Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our economy infantilises young people

182 replies

HurryupwiththeteA · 10/12/2022 17:34

I’ve got a DS who’s 18 and I’ve been thinking a lot about this. I love history and learning about different time periods and when I think what some of the 18-25 year olds used to have vs now it’s stunning. Henry VIII became king when he was 18. Slightly more realistically, up until not so many years ago young people were able to move out, get jobs that actually pay money you can live on, get married, have children, etc. I know some can especially closer to 25 but for many that’s simply not a reality.

Today minimum wage jobs (which are absolutely necessary and often quite skilled) are simply not enough to live on meaning that for many they feel their only option is university.

The student loan system requires you to be dependent on your parents (especially if they earn more) as the maintenance grant simply will not cover living expenses and (back to my last point) they’re only option is minimum wage will does not pay.

After graduating in most areas home ownership is not realistic given the exorbitant cost. This leaves them with the option of living at home for many years to try and save up (or rent and most likely never be able to afford a house deposit).

Because they don’t have their own place, relationships are often either causal hookups or quite short lived. This means that marriage or children if usually out of the question until they are much older.

Many other things such as being treated like they’re not really adults by older people, being marketed crap they don’t need keeping them in the rat race, calls to raise the age to smoke, so many other things.

Sadly I think the answers to these problems just aren’t going to happen. Major house building, distressing the importance of degrees for jobs that simply don’t need them, making the minimum wage enough to actually live on, controls on rent, stopping interest on student loans and raising the repayment threshold. None of these will ever happen, for political reasons, but frankly they should.

Aibu to think that young adults (18-25) are pretty infantilised today. It seems like 25 is the new 18 and until your mid 20s now society often still sees you as a child. Furthermore, Aibu to think this

OP posts:
AndEverWhoKnew · 11/12/2022 12:45

It's not the fault of the economy. I had a job as soon as I could ie whilst at school. I worked my way through uni. When I graduated, I went where I could get work and lived in shared flats until I could save a deposit for a mortgage.
There have always been marketing companies pushing rubbish. You need to take responsibility for your own choices and purchases. Young adults are infantilising themselves.
Yes, we need more social housing. Yes, we need an end to zero hours contracts. Yes, London needs to stop allowing a market that has priced out locals. But even with all those changes, young people need to stop acting like children and expecting everything all at once. Real life isn't social media.

R0ckPaperCat · 11/12/2022 12:45

"You won't get a state pension at 56"

The earliest that I can access my private pension is 55
Although, I believe that the rules are changing for younger people, I believe that the age is increasing

doorheckk · 11/12/2022 12:33

isn't life expectancy reducing despite moving out the pension age?

JackTorrance · 11/12/2022 12:21

Yes, infant mortality brought the average age way way down, but once you did survive into adulthood you weren't going to randomly drop at 35, especially if you were male and didn't have the risks of childbirth (which also impacted on the average age).

latetothefisting · 11/12/2022 12:13

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/12/2022 11:19

I think the average age amongst common people was about 35 in the 16th century.

People had to grow up fast.

what do you mean by "average age"? Do you mean life expectancy? If so that's only because of the infant mortality rate, throughout most of history, if children survived to adulthood they didn't die much earlier on average than we do.
"From 1200 to 1745, 21-year-olds would reach an average age of anywhere between 62 and 70 years." (exeptions being during periods like the black death)

Why do people regurgitate half remembered facts without taking a second to google them to check they are right?

lljkk · 11/12/2022 12:03

DS's digs technically have parking spaces outside, and most rooms at his Uni are en-suite. DS has neither car nor desire to have en suite. He's 6'2" and we did pay extra to get him a larger bed.

FelicityFlops · 11/12/2022 11:59

I agree with you PP, although I would argue that this is not happening in all social demographics.
A PP mentioned something about longer life expectancy, but I do not believe this generation will benefit. People of the late Queen's generation and of my parents' generation are the ones whose longer life expectancy has put a squeeze on resources.
My generation (late 1950s to mid 1960s) are also more likely to live longer, but look at the issues facing the next in line. I do not believe the vast majority will make ancient bones.

doorheckk · 11/12/2022 11:58

today we were looking at en suite uni rooms with parking - I mean wtf????

were they free?

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/12/2022 11:57

MaPaSpa · 11/12/2022 11:55

In a lot of places in my area a room rental is between 1000-1500 a month.

most young people do not live alone and have probably never.

Exactly - people have no idea the cost of rent. My friends stayed at home until 30- why- because their parents wanted them to save £1k a month on a deposit rather than waste on rent. This means bills etc are new to them come 30- the system is a mess.

