Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Scientists Confirm Short Man Syndrome Is Real."

185 replies

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 10/12/2022 14:34

To think this is a strange finding:

www.menshealth.com/uk/health/a42175436/short-man-syndrome/

From my experience, this is not true. I have met many aggressive men short, medium height and very tall. I do not understand why men who are short are more likely to be aggressive it seems like quite a generalisation. By that logic, are short women also more aggressive.

I think "short" is also subjective. A 6 foot man can be seen as short for a 5 foot 10/11 women. A man who is 5 foot 6 is not necessarily short for a 5 foot 1 women. It is relative.

OP posts:
MeetPi · 12/12/2022 07:27

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 06:44

MeetPi · Yesterday 11:11
MrsSkylerWhite · Yesterday 10:58
Seems fairly widespread through the animal kingdom. Obviously there are exceptions but small animals can be very aggressive whilst larger ones are often very gentle.

“What an odd comparison to make”

why, we’re animals?

I was going to say "silly" but thought I'd be kinder. The more aggressive animals - the apex ones - tend to be larger. Think crocodiles, hippos, water buffalo, wild boar, bears, elephants. There is little gentleness about them, except perhaps when caring for their own young. (However, peak aggression tends to occur when defending their young.)
^
There are dangerous small animals, such as ants, snakes, spiders and scorpions - but they are commonly not aggressive.^

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 06:44

MeetPi · Yesterday 11:11
MrsSkylerWhite · Yesterday 10:58
Seems fairly widespread through the animal kingdom. Obviously there are exceptions but small animals can be very aggressive whilst larger ones are often very gentle.

“What an odd comparison to make”

why, we’re animals?

TiAmoTiAmo · 12/12/2022 06:42

I think "short" is also subjective. A 6 foot man can be seen as short for a 5 foot 10/11 women. A man who is 5 foot 6 is not necessarily short for a 5 foot 1 women. It is relative.
I don't agree with this. A 5ft6 man is still short regardless of the woman's height.

You've started the thread with the premise of look at the findings of this study and then turned it into a moan at SOME women who prefer tall men. Then it turned into short men getting mocked for something out of their control. This type of thread comes up so often. You're not going to change people's preferences no matter how unjust or unreasonable you think them. There is stereotypes about 'dumb blond' and many other offensive and insulting comments about other aspects that people were born with. You need to find a way to not be so hung up about it. We've all got our insecurities and imperfections. Very few are born attractive, tall, fit and healthy. That's why top models are top models. Don't compare yourself up, compare yourself down.

SleeplessInEngland · 12/12/2022 06:24

I suspect it’s pure confirmation bias. If short men are aggressive we just notice it more. Call it the Scrappy Doo Effect.

middleager · 12/12/2022 06:21

Some depressing heightism on here.

I'm short, my husband is short and my sons, who are teens, are short. They are some of the kindest, gentlest males I know.
All the men in my family (dad, brothers, uncles etc are tall, so I have experience of both short and tall males).

My one son is 16 and 5ft 6. He's always been small for his age, and has had to deal with lots of comments (like pp said, about being in the wrong lunch queue etc, getting turned away from cinema, even with id, while his friends were let in).
Another pp said for women who are short it isn't a problem. This is not true, I've been ridiculed for my height lots too.

Why is this acceptable? I am sensitive about it, because it seems to be an acceptable form of abuse. When I saw the thread title, I knew it would attract some sweeping statements about height. The first few posts show this to great effect.

FavouriteDogMug · 12/12/2022 06:11

A study of 367 people means nothing.

5YearsLeft · 12/12/2022 05:55

I’m thinking you should have read the article or maybe the original study, which refers to short people as a whole, and not just short men. So, if anything, you should be upset for both genders. This study isn’t singling out men at all.

It was a scientific study called “the Napoleon complex revisited” (it’s linked in the article) and refers to people of both genders who are dissatisfied with their height:
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0191886922004950

They asked 367 people questions to determine if they had traits for the “dark triad” - psychopathy, narcissism, and Machiavellianism. Men and women scored equally. According to the article:

”The results showed that shorter participants wished to be taller and scored more highly for all three dark triad traits – narcissism was particularly strong with the male participants.” (FROM ARTICLE)

But in the conclusion of the study itself it says that the traits are NOT affected by gender, barring that “weak” connection to narcissism:
”The correlations were not moderated by participants' sex, baring one weak effect for narcissism.” (FROM STUDY)

Which is why the study NEVER calls it “short man syndrome.” According to them, this almost equally affects both genders. And then, as far as who determines what’s short, at the VERY beginning of the article, it talks about what constitutes average height, and “short,” for study purposes, will be below that average. That’s how science works: people are classified as average, above the average, or below the average, in all kinds of areas.

I hope this was just a goady post because otherwise, the whole damn thing falls apart.

MintyFreshOne · 12/12/2022 05:01

BringOnAutumn · 11/12/2022 21:15

First I’ve heard of it and I’ve been on the internet for a long time.

And I hate the term 'Karen' and I would never use it.

Definitely in wide use in the US and yeah, it must be horrible to be on the receiving end of such insults.

MeetPi · 11/12/2022 23:38

@SleepDreamThinkHuge

Indeed I have heard people gossip and say "at least my kid won't be short like him."

