Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary school homework ONLY available online?

139 replies

HereBeFuckery · 09/12/2022 18:56

I'll start by saying I am raging about this, but I'll try not to rant.
DDs school has started setting homework (after a bad Ofsted, but that's another thread).

Homework is ONLY posted on this fucking stupid 'Showbie' app. No other way to access. I must have missed a notification, as I don't check the shitty app daily, because, well, I have a life.

DD missed a piece that was set on Wednesday and due today, as she doesn't have her own phone (because she is eight), or her own tablet or laptop - she uses one of ours when she wants to.

As a result, she missed break time today.

The 'homework'?
"Tell me your favourite Christmas joke"

Give me a fucking break. That's not even close to homework, so lets acknowledge you're phoning it in. Fine. Do not then punish a kid for your shit system that is predicated on her having free access to technology WHICH SHE DOESN'T HAVE.

I'm considering writing to school and saying that we don't allow her to use phones or tablets and so homework will need to be set another way.

Before the pile on, I am also a teacher, but secondary. We set online homework and it is school policy to offer EVERY kid a paper copy too. Because we don't assume access to technology. If I set such a shit piece of homework with 2 days to complete and didn't offer a paper alternative to the online portal, I would be in trouble.

OP posts:
Wronglane · 09/12/2022 22:27

Primary school children should not be punished for missing homework. It’s the parents fault if they do not theirs (not that it was anyones in this instance) I’d complain to head and then OFSTED .

Saltywalruss · 09/12/2022 22:24

Bucketheadbucketbum · 09/12/2022 19:19

That's appalling OP. They should also be encouraging children away from online it's no good for children

Quite. We are meant to encourage children to get off screens and do other activities. Schools really aren't helping by forcing parents to :

  1. Buy devices they might not want or afford
  2. Making children spend even more time in front of a screen
saraclara · 09/12/2022 22:23

Inclined? Involved.

saraclara · 09/12/2022 22:22

HereBeFuckery · 09/12/2022 21:36

@BotWaterHottle also, the system IS at fault. I don't get homework, I'm an adult. If I am required to check, then I am being set homework. They can shove that plan up their tailpipes. I have more than enough to do without logging in to an app to tell a fucking joke.

I was with you up to that point.

It's always been a parent's job to check whether a primary age child has homework/reading/spellings to do. The difference was that it was written in a book that came home with the child every day. They had a book bag, and it was routine that we went through the bag and read the reading/homework/ parent communication book.

I still much prefer that to an app that the parent has to check, as much as anything because the 'going through the book bag' routine inclined us both, where's the app is something that the parent alone has to check and advise their kids of.

But yes, it is and always has been a parent's job to check what homework needs doing until the kids are well into their teens.

TerraNostra · 09/12/2022 22:18

To all the people frothing at the mouth over the PP who commented

"You are being unreasonable to say she's not allowed a phone"

I think that you are missing the point - the point is that of course it's not standard for an 8 year-old to have a phone, but you cannot use "she hasn't got her own phone" as an excuse not to have seen or done the homework. The adult is responsible for finding the homework on their phone and passing the task on to the child, who can complete it on a piece of paper.

As to the criticism of the task itself- thinking about jokes helps children learn about puns, joke structure, why some things are funny and others are not, different types of joke (what do you get if you cross/knock knock/ what do you call a..) and also probably encourages a family discussion to compare jokes that different people like, as well as possibly chat about jokes in crackers and why we do that as a cultural tradition.

LittleBearPad · 09/12/2022 21:59

HereBeFuckery · 09/12/2022 21:36

@BotWaterHottle also, the system IS at fault. I don't get homework, I'm an adult. If I am required to check, then I am being set homework. They can shove that plan up their tailpipes. I have more than enough to do without logging in to an app to tell a fucking joke.

That’s parenting. You make sure your children do their homework.

