Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our economy infantilises young people

182 replies

HurryupwiththeteA · 10/12/2022 17:34

I’ve got a DS who’s 18 and I’ve been thinking a lot about this. I love history and learning about different time periods and when I think what some of the 18-25 year olds used to have vs now it’s stunning. Henry VIII became king when he was 18. Slightly more realistically, up until not so many years ago young people were able to move out, get jobs that actually pay money you can live on, get married, have children, etc. I know some can especially closer to 25 but for many that’s simply not a reality.

Today minimum wage jobs (which are absolutely necessary and often quite skilled) are simply not enough to live on meaning that for many they feel their only option is university.

The student loan system requires you to be dependent on your parents (especially if they earn more) as the maintenance grant simply will not cover living expenses and (back to my last point) they’re only option is minimum wage will does not pay.

After graduating in most areas home ownership is not realistic given the exorbitant cost. This leaves them with the option of living at home for many years to try and save up (or rent and most likely never be able to afford a house deposit).

Because they don’t have their own place, relationships are often either causal hookups or quite short lived. This means that marriage or children if usually out of the question until they are much older.

Many other things such as being treated like they’re not really adults by older people, being marketed crap they don’t need keeping them in the rat race, calls to raise the age to smoke, so many other things.

Sadly I think the answers to these problems just aren’t going to happen. Major house building, distressing the importance of degrees for jobs that simply don’t need them, making the minimum wage enough to actually live on, controls on rent, stopping interest on student loans and raising the repayment threshold. None of these will ever happen, for political reasons, but frankly they should.

Aibu to think that young adults (18-25) are pretty infantilised today. It seems like 25 is the new 18 and until your mid 20s now society often still sees you as a child. Furthermore, Aibu to think this

OP posts:
TodayIsFridayHooray · 11/12/2022 09:17

Peedoffo · 11/12/2022 02:06

YANBU someone was calling Meghan and Harry young they are middle aged ffs.

Yes, but they act about 13. And I simply can't get my head around the fact that Meghan is in her 40s and already been married once, Harry is approaching 40, and they have children. They just seem to act like such teenagers. They really don't seem like proper grown ups!

containsnuts · 11/12/2022 09:15

doorheckk · 11/12/2022 08:47

I worked with someone age 25 who's dad pack her lunch for her. She was annoyed he put in the wrong flavour yoghurt. I was like..

you think this is representative of a whole generation?

The fact that it's acceptable to be like that is representative. How would that person have been viewed in the past? Not able to make a sandwhich at age 25 they'd have been institutionalised.

Eleganz · 11/12/2022 09:05

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 18:20

Well then it’s on those doing the apprenticeship to research whether the qualification is worth it.

I agree many businesses are going down the apprentice route for cheap labour, but anyone with a few brain cells can see through it.

And the taxpayer just gets to foot the bill for this exploitation then. Apprenticeships are funded in part by public money.

We've had a long time of pandering to unscrupulous employers who will always claim it is too expensive to pay people properly. Under Tony Blair it was tax credits which were just a subsidy for companies that paid too little dressed up as a benefit and now under the Tories we just have the normalisation of poverty wages, wage stagnation and attempts at union busting.

The problem is that without any disposable income in the working population the whole economy suffers. People don't buy goods and services. The Tories have been pretending to be baffled by the lack of productivity in the country when the low wage, low ambition, low investment economy is what they are creating.

TodayIsFridayHooray · 11/12/2022 09:01

XelaM · 11/12/2022 00:34

This was also my experience of teaching at a university. I couldn't take some of the "problems" the students had seriously 😳 It was ridiculous how many wanted to defer exams because of "anxiety". I mean, everyone gets anxious about taking exams. It's a pretty normal feeling. How will constant deferring help that?

And this was my experience of teaching at a university too. A load of babied, entitled kids that wanted everything (I mean basically and literally the answers to an upcoming exam) handed to them on a plate. They had no clue how to stand on their own two feet. Most complained massively about group work and several refused to participate in group exercises. A lot would refuse to give a presentation because they 'dont like presentations'. They moaned about absolutely everything (I think them paying the fees for uni now has contributed to their sense of entitlement and really not helped - it was like babies demanding gold plated milk because they are paying for it.) So sad to watch the future workforce acting in this way - and the university I worked for pandered to it so they would get good student ratings in the league tables, and meet various targets, and keep the money coming in.