I have a short DH and my DS is tall. I come from a tall family (although I'm not that tall myself; my nephew, for example, is 6 8"). There is more to genetics than this.

BringOnAutumn · 11/12/2022 21:15

Justanotherlurker · 11/12/2022 20:49

I'm not a troll, Manlet is a term that is widespread, it is admittedly shorthand and sexist, it is akin to Karen etc but for males. It has been a descpritor since the internet was borne.

First I’ve heard of it and I’ve been on the internet for a long time.

And I hate the term 'Karen' and I would never use it.

BringOnAutumn · 11/12/2022 21:14

5128gap · 11/12/2022 21:09

Some men are aggressive. Saying that short men have special reasons for this (basically that it's women's fault for not dating them/not seeing them as manly compared to tall men) is just another excuse for male bad behaviour.
And no, short is not relative to the height of the woman they wish to date. Its relative to other men. So any man shorter than average is short.

Nobody is saying this.

rumship · 11/12/2022 21:11

is in internet history of IRC.

So it was not around on the birth of the internet as IRC was later on after BBS and Newsgroups, also strangely not something I've ever seen on IRC either, as it was not used in the same way as people use it now days. As others have said you seem a nasty piece of work.

5128gap · 11/12/2022 21:09

Some men are aggressive. Saying that short men have special reasons for this (basically that it's women's fault for not dating them/not seeing them as manly compared to tall men) is just another excuse for male bad behaviour.
And no, short is not relative to the height of the woman they wish to date. Its relative to other men. So any man shorter than average is short.

FloydPepper · 11/12/2022 21:06

Justanotherlurker · 11/12/2022 21:04

Karen is an attitude (not that it’s ok to use)

Feel free to start a thread on that and see the responses.

(manlet sounds like it’s laughing at a physical attribute. Do you think it’s ok? Is it funny?

Shorthand for small man syndrome re Manlet is terminology that has been widely used for decades across the globe, it is in internet history of IRC , if you belive in Karen then you can't complian about Manlet, it has become a 'thing' that even men refer to it

Asking again
do you think it’s ok?
do you think it’s funny?

Justanotherlurker · 11/12/2022 21:04

Karen is an attitude (not that it’s ok to use)

Feel free to start a thread on that and see the responses.

(manlet sounds like it’s laughing at a physical attribute. Do you think it’s ok? Is it funny?

Shorthand for small man syndrome re Manlet is terminology that has been widely used for decades across the globe, it is in internet history of IRC , if you belive in Karen then you can't complian about Manlet, it has become a 'thing' that even men refer to it

KimberleyClark · 11/12/2022 20:59

I’d never seen the term manlet before now. What a nasty term.

rumship · 11/12/2022 20:58

Justanotherlurker · 11/12/2022 20:49

I'm not a troll, Manlet is a term that is widespread, it is admittedly shorthand and sexist, it is akin to Karen etc but for males. It has been a descpritor since the internet was borne.

Pretty sure it was not around on BBS and irc. But then again everything you said so far is pretty low and incorrect 🙄

FloydPepper · 11/12/2022 20:52

Justanotherlurker · 11/12/2022 20:49

I'm not a troll, Manlet is a term that is widespread, it is admittedly shorthand and sexist, it is akin to Karen etc but for males. It has been a descpritor since the internet was borne.

Karen is an attitude (not that it’s ok to use)

manlet sounds like it’s laughing at a physical attribute. Do you think it’s ok? Is it funny?

Justanotherlurker · 11/12/2022 20:49

BringOnAutumn · 11/12/2022 20:35

Ignore the troll. The only motivation for that post can be nastiness. Classic example of why shorter boys may grow up to be men who are sick of being picked on for something they have no control over.

I'm not a troll, Manlet is a term that is widespread, it is admittedly shorthand and sexist, it is akin to Karen etc but for males. It has been a descpritor since the internet was borne.

BringOnAutumn · 11/12/2022 20:35

FloydPepper · 11/12/2022 20:29

Manlet?

Ignore the troll. The only motivation for that post can be nastiness. Classic example of why shorter boys may grow up to be men who are sick of being picked on for something they have no control over.

FloydPepper · 11/12/2022 20:29

Justanotherlurker · 11/12/2022 19:12

Manlets are world wide meme so it isn't really a ground breaking study.

No man or women who has witnessed the manlet will be questioning this study.

Manlet?

lieselotte · 11/12/2022 19:32

Fleurdecerisier · 10/12/2022 14:40

If it is indeed true then I'd be inclined to think they'd be less aggressive if people were less rude and cruel about their height and stopped telling them they have short man syndrome. Toxic feedback loop innit?

Exactly this. It is really annoying - you can do nothing about your height so it should be treated the same as sex, race, sexual orientation etc. Heightism is unpleasant and can be very damaging.

Justanotherlurker · 11/12/2022 19:12

Manlets are world wide meme so it isn't really a ground breaking study.

No man or women who has witnessed the manlet will be questioning this study.

Cuppasoupmonster · 11/12/2022 18:54

Conversely I find very tall men to actually be quite wimpish and passive!

BlackeyedSusan · 11/12/2022 18:50

Fleurdecerisier · 10/12/2022 14:40

If it is indeed true then I'd be inclined to think they'd be less aggressive if people were less rude and cruel about their height and stopped telling them they have short man syndrome. Toxic feedback loop innit?

Same with fiery red heads.