LittleBearPad · 09/12/2022 21:55

Pineconederby · 09/12/2022 20:33

@LittleBearPad - not a guarantee and not in some of the schools I’ve worked in. They may also need that smartphone for work, not want to share it with their child or simply not want their child to use a device. Schools are not allowed to discriminate based on access to tech, end of. To punish because of it is despicable.

But then OP should have said her daughter didn’t have access to tech when this App was introduced.

She didn’t.

UsernameAlreadyTaken101 · 09/12/2022 21:52

A lot of schools are moving to online homework and communication with parents due to lack of money and resources. We simply can't afford to make the number of photocopies we used to for letters, worksheets etc.
We did an audit of IT provision during lockdown and children without appropriate access to technology were given iPads or chrome books.

Thankfully my school are still clinging on to sending home actual books for reading practice but there are so many ruined each week or not returned that the cost of replacing them is unsustainable and we'll probably have to move to ebooks eventually which I find really sad.

Homework is not compulsory and should only be to reinforce what has been learned. Practising phonics and reading is essential in the infant years but any other stuff should be optional. Giving detention to a child for failing to tell a joke is bizarre and I would definitely ask about in case there was more to it. Also, children have the right to play, so preventing them from having break time is not an appropriate response to failing to complete work.

StrikeItMucky · 09/12/2022 21:50

What a load of old shit. Poor love, being given detention for not doing homework....sorry, I mean not answering a question in a message!!
Definitely don't let this go unchallenged.
And you most certainly aren't being unreasonable for not allowing your 8 year old access to a mobile phone etc.

BotWaterHottle · 09/12/2022 21:47

You're required to do a million things on behalf of your child. This isn't that unreasonable or out of the ordinary.

With the Christmas joke, I see your point that it wasn't the most useful homework, but I guess they just want to ease children in to getting homework if they've never set it before and been pulled up on it in an inspection. It's not exactly onerous for you and your child though, is it? it's also nearly Christmas and kids are tired, and the teachers obviously don't have consolidation tasks planned alongside their curriculum for this half term, as they would have been setting them before now.

HereBeFuckery · 09/12/2022 21:36

@BotWaterHottle also, the system IS at fault. I don't get homework, I'm an adult. If I am required to check, then I am being set homework. They can shove that plan up their tailpipes. I have more than enough to do without logging in to an app to tell a fucking joke.

OP posts:
HereBeFuckery · 09/12/2022 21:34

@BotWaterHottle
And she will learn precisely what from telling 'her favourite Christmas joke'? She doesn't even have a favourite Christmas joke, ffs.

OP posts:
Whattodo182 · 09/12/2022 21:33

ReadyForPumpkins · 09/12/2022 19:05

It’s been like this for many years. DC2 is year 3 and she has online only work since year R.

You are being unreasonable to say she’s not allowed a phone.

It is primary. You can opt out of doing homework. But stop being a technophobe and pass that onto your child.

OP is unreasonable for not letting her EIGHT YEAR OLD child have free access to a phone?
Give over

HereBeFuckery · 09/12/2022 21:32

@AlwaysFullOfQuestions22
I wish. I've now checked it. Here it is, the homework it's worth being put in detention for. The format is how this app displays homework. It looks like a bloody text message!

Primary school homework ONLY available online?
OP posts:
Parker231 · 09/12/2022 21:32

LoveBluey · 09/12/2022 21:27

The main issue isn't the online format it's the detention. I think punishing children for something they have little to no control over is awful - see also rewards/punishments for attendance. In primary these are all down to parents not kids.

As an aside my Y1 DD has had every single piece of weekly home learning set online since starting school and this year they've moved to online reading which I'm really not loving. It's one thing having to print out the homework sheet but it's near on impossible practising the reading with an ebook rather than a print book.

Why is she doing homework in yr-1 ? Instead of an ebook - ask her school for a proper reading book. She’s going to end up with eye problems. Sounds like the teacher/school are being lazy.

HereBeFuckery · 09/12/2022 21:30

@ditherydotty you've forgotten, this is MN. Others have disagreed with me, so they must not only say they disagree, they must go further and imply unpleasant things about a child they've never met so that I meekly accept I'm wrong and scuttle away.

OP posts:
LoveBluey · 09/12/2022 21:27

The main issue isn't the online format it's the detention. I think punishing children for something they have little to no control over is awful - see also rewards/punishments for attendance. In primary these are all down to parents not kids.

As an aside my Y1 DD has had every single piece of weekly home learning set online since starting school and this year they've moved to online reading which I'm really not loving. It's one thing having to print out the homework sheet but it's near on impossible practising the reading with an ebook rather than a print book.

TumbleFryer · 09/12/2022 21:25

ReadyForPumpkins · 09/12/2022 19:05

It’s been like this for many years. DC2 is year 3 and she has online only work since year R.

You are being unreasonable to say she’s not allowed a phone.

It is primary. You can opt out of doing homework. But stop being a technophobe and pass that onto your child.

She’s 8 years old! Of course she doesn’t have a phone!

saraclara · 09/12/2022 21:11

In a teacher and I'd be equally furious. My DD was a quiet perfectionist, and getting a detention at that age would have really upset her. It's absolutely ridiculous to give an eight year old a detention for not typing out a joke, whatever. But even more so if she had no idea that the 'homework' was set because the school hadn't informed parents that it was being set on the wrong day.

ScroogeMcDuckling · 09/12/2022 21:00

I hope your daughter has a good cry and gets a good sleep tonight. It’s horrible when you’re that age getting “told off” and losing your break time with your friends.

I fully understand you’re reasoning about phones at her age.

Perhaps the school will sort out a computer area with printers so on the required day of homework, (or when the teacher tells them theirs homework) the pupil can go to the area and get the “download”.

If it’s an app, doesn’t the app inform the app holder new stuff has gone on it? You can then say to your daughter we will check the system together later.

BotWaterHottle · 09/12/2022 20:55

The system isn't at fault. She, or you, must check. Then the homework needs doing. Or a detention will need doing.

It's nothing to do with 'having a life'. You have a child. Who needs to learn. Homework is part of that.

Maybe it'll become more meaningful as parents actually parent their eight year olds and it consistently is done well. Otherwise, it just reinforces and widens a gap between those who are already at an educational advantage and those who are behind.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 09/12/2022 20:55

Also all this "it's not normal to be so upset hours later" bullshit, what's that implying? Op's child is abnormal as she's still upset?

Firstly it is literally not normal for a child to be still crying 5 hours later, on a Friday night.

But then most children's parents would have rolled their eyes and said "That's a bit daft" when they found they had missed the homework and their child had done it at break instead. A child whose parent gets angry and talks about withdrawing their child from doing homework and wanting a "fucking apology" from the school may find it harder to cheer up and forget it.

Abraxan · 09/12/2022 20:51

Pineconederby · 09/12/2022 20:33

@LittleBearPad - not a guarantee and not in some of the schools I’ve worked in. They may also need that smartphone for work, not want to share it with their child or simply not want their child to use a device. Schools are not allowed to discriminate based on access to tech, end of. To punish because of it is despicable.

Firstly, we know our catchment. We know that very few, if any, don't have access to a smartphone, through our years of experience with our parents.

We also don't expect children to use the device. All our children are if a young age, so parents are the ones dealing with home learning regardless of the format it comes home in. No requirement to complete it online at all. Just for parents to read it and tell their child, IF they want to complete it, as it's optional, as I said previously.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/12/2022 20:51

Ours is mainly in their homework book but we get the odd piece online but the instructions are written in their homework book.

When they first set up the online stuff we missed a few pieces here and there but there was no punishment!

I'd be furious too OP, moreso if my DC was upset about it. Speak to the school

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/12/2022 20:48

My Gdcs, 6 and 7, do maths homework (Doodlemaths) online - using parents’ phones or laptops, they certainly don’t have their own.