Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our economy infantilises young people

182 replies

HurryupwiththeteA · 10/12/2022 17:34

I’ve got a DS who’s 18 and I’ve been thinking a lot about this. I love history and learning about different time periods and when I think what some of the 18-25 year olds used to have vs now it’s stunning. Henry VIII became king when he was 18. Slightly more realistically, up until not so many years ago young people were able to move out, get jobs that actually pay money you can live on, get married, have children, etc. I know some can especially closer to 25 but for many that’s simply not a reality.

Today minimum wage jobs (which are absolutely necessary and often quite skilled) are simply not enough to live on meaning that for many they feel their only option is university.

The student loan system requires you to be dependent on your parents (especially if they earn more) as the maintenance grant simply will not cover living expenses and (back to my last point) they’re only option is minimum wage will does not pay.

After graduating in most areas home ownership is not realistic given the exorbitant cost. This leaves them with the option of living at home for many years to try and save up (or rent and most likely never be able to afford a house deposit).

Because they don’t have their own place, relationships are often either causal hookups or quite short lived. This means that marriage or children if usually out of the question until they are much older.

Many other things such as being treated like they’re not really adults by older people, being marketed crap they don’t need keeping them in the rat race, calls to raise the age to smoke, so many other things.

Sadly I think the answers to these problems just aren’t going to happen. Major house building, distressing the importance of degrees for jobs that simply don’t need them, making the minimum wage enough to actually live on, controls on rent, stopping interest on student loans and raising the repayment threshold. None of these will ever happen, for political reasons, but frankly they should.

Aibu to think that young adults (18-25) are pretty infantilised today. It seems like 25 is the new 18 and until your mid 20s now society often still sees you as a child. Furthermore, Aibu to think this

OP posts:
BabyFour2023 · 11/12/2022 00:57

Tiredallofthetime · 10/12/2022 18:24

Indeed, but are you suggesting that women have and complete their families before the age of 25?

And actually amongst women who haven’t accessed higher education there is more of a trend to have their first baby younger. I don’t see that as a bad thing: women should always do what suits them, but it does show that women with degrees tend to choose to postpone their families. Having your first baby at 32 rather than 22 is really not a societal or personal disaster.

it does show that women with degrees tend to choose to postpone their families

I disagree with this; I think the OP is right in that women who end up going to university don’t have a choice but to have their children later due to delay saving a house deposit, having more outgoings with student loan, often starting on a low wage after 3/4 years at uni so can’t afford to save / move out for a while.
I don’t think it’s a choice at all. It’s a circumstance.

BirdyWoof · 11/12/2022 00:48

I agree massively.

I’m still in my twenties but I had jobs (and some tough jobs at that) when I started uni at 18 and beyond. I’ve always been an incredibly hard worker- I take pride in doing a job well, I’m meticulous and like things to be done properly.

I now work in management and I am really struggling with some of the younger hires.

The job they’ve been hired to do is pretty simple and straightforward. And the same jobs need done every single day in the workplace. There’s an incredibly consistent routine for them to follow- nothing really changes in regards to their workload (it’s management who deals with everything else).

Yet apparently it’s too difficult. They tend to spend the majority of the shift-

  • complaining about the task they’ve been given
  • complaining about being bored (yet when given a task it remains untouched unless it’s something they deem worthy of doing)
  • don’t listen fully when you’re giving them an instruction, so come back 15-30 minutes later asking “what did you want me to do, again?”
  • hiding in the toilets/other areas of the workplace
  • ignoring other staff when they’re being called down to assist them (basically waiting until someone else does it so they can go back to skiving)
  • trying to take extra time on their allocated breaks
  • constantly on their phones

And so on.

I always give new starts some leeway for the first few months as I know it’s hard fitting into a new workplace with new staff, routines etc to follow. And I know younger staff members need extra time sometimes as they’re just teenagers themselves. But there comes a point where a boundary is crossed and as a result, some uncomfortable conversations will have to be had.

