Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Married 17 years but never had that sexual spark with DH

110 replies

7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 08:16

Both in our early 40s, been married for 17 years. DH is very attractive but even when we first got together there just wasn't the compatibility in the bedroom. To me he always just came across as quite wooden and we never clicked. However, we used to really connect in other ways so I sort of overlooked it. I had lived with other partners before DH so in a way I know its us rather than men and me in general.

Fast forward to now and we have each changed and have less in common etc and things are definitely fraying badly at the seams. Not really had much of a sex life since DC four years ago now. DH wants to stay together because of DC but I was wondering whether if we had had that initial sexual spark it would help us ride out the fact that by now we're just quite different people esp. since having DC. Obviously can't unmade the last 17 years but also not sure how to move forward beside resigning myself to both of us unhappily muddling along till kids leave home

OP posts:
Walkaround · 10/12/2022 17:07

Well, you both sound unhappy, sustaining lives neither of you is happy with. It does sound as though you are saying that you can only live in London doing your job because of the free childcare help you are giving each other, and shared financial resources, and that you could not actually afford to live separately in London. And he doesn’t even want to live in London in the first place - that’s your choice. Is this the case, or is it more the case that you couldn’t tolerate an even worse quality of life than you have now just to enable you to keep living in London and working full time without your dh?

What would happen if you separated? Would you be able to share childcare amicably? Or would he want to move well away from London, making your children’s schooling and lives very difficult and complicated, or resulting in one of you having the children for the lion’s share of the time? Could you cope with your full time job and elderly parents and full time responsibility for your children for large parts of the year? Or would you need your dh to do at least half and therefore continue to live nearby, even though he clearly doesn’t want to? Or would you be happy to give up custody of your children for most of the year? Or every weekend, if you take them to schools local to you during the week? Or during the week, if he takes them to school near him? Tbh, it sounds like you have already completed your emotional separation, so just need to sort out practicalities, which may well be shit for everyone for a considerable period of time, particularly if the whole problem in the first place is you are incapable of agreeing what is the best thing for your children.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/12/2022 15:23

7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 13:13

@Thepeopleversuswork I guess in a way he's right. I'd have half the money, less support than I do now, probably unlikely to meet anyone new as I won't have time, but still just as much to do so more stressed and juggling everything.

OP that's him talking, not you.

I'm a single parent and I can tell you right now my life is a million times better than it was married to a man not dissimilar to your husband. I don't have the support, no, but I didn't much in the marriage. I did meet someone. And I have more money than I ever did in the marriage.

Society is geared up to tell us that we are nothing without a man. And you know what, the greatest secret I learned in my life is that that narrative is set up because its men, not women, who benefit most from marriage.

Get rid of his voice from your head and keep telling yourself you can do what you want and you don't need his authority. You may or may not choose to leave. But don't stay purely because he's telling you you can't do it. That suits him more than you.

Goodgrief82 · 10/12/2022 13:20

7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 13:16

Man adult life is crap

I am afraid to say OP, that it is for you.

but adult life per se, is not.

I am a single parent, decorating the tree atm with my two very happy settled children growing up in an environment of no tension or moodiness between parents that don’t really like each other let alone love each other.

you seem to think the alternative to being with him is to horrifying to contemplate. Whereas your current existence seems pretty awful to me

7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 13:16

Man adult life is crap

OP posts:
7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 13:13

@Thepeopleversuswork I guess in a way he's right. I'd have half the money, less support than I do now, probably unlikely to meet anyone new as I won't have time, but still just as much to do so more stressed and juggling everything.

OP posts:
sweeneytoddsrazor · 10/12/2022 12:53

How would you feel as a single parent though OP. If the DC were to stay with you would you still want to stay late at the office, manage an hours commute and drop offs, clubs etc on your own. Would you still want to travel so far to elderly parents on top of all this? Would you be able to go out when you want to?

Stompythedinosaur · 10/12/2022 12:49

I think the sexual issue might be a distraction. It sounds like you were previously happier in the relationship. Is there any chance you are rewriting history a bit, and that there was a time you were more attracted to him? Clearly you were sleeping together at one point.

I think you need to think about counselling to resolve some of the difficulties in your relationship.

ICriedAllTheWayToTheChipShop · 10/12/2022 12:48

Claireintheclouds · 10/12/2022 11:49

Not sure it’s a sign of not being a good man to be honest. From what the OP has written I don’t think she’d be a good single mum either. Couldn’t afford it for a start

As I said, low bar. It might not make him "bad" but it certainly doesn't mean he warrants all the "decent guy worth hanging onto at all costs" comments that other posters have been handing out to him.

Skyla01 · 10/12/2022 12:45

Maybe you should try some relationship counselling to work out what you both want? Or just have an honest conversation yourselves. If you have both stopped trying in the relationship I think you need to decide what to do- split up, stay together as friends for the kids, or start trying to make it work. Might be better than staying in unspoken limbo? I would say a "spark" is the least of your worries at this point.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/12/2022 12:41

The reason he stays - is that he thinks I would be a crap single mum so he stays for the kids

Honestly I would probably leave him for that remark alone, never mind what he's like in the sack. So much to hate about that statement:

  • He's stating he only stays for the kids and therefore would not be with OP if it weren't for the kids
  • He's saying she can't parent alone which is really fucking insulting
  • He's belittling and patronising her for implying that she couldn't cope without him to run hers and her kids' life

Why on earth would anyone want to remain with someone who talks to his wife as if she was a helpless cretin who can't look after her own kids?

Perhaps you should show him you're not actually a crap single mum. I'd be prepared to bet you'd find parenting more fun without him.

