Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Scientists Confirm Short Man Syndrome Is Real."

185 replies

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 10/12/2022 14:34

To think this is a strange finding:

www.menshealth.com/uk/health/a42175436/short-man-syndrome/

From my experience, this is not true. I have met many aggressive men short, medium height and very tall. I do not understand why men who are short are more likely to be aggressive it seems like quite a generalisation. By that logic, are short women also more aggressive.

I think "short" is also subjective. A 6 foot man can be seen as short for a 5 foot 10/11 women. A man who is 5 foot 6 is not necessarily short for a 5 foot 1 women. It is relative.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Burgoo · 12/12/2022 19:06

Full disclosure on this... I am (relatively) short for a man at 5ft7. The article is a bit misleading because it isn't sex specific, the sample size was 420 (265 male v 155 female. I can't access the full research paper so it is hard to look at the methodology, so I will go from a sex neutral perspective to be fair.

Firstly, it would make sense that individuals that are shorter would display higher levels of aggressive behaviours - they are likely to have encountered much more "push back" than taller counterparts and have probably learnt that the way to get their point across (and their needs met) is through a higher degree of forcefulness. Taller individuals may not have had as many problems and therefore it would make sense.

Secondly, I would love to see what measures they used in relation to the behaviours involved. My "aggressive" or "rude" is going to be different to the next person's and therefore it is hard to ascertain at what point someone moves from normal levels of behaviour to "small person" realms. I'd also be interested in seeing the measures used in determining the Dark Triad traits as these tools, without sufficient exploration using them, are essentially meaningless. It is also interesting that traits need to be independent of any other mental health condition which would require a full psychological work-up for each of those individuals.

Thirdly, and more importantly, is the need to control. The question I would pose is whether those individuals with "short person syndrome" traits would have those traits regardless of being short? Given that it is extremely hard to prove a negative (how can you prove it is BECAUSE they are short or whether they just happen to be short?) the research is going to need to do a hell of a lot of leg-work for me to buy the evidence.

I am also curious about whether they broke the stats down into race, sexuality, disability, class and ethnicity backgrounds. Is this a cultural thing? Was it strictly white people? Black? Asian? A mix? What jobs were they in? So many questions.

I am always suspicious when researchers claim big with such possibly flimsy stats/data.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 12/12/2022 17:59

lieselotte · 12/12/2022 11:49

No it hasn't, you have made it up. I was an early adopter of the internet and this is the first time I've heard it.

There is no justification whatsoever for criticising men on the basis of their height.

A quick Google search will show that @Justanotherlurker didn't make it up. Or, if so, it was eight or nine years ago at least.

First time I've heard it too, but the history is there. Though perhaps not since the internet was born. More like, since social media got mean.

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 12/12/2022 16:42

Think a lot of people are not understanding you can HAVE any preference you want. You can DATE WHOEVER you want. But being nasty to others either directly or indirectly is not nice. Like the examples I mentioned:

"at least my son won't be short like him."
"what do you call a man under 6 foot a friend."
"he is good looking but too bad he is short."

There is a lot of whataboutery. "Men do this to women." Who said that was right in the first place? Two wrongs do not make a right. We can say both actions are wrong. Plus if you want to talk about things men do make your own separate thread. It is like someone discussing racism they faced in this country and you saying "will women also face a lot of injustice" although that is true it is not really helpful when someone discusses their issues we can listen and see what they face instead of saying "will they do this."

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 12/12/2022 12:06

phoenixrosehere · 12/12/2022 12:06

My husband was and his mother constantly told he just needed to be fed, until they saw how much he ate, then crickets. He eventually became of average height when he was in uni. He did own one t and didn’t let anyone push him around but despite that there is a wound there where he needs a certain amount of reassurances when it comes to his body.

*own it

phoenixrosehere · 12/12/2022 12:06

lieselotte · 12/12/2022 11:50

The supposed heightism thing that some people seem to get upset about on here I've never actually encountered IRL

Smaller boys are very often bullied. I know many taller boys will get bullied for other characteristics, but I would have thought it was fairly obvious that heightism was a thing IRL.