IneedanewTV · 11/12/2022 08:57

It’s all he did, she did about the youngsters.

I know so many elderly people who retired from BA, GPS, teachers, local govt, banks, BP, BT, insurance companies in their early 50s on a final salary. Ok they started working at 16 for a lump of coal but they still worked less than 40 years.

generations now will be working more than 40 years for a crap pension to be honest. Even the public sector pensions are crap now with all of the changes that have been made. why would anyone want to rush into adulthood? Huge mortgages, a govt that wants to erode our rights, pay rapidly falling behind inflation. Looks great!

TodayIsFridayHooray · 11/12/2022 08:54

TheLostNights · 10/12/2022 18:39

Well it's a lot harder now to find affordable housing and then lets factor in cost of living etc. Back in the 80's, early 90's, it was do-able to move into your own flat at 19 and the cost of everything was cheaper then it is now. It was much easier to make your own way then it is now.

I was 19 in the 90s. Me and most of my friends were in house shares at that age. I progressed to bedsit with shared bathroom at 21.

I managed to form a relationship when I lived in rented accomodation (I think the suggestion by OP that you need your own place to have a partner is a bit ridiculous!) We moved in to a rented property together and stayed a few years. We finally bought our own place after the birth of baby number 1, when I was mid 30s.

I don't think owning your own property has ever been, or should ever be, a given for young people. There is simply not enough time to earn the money, and we should be learning to save for things when young, and aspire to things, not just have everything handed to us.

I loved my rented places, house shares, bedsits. It's part of being young and the process of getting older ...

SD1978 · 11/12/2022 08:53

Yup. Just seeing some of the threads on her of parents with children 17+ wanting to call managers because they don't think their child's being treated fairly, etc shows that 18 is the new 14.....

JackTorrance · 11/12/2022 08:52

I think basically from 18 it's time to be an adult. With a bit of leeway given till maybe 20/21 as it's all very new.
I think that bit of research, as interesting as it was, about brain development up to age 25, has been latched onto and poorly understood by laypeople.

Scotland, when it comes to criminal sentencing guidelines, considers under 25s "young people" and they serve lesser sentences. The thought of a 24 year old man receiving a lesser sentence because he's considered not a grown-up is frankly ridiculous.

MintJulia · 11/12/2022 08:51

doorheckk · 11/12/2022 08:31

I also paid NI during my 16th, 17th and 18th years because I worked all the holidays. I had my 35 years NI paid by 56 so I can retire if necessary.

You won't get your state pension at 56 though!

Also that's not unusual, I paid NI since 17 & throughout uni, the contributions needed were pretty small. You don't stop paying after 35 years of contributions.

I realise all of that, but I don't have to earn more years NI now if I can find a way to support myself. Dsd has no choice but to work to 65 because she wasted the first 10 years. I just think she was very badly advised.

Changeyncchange · 11/12/2022 08:50

There is a lot of anecdotal stuff in here about lazy, entitled young adults. I want to throw in my own anecdotal observation. Older parents are to blame. I was a young mum and a lot of my DCs peers had older parents, they were all infantalised and generally spoiled. I was baffled at some of the shit they got away with and the things they were bought. I noticed that that the common thread among their spoiled peers was the age of the parent

doorheckk · 11/12/2022 08:47

I worked with someone age 25 who's dad pack her lunch for her. She was annoyed he put in the wrong flavour yoghurt. I was like..

you think this is representative of a whole generation?

containsnuts · 11/12/2022 08:42

JudgeJ · 10/12/2022 19:09

So true, I still recall the poster who thought her son wasn't an adult at 25! When I was teaching I used to be annoyed at parents who involved them selves in their children's Work Experience, driving them there when it's on a bus route, calling school or the WE provider to complain that their youngster didn't like what they were doing. No matter how often we tried to explain that part of the exercise was the pupil sorting their own minor problems they still wanted them to be babied. One mother insisted that I find out about the bus he would need to take, I told her it was the one that stopped outside his house!

I worked with someone age 25 who's dad pack her lunch for her. She was annoyed he put in the wrong flavour yoghurt. I was like...

