Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Scientists Confirm Short Man Syndrome Is Real."

185 replies

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 10/12/2022 14:34

To think this is a strange finding:

www.menshealth.com/uk/health/a42175436/short-man-syndrome/

From my experience, this is not true. I have met many aggressive men short, medium height and very tall. I do not understand why men who are short are more likely to be aggressive it seems like quite a generalisation. By that logic, are short women also more aggressive.

I think "short" is also subjective. A 6 foot man can be seen as short for a 5 foot 10/11 women. A man who is 5 foot 6 is not necessarily short for a 5 foot 1 women. It is relative.

OP posts:
LuciferRising · 11/12/2022 12:14

jicora · 11/12/2022 11:50

Wonder if small man syndrome is like fat woman syndrome. Overweight women full of self loathing constantly asuming anyone who is a healthy weight must have an eating disorder. Walking around with a chip on their shoulders, blaming everyone and everything other than their selves.

Unpleasant. And no I don't think it is a thing.

Following the tone of the thread.

It isn't a great study. You can design these to prove many things.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 11/12/2022 12:11

The OP cited a scientific study. If you want to challenge it then feel free but look at things like their method, sample size etc. Challenging a scientific study with personal anecdotes is

mitsy5 · 11/12/2022 12:05

Of course not all “short” men are like this. But my DH is 6 ft 5, mild-mannered sort who keeps himself to himself and generally gets on with everyone. But once in a while at work, someone of considerably smaller stature will have an issue with him for no good reason. Or if out in the pub, minding his own business, someone will take offence to his height. We find it comical now really because it’s not like he can disguise it. Again, not saying this is every short man, but this is his experience.

Why is it acceptable to comment on someone’s height when they’re tall but seen as derogatory to call someone short. Had it with my DS when he was at primary - “oh my goodness, he’s so TALL, look at him!” Actually he wasn’t the tallest in has class by a long shot but because his dad is tall, people felt the need to comment. Never heard anyone say to the mum with the smaller son “oh my goodness he’s so SHORT, look at him, just like his dad” 🙄Kids will be what they’ll be, why do people feel the need to comment on their appearance. They can’t change their height either way.

KimberleyClark · 11/12/2022 11:58

There’s even a study that indicates tall men are more likely to cheat

illicitencounterspress.wordpress.com/2020/10/22/tall-men-are-more-likely-to-cheat/

Itisbetter · 11/12/2022 11:56

What a lot of bollocks

A man who is 5 foot 6 is not necessarily short for a 5 foot 1 women. It is relative.
and what nonsense is this?!!! You are either shorter or taller than the average man, it’s nothing to do with your partner. Dh is average height for his ethnicity which is shorter than the average uk man. I’m tall for a white British female…..aggression isn’t an issue

JaninaDuszejko · 11/12/2022 11:52

It's shite science performed to make money by selling the story to the gutter press who love this kind of thing. There are also studies that show that short men are less aggressive (news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6501633.stm) which frankly make more sense, it's dangerous to be aggressive when you are smaller than your opponent because they are stronger and can do you more harm.

You can also say short men have more stable marriages, live longer and have less chance of cancer and blood clots than tall men but nobody is going on about how tall men are shit husbands.

jicora · 11/12/2022 11:50

Wonder if small man syndrome is like fat woman syndrome. Overweight women full of self loathing constantly asuming anyone who is a healthy weight must have an eating disorder. Walking around with a chip on their shoulders, blaming everyone and everything other than their selves.

Unpleasant. And no I don't think it is a thing.

MeetPi · 11/12/2022 11:11

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/12/2022 10:58

Seems fairly widespread through the animal kingdom. Obviously there are exceptions but small animals can be very aggressive whilst larger ones are often very gentle.

What an odd comparison to make!

My DH is short - 5 5", and I'm just slightly taller than him. He isn't aggressive in any way and manages to be an executive leading over 1000 others in a male-dominated industry. I think he is concerned more about the perception others might have of him before they are better acquainted with him - like the stereotypes written here.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 11/12/2022 11:04

Thighlengthboots · 11/12/2022 10:24

So, are you saying that because short men have a hard time in dating, it’s acceptable for them to ask a tall woman out and then spend the entire relationship criticising them and putting them down for being tall?

No. I do not accept that at all. Having a hard time doesn’t give you carte Blanche to treat others like shit. That’s ridiculous. Plenty of people have difficult childhoods/ experiences- doesn’t then make it ok to take that out on others. It might be the reason but it’s not an excuse.

….are you sure you’re replying to the post you quoted? Because there appears to be no connection at all.

XanaduKira · 11/12/2022 11:04

Who knows @LuciferRising - maybe scientists will research that next & then there will be evidence to prove / disprove your assertion.

It's not something I've ever experienced thankfully.

phoenixrosehere · 11/12/2022 11:04

Changechangychange · 11/12/2022 10:52

Black men are frequently accused of “aggression” over interactions that could more accurately be described as “polite disagreement” - you must be aware of this?

Yes and that poster is forgetting the widely and heavily used term “black on black” crime yet no one says “white on white, Asian on Asian”, etc.. when all racial groups commit crimes against each other.

LuciferRising · 11/12/2022 11:01

HeleneLagonelle · 11/12/2022 10:32

Yup. I’m married to a 5 ft 3 man (who is professionally very successful and a well-balanced, laid-back character, from a family of lovely short people — very poor, probably linked to generations of poor nutrition as well as genetics) and mother to a short ten year old, who is a delight. We’re both working hard to instil confidence into DS, but he definitely hears a lot about his height already.

My DF is very successful. Mid 70s and earns a large wage part time. Had to put more effort in than others, but is very quietly spoken. He stayed away from the pissing competitions, and focused on the tasks.