My husband was and his mother constantly told he just needed to be fed, until they saw how much he ate, then crickets. He eventually became of average height when he was in uni. He did own one t and didn’t let anyone push him around but despite that there is a wound there where he needs a certain amount of reassurances when it comes to his body.

OneTC · 12/12/2022 11:52

Sorry I wasn't clear I meant the women not liking small men thing that some people complain about on here. I understand full well about getting bullied for your height.

lieselotte · 12/12/2022 11:50

The supposed heightism thing that some people seem to get upset about on here I've never actually encountered IRL

Smaller boys are very often bullied. I know many taller boys will get bullied for other characteristics, but I would have thought it was fairly obvious that heightism was a thing IRL.

lieselotte · 12/12/2022 11:49

Justanotherlurker · 11/12/2022 20:49

I'm not a troll, Manlet is a term that is widespread, it is admittedly shorthand and sexist, it is akin to Karen etc but for males. It has been a descpritor since the internet was borne.

No it hasn't, you have made it up. I was an early adopter of the internet and this is the first time I've heard it.

There is no justification whatsoever for criticising men on the basis of their height.

OneTC · 12/12/2022 11:45

Every day from when I was 9 to when I left school I had a French teacher who used to say "OneTC you're supposed to stand when a teacher comes in" and he said it every lesson and every lesson people laughed.

The supposed heightism thing that some people seem to get upset about on here I've never actually encountered IRL. The most likely candidate for giving me a hard time is someone who's taller than me but not tall, average height people basically. IME people at any physical extreme trend to have pretty thick skin about it

PattyJones · 12/12/2022 11:39

I HATE WHEN PEOPLE SAY SHORT MEN ARE ANGRY. as a 5'1 man myself (in my brogues) i have literally never been angry. THESE PEOPOLE MAKE ME SO MAD WITH THEIR SILLY THEORY. xoxo Pat

headstone · 12/12/2022 11:34

It’s just nasty stereotyping people based on physical characteristics outside one’s control. As for the science , well ‘science’ in the past has found women stupider them men and all sorts of dubious racial differences.

FloydPepper · 12/12/2022 11:24

5128gap · 12/12/2022 11:19

Its not OK. And it wouldn't be condoned in my workplace or at my DCs school (and that was the case 5 years ago) While its not such a social taboo to mock height as it is weight or ugliness, most people know its inappropriate. And yes, they do it anyway, but they also mock weight and ugliness anyway.
I wonder how many 5' 6" men get heckled in the street by women in vans while they're out jogging as so frequently happens to OW women?
How difficult they find it to attract a partner compared to ugly women (threads like these are full of women who don't mind height. Find me a thread where a bunch of men are saying they don't mind ugly)?
Mocking height is wrong, but this short man thing is generally blown up out of all proportion. Basically it tends to boil down to the fact that some men can't date every woman they might want to because some women like tall men; and that sometimes they are the target for cruelty about an aspect of their appearance. Just like every human being who fails to meet society's ideal, with women being far more frequently on the receiving end.

It’s not an entitlement to date anyone (I can’t speak for everyone under average height), it’s wanting to not have the piss taken out of you and be insulted, by both men and women. Surely that’s not an unreasonable ask…

5128gap · 12/12/2022 11:19

Robekinobi · 12/12/2022 11:05

I think a big difference between attractiveness (which has been subject of countless studies showing the big impact it has on your life) and height is that it's still socially acceptable to mock height. This is my issue. I'm not saying short man syndrome is "caused" by women, or that women are wrong not to be attracted to short men. Far from it. But would teachers poke fun at fat kids? Or comment on how ugly someone is? Of course not! Yet height seems to be fair game (both short men and tall women). Why is that ok?