I really struggle to understand why this age group is so difficult to get (any) work out of. My friends in other sectors, and also within the same company, are struggling with exactly the same issues that I am with their younger hires as well, so it’s not as if I just got “unlucky”.

They basically want to only do what they want, take constant breaks to text people and be on their phones, get paid for a full shift and go home.

It really fucks me off. I’m in an industry which is incredibly busy over Christmas and I don’t have the time to micromanage my staff as I have a thousand and one other jobs that I need to do myself, but unfortunately going forward I will have to until they either get with the programme or quit.

I feel like a lot of it is parents who are babying their kids, though. Ie I asked one of my staff members to tidy up their workplace as it was a complete mess (we’re talking stuff all over the floor, items not put back when not being used, etc). I came back 30 minutes later and not a single item had been moved, and asked why it hadn’t been done. The response I got was “what do you mean tidy up?” So I had to stand there and explain how to put rubbish into a bin.

I’m sorry, but that shit is on their parents.

LemonSwan · 11/12/2022 00:44

I agree for the most part so Yanbu.

But I think you yourself are adding to the infantilising with this…
After graduating in most areas home ownership is not realistic given the exorbitant cost. This leaves them with the option of living at home for many years to try and save up (or rent and most likely never be able to afford a house deposit).

Its such a commonly held belief drilled into us from so young in liberal politic circles, the media, common parlance that I nearly fell for it myself. But it is simply untrue. Many can buy houses in their 20s on minimum wage. If living in a house share and living off similar amounts of cash as the student maintenance loan then the maths leave you with a decent saving for deposit in most midlands and northern areas.

The thing no one wants to say is ‘yes you can buy a house - just not where you want it what you want.’ But these kinds of limiting expectations and being expected to move away and travel are important parts of adulthood all previous generations have had to do.

XelaM · 11/12/2022 00:39

Oh, and the exams were OPEN BOOK exams where we actually just gave the students the answers to all the questions!

XelaM · 11/12/2022 00:34

Icannoteven · 10/12/2022 17:57

YANBU. I worked in the higher education sector until recently and the babying of students is insane. I'm talking of 18,19, 20 year olds, ADULTS, who need sooo much hand holding and support. Equivalent to what my generation (elder millenials) would have outgrown at the age of 13/14. Parental involvement in their decisions seems to go on until people are well into their 20's and it has created a generation of overgrown babies who will have a big shock when they enter the real world!

This was also my experience of teaching at a university. I couldn't take some of the "problems" the students had seriously 😳 It was ridiculous how many wanted to defer exams because of "anxiety". I mean, everyone gets anxious about taking exams. It's a pretty normal feeling. How will constant deferring help that?

Allsnotwell · 11/12/2022 00:17

I don’t understand why it isn’t classed as age discrimination to pay differently due to age. If the job is the same, and one worker is 16 and the other 56, and they both do it to the same standard, how is it fair for the older employee to earn more?!

Why should someone with 30 plus years experience be paid the same as a new starter? This is where minimum wage is a rubbish idea, which then pushes people into the benefit system - which in turn means they can’t earn more without losing money in the bank.

They system is set up to keep people poor.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 11/12/2022 00:03

Kennykenkencat · 10/12/2022 20:35

NMW is a relatively recent thing (1998)

My first salary worked out at 46p per hour.

A case of take it or leave it as there were 4 million other people queuing behind you who would take it.

Mine was £25 per week. 1981

Sugarplumfairy65 · 11/12/2022 00:00

TheLostNights · 10/12/2022 18:39

Well it's a lot harder now to find affordable housing and then lets factor in cost of living etc. Back in the 80's, early 90's, it was do-able to move into your own flat at 19 and the cost of everything was cheaper then it is now. It was much easier to make your own way then it is now.

Not for everyone it wasn't. When i got married in 82 my husband was a clerk for the dss and i was an apprentice. We had to live with my in-laws for the first 2 years as did many young people in those days

Pineconederby · 10/12/2022 23:54

I don’t understand why it isn’t classed as age discrimination to pay differently due to age. If the job is the same, and one worker is 16 and the other 56, and they both do it to the same standard, how is it fair for the older employee to earn more?!