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/12/2022 08:37

Could not agree more OP- it’s also insulting when much older generations throw it in their faces “well I had two kids and two mortgages by 24”-
“I worked full time when my children were 1” good for you, you had a hell of an easy time of it didn’t you? They honestly think it’s down to them rather than the luck of the society you grew up in.

MarshaBradyo · 11/12/2022 08:36

Comparing at age Ds is now he is doing more than we did. At 17 we didn’t have casual jobs but he does plus his friends.

doorheckk · 11/12/2022 08:32

Really, anyone young now should get the fuck out of here if they have any kind of skillset at all. The UK has very little to offer them even when they work hard.

i agree with this.

doorheckk · 11/12/2022 08:31

I also paid NI during my 16th, 17th and 18th years because I worked all the holidays. I had my 35 years NI paid by 56 so I can retire if necessary.

You won't get your state pension at 56 though!

Also that's not unusual, I paid NI since 17 & throughout uni, the contributions needed were pretty small. You don't stop paying after 35 years of contributions.

Peedoffo · 11/12/2022 02:06

YANBU someone was calling Meghan and Harry young they are middle aged ffs.

Kissmybaubles · 11/12/2022 02:00

Yes I completely agree. I’m 30 and still treated like a child by my entire family. It’s very frustrating, but ultimately comes from the fact I have never been able to be financially independent (all minimum wage jobs despite working lots of hours). I have accepted that I’m viewed as and always will be viewed as a ‘dependent’. I’m now dependent on DH… I’m aware if ever my relationship was to fail I would be basically screwed…

Fuck the broken system we have to live in 😢

BirdyWoof · 11/12/2022 01:40

MintJulia · 11/12/2022 01:25

@BirdyWoof I'm glad I'm not the only one finding them difficult. I've just had to fire someone who could not get it into her head that work starts at 9. We wfh four days a week. She only had to roll out of bed and switch on her PC. In fact she could stay in bed if she turned off her camera.

Instead she logged on at 9.45, she turned up for a 9.30 meeting in the office at 11.58, and (the final straw) phoned me 10 mins before another meeting to admit she was still in Spain after her weekend because she couldn't get a flight - except this was Thursday.

Now I'm trying to recruit a replacement and 1 in 4 applicants doesn't show up for interview. I'm genuinely puzzled. We're paying £35k to start so it's not peanuts. I've found a candidate who is early 40s and seems a better bet. I can't afford another failure.

@MintJulia much of what you’ve said is exactly what my colleagues are dealing with in other departments in regards to hiring staff as well (in a role that is suited for young adults)

Job ads go up, and then you check out who’s applied. Say 10 have applied for a full time role-

  • 3 of them don’t meet the criteria in any way and clearly haven’t read the JD
  • 7 of them do so you invite them to interview, where 4 don’t show up at all
  • out of the 3 remaining, two interview awfully to the point where you can’t offer them a job
  • you then are left with 1 candidate, and then it’s a 50:50 chance on whether they’ll even accept the role or show up for their induction.

It’s utterly depressing.

I also agree with you on them not showing up on time as well. One of ours never checks their shift patterns so you always get a text asking “when am I working next?”

This drives me up the wall. The rotas are available online and paper copies are printed out and left in the communal area 3 weeks in advance. Yet you still need me, or another member of management, to essentially be your PA. Again, I blame this on the parents who clearly give them 0 responsibilities at home.

MintJulia · 11/12/2022 01:25

@BirdyWoof I'm glad I'm not the only one finding them difficult. I've just had to fire someone who could not get it into her head that work starts at 9. We wfh four days a week. She only had to roll out of bed and switch on her PC. In fact she could stay in bed if she turned off her camera.

Instead she logged on at 9.45, she turned up for a 9.30 meeting in the office at 11.58, and (the final straw) phoned me 10 mins before another meeting to admit she was still in Spain after her weekend because she couldn't get a flight - except this was Thursday.

Now I'm trying to recruit a replacement and 1 in 4 applicants doesn't show up for interview. I'm genuinely puzzled. We're paying £35k to start so it's not peanuts. I've found a candidate who is early 40s and seems a better bet. I can't afford another failure.

Honper · 11/12/2022 01:23

I don't think it infantilises them. I think it gives them very few choices though and also leaves them ripe for exploitation of all sorts.