Its not OK. And it wouldn't be condoned in my workplace or at my DCs school (and that was the case 5 years ago) While its not such a social taboo to mock height as it is weight or ugliness, most people know its inappropriate. And yes, they do it anyway, but they also mock weight and ugliness anyway.
I wonder how many 5' 6" men get heckled in the street by women in vans while they're out jogging as so frequently happens to OW women?
How difficult they find it to attract a partner compared to ugly women (threads like these are full of women who don't mind height. Find me a thread where a bunch of men are saying they don't mind ugly)?
Mocking height is wrong, but this short man thing is generally blown up out of all proportion. Basically it tends to boil down to the fact that some men can't date every woman they might want to because some women like tall men; and that sometimes they are the target for cruelty about an aspect of their appearance. Just like every human being who fails to meet society's ideal, with women being far more frequently on the receiving end.

Robekinobi · 12/12/2022 11:05

I think a big difference between attractiveness (which has been subject of countless studies showing the big impact it has on your life) and height is that it's still socially acceptable to mock height. This is my issue. I'm not saying short man syndrome is "caused" by women, or that women are wrong not to be attracted to short men. Far from it. But would teachers poke fun at fat kids? Or comment on how ugly someone is? Of course not! Yet height seems to be fair game (both short men and tall women). Why is that ok?

rumship · 12/12/2022 10:56

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 12/12/2022 10:52

But it is researched academically...

journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0956797618772822

So was the one you quoted, But thats the intresting thing about research,

"Why Most Published Research Findings Are False"
journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124

😂

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 12/12/2022 10:52

JaninaDuszejko · 11/12/2022 11:52

It's shite science performed to make money by selling the story to the gutter press who love this kind of thing. There are also studies that show that short men are less aggressive (news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6501633.stm) which frankly make more sense, it's dangerous to be aggressive when you are smaller than your opponent because they are stronger and can do you more harm.

You can also say short men have more stable marriages, live longer and have less chance of cancer and blood clots than tall men but nobody is going on about how tall men are shit husbands.

But it is researched academically...

journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0956797618772822

Palmfrond · 12/12/2022 10:05

I’m 6’4” (+ big hair so look taller) and I’ve never been singled out for aggression by a short man, except maybe once, but the man in question was very very drunk, and im going to make an educated guess that it was the drunkenness that was aggravating his behaviour rather than his height.
I have noticed that short men can be initially wary of me, but I believe that’s because so many tall men act like entitled dickwands, it’s astonishing. I even get it from other tall men, that “get out the way, here I come” attitude, or a sort of lordly bearing that naturally rubs other men up the wrong way. Tbh I possibly do it myself, it’s not necessarily conscious. We’re primates and creatures of social habit, there’s a lot to unravel.
I can understand why short men would be resentful of women’s reaction to tall men, and how that might play out negatively in their heads. I can say from personal experience that it is a thing, tall men getting more attention from women, even if just on the very basic level of making you more noticeable. That said, one of the greatest casanovas I’ve ever known can’t have been much over 5’6” and looked like a troll, but had an enormous (and benign) personality.
I have come across napoleonic type characters, but I’ve come across just as many, or more, tall men who are tossers in their special tall man way.
I should probably mention that I’m a man, not a 6’4” woman, though with the big hair I always try and have a bit of stubble going to avoid confusion.

OneTC · 12/12/2022 09:42

Yet somehow they need a 'syndrome' to excuse the fact some can't seem to accept they are not the fortunate ones (despite this being only when compared with taller men) get over it and develop other aspects of themselves, personality, decency, rather than exacerbate their situation by becoming aggressive.

The article and study is literally about men and women. Also I don't think (many short) men feel they "need" an essentially made up syndrome just so that others have a stick to beat them with.

RobinRobinMouse · 12/12/2022 09:40

My worst and really aggressive nasty boss was about 6ft, however that's just one example and making claims based on that is almost as ridiculous as this study which was based on a teeny amount of people. You'd think researchers had more important things to explore.