7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 12:41

@FreshCop so once upon a time, yes I did consider it. However, I actually think he was ok with it. I think sex is often like a conversation right. With some people its just polite small talk whilst with others you feel a real connection. And originally the strange thing with us was that it was a real connection when we talked and interacted but not in the bedroom. No idea why. But we never quite connected but now the connection outside the bedroom is also lost

OP posts:
FreshCop · 10/12/2022 12:30

Have you had any feeling he is gay and using you to keep up the “family” image?

RiverSkater · 10/12/2022 12:26

@Claireintheclouds I've seen nothing to say OP would not make a good single mum. The practical stuff can be worked on.

RiverSkater · 10/12/2022 12:24

@TheAngryFeminist they don't have sex so this isn't the issue. Your other comments need a thread of their own!

OP Have you worked out the maths, could you do it alone?

I'm in the same position, I 'settled' as was in the last chance saloon, nothing in common, no sex, in London, unhappy but God knows how we'd both afford a place!

Claireintheclouds · 10/12/2022 11:50

This reply has been deleted

We have concerns about this user so we have deleted their posts and threads.

Living up to your user name here I see. Who hurt you?

also sexual slave? Ffs how offensive to the many women (and men, children etc.) who are genuinely kept in sexual slavery the world over

HotChoxs · 10/12/2022 11:49

OP, before you beat yourself up, like other posters on here are so keen to do because it justifies their own choices (which tells you they're not as great as they think they are), remember that 17 years is a good innings and you could have done a hell of a lot worse. We are all human.

Claireintheclouds · 10/12/2022 11:49

ICriedAllTheWayToTheChipShop · 10/12/2022 11:24

Has everyone missed where the OP said that the husband only wants to stay together because he thinks she would be a crap single mum? Doesn't sound like there's much love and respect there on his side. I know the bar is very low for what constitutes a "good man" on MN but I would be concerned about that in the OP's place.

Not sure it’s a sign of not being a good man to be honest. From what the OP has written I don’t think she’d be a good single mum either. Couldn’t afford it for a start

Redkettle · 10/12/2022 11:48

Walkaround · 10/12/2022 11:28

Where does the OP say that?

Oh just saw this.

Redkettle · 10/12/2022 11:46

You could meet a man and have explosive sex and he could end up a right shithouse . You can always improve things in the bedroom area and get a spark . Hard finding good guys though

7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 11:44

@Goodgrief82 I guess because by now it's really not about what he thinks about me but about whether or not he picks up the kids so I can work late in the office, helps with getting them to clubs, elderly parents etc. As I said, we essentially mostly relate to each other as project managers. Yes, he might think that am crap but I guess we need each other in order to life to carry on as it is. I really have no idea how single parents in London manage everything unless they earn 6figure sums.

OP posts:
TheAngryFeminist · 10/12/2022 11:42

This reply has been deleted

We have concerns about this user so we have deleted their posts and threads.

Goodgrief82 · 10/12/2022 11:38

7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 11:34

And to the answer of why DH stays - yes, his exact words were - I dont want to leave the kids with you - you'd be crap at it on your own. So no I dont think he thinks much of me either.

I think on the whole he is a good person

he doesn’t even to think you are “on the whole person”

op how on earth can you be under the same roof as someone who thinks this is lowly of you

PrincessConstance · 10/12/2022 11:36

7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 08:59

I think it used to be ok enough esp. before having kids. But since then there have been quite a few changes in our lives - we moved countries, he no longer work in my industry - i.e. we are less able to talk shop in ways we used to, had kids, so the 'friends' bit functions a lot less well. For example, since coming back to the UK we clearly want very different things when it comes to our kids, careers, how best to do things. It's hard - he is a nice guy and the classic attractive type over 6 foot, still has a six pack and does 50/50 with the kids. So on the surface, he's great. But we want different things in our lives now and I just never wanted to shag him all that much. It sounds really harsh. Not sure what a counsellor can say - we cant exactly go back to regaining the spark that for me was never there in the first place. We also cant go back to wanting the same things - it was fine abroad when we could create a compromise but we live in London and things are a lot more intense with jobs, kids, elderly parents.

Adult relationships are so hard, you got to get really lucky to have everything

Adult relationships are so hard- Yes they can be.
You got to get really lucky to have everything- That is because the everything panacea doesn't exist.

7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 11:34

And to the answer of why DH stays - yes, his exact words were - I dont want to leave the kids with you - you'd be crap at it on your own. So no I dont think he thinks much of me either.

OP posts:
7tgu467g · 10/12/2022 11:33

So in terms of whether I like him - I think on the whole he is a good person and he is definitely very similar to my other friends in terms of what he wants out of life. The trouble is that am not sure that this is what I want which is the confusing bit. It also hasnt been helped by living abroad for so long and the UK having changed as much as it has.

Looking around me by now all of my friends from uni/school have left London, embraced having a nice house, going part time and focusing more on other things in life like kids, hobbies etc. But I dont want that. Despite I guess not being a super high earner (but still a professional on 65k with a job that has to be done in London) - I want to stay put, embrace what London has to offer (and be close to both our families) even if that is at the expense of living in a flat, having an hour's commute each way and another hour and half to our parents while trying to advance our careers. For me that is worth it but not for DH. So in a very weird way - I think at this stage of our lives - he would be a perfect husband for my closest friends but maybe not for me. Clearly our reaction to coming back to the UK in our circumstances - especially the UK that has changed so much over the last fifteen years is very very different. I don't think that I was anticipating it, which was probably short sighted of me.

OP posts: