Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be annoyed by this headline stating that a mother only earns £2 per shift after childcare when the article mentions the childrens' father who lives with them

81 replies

ASandwichNamedKevin · 10/12/2022 00:57

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-63904607

I know childcare is expensive but surely it ought to be a shared expense when parents are living together?
Is there any way to challenge this perception that it's the sole responsibility of mothers?

I'm not intending this as a criticism of this individual family but of the reporting.

If you don't want to click the link, it says the mum earns £73 and pays out £71 so only 'makes' £2. AIBU to think she 'makes' £37.50 (please let my maths be right!)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Justthisonce12 · 11/12/2022 08:29

Cheeseandhoney · 10/12/2022 08:57

I don’t really understand the subsidising bit, I believe people should look at rhe cost of children before having children and then deciding, and already people get a lot of help from tax to free hours.

I also see plenty of folks who use those free hours the tax payer pays when they don’t actually work.

I do believe it should be reworked though, only those whose parents are both in full time employment, or the single parent is, and earn below x should get support to childcare to get them back in work .

i really dislike the fact that so many people want others to pay for their choices. Having a child is a choice. Not a right.

The children put in childcare when the parent doesn’t actually work is benefiting enormously and the advantage to you is that investing in their early years means they are more likely to get a job and less likely to mug you when they are older. Itll cost you more to imprison them in the long term.

oviraptor21 · 11/12/2022 08:16

SingingSantaChristmas · 10/12/2022 03:11

Oh, and to boot they have better sex equality, less poverty in general, higher productivity (which raises everyone's living standards) and that in these circumstances - with proper parental leave policies etc for men also - parenting and household work is also generally far more equally shared.

In short it's a no brainer. Better for children and all family members and the country as a whole.

That is why sensible Governments fund it. They aren't basing their policies on decades old sexist and debunked nonsense, rather on actual, current, undeniable data on a huge scale which proves that this is beneficial for everyone.

This government does fund it, 85% of it up to a maximum of £600odd for one child, via universal credit.
If you're not eligible for universal credit then you don't need the childcare help in the same way and the tax burden won't be increased to help you.

poefaced · 11/12/2022 08:03

YANBU, OP. You can see the effects of this thinking every day on AIBU. countless threads written by women saying it’s not worth working because her wage just goes on childcare. Or even worse, women posting saying that their partners have said she needs to pay for the childcare cost because it’s her choice to work.

VestaTilley · 11/12/2022 07:58

YANBU. I’ve tweeted at BBC News about it complaining about the headline.

freyamay74 · 11/12/2022 07:25

Bottom line is, we never see an article about working parents where the headline is what the dad is left with after paying the childcare bill. Because the default assumption is always that dad will carry on working but if mum carries on working then she is going to be paying the childcare bill.

Pretty depressing in 2022.

LemonSwan · 10/12/2022 15:48

Getoff · 10/12/2022 08:30

Explain again how having fellow-citizens rather than parents pay for childcare makes the production of future citizens cheaper? I didn't quite get it the first time.

Also, there's nothing wrong with importing people, if you have a shortage, which we don't. In fact if we want to rationally optimise the "pyramid scheme", we should actively discourage people from having children, perhaps by charging the parents via tax for all the costs of education and healthcare, as it would be much cheaper to import people, and the quality would be better because we could choose only educated healthy adults.

It’s a net plus the more people who work. Deskilling half the country (women) during the peak of their career years is not a good strategy. Many countries know this and so subsidise childcare.

And you pay for it anyway. Just through benefits instead. So it really does mainly affect the productivity aspect and future taxable earnings.

SpecialTowels · 10/12/2022 12:35

Mycatsgoldtooth · 10/12/2022 10:01

For the last 8 years I’ve paid for childcare and it’s a massive money maker for the state, why would they subsidise it. I pay tax on my earnings, then I pay a childminder who pays tax on her earnings. They get double the tax from my hourly wage. Not entitled to child benefit or tax free childcare so it’s a win for the government. I earn £300 a month after paying tax, childcare and NI. From this I pay for my travel to work. It’s not actually worth me working financially or for the stress but I do a socially useful job and iIt means in a couple of years I’ll not be paying childcare and will have advanced in my career and added to my pension.
The government have no interest in making society better, just making money off its citizens to waste.

Because it pays for itself, as stated above.

Nsenene · 10/12/2022 10:24

freyamay74 · 10/12/2022 09:49

Of course in principle people should be better off working. However I completely disagree that people should be better off working 'regardless of how many children they have.' What if a couple choose to have 5,6, 8 children? Is it really right that public funds should pay for that choice? Not to mention the fact that the mother might take a whole year out of the workplace each time she has a child!