LoopyLoo1991 · 12/12/2022 09:31

Two worst male bosses I've had definitely had short man syndrome. One also had a really bad skin conditio and was bullied at school. So come the workplace, as soon as he got a tiny bit of power he turned in to a right little H1tler, as payback for his previous bullying.
Alienated long term staff, annoyed customers & even peed off & had a go at my boyfriend for chatting to his partner at a works drink. My BF has known his partner for years before boss even met here! FFS
Result half the staff left, git boss was demoted and forced to apologise to all staff & a few who'd left in a reviewed meeting. His partner later got shot of him due to him 'not dealing with being higher up in the company than him!'
He left company 'shortly' afterwards and went to work for a housing association, where being hated is normal.

Shouldn't generalise but do think a 'large' number are effected by small man syndrome.

5128gap · 12/12/2022 09:29

TiAmoTiAmo · 12/12/2022 09:11

Yeah, it's interesting the anger is targeted at women rather than tall men. But if it were beauty between women, they expect the woman to be bitchy towards the other prettier women and not at men for preferring the hotter woman. It's always the woman's fault (!)
Guys can absolutely be cruel bullies towards other short guys but you're not on their forums lecturing them on giving short guys a chance. It's always on us to bend backwards, to be more kind. 'Men are visual' and woman are supposed to be motherly, sweet and sexually available for every man as it's their human right to have access to sex. It's so predictable on these threads.

Indeed. Particularly as the tall man as the ideal is based in ideas that men should be big, strong and dominant over smaller weaker females.
Women didn't create that and we don't benefit from it. Men have perpetrated this for their own advantage, and unfortunately for the shorter ones it's a bit of an own goal.

TiAmoTiAmo · 12/12/2022 09:11

Yeah, it's interesting the anger is targeted at women rather than tall men. But if it were beauty between women, they expect the woman to be bitchy towards the other prettier women and not at men for preferring the hotter woman. It's always the woman's fault (!)
Guys can absolutely be cruel bullies towards other short guys but you're not on their forums lecturing them on giving short guys a chance. It's always on us to bend backwards, to be more kind. 'Men are visual' and woman are supposed to be motherly, sweet and sexually available for every man as it's their human right to have access to sex. It's so predictable on these threads.

5128gap · 12/12/2022 08:51

BringOnAutumn · 11/12/2022 21:14

Nobody is saying this.

Of course they are. The OP started this thread in a forum used mainly by women with the express purpose of defending short men to them. (And to tell us again that short men aren't really short) The study was merely their vehicle and provides a further reason why women who don't favour short men are wrong. We make them aggressive now.
Being a short man is similar to being an unattractive woman. Both have physical characteristics not deemed ideal in our society. Both are targets for mockery. Both may find their progression through the world less easy than their 'physically blessed' peers. Both will find their dating pool significantly reduced.
However given the flurry of protectivism from many women towards them, I think its safe to say they have an easier time overall than a woman who isn't aesthetically ideal.
Yet somehow they need a 'syndrome' to excuse the fact some can't seem to accept they are not the fortunate ones (despite this being only when compared with taller men) get over it and develop other aspects of themselves, personality, decency, rather than exacerbate their situation by becoming aggressive.
If an unattractive woman is aggressive you can bet your house there wouldn't be studies to explain and excuse her.

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/12/2022 08:23

I was going to say "silly" but thought I'd be kinder. The more aggressive animals - the apex ones - tend to be larger. Think crocodiles, hippos, water buffalo, wild boar, bears, elephants. There is little gentleness about them, except perhaps when caring for their own young. (However, peak aggression tends to occur when defending their young.)
^
There are dangerous small animals, such as ants, snakes, spiders and scorpions - but they are commonly not aggressive“

why silly? We are animals.

Elephants, giraffes, blue whales, manatees, newfoundlands, great Dane’s, etc 🤷‍♀️

dearohdeary · 12/12/2022 08:17

I'm a 5 foot 3 woman and apparently that's tiny. 😅

Swipe left for the next trending thread