For every five young people who have the "infantilising" safety net of a secure parental home for when they just aren't able to support themselves short term, there's at least one whose family life is a disaster - if not emotionally abusive then just without enough money coming in to do that. And those young people are, quite frankly, screwed, because they get shit insecure work that buys them shit insecure substandard housing and they can't afford bills and food.

Really, anyone young now should get the fuck out of here if they have any kind of skillset at all. The UK has very little to offer them even when they work hard.

BirdyWoof · 11/12/2022 01:21

MintJulia · 11/12/2022 01:08

I don't think you need to look back as far as Henry VIII.

I went to university at 18. I wasn't expected to live at home again. I managed my own money - no contribution from parents - and had no further support. I spent 3 years in a bedsit, graduated, got a job, saved up by never going out or spending anything, and bought a dump of a flat at 24. Grim but by 25 I was on my feet. I also paid NI during my 16th, 17th and 18th years because I worked all the holidays. I had my 35 years NI paid by 56 so I can retire if necessary. I started paying into a private pension at 22.

My dsd had two gap years, a year at uni, swapped courses and started again, another 3 years, then came home & bummed around for four years, then did PGCE and finally got a job just before her 30th birthday. It was ridiculous.

And will cause her issues in the long run because if she wants a full state pension, she now has to work to 65. Her teacher pension only started at 30. She was allowed to miss out on a decade of earnings.

Maybe a total withdrawal of support at 18 wasn't the best, but I'd rather that than be a perpetual child. My DS will always be welcome at home but I expect him to be financially independent at 21.

Your DSD didn’t have a single job until she was nearly 30? Or do you mean she had part time jobs that were NMW or similar before her teaching job?

Because if her teaching role is her first ever job then you’re totally right in that being utterly ridiculous.

I will always believe that every single 18 year old needs to have a customer facing job before they graduate university. Even if it’s only a few hours a week- it teaches you so much that university courses alone just can’t offer.

I think that’s also a big issue as well. Kids who go from their course in uni into a grad job and then have these grandiose expectations of what their role is as they’ve never experienced anything else before.

Anyone I’ve ever worked with who was a graduate who had never had another job, to this day, has always been a bit of an arsehole. Very fussy about what they want to do, not a team player, and struggles to cope when shit hits the fan. Always the first to pull out excuses as well, or blame others. Whereas colleagues who had those part time gigs tend to pull their weight and stay fairly calm and collected, and take responsibility for their work.

Sometimes it really is like night and day between them.

Florenz · 11/12/2022 01:15

I know of a mother who went mad at the people running her daughter's student accommodation because the igniter on the cooker had stopped working and they'd provided a box of matches for them to light it with until they got it fixed. She "didn't want her daughter playing with matches".

Parents really aren't doing their children any favours. The purpose of being a parent and having children is to produce fully formed, well-rounded adults. Not adult children who are reliant on their parents all their lives.

mathanxiety · 11/12/2022 01:12

My DCs (in the US) all started babysitting or doing odd jobs for money at about age 12-13. I've mentioned this here and got howls of horror in response. When they were 16 they got summer office jobs at the going rate for entry level work, using their babysitting clients for references, and kept up the babysitting during the school year.

It stands to reason that when employers can pay less for the work of a person under 18 or 21 or whatever, they'll have a workplace with a revolving door, and they'll laugh all the way to the bank - not sure why this is hard to understand?

MintJulia · 11/12/2022 01:08

I don't think you need to look back as far as Henry VIII.

I went to university at 18. I wasn't expected to live at home again. I managed my own money - no contribution from parents - and had no further support. I spent 3 years in a bedsit, graduated, got a job, saved up by never going out or spending anything, and bought a dump of a flat at 24. Grim but by 25 I was on my feet. I also paid NI during my 16th, 17th and 18th years because I worked all the holidays. I had my 35 years NI paid by 56 so I can retire if necessary. I started paying into a private pension at 22.

My dsd had two gap years, a year at uni, swapped courses and started again, another 3 years, then came home & bummed around for four years, then did PGCE and finally got a job just before her 30th birthday. It was ridiculous.

And will cause her issues in the long run because if she wants a full state pension, she now has to work to 65. Her teacher pension only started at 30. She was allowed to miss out on a decade of earnings.

Maybe a total withdrawal of support at 18 wasn't the best, but I'd rather that than be a perpetual child. My DS will always be welcome at home but I expect him to be financially independent at 21.

Swipe left for the next trending thread