Ariela · 10/12/2022 23:42

I'm not sure I agree with you - neither my nephew or niece went to Uni, but both had moved out before they were 25 and bought their own flats. They live within 50 miles of London. Both have worked very hard, nephew is now married and they've upgraded the flat by completely redecorating (bought a doer upper) to a vey nice semi

JackTorrance · 10/12/2022 23:36

At 21 (am only 29 now) I was earning £25k a year

What's "only" about 29?

SofiaSoFar · 10/12/2022 23:09

doorheckk · 10/12/2022 21:43

My first salary worked out at 46p per hour.

In what year though?

Well there was mention of Henry VIII in the OP, so around his era I'd guess?

latetothefisting · 10/12/2022 22:47

I also disagree that people are discouraged from forming serious relationships - if anything it is SO expensive now that it's hugely beneficial to be in a couple early on so you can share expenses, whether that's 1 room in a houseshare or both getting the H2B ISA bonus rather than just 1 person etc.

latetothefisting · 10/12/2022 22:45

Notcontent · 10/12/2022 18:30

I think throughout history young people have lived at home with their parents. I think the idea that you can get your own house, car etc at say 20 is a very modern expectation.

This. People's view of history is so tinted by a) the very recent past and b) the majority of our information/media focussing on the richest 1% of the historical population

It really was not the norm for most girls to be getting married and having children at 12/13 - that was nearly only the most aristocratic families. The majority of women throughout history didn't marry until their mid 20s on average. Yes people would have joined the workforce earlier but on the other hand until 1918 the majority of the population wouldn't even have been entitled to vote. Until the 19th century most would have been barely literate. Lots of people would have stayed living with their parents in 3/4/5 generation homes until the older generation died off. For centuries the majority of people would have lived within a few miles of where they were born.

Rather than comparing, eg. Margaret Beaufort to your average 13 year old today, compare her to someone like Greta Thunberg or Malala Yousafzai - i.e. an outlier!

Comparing my life to my mum, in her late 50s, she moved straight from her parents house to living with my dad. I used to get the 'when I was your age I had a mortgage and was married with a child...' schtick but on the other hand she's never lived alone or with friends, been the sole person responsible for paying the bills, never travelled alone - all of which my sister and I had done by our late teens, even if it was in uni houseshares. So its peaks and troughs in terms of who has experienced the most 'independence.'

Also agree with the poster who pointed out that for young people who don't go to uni they often do achieve these 'milestones' early - my brother's friendship cohort were getting married, buying houses and having kids on average nearly a decade before mine, because they nearly all left school at 16-18 and went straight into apprenticeships, so were earning good money by the time I was still trying to get on my first graduate scheme.

doorheckk · 10/12/2022 22:27

Expectations have changed.

But logically expectations would be different as FTBs are much older now. My DB bought recently & went straight for a house because he's older & expecting a baby.

Your colleague cannot be very representative if they are buying when young & have 1000s held back for furnishing. That's not the typical FTB is it?

howmanybicycles · 10/12/2022 22:15

TeenDivided · 10/12/2022 18:25

After graduating in most areas home ownership is not realistic given the exorbitant cost. This leaves them with the option of living at home for many years to try and save up (or rent and most likely never be able to afford a house deposit).
Because they don’t have their own place, relationships are often either causal hookups or quite short lived. This means that marriage or children if usually out of the question until they are much older.

I disagree with most of this.

In my generation (graduated in the 80s) I think it was pretty common for young people to house/flat-share. I really get the feeling that these days people seem to 'want their own space' and not be so willing to flat share including bathroom / kitchen share with others.

And I really don't see why not having your own place means you can't develop relationships. OK not have children, but no reason for making relationships short lived.

I'd agree with that. I left uni in 1995. No chance of getting my own place and family not supporting me. I rented a room in a house share but still managed to have the same boyfriend for 8 years. It was also not possible then to live off full student grant. I worked as well.