I'm all for support - it would have made a huge difference to dh and I just to have the free hours that kick in now when the child is 3. Or the longer maternity leave which means you're not paying childcare from 12 weeks old as families used to do.

But there have to be parameters. No one has a right to just keep popping out as many kids as they want and be guaranteed to still be better off working

I doubt most people would have more children even with free childcare. There are lots of reasons people have small families, childcare is just one.
Childcare, like education, should be viewed as an investment in our future and current workforce surely?

PinkPink1 · 10/12/2022 10:17

@freyamay74 15 hours free childcare if both parents work full time would be brilliant. Regardless of how many dc someone has, at least they’d be able to work full time and only pay for part time childcare (as the rest is paid for). Obviously the more dc you have, the more expensive childcare is (unless you don’t work and are still entitled to free childcare which doesn’t make sense).

Justthisonce12 · 10/12/2022 10:08

Any subsidies would be immediately swallowed up by the childcare providers. In Australia They have a childcare tax credits type things and you can claim $120 a day which means that the staff get paid well, average is about $25-$30 an hour. The management would be on $40 an hour, what it doesn’t mean as an improve in the quality of food provided, the services are constantly asking for donations of craft, materials, toys, all the things that you would expect a profitable business to provide for itself.
Typically when I was there six years ago, it would cost between 130 and $140 a day.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 10/12/2022 10:01

For the last 8 years I’ve paid for childcare and it’s a massive money maker for the state, why would they subsidise it. I pay tax on my earnings, then I pay a childminder who pays tax on her earnings. They get double the tax from my hourly wage. Not entitled to child benefit or tax free childcare so it’s a win for the government. I earn £300 a month after paying tax, childcare and NI. From this I pay for my travel to work. It’s not actually worth me working financially or for the stress but I do a socially useful job and iIt means in a couple of years I’ll not be paying childcare and will have advanced in my career and added to my pension.
The government have no interest in making society better, just making money off its citizens to waste.

freyamay74 · 10/12/2022 09:49

Of course in principle people should be better off working. However I completely disagree that people should be better off working 'regardless of how many children they have.' What if a couple choose to have 5,6, 8 children? Is it really right that public funds should pay for that choice? Not to mention the fact that the mother might take a whole year out of the workplace each time she has a child!

I'm all for support - it would have made a huge difference to dh and I just to have the free hours that kick in now when the child is 3. Or the longer maternity leave which means you're not paying childcare from 12 weeks old as families used to do.

But there have to be parameters. No one has a right to just keep popping out as many kids as they want and be guaranteed to still be better off working

Kpo58 · 10/12/2022 09:43

I think that it's irrelevant who pays for the childcare out of the couple. It boils down that the family is not really better off by both parents working and in many cases they are often worse off and that's before taking into account pension contributions that they probably can't afford to pay anyway.

We should make it so that you are never worse off working regardless of how many children you have or wether or not they have sen. It's not short sighted that people aren't working when their children are young, it's because they can't afford to get into debt BY working.

freyamay74 · 10/12/2022 09:36

I'm another one who was annoyed by the article.

Yes, affordable childcare is important. Not denying that. But the whole tone of the article made it into the mother's issue, that she is only left with a few quid a day after paying the nursery bill. It's a joint expense- why isn't there any emphasis on what nursery is costing the dad?

Like some pp, when our kids were small, there was no immediate financial advantage to having dh and I both working. Childcare for our 3 children cost the equivalent of one income. If I'd stayed home, or if dh had stayed home and just one of us had worked, we would have been financially just as well off. No free childcare hours and much shorter maternity leave in those days too so the childcare bills went on way longer.

So why did I continue working? In a nutshell, for the same reasons my dh did! I was just as skilled and capable as him, I didn't want to ditch my working life and end up without career progression and a pension. It was our choice to have kids and although it's financially painful when they're young, I certainly didn't resent paying for the most precious beings in my world to be cared for.

This is poor journalism. It undermines women and makes something which is a parent issue into just a mums one.

Oh and btw to the poster near the start of the thread who referred to 'why would anyone want their children brought up by a nursery?' - actually, nurseries don't bring children up. Their parents do. Some parents happen to work as well as being parents. The crap about 'offloading your kids to be raised by someone else' is IME a line trotted out by resentful women who realise later on that children who went to nursery as just as happy and well adjusted as children who don't- and their parents have successful work lives, secure pensions etc to boot!

Aprilx · 10/12/2022 09:35

I find the idea that the woman is responsible for childcare costs to be outrageous, make no mistake.

But in this particular story I think the point is that the household income only increases by £2 if she works an extra day. Yes maybe it could have been written as “she would make £37.50 whilst he would be down £35.50” but I think viewing it as the household income increases by £2 is a more sensible way of looking at it.

