Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our economy infantilises young people

182 replies

HurryupwiththeteA · 10/12/2022 17:34

I’ve got a DS who’s 18 and I’ve been thinking a lot about this. I love history and learning about different time periods and when I think what some of the 18-25 year olds used to have vs now it’s stunning. Henry VIII became king when he was 18. Slightly more realistically, up until not so many years ago young people were able to move out, get jobs that actually pay money you can live on, get married, have children, etc. I know some can especially closer to 25 but for many that’s simply not a reality.

Today minimum wage jobs (which are absolutely necessary and often quite skilled) are simply not enough to live on meaning that for many they feel their only option is university.

The student loan system requires you to be dependent on your parents (especially if they earn more) as the maintenance grant simply will not cover living expenses and (back to my last point) they’re only option is minimum wage will does not pay.

After graduating in most areas home ownership is not realistic given the exorbitant cost. This leaves them with the option of living at home for many years to try and save up (or rent and most likely never be able to afford a house deposit).

Because they don’t have their own place, relationships are often either causal hookups or quite short lived. This means that marriage or children if usually out of the question until they are much older.

Many other things such as being treated like they’re not really adults by older people, being marketed crap they don’t need keeping them in the rat race, calls to raise the age to smoke, so many other things.

Sadly I think the answers to these problems just aren’t going to happen. Major house building, distressing the importance of degrees for jobs that simply don’t need them, making the minimum wage enough to actually live on, controls on rent, stopping interest on student loans and raising the repayment threshold. None of these will ever happen, for political reasons, but frankly they should.

Aibu to think that young adults (18-25) are pretty infantilised today. It seems like 25 is the new 18 and until your mid 20s now society often still sees you as a child. Furthermore, Aibu to think this

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsSkylerWhite · 13/12/2022 11:36

entropynow · Yesterday 10:40
MrsSkylerWhite · Yesterday 09:05
Dr Ramirez was no doubt talking about life expectancy at birth and as you say yourself your recollection is faulty.

“How about "sorry, my error" instead of this passive aggressive nonsense?“

not sure I’m the passive aggressive person here, you sound quite cross.

Dr. Ramirez. That’s it, thanks. Like her, knows her stuff.

have a nice day.
More pass agg ( 'have a nice day'? That it?) . I care about history and the facts. You are wrong. Deal with it“

Ok. You really need to calm down. Such anger with an irrelevant someone not as knowledgeable as you really isn’t good for your life expectancy.

I meant have a nice day. Hope you do.

potniatheron · 13/12/2022 11:17

Everyone's infantilised now. When this current cold snap began, BBC News had a headline and major segment telling people to heat their living rooms during the day and their bedrooms at night. This was a SEGMENT, with the newsreader interviewing an expert and everything. On the NEWS. I was utterly flabbergasted.

At this rate, the six o clock news will soon be headlined with segments suggesting that it's a good idea to eat food two or three times a day and to cover the soles of our feet when going outside.

The rolling 24 hours updates on what a good idea it is to oxygenate our blood by inflating our lungs can surely not be far behind.

SleeplessInEngland · 13/12/2022 11:06

SofiaSoFar · 13/12/2022 11:03

"...every bit of green space built on..." is a stretch, given that the vast majority of land in the UK is undeveloped.

From Fullfact: "29% is pastures, 27% is non-irrigated arable land (or land where crops are planted), 24% is forest and other natural land (such as beaches or moors), and 11% is wetlands."

That's 91% of land being, essentially, 'green'.

And boring, unused fields at that. If it were lush forests I'd understand the (still wrong) assumption, at least they're econologically diverse.

SofiaSoFar · 13/12/2022 11:03

barneshome · 12/12/2022 10:59

No the problem has been mass immigration
I do not want every bit of green space built on
Insects and animals have lived here for years - they have the right not to have their homes destroyed

"...every bit of green space built on..." is a stretch, given that the vast majority of land in the UK is undeveloped.

From Fullfact: "29% is pastures, 27% is non-irrigated arable land (or land where crops are planted), 24% is forest and other natural land (such as beaches or moors), and 11% is wetlands."

That's 91% of land being, essentially, 'green'.

sashh · 13/12/2022 04:37

I think a lot of parents don't see their children as young adults. I was desperate to be independent at 16, my brother is two years older and was quite happy to be babied.