A colleague of mine is much younger than me and buying his own place at the moment. When I bought I cobbled together hand me downs and very cheap second hand stuff to try and get the basics (fridge, mattress) and then made do without the rest, buying it over time. He can't fathom that and says he 'has' to keep 1000s back to furnish the whole place with reasonable stuff in one go. Expectations have changed.

doorheckk · 10/12/2022 21:43

My first salary worked out at 46p per hour.

In what year though?

IneedanewTV · 10/12/2022 21:30

Someone made a good point earlier. If the youngsters are expected to retire at 70 (my FIL retired on final salary pension at 52) then I don’t blame them having some fun and not being responsible adults until they are older. My FIL started work at 16 snd retired at 52 so 36 years. I didn’t start work until 22 and will retire at 67 so 45 years. Therefore if they start proper working at 25 that’s 45 years to the age of 70.

realmsofglory · 10/12/2022 21:24

Icannoteven · 10/12/2022 17:57

YANBU. I worked in the higher education sector until recently and the babying of students is insane. I'm talking of 18,19, 20 year olds, ADULTS, who need sooo much hand holding and support. Equivalent to what my generation (elder millenials) would have outgrown at the age of 13/14. Parental involvement in their decisions seems to go on until people are well into their 20's and it has created a generation of overgrown babies who will have a big shock when they enter the real world!

Parents are nowadays expected to contribute significantly to higher ed costs and so i think their involvment is inevitable

Kennykenkencat · 10/12/2022 20:35

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 18:57

They’d only get paid less if they went for a NMW role. Most people gain a year or twos experience on low wage and then progress. I’ve never been on NMW and started work at 16.

I agree with looking at other ways to incentivise businesses to take on younger people, but that doesn’t change the issue being that people are staying in low paid roles for far longer than they should be

NMW is a relatively recent thing (1998)

My first salary worked out at 46p per hour.

A case of take it or leave it as there were 4 million other people queuing behind you who would take it.

Kennykenkencat · 10/12/2022 20:28

Notcontent · 10/12/2022 18:30

I think throughout history young people have lived at home with their parents. I think the idea that you can get your own house, car etc at say 20 is a very modern expectation.

Dd had her own flat and car before she was 20

TonTonMacoute · 10/12/2022 20:15

Agree with PPs who say it's not the economy, it's us!

I was in a meeting this week and someone was complaining that her daughter was in Germany and was planning to fly back to Britain for Christmas but was very stressed about possible delays due to the strikes. 'She's only 26', she said.

Only 26!!! That's an adult, FFS. I had dealt with that sort of situation several times by the time I was 26, as I travelled to Europe quite often for work. Yes, it's quite stressful but nothing really bad happens, and often you meet some really interesting people as everyone gets together to make the best of things.

This woman and her husband are prepared to drive to Germany to pick up their daughter and bring her home. I was astonished at how pathetic they all are.

BeyondMyWits · 10/12/2022 20:09

There is a huge mix out there... Dd21 is living as a student in Germany in a shared house she arranged herself, learning the language as she goes. Made the money to follow her dreams working in a tech support call center during covid.

Not all young people are living at home waiting for life to be delivered to them.

Itsoktogiveup · 10/12/2022 20:08

Yanbu. It’s a big problem. Agree with what you say.

Chattycathydoll · 10/12/2022 20:02

SnackSizeRaisin · 10/12/2022 19:54

Sounds like you did ok all things considered. Wasn't criticising you just saying that qualifications do help with getting better paid jobs. That is what they are for after all. I've witnessed the repeated reception apprentices in my work place. The apprentices were usually much better and less lazy than the permanent staff. It was the other poster's professional at 18 story that seemed dubious.

Thanks, I did- it was hard work obviously but the career I’m in now has real prospects. I needed to get out from the abuse first in able to get here though and I can see why many people don’t come out of it okay. I don’t think anyone should be treated the way I was, and wish society would make it easier for future young people to survive and better themselves.