SpottyBalloons · 10/12/2022 09:31

@Nsenene I agree, I think the objection is the fact the article doesn't refer to it as though it's a household cost. If the article said the mother working only increased the family income by £2 a day, that would be accurate (forgetting pension contributions!) without perpetuating the idea that childcare costs are the mother's problem.

fiftiesmum · 10/12/2022 09:30

It was like that a few years back when I first returned to work with two DC in nursery (their was no thirty "free" hours then and childcare vouchers kicked in later). I think I was worse off working for a year until the elder DC started school (DH worked full time so paid for most things) I had to look in the longer term and kept my career going and as a family we had a decent lifestyle once they were teenagers.
Why should now I pay extra tax now so couple in the news article can spoil their DC over Christmas.

Nsenene · 10/12/2022 09:22

SpottyBalloons · 10/12/2022 09:17

@sweeneytoddsrazor No, she wants the article to say the Mum is left with £37.50 per day, which is the amount earned (£73.00) minus half of the childcare cost (£35.50).
Deducting the full £71 from the mother's wage perpetuates the idea that childcare costs fall solely to the mother and aren't a joint expense.

But if the father was paying half the childcare, I assume the mother would have to take on half the household bills. It doesn't change the household finances however you split it.

SpottyBalloons · 10/12/2022 09:17

sweeneytoddsrazor · 10/12/2022 07:51

So what you wanted was for the article to say if X went back to work she would be working for £2 an hour after her share of household bills had been paid.

@sweeneytoddsrazor No, she wants the article to say the Mum is left with £37.50 per day, which is the amount earned (£73.00) minus half of the childcare cost (£35.50).
Deducting the full £71 from the mother's wage perpetuates the idea that childcare costs fall solely to the mother and aren't a joint expense.

alwayslearning789 · 10/12/2022 09:15

cptartapp · 10/12/2022 07:58

I worked for the equivalent of nothing for over two years when DC went to nursery pt from a few months. But it came out the joint pot of course. DH didn't want to stay at home any more than I did.
Twenty years on, my God it was worth it. It maintained the power balance in our relationship, my mental health and now my pension looks great.
DC are smart independent teens off at uni. Can't think of one downside.

Agreed.

A lot don't realise just what they are sacrificing until they are in their latter half of life.

alwayslearning789 · 10/12/2022 09:07

Ginglymostomatidae · 10/12/2022 08:40

Surely it depends how finances are shared within the household.

My BF will complain to anyone who'll listen that she only has x amount after paying childcare. Her husband however, pays for absolutely everything else - mortgage, bills, food. The nursery fees are literally all she contributes, and if they split everything evenly, or depending on their salary, she would have nothing left.

How many other households do this. Sometimes it is the woman paying for the childcare, but the partner is picking up everything else.

This.

Girasoli · 10/12/2022 09:05

And your thinking betrays a huge lack of understanding of child development. Do you honestly believe a child is better brought up hy a nursery than its own parents?

Anytime I've seen one of those big international surveys about childrens and teens mental health, the UK tends to score amongst the lowest in Western Europe (e.g. lower than France/Italy/Spain etc who all have subsidised childcare)

Seymour5 · 10/12/2022 09:03

LisaJool · 10/12/2022 08:46

Working isn't always 'investing' in your career, it depends on the job. Things like cleaning and retail you could stay in the same job for years and never progress. With the rise of zero hours contracts this is going to be even harder.

I agree, a basic rate job is very different to a well paid career. However, if the cost of childcare negates two parents working at the same time, then whats to stop them working at different times and sharing childcare?

Lots of us did that years ago. DH often worked away, but when he was home, it was often just evenings and weekends, so I got temp work through an agency for several years. A friend worked evenings in a chippy, and another did weekend work in a hospital. The sacrifice there was family time but we needed the extra money. Eventually we all went back to full time work.

All my DGC went to nurseries, and the families have benefited, certainly long term. Of course that equality has to be supported by both parents.

ResisterRex · 10/12/2022 09:03

OP this was the first thing I thought when I read it. They might as well have said she has pin money FFS

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 10/12/2022 08:59

This "dad pays half" is not the gotcha moment some people think it is.
Reducing it to basic numbers.

A brings in £2000 a month, household costs £1900. Everything covered with a bit extra. B brings in £1500 a month. Nursery as an added cost is £1500 . It doesn't matter how much either of them pays for the nursery, they're still only £100 better off as a family. If there are any associated costs with working ,unpaid days off looking after children while still paying for nursery, etc they could even operate at a loss. It does make sense for B to be a SAHP for a few years if that's what everyone is happy with.

While long term it's obviously better to keep working, while you're scrimping and saving, exhausted,running around all over the place and stressed for no immediate benefit,or worse a loss, it's hard to see the woods from the trees.