Wonder if small man syndrome is like fat woman syndrome. Overweight women full of self loathing constantly asuming anyone who is a healthy weight must have an eating disorder. Walking around with a chip on their shoulders, blaming everyone and everything other than their selves.

gannett · 11/12/2022 11:01

XanaduKira · 11/12/2022 10:54

I absolutely have @gannett and I didn't say they couldn't be. All I did say was in a work context over the years, no tall man has physically aggressive & shouted at me, whereas quite a few short men have.

Thankfully I've never worked somewhere where I've been shouted at by anyone, but I have experienced tall and broad men trying to physically intimidate me in a supposedly professional setting.

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/12/2022 10:58

Seems fairly widespread through the animal kingdom. Obviously there are exceptions but small animals can be very aggressive whilst larger ones are often very gentle.

KimberleyClark · 11/12/2022 10:55

XanaduKira · 11/12/2022 10:54

I absolutely have @gannett and I didn't say they couldn't be. All I did say was in a work context over the years, no tall man has physically aggressive & shouted at me, whereas quite a few short men have.

As I said upthread I have been shouted at by a tall man at work. Never experienced anything like that from shorter men.

newnamethanks · 11/12/2022 10:55

Yes, real. Also small dog 'syndrome'. Smaller so everything, consciously or not, is that much more threatening. If it wasn't true (thanks scientists, have you nothing better to do?) It wouldn't be the familiar old cliche that it is.

XanaduKira · 11/12/2022 10:54

I absolutely have @gannett and I didn't say they couldn't be. All I did say was in a work context over the years, no tall man has physically aggressive & shouted at me, whereas quite a few short men have.

Changechangychange · 11/12/2022 10:52

Snufkinhastherightidea · 10/12/2022 18:58

Height is like skin colour, age and sex surely - something you cannot control and a very weird thing to be proud of. Old people, women and non-white people all have to cope with ill- treatment but we don’t say someone has angry black man syndrome.

Black men are frequently accused of “aggression” over interactions that could more accurately be described as “polite disagreement” - you must be aware of this?

PeaceJoySleep · 11/12/2022 10:45

@BringOnAutumn that is really sad, you can be surrounded by love and support but still be so hurt that the outside world judges you only by your appearance/height. I've been single almost all of my adult life and tbh have achieved more as a single person and was unsupported in relationships, so being single doesn't = unhappy. I think it's hardest when you're young though.

@Thighlengthboots no words, you read what @BringOnAutumn wrote and made it about a comment you had once 🙄

gannett · 11/12/2022 10:43

XanaduKira · 11/12/2022 09:33

This is my experience also. Tall men don't seem to have a point to prove whereas some of the short men I've known, have absolutely been aggressive & it's very much felt like they're trying to demonstrate just how tough & manly they are (toxic!)

Plenty of tall men are aggressive and intimidating. Ever been in a pub with a group of drunk burly rugby lads the size of mountains?

KimberleyClark · 11/12/2022 10:38

Thighlengthboots · 11/12/2022 10:24

So, are you saying that because short men have a hard time in dating, it’s acceptable for them to ask a tall woman out and then spend the entire relationship criticising them and putting them down for being tall?

No. I do not accept that at all. Having a hard time doesn’t give you carte Blanche to treat others like shit. That’s ridiculous. Plenty of people have difficult childhoods/ experiences- doesn’t then make it ok to take that out on others. It might be the reason but it’s not an excuse.

You seem to have extrapolated from your experience dating short men that they all behave like this. Of course it’s not acceptable but there are arseholes at every height.

Abhannmor · 11/12/2022 10:34

LikeTearsInRain · 10/12/2022 18:27

Yep for sure and same for bashing balding/bald guys. The joking, insults and saying they look like thugs.

Although balding / bald seems to be cooler these days. Maybe because it's more common? I watched an old football match from the 60s and was surprised at all the hirsute men!

Height anxiety is certainly a thing with women too. A friend told me she was always the tallest girl in her class - she is 5ft 8in. Now when she meets taller women she feels inadequate.

BringOnAutumn · 11/12/2022 10:33

HeleneLagonelle · 11/12/2022 10:32

Yup. I’m married to a 5 ft 3 man (who is professionally very successful and a well-balanced, laid-back character, from a family of lovely short people — very poor, probably linked to generations of poor nutrition as well as genetics) and mother to a short ten year old, who is a delight. We’re both working hard to instil confidence into DS, but he definitely hears a lot about his height already.

It’s depressing, isn’t it?

HeleneLagonelle · 11/12/2022 10:32

LuciferRising · 11/12/2022 08:10

If this stereotype is true, I guess the one about overweight people being lazy and greedy is too. Can't argue with stereotypes can we? Especially if you have first hand experience of nasty short FILs.

Yup. I’m married to a 5 ft 3 man (who is professionally very successful and a well-balanced, laid-back character, from a family of lovely short people — very poor, probably linked to generations of poor nutrition as well as genetics) and mother to a short ten year old, who is a delight. We’re both working hard to instil confidence into DS, but he definitely hears a lot about his height already.

BringOnAutumn · 11/12/2022 10:28

Thighlengthboots · 11/12/2022 10:24

So, are you saying that because short men have a hard time in dating, it’s acceptable for them to ask a tall woman out and then spend the entire relationship criticising them and putting them down for being tall?

No. I do not accept that at all. Having a hard time doesn’t give you carte Blanche to treat others like shit. That’s ridiculous. Plenty of people have difficult childhoods/ experiences- doesn’t then make it ok to take that out on others. It might be the reason but it’s not an excuse.

Did you read anything I wrote? Where on earth did I say anything of that?