MaPaSpa · 11/12/2022 11:55

TeenDivided · 10/12/2022 18:25

After graduating in most areas home ownership is not realistic given the exorbitant cost. This leaves them with the option of living at home for many years to try and save up (or rent and most likely never be able to afford a house deposit).
Because they don’t have their own place, relationships are often either causal hookups or quite short lived. This means that marriage or children if usually out of the question until they are much older.

I disagree with most of this.

In my generation (graduated in the 80s) I think it was pretty common for young people to house/flat-share. I really get the feeling that these days people seem to 'want their own space' and not be so willing to flat share including bathroom / kitchen share with others.

And I really don't see why not having your own place means you can't develop relationships. OK not have children, but no reason for making relationships short lived.

In a lot of places in my area a room rental is between 1000-1500 a month.

most young people do not live alone and have probably never.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 11/12/2022 11:50

IneedanewTV · 10/12/2022 19:45

I was thinking this today as I took my son to a uni open day. My parents in the 80s didn’t take me to uni open days - not sure they were even a thing for first generation uni students. On my first day at uni I caught the coach with my bag and went to a new city 100s of miles away to a room in lodgings with a family.

today we were looking at en suite uni rooms with parking - I mean wtf???? Not sure if they are enfantised or spoilt to be honest,

Neither of my uni age children have en suites or parking spaces. Shared grotty bathrooms and tiny kitchens all the way.

I can say the reason I’ve driven them is cost. For ds2 to get to uni by train it’s over £100 for a single. A coach is half the price but it’s 14 hrs. Nearly 3 times the time it takes me to drive them and I can visit my parents en route. It didn’t cost me nearly that amount to travel long distances when I was young.

doorheckk · 11/12/2022 11:34

I agree, don’t think there was ever a time you could buy a house straight after graduating. But now there seems an expectation that one should be able to do this.

who on earth expects to buy straight after graduation?

Kabalagala · 11/12/2022 11:30

KimberleyClark · 11/12/2022 11:27

In my generation (graduated in the 80s) I think it was pretty common for young people to house/flat-share. I really get the feeling that these days people seem to 'want their own space' and not be so willing to flat share including bathroom / kitchen share with others.

I agree, don’t think there was ever a time you could buy a house straight after graduating. But now there seems an expectation that one should be able to do this. As you say people used to flat/house share or live in bedsits with shared facilities.

Lol. Yeah there was. My parents bought with 100% literally weeks after they graduated. As did many of their peers.

KimberleyClark · 11/12/2022 11:27

In my generation (graduated in the 80s) I think it was pretty common for young people to house/flat-share. I really get the feeling that these days people seem to 'want their own space' and not be so willing to flat share including bathroom / kitchen share with others.

I agree, don’t think there was ever a time you could buy a house straight after graduating. But now there seems an expectation that one should be able to do this. As you say people used to flat/house share or live in bedsits with shared facilities.

RouletteWheelerDealer1 · 11/12/2022 11:20

"I paid NI during my 16th, 17th and 18th years because I worked all the holidays. I had my 35 years NI paid by 50s so I can retire if necessary."

I have done the same

The paid work & volunteering that I started in my teens was the making of me & led to so many opportunities & meeting different people.

My older relatives left school at 14, 15 with no higher education. I completed a degree, then started earning a better wage.

I think that some young people have greater expectations; like not sharing accommodation, gap years, not working, less respect, poor time keeping, entitlement (but not everyone)

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/12/2022 11:19

I think the average age amongst common people was about 35 in the 16th century.

People had to grow up fast.

JackTorrance · 11/12/2022 11:17

@Saracen excellent article, fascinating, and clarifies absolutely what I've suspected for some time about the erroneous conclusion/overstatement of the "brains don't mature till 25" thing that I see constantly trotted out on here to excuse all sorts of immaturity and over-protective parenting.

I agree that in most societies, including ours until recently, the teens were a time of learning from adults when the brain is most adept and quickly absorbing that knowledge, and it was also a time of learning and taking on greater adult responsibilities.

Saracen · 11/12/2022 11:06

OP, you may enjoy this article about the capabilities of young people. It echoes some of the things you are saying: www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-myth-of-the-teen-brain/

Chattycathydoll · 11/12/2022 10:33

TodayIsFridayHooray · 11/12/2022 08:54

I was 19 in the 90s. Me and most of my friends were in house shares at that age. I progressed to bedsit with shared bathroom at 21.

