year old girls these days being able to arrange massive banquets, raise children, keep up with politics to advance their family

tickticksnooze · 10/12/2022 19:20

"Young people today just aren't living up to the standard of Henry VIII" may be peak Mumsnet.

Henry VIII is a pretty questionable role model anyway.

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 19:19

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 19:01

When I went for higher paid roles, they’d offer me the job on the condition I took it for a lower wage. Multiple times. Don’t know if it was legal but was not really in a position to debate it!

Then you can’t have had much in terms of experience they valued.

tickticksnooze · 10/12/2022 19:19

sashagabadon · 10/12/2022 19:14

I agree but life expectancy is also longer. In Henry viii times you’d live till your 40’s or less as a working person so 18 was half your life expectancy!

Not true. High infant mortality rates in the past distort "average" lifespan. Those who survived the early years would have had similar life expectancy to us.

Dacadactyl · 10/12/2022 19:18

It annoys me no end. Your job as a parent is to raise them to be able to stand on their own 2 feet, not run round after them so that at 32 or 34 you are still supporting them financially (like some of my colleagues are doing for their kids)

I'm 37. I had a baby at 21 in my final year of uni. My parents were not well off and my (now) husband still had 2 more years of uni to go.

I admit we had the support of our parents in that we lived with either set of our parents for the first 4 years of our child's life so that we could save a deposit. But we still had to pay them rent.

My colleagues complain their kids won't move out, but they're not charging them rent...well why would they move out? And according to them their kids arent saving their money either. I mean, they are complicit in infantilising them imo.

tickticksnooze · 10/12/2022 19:16

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 18:01

YANBU, I was watching a really good documentary about Margaret Beaufort, who was the mother of Henry VII, she was 12/13 when she gave birth to the first Tudor king and was from all accounts very sharp, she managed to negotiate her own marriage contracts, politically shmooze to ensure the safety of her son, all before she was 15!

I know it’s not a good thing for teens to have children, but there has been a shift in terms of infantilising children to where they now ‘can’t’ do much, whereas even just a few hundred years ago 12/13 year olds would be running households, raising children, and in some circles playing political chess with grown adults and having to be strategic with their choices etc. boys would govern whole countries before many teens these days are allowed a phone!

You can't have a very good understanding of history and social or political structures if you think they were doing those things alone.