A few years ago I pulled a friend up, she'd come round for dinner with her son and when the food was on the table she picked up the salt and pepper, seasoned her own food and then her son's.

He was 20!

autienotnaughty · 13/12/2022 03:11

My sister grew up in the 80's left school at 16 , did an apprenticeship (although I think it had a different name) moved out at 23. I grew up in 90's left school at 18 and moved out at 19. My dd grew up in00's left uni at 21 and moved out at 21.

mathanxiety · 13/12/2022 02:32

@unlimiteddilutingjuice

Nikita Khruschev's words are well worth repeating.

However, it's worth pointing out that most of the key players throughout history (at least in the modern era) have been old or at least middle aged men. JFK was unusually young for a President.

ILoveeCakes · 12/12/2022 20:15

Soothsayer1 · 12/12/2022 11:03

I agree, imo much of it is about using them as cash cows, stopping them from becoming properly adult is a way of keeping them subservient and obedient so they can be manipulated according to the interests of those in power

Getting them into massive debt at age 18 (uni) being an example of how they can then be controlled and kept down - and without even the perks of having a house, which is what you used to get if you took on £50k of debt!

NoelNoNoel · 12/12/2022 17:31

e tell them to drift into uni to do courses whete they have six hours contact time a week, they sit around halls most of the other time essentially playing. Its not healthy. Compare that to a 19 year old getting out there in the world of work
I think uni is a good idea, youngsters will have enough years to work as it is, what’s the rush?

Allsnotwell · 12/12/2022 17:19

Nothing to do with parents over praising and them believing they could do anything? Then they find out the world doesn’t owe them and they have to work at it?

rudolphrainbownose · 12/12/2022 15:53

I completely agree OP, and I think the mass rise in mental health crisis in young people is cos of the drifting that is actively encouraged in adults under 30.

We tell young people to delay getting married until their late twenties minimum, so we essentially tell them not to take relationships seriously in their early 20s.

We tell them to drift into uni to do courses whete they have six hours contact time a week, they sit around halls most of the other time essentially playing. Its not healthy. Compare that to a 19 year old getting out there in the world of work.

We actively encourage too much drifting which is bad for mental health imo.

Soothsayer1 · 12/12/2022 11:08

barneshome · 12/12/2022 10:59

No the problem has been mass immigration
I do not want every bit of green space built on
Insects and animals have lived here for years - they have the right not to have their homes destroyed

I'm inclined to see mass immigration as another of the governments 'blunt instruments'.... It's a way of keeping us riled up stressed and angry so that we are easier to manipulate, while we are all stressed and angry it's difficult for us to think logically and in a nuanced way about problems

Oliotya · 12/12/2022 11:05

barneshome · 12/12/2022 10:59

No the problem has been mass immigration
I do not want every bit of green space built on
Insects and animals have lived here for years - they have the right not to have their homes destroyed

Immigration has been entirely necessary due to falling birth rates and a rising dependency ratio. We can't fund all the pensions and run the NHS and care system without migration.
I also assume anyone complaining about house building has 1. Not had kids, 2. Is not under occupying their house. Otherwise it's pure hypocrisy.

Soothsayer1 · 12/12/2022 11:03

ILoveeCakes · 10/12/2022 18:12

A lot of people have a lot of vested interest in keeping people infantilised as long as possible.

Companies paying them less, bloating higher education systems selling them expensive courses and plenty else I'm sure.

I agree, imo much of it is about using them as cash cows, stopping them from becoming properly adult is a way of keeping them subservient and obedient so they can be manipulated according to the interests of those in power

barneshome · 12/12/2022 10:59

Blip · 12/12/2022 09:05

YANBU
There is a conspiracy in government and has been for decades now not to build enough homes for our population.

This is due to vested interests of the powerful in keeping house prices high. It's a tragedy for young people, ditto the huge number of unnecessary degrees and making so many jobs require a degree just as a way of sorting the applications.

No the problem has been mass immigration
I do not want every bit of green space built on
Insects and animals have lived here for years - they have the right not to have their homes destroyed

barneshome · 12/12/2022 10:58

I think the reason that many people in their mid 20s are regarded as children is precisely because they are childish
The dean of Durham uni said in an interview that 20 year ago when people arrived at Uni they were young adults but most are now still children
That said I know a lot on the mid 20s who are buying theor own home
They have well paid jobs from stockbroker to electrician and did not wats 4 years and get a 50k debt studying sociology or humanities which are worthless in the work place

entropynow · 12/12/2022 10:40

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 09:05

Dr Ramirez was no doubt talking about life expectancy at birth and as you say yourself your recollection is faulty.