I managed to form a relationship when I lived in rented accomodation (I think the suggestion by OP that you need your own place to have a partner is a bit ridiculous!) We moved in to a rented property together and stayed a few years. We finally bought our own place after the birth of baby number 1, when I was mid 30s.

I don't think owning your own property has ever been, or should ever be, a given for young people. There is simply not enough time to earn the money, and we should be learning to save for things when young, and aspire to things, not just have everything handed to us.

I loved my rented places, house shares, bedsits. It's part of being young and the process of getting older ...

Yes, this is how it should be, so no wonder you look on it with nostalgia.

However rents are so staggeringly high now that it is often impossible to save adequately to buy. Once people begin renting, they are trapped in the cycle of spending the vast majority of their pay on unstable housing. It’s savvy to stay with parents until you can buy, not immature or entitled. It’s virtually impossible to buy a house without family input now, be it help with the deposit or years spent saving in the family home.

Which is not to say that all young adults who stay at home are being savvy, but that once you begin renting privately it’s painfully difficult to extricate yourself.

Iam4eels · 11/12/2022 10:32

It really was not the norm for most girls to be getting married and having children at 12/13 - that was nearly only the most aristocratic families. The majority of women throughout history didn't marry until their mid 20s on average.

And even then 12/13, was considered at the very young end of the scale and those married at that age generally wouldn't live with their husband or share his bed. They'd either stay with their parents or would live in some appropriate place in their husband's household such as with his parents. 15-16 was more acceptable and consummation almost never took place prior to around age 14 for health reasons (outliers excepted).

The whole Maragaret Beaufort situation was shocking even by standards of the time.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 11/12/2022 10:30

I love history and learning about different time periods and when I think what some of the 18-25 year olds used to have vs now it’s stunning. Henry VIII became king when he was 18

I sometimes think about this OP. But in reverse. Today our political leadership are people in their 60's.

In the past, as you say, political leaders may have been men in their 20's or 30's.
Different perspective, greater levels of testosterone, perhaps more to prove. I sometimes wonder how things might have played out differently if older people had made some of the key decisions in history.

In the Cuban missile crisis; John F Kennedy was 45. Nikita Kruschev was 68. It was Kruschev who made the first move to deescalate.

"We and you ought not to pull on the ends of a rope which you have tied the knots of war. Because the more the two of us pull, the tighter the knot will be tied. And then it is necessary to cut that knot, and what that means is not for me to explain to you. I have participated in two wars and know that war ends when it has rolled through cities and villages, everywhere sowing death and destruction. For such is the logic of war. If people do not display wisdom, they will clash like blind moles and then mutual annihilation will commence"

That's very much the perspective of an older man.

Nsenene · 11/12/2022 10:16

It's deliberate though isn't it? In the same vein as the education system entirely discouraging independent thought. Good little wage slaves who will fight for nothing.

doorheckk · 11/12/2022 09:58

good article today in the Times about what younger generations face.

"Since the 2008 recession there has been very little increase in real earnings, meaning that millennials and Gen Zers are seeing much less income growth in their working lives than previous generations,” said Tom Wernham from the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS)."

"Houses are more unaffordable than at any time since 1880, according to Schroders."
"In 1972 the average monthly mortgage payment for someone with a 25 per cent deposit was £46 (about £500 at today’s prices) compared with £1,395 today, the estate agency Hamptons said."

HollyHobbie12 · 11/12/2022 09:50

Even rent is crazy round our way so no, it isn't easy to just move out especially if you are a single person on NMW or with health issues.
Of course it was more do-able back in the 80's/90's.
Some very judgemental responses on here. I know plenty of older people who act like kids and who are terrible to work with. I also know a 40 something who lives at home and at times gets a lift into work. She has RA and it's just a supportive thing that a family member can do for her at the end of a long day. She's our hardest worker and liked by everyone. We don't always know what's going on in someone's life.

Namenic · 11/12/2022 09:41

I wonder whether the structure of society and education have contributed?

Nowadays companies don’t seem to want to train people while employed. Which is why the govt subsidises apprenticeships. In the past, people would move job less often, so it made sense for companies to train people. I guess it is a chicken and egg - people are mobile so can switch job easily, so companies don’t want to invest in training…

a lot of the training is then placed on the education sector - which is different. You also have the requirement for people to be in full time education or training until 18. Even though it might be possible to start apprenticeships at 16, I think many people do it post-18. I don’t really think this benefits everyone. I agree that gcse/a-level English, maths and science courses plus btecs should be available (via day and evening classes) and free for those 16-25 - but some people need to do a job before taking those qualifications (because then they understand why they are important and put in more effort).