“How about "sorry, my error" instead of this passive aggressive nonsense?“

not sure I’m the passive aggressive person here, you sound quite cross.

Dr. Ramirez. That’s it, thanks. Like her, knows her stuff.

have a nice day.

More pass agg ( 'have a nice day'? That it?) . I care about history and the facts. You are wrong. Deal with it.

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 09:29

“Lol, sorry... just read back my response, sounds arsey, wasn't meant to.“

No worries, BeyondMyWits, not taken as arsey at all. Actually realised you had made a very fair point!

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 09:05

Dr Ramirez was no doubt talking about life expectancy at birth and as you say yourself your recollection is faulty.

“How about "sorry, my error" instead of this passive aggressive nonsense?“

not sure I’m the passive aggressive person here, you sound quite cross.

Dr. Ramirez. That’s it, thanks. Like her, knows her stuff.

have a nice day.

Blip · 12/12/2022 09:05

YANBU
There is a conspiracy in government and has been for decades now not to build enough homes for our population.

This is due to vested interests of the powerful in keeping house prices high. It's a tragedy for young people, ditto the huge number of unnecessary degrees and making so many jobs require a degree just as a way of sorting the applications.

entropynow · 12/12/2022 08:56

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 07:18

latetothefisting · Yesterday 12:13
MrsSkylerWhite · Yesterday 11:19
I think the average age amongst common people was about 35 in the 16th century.

People had to grow up fast.
what do you mean by "average age"? Do you mean life expectancy? If so that's only because of the infant mortality rate, throughout most of history, if children survived to adulthood they didn't die much earlier on average than we do.

"From 1200 to 1745, 21-year-olds would reach an average age of anywhere between 62 and 70 years." (exeptions being during periods like the black death)

Why do people regurgitate half remembered facts without taking a second to google them to check they are right?”

well that’s me told 🤣

im not an historian, you obviously are. The last person I heard regurgitating that half remembered fact was a TV historian, can’t remember her name, Dr. or Professor someone. Spanish name, black hair, very pale skin and bright red lipstick.
tbh, I didn’t feel the need to second guess her by googling. But hey, you know best 😃

Dr Ramirez was no doubt talking about life expectancy at birth and as you say yourself your recollection is faulty.
How about "sorry, my error" instead of this passive aggressive nonsense?

entropynow · 12/12/2022 08:52

Baconsprouts · 10/12/2022 18:27

It’s so tiring to see this trotted out.

Some peoples brains don’t fully develop until 25, some don’t fully develop until 40, some have developed at 18. It’s simply false to say the brain doesn’t fully mature until 25. Studies in Australia have seen the full development delayed until 40 and that’s only because that was their oldest cohort, there is no evidence there aren’t people who don’t fully develop neurologically until after 40.

The final elements to develop are also minor and make no difference in day to day life either

THANK YOU.
Far too much "we now know" pseudoscience trotted out on MN when what they actually mean is " I read it in a magazine or on MN once and it suits what I would like to believe"

BeyondMyWits · 12/12/2022 08:44

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 08:36

BeyondMyWits · Today 08:22
Does anyone care about life expectancy in the 1200s?

Really? when generalising about kids and young adults in 2022.“

Fair point 😁

Our youngest, 19, is studying for his degree, works on non-uni days and is pretty independent. Our eldest left home at 16 and 12 years on is a mother, married with her first (owned) home.

No infantilising young people here.

Lol, sorry... just read back my response, sounds arsey, wasn't meant to...

We don't infantilise ours either ... one at uni abroad (21), other (20) at UK uni... they sort themselves out.

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 08:36

BeyondMyWits · Today 08:22
Does anyone care about life expectancy in the 1200s?

Really? when generalising about kids and young adults in 2022.“

Fair point 😁

Our youngest, 19, is studying for his degree, works on non-uni days and is pretty independent. Our eldest left home at 16 and 12 years on is a mother, married with her first (owned) home.

No infantilising young people here.

BeyondMyWits · 12/12/2022 08:22

Does anyone care about life expectancy in the 1200s?

Really? when generalising about kids and young adults in 2022.

Swipe